WikiBias: How Wikipedia erases fringe theories and enforces conformity – Minding The Campus
Wikipedia is probably the most widely used encyclopedia in the world. If youre looking for facts, it is pretty reliable. For example, if you want to compare the number of traffic roundabouts per capita in the US and other countries, Wikipedia will provide a nice graph from the World Economic Forum showing that the UK has about thirteen times as many as the US.
On the other hand, Wikipedia is not a reliable source for some controversial topics. The very biased entry for political scientist Charles Murray is a striking example. The following history shows something of how this works.
A friend tried to make a small change to the entry for Murray. His account was then blocked. This was done by an anonymous and self-selected collection of highly motivated individualsmore about them in a moment.
After hearing of my friends failure, I decided to have a go myself. I tried several things, but the simplest was to change a single word. I altered a paragraph referring to Herrnstein and Murrays widely attacked 1994 book The Bell Curve. As it stood, this section read as follows:
The books most controversial argument hinged on a hypothesized relationship betweenrace and intelligence, specifically the hypothesis that differences in average IQ test performance between racial groups are at least partially genetic in origin. Subsequent developments in genetics research have led to a scholarly consensus that this hypothesis is false. The idea that there are genetically determined differences in intelligence between racial groups is now considered discredited by mainstream science [emphasis added].
This paragraph is factually incorrect. First, there is no real consensus that the difference in test performance between racially identified groups is not partly genetic. Almost any measurable characteristic, whether physical or behavioral, has some heritable component. Second, since this position has not been proved falsewhich would be extremely difficult to do for a human population not available for breeding experimentsits incorrect to say that it has been discredited. On the other hand, theres no doubt that many reject it.
I therefore corrected the last sentence as follows:
The idea that there are genetically determined differences in intelligence between racial groups is now rejectedby mainstream science.
The change was accepted, but then reversed a few hours later. I tried again, but it was again reversed. This repeated a few times and, eventually, I got this message: Please stop. If you continue to vandalize Wikipedia, as you did at Charles Murray (political scientist), you may be blocked from editing. Apparently, my minor change was regarded as vandalism. (The message was pseudonymous, but it linked to a website which proclaims, This user is of dubious and undisclosed gender, and uses they/them pronouns.)
It turns out that the Wikipedia editorial system, organized in a complicated way that I confess I do not fully understand, classifies some positions as fringe: the theory that a genetic link exists between race and intelligence is enough of a minority viewpoint in the scientific consensus that it falls under Wikipedias definition of a fringe theory. Fringe theories are to be excluded from Wikipedia, apparently.
Of course, the idea that many behavioral characteristics, including IQ, are heritable is far from a fringe theory. Wikipedias fallacious summary of the issue is:
Group differences in IQ are real and areprimarily or entirely caused by social and/or environmental factors. Group differences in IQ do not truly exist and are the result of inappropriate use of the tests themselves [emphasis added].
No unbiased discussion of group differences in intelligence may be found in Wikipedias vast corpus. So, I decided to try a different tack.
This paragraph in the Charles Murray entry cites several critiques of The Bell Curve:
After its publication, academics criticized the book over his assertions on race and IQ.[38][39] Some said it supported long-discredited scientific racism[40][41][42][43] and a number of books were written to rebutThe Bell Curve. Those works included a 1996 edition of evolutionary biologist Stephen Jay Goulds The Mismeasure of Man; a collection of essays, The Bell Curve Wars(1995), reacting to Murray and Herrnsteins commentary; and The Bell Curve Debate (1995), whose essays similarly respond to issues raised in The Bell Curve. Arthur S. GoldbergerandCharles F. Manskicritiqued the empirical methods supporting the books hypotheses.[44]
The Bell Curves most influential critic was Stephen Jay Gould in the updated version of his 1981 book The Mismeasure of Man. The most effective critique of Gould is J. Philippe Rushtons 1997 paper Race, intelligence, and the brain: The errors and omissions of the revised edition of S. J. Goulds the mismeasure of man (Person. individ. Diff. Vol. 23, No. 1, pp. 169-180, 1997). Rushtons critique is not mentioned in the Wikipedia entry.
Rushton himself is a controversial figure. So, rather than cite his work, I decided to focus on two of the most blatant errors in Goulds book. I therefore inserted a passage after the paragraph of critical references along the following lines:
Goulds criticism of The Bell Curve was probably the most effective. For example, in Mismeasure he wrote Herrnstein and Murray violate fairness by converting a complex case that can yield only agnosticism into a biased brief for permanent and heritable difference. Herrnstein died in 1994, just as the book was published, but Goulds accusations still dog Murray.
In fact, on p. 311, The Bell Curve says precisely what Gould accused Herrnstein and Murray of not saying:
It seems highly likely to us that both genes and environment have something to do with racial differences. What might the mix be?We are resolutely agnostic on that issue; as far as we can determine, the evidence does not yet justify an estimate. [emphases added]
Herrnstein and Murray also cited the work of 19th century physician and scientist Samuel Morton, who compared the brain volumes of European, Asian and African skulls, finding that African brains were smaller than Asian and European. Gould, in Mismeasure, disputed that also, suggesting that Morton had subconsciously manipulated the brain volumesto favor his bias that Europeans had larger brains and African smaller ones. However, a 2011 study[1] by physical anthropologists at the University of Pennsylvania confirmed a few earlier studies which found that Morton was in fact correct and Goulds claim is wrong.
Nevertheless, these flawed, not to say mendacious, attacks by Gould and others, have effectively excluded Murrays work from the public IQ debate.
Needless to say, this insertion was also repeatedly deleted.
This little history reveals a flaw in the way that Wikipedia treats science. Error and debate are intrinsic to science. A consensus isnt necessarily correct. If opinion is divided, it is simply wrong to dismiss the minority view as fringe.
Wikipedia treats some other controversial issues more fairly. Its discussion of climate change, for example, acknowledges that there is debate over the amount and causes of global temperature change (although it exaggerates the size of the dominant majority).
But race and intelligence is clearly a taboo subject, as I have noticed in other interactions. Even after lengthy phone and email conversations with a reporter for Inside Higher Education, for example, he continued to charge that the factual claim that blacks have, on average, substantially lower IQs than whites is itself racist. The fact that Herrnstein and Murray make a similar claim in their book evidently places them beyond the pale.
Unfortunately, this blackwhite difference exists. Whether it is genetically based is almost impossible to determine and absolutely irrelevant for public policy. If there is a difference in cognitive ability, and if politicians insist on obsessing over group-average data on income, health, etc., then honest science demands that we also look at other differences, such as IQ, that may help account for these socio-economic differences.
But we mustnt do this, according to other sources such as top science journals and the mass media. The problem, of course, is that if Wikipedia readers are forbidden to even consider the possibility of differences in interests and abilities between racial groups, all that is left to account for the economic and social disparities between blacks and whites is systemic racism, an unmeasurable, hence irrefutable, evil perpetrated by whites against black people. Which is what has happened. White people are now routinely slandered as racists because other potential causes of blackwhite group disparities have been suppressedWikipedia is one of the guilty parties.
Image: Adobe Stock
More:
WikiBias: How Wikipedia erases fringe theories and enforces conformity - Minding The Campus
- Miles Teller tops the list of the most-searched Wikipedia pages of celebrities born in Chester County - Inquirer.com - November 15th, 2026 [November 15th, 2026]
- Google killed my favorite internet game years ago, so I rebuilt it using Wikipedia - How-To Geek - November 15th, 2026 [November 15th, 2026]
- Wikipedia in the age of ChatGPT: competitor or collaborator? - The Daily Star - November 15th, 2026 [November 15th, 2026]
- From 911 to Wikipedia: Alabama innovations that matter - Montgomery Advertiser - November 13th, 2026 [November 13th, 2026]
- Pete Hegseth humiliated as Wikipedia page updated after Tomb of the Unknown Soldier scolding - Irish Star - November 13th, 2026 [November 13th, 2026]
- Pete Hegseth's Arlington Reprimand Added to Wikipedia Following Veterans Day Visit to Soldier's Tomb - inkl - November 13th, 2026 [November 13th, 2026]
- 'This is how you rig elections: Stephen Millers wife slams Wikipedia for scrubbing Abdul El-Sayed's past - Blaze Media - November 13th, 2026 [November 13th, 2026]
- Did Abdul El-Sayed get his Wikipedia page edited to soften controversial sentences before Michigan Senate - The Times of India - November 7th, 2026 [November 7th, 2026]
- El-Sayeds Wikipedia page reportedly sanitized by mystery editor before election - BizPac Review - November 7th, 2026 [November 7th, 2026]
- Elon Musks Grokipedia is littered with mistakes. But Wikipedia could still learn some things from it. - Nieman Journalism Lab - November 5th, 2026 [November 5th, 2026]
- From Linux to Wikipedia: How Volunteers Build the Internet - The MIT Press Reader - November 5th, 2026 [November 5th, 2026]
- The Death of Wikipedia - The Tufts Daily - November 5th, 2026 [November 5th, 2026]
- This offline Wikipedia project is the perfect introduction to local LLMs - How-To Geek - November 5th, 2026 [November 5th, 2026]
- I host the entire Wikipedia locally with a Raspberry Pi, and it's easy - How-To Geek - November 5th, 2026 [November 5th, 2026]
- Blackjack Simple English Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia - MedanHeadlines - November 5th, 2026 [November 5th, 2026]
- Humans will never again create a project quite like Wikipedia - The Economist - November 1st, 2026 [November 1st, 2026]
- A dated benchmark of NPOV disputes on English Wikipedia, and what it says about catching bias early - Wikimedia.org - November 1st, 2026 [November 1st, 2026]
- Immersion to Involvement: Introducing Wikipedia and the Wikimedia ecosystem to the English Club Project in Jakarta - Wikimedia.org - November 1st, 2026 [November 1st, 2026]
- Watch The Tragedy Of Having Your Wikipedia Page Deleted - WIRED - November 1st, 2026 [November 1st, 2026]
- A Star Trek actor, athletes, and coaches: These are the 5 most-searched Wikipedia pages of celebrities born in Media - Inquirer.com - November 1st, 2026 [November 1st, 2026]
- The Tragedy of Having a Wikipedia Pageand Then Losing It - WIRED - October 28th, 2026 [October 28th, 2026]
- The fight to preserve queer history is happening one Wikipedia edit at a time - Advocate.com - October 28th, 2026 [October 28th, 2026]
- Local Wikipedia is Wikipedia, but only for things a half ho... - Kottke.org - October 28th, 2026 [October 28th, 2026]
- Tyler Scherer Age and Wikipedia: What Fans Should Know About the Rising Personality - - October 28th, 2026 [October 28th, 2026]
- Verify Before You Contribute: Connecting Fact-Checking with Wikipedia Editing - WikiMedia.org - October 28th, 2026 [October 28th, 2026]
- Why Wikipedia is a Wonder of the Modern WorldThat Well Never See the Likes of Again - Literary Hub - October 28th, 2026 [October 28th, 2026]
- He Said He Learned About Hunter's Laptop From Wikipedia. Prosecutors Say FBI Files Tell Another Story. - Hoosier Enquirer - October 28th, 2026 [October 28th, 2026]
- This new tool layers Wikipedia articles onto a map to make your half-hour walk more interesting - Yahoo Tech - October 28th, 2026 [October 28th, 2026]
- CPCF shows up for Wikipedia Edit-a-thon Communication, Popular Culture and Film - Brock University - October 28th, 2026 [October 28th, 2026]
- Wikipedia and 70% Of Internet At Risk After Security Flaw. What You Need To Know - October 22 - Modern Ghana - October 28th, 2026 [October 28th, 2026]
- Rogue AI Agents Have Gone Too Far Now That Theyve Infiltrated Wikipedia - Futurism - October 10th, 2026 [October 10th, 2026]
- OpenAI agents tried to hack Wikipedia tools and flooded it with traffic - Ars Technica - October 10th, 2026 [October 10th, 2026]
- Wikipedia operator says OpenAI's rogue agents possibly tied to data service disruption in May - Reuters - October 10th, 2026 [October 10th, 2026]
- Wikipedia operator says OpenAIs rogue bots may be linked to a May outage - The Verge - October 10th, 2026 [October 10th, 2026]
- Six people are building the first Wikipedia in Baoul Cte dIvoires most widely spoken indigenous language - WikiMedia.org - October 10th, 2026 [October 10th, 2026]
- AI and the End of Wikipedia, Socialists Strike Back - Bloomberg.com - October 10th, 2026 [October 10th, 2026]
- The Social Reckoning Reaches The Thrilling Depths of a Big-Budget Wikipedia Entry - DIASPORA | Substack - October 10th, 2026 [October 10th, 2026]
- Wikipedia says rogue OpenAI agents attacked its platforms and hammered its servers - Digital Trends - October 10th, 2026 [October 10th, 2026]
- Wikipedia blames rogue OpenAI bots for rare outage and says AI firms must do more to protect public from harm - The Independent - October 10th, 2026 [October 10th, 2026]
- Wikipedia accuses OpenAI's agents of crashing its servers - Korben - October 10th, 2026 [October 10th, 2026]
- OpenAI agents allegedly tried to hack Wikipedia tools, flooded its systems - Gulf News - October 10th, 2026 [October 10th, 2026]
- Wikimedia accuses OpenAI's AI of illegally editing the Wikipedia system. - Vietnam.vn - October 10th, 2026 [October 10th, 2026]
- Prolific photographers can get cash from Wikipedia for taking pictures of these sites - KTLA - October 4th, 2026 [October 4th, 2026]
- Wikipedia Fans Worry the Site Is Getting a Bad Deal From Its Streetwear Brand Collab - Gizmodo - October 4th, 2026 [October 4th, 2026]
- Wikipedia says Notre Dame has 19 football rivalries. Lets rank them, from fake to real - The Athletic - The New York Times - October 4th, 2026 [October 4th, 2026]
- Old Mosul on Wikipedia 2026: Documenting the Heritage of Mosul through Wikimedia Projects - WikiMedia.org - October 4th, 2026 [October 4th, 2026]
- Wikipedia, Podcasts & Reddit Now Drive AI Citations, Ask Your PR Team How They Did It - Search Engine Journal - October 4th, 2026 [October 4th, 2026]
- Wikipedia loses 8% of visits and its CEO tells AI firms to pay - pasqualepillitteri.it - October 4th, 2026 [October 4th, 2026]
- Wikipedia Is 25. The Island Of Tawi-tawi Just Met It - WikiMedia.org - October 4th, 2026 [October 4th, 2026]
- First line of Wikipedia Oct. 7 entry says Hamas terrorists came from blockaded Gaza, seeming to justify attacks - JNS.org - October 4th, 2026 [October 4th, 2026]
- Revealed - the five most Wikipedia searched celebrities from Romford in 2026 - Southend Echo - October 4th, 2026 [October 4th, 2026]
- WWE Star Karmen Petrovic Reacts to False Reports of Her Death on Wikipedia and Google - Yahoo Sports - October 4th, 2026 [October 4th, 2026]
- 25 Years of Wikipedia - History Today - September 26th, 2026 [September 26th, 2026]
- From Armenia to Tunisia: The Story of Wikipedia Camp Tunisia 2026 - Wikimedia.org - September 6th, 2026 [September 6th, 2026]
- Runyankole to go live on Wikipedia - monitor.co.ug - September 6th, 2026 [September 6th, 2026]
- Access Restored to Wikipedia in Russia After Overnight Outage - The Moscow Times - September 2nd, 2026 [September 2nd, 2026]
- You, too, can squeeze an offline Wikipedia onto an ESP32 CYD with this project - XDA - September 2nd, 2026 [September 2nd, 2026]
- Dolly Partons Wikipedia page vandalised with swastika hours after her death - The Jewish Chronicle - September 2nd, 2026 [September 2nd, 2026]
- African science innovation is growing exponentially, but it's almost entirely absent from Wikipedia. Why that's a problem. - Genetic Literacy Project - September 2nd, 2026 [September 2nd, 2026]
- Anna Delveys crusade against Wikipedia, and what it means for the First Amendment - Straight Arrow - August 18th, 2026 [August 18th, 2026]
- Toast, boners, and margarine haters all come together on Wikipedia - A.V. Club - August 18th, 2026 [August 18th, 2026]
- Depths of Wikipedia (Annie Rauwerda) Underbelly Cowbarn, Bristo Square | Review by Avery Mitchell - theatrescotland.co.uk - August 14th, 2026 [August 14th, 2026]
- Hes edited six million Wikipedia articles for free and almost no one knows his name - News24 - August 14th, 2026 [August 14th, 2026]
- Poet Kyle Flemmer zooms in on Wikipedia as a bastion of collective knowledge in new collection - Yahoo News Canada - August 14th, 2026 [August 14th, 2026]
- Google Search Briefly Showed False 'Sam Altman Dead' Result Amid Wikipedia Vandalism - finance.biggo.com - August 14th, 2026 [August 14th, 2026]
- Poet Kyle Flemmer zooms in on Wikipedia as a bastion of collective knowledge in new collection - Calgary Herald - August 14th, 2026 [August 14th, 2026]
- Wikipedia has become compromised by intelligence agencies and ideological capture - thevibes.com - August 14th, 2026 [August 14th, 2026]
- Evidence of sneaky Shellrelated monitoring and editing of Wikipedia - Royal Dutch Shell Plc .com - August 12th, 2026 [August 12th, 2026]
- From Should we? to How do we?: A community weekend on AI and Wikipedia - WikiMedia.org - August 12th, 2026 [August 12th, 2026]
- A Wikipedia-Loving but Wikipedian-Intimidated Dork Explores the Minnesota Wiknic - Racket MN - July 21st, 2026 [July 21st, 2026]
- After 3,000 Years, People Are Finally Reading The Odysseyat Least on Wikipedia - WSJ - July 21st, 2026 [July 21st, 2026]
- Welcome to the high-stakes universe of World Cup Wikipedia editing - The New York Times - July 21st, 2026 [July 21st, 2026]
- Does Israel Control the World Cup Wikipedia? - The Times of Israel - July 21st, 2026 [July 21st, 2026]
- After 3,000 Years, People Are Finally Reading The Odysseyat Least on Wikipedia | Hollywood - Hindustan Times - July 21st, 2026 [July 21st, 2026]
- There's a way to have the entire Wikipedia offline, and it's smaller than you'd expect - MakeUseOf - July 21st, 2026 [July 21st, 2026]
- Sanger Banned by Wikipedia: Diagnosing a Disease - Science and Culture Today - July 21st, 2026 [July 21st, 2026]
- How Wikipedia Turned a World Cup Controversy into an Antisemitic Conspiracy Theory - The Free Press - July 13th, 2026 [July 13th, 2026]
- PeaZip 11.2 Releases With Offline Wikipedia Support And Upgraded Drag-and-Drop - Open Source For You - July 13th, 2026 [July 13th, 2026]
- EduWiki Workshop: Combining PETScan and Generative AI for Smarter Wikipedia Editing - Wikimedia.org - July 13th, 2026 [July 13th, 2026]
- I co-founded Wikipedia, but an anonymous mob runs the show and now Im banned - Washington Examiner - July 11th, 2026 [July 11th, 2026]