Opinion | What a Russian and Ukrainian general agree on: This battlespace is different – The Washington Post
As top Russian and Ukrainian generals assess the battlefield after nearly two brutal years of stalemated positional warfare, they draw the same lessons: Tanks, manned aircraft and traditional maneuver forces are sitting ducks, while advanced drones and digital battle-management systems can have a decisive impact.
Russia has come to realize what Ukraine recognized more than a year ago: This is an algorithm war, one where digital intelligence and targeting systems have rewritten the rules of conflict. The fog of war experienced by commanders for centuries has cleared. In the newly transparent battlespace, movements by large units are instantly visible and vulnerable.
This look into Russian and Ukrainian military assessments is possible thanks to commentaries published in the past two weeks by two veteran commanders, Gen. Yuri Baluyevsky, a former chief of the Russian general staff, and Gen. Valery Zaluzhny, head of the Ukrainian military. They appeared, respectively, in Army Standard, a Russian publication, and on the website of the Ukrainian defense ministry.
The commentaries were flagged to me by Kevin Ryan, a retired Army brigadier general who served as U.S. defense attach in Moscow and then taught at the Harvard Kennedy Schools Belfer Center. He translated the articles and circulated them this week among Russia specialists. Zaluzhny made similar comments about the importance of drones in an interview published in November in the Economist, but the Russian analysis is new and startling.
These two adversaries see many of the same lessons, Ryan writes in an email summarizing the commentaries. The generals recognize that in the Ukraine battlespace, no concentration of troops, large or small, can escape the ever-present reconnaissance by unmanned aerial systems and satellites, he notes.
The tactical revolution underway in Ukraine underlines why a congressional failure to approve continued U.S. military support for Kyiv would be so devastating. As Russia gains increasing mastery of digital warfare, Zaluzhny worries that Ukraine is hobbled by exhaustion of our partners stocks of missiles and ammunition and the difficulty of our allies in determining the priorities of support.
Baluyevskys comments read like a wake-up call to his fellow Russian officers. He argues that the so-called special military operation in Ukraine has been an unprecedented test of literally all components of military affairs and military construction. His analysis came in the foreword for an anthology of essays about the war, which was then summarized in Army Standard by Russian journalist Sergey Valchenko.
Baluyevsky echoes many Western commentators who have argued that defense has trumped offense in Ukraine. Air defense has won an unexpected triumph over military aviation, which has lost the ability to operate en masse over enemy territory and even must fly with caution over its own territory.
The tank has become one of the main casualties of the combat experience of the last two years, he explains, since it was an easily detected and easily hit target and turned out to be very vulnerable to mines. Similarly, the impossibility of concentrating troops forces us to conduct combat operations with small units and separate combat vehicles.
Baluyevsky has some scathing comments about the performance of Russian weapons. The qualitative superiority of NATO artillery is evident, he contends. Ukraine has revealed a significant lag in Russian artillery and missile systems and requires their priority radical rearmament in the next few years.
The winners in this war are drones. Unmanned aircraft have rapidly and unconditionally conquered the airspace, Baluyevsky argues. Zaluzhny agrees that unmanned systems, along with other new types of weapons, are almost the only tool for getting out of the stalemate of trench warfare.
Zaluzhny bemoans Russias manpower advantage and Ukraines inability to improve the state of staffing of the Defense Forces without the use of unpopular measures, such as a nationwide draft. His disagreement with President Volodymyr Zelensky about the need for such an all-out mobilization is one reason for recent tension between the two men and Zelenskys reported readiness to sack his commander.
Ukraine, as I wrote after visiting Kyiv in October, is exhausted by war and slowly bleeding out. Zaluzhny implicitly recognizes this war fatigue in arguing for increased use of unmanned systems to reduce the level of losses reduce the degree of participation of traditional means of destruction [and] limited involvement of heavy equipment.
The lesson for the United States, beyond the simple but urgent need to continue military assistance for Ukraine, is to focus that support on the high-tech weapons that matter. The weapons that have generated endless debate, such as tanks and F-16 fighters, are less important than drones, antiaircraft systems and electronic-warfare jammers.
The best weapons today, agree the Russian and Ukrainian generals, might be small, cheap systems such as first-person view, or FPV drones that fly into targets like tiny suicide bombers and can be almost impossible to stop. The chilling fact is that these silent killers can be bought and used by almost any combatant, anywhere on Earth. It is, as the generals agree, a new day in warfare.
- Rand Paul slams Biden, McConnell for spending borrowed money on Ukraine aid - The Hill - May 5th, 2024 [May 5th, 2024]
- Russia pushing 'at all costs' for territory in Ukraine before fresh US weapons arrive - The Independent - May 5th, 2024 [May 5th, 2024]
- A fresh Russian push will test Ukraine severely, says a senior general - The Economist - May 5th, 2024 [May 5th, 2024]
- Zelenskyy briefed by Ukraine's commander-in-chief and intelligence chief : We are aware of all the aspects of the current situation - Ukrainska Pravda - May 5th, 2024 [May 5th, 2024]
- Is U.S. Aid to Ukraine Too Little, Too Late? - Council on Foreign Relations - May 5th, 2024 [May 5th, 2024]
- Ukraine-Russia war latest: Russian fighter-bomber 'shot down over Donetsk'; Ukraine faces another wave of Russian ... - Sky News - May 5th, 2024 [May 5th, 2024]
- Russia's 'line of hell:' Ukraine says it destroyed 42 tanks and armor in a Donetsk sector - Business Insider - May 5th, 2024 [May 5th, 2024]
- Opinion: Ukraine Doing Much Better on the Front Than Its Being Given Credit For - Kyiv Post - May 5th, 2024 [May 5th, 2024]
- U.S. Approved More Weapons for Ukraine. Now It's a Race Against Time. - The New York Times - May 5th, 2024 [May 5th, 2024]
- Ukraine is ready for a just peace not Russia's version of one - POLITICO Europe - May 5th, 2024 [May 5th, 2024]
- Can Franco-German relations be rekindled over the Ukraine war? - Euronews - May 5th, 2024 [May 5th, 2024]
- Norwich photo exhibition captures Ukraine's fight for freedom - BBC.com - May 5th, 2024 [May 5th, 2024]
- As China's Xi Jinping visits Europe, Ukraine, trade and investment are likely to top the agenda - The Associated Press - May 5th, 2024 [May 5th, 2024]
- FT: US aid to Ukraine will help Ukraine launch counteroffensive in 2025, Sullivan says - Kyiv Independent - May 5th, 2024 [May 5th, 2024]
- Ukraine highlights Russia's 'line of hell.' Claim of dozens of tanks and military vehicles destroyed on one sector of the ... - Yahoo! Voices - May 5th, 2024 [May 5th, 2024]
- Ukraine Plans Counteroffensive in 2025 with $61 Billion US Military Aid, Sullivan Says - Kyiv Post - May 5th, 2024 [May 5th, 2024]
- Britain's Cameron, in Kyiv, promises Ukraine aid for 'as long as it takes' - Reuters UK - May 5th, 2024 [May 5th, 2024]
- Ukraine Breaking News Today Live on 05-05-2024 - Kyiv Post - May 5th, 2024 [May 5th, 2024]
- Kremlin brands France and UK's Ukraine comments as 'dangerous' - Euronews - May 5th, 2024 [May 5th, 2024]
- Ukraine's balloon-borne bomber blitz: Designed to waste Russian shells and missiles - Yahoo! Voices - May 5th, 2024 [May 5th, 2024]
- Israel is retiring Patriot missile systems that could help Ukraine - Business Insider - May 5th, 2024 [May 5th, 2024]
- Ukraine wiped out 100 Russian troops at once in a strike showcasing the range and power of its new US ATACMS - Yahoo! Voices - May 5th, 2024 [May 5th, 2024]
- Russia says it has driven Ukrainian army from 211 square miles of territory this year - Yahoo! Voices - May 5th, 2024 [May 5th, 2024]
- Russia-Ukraine war: Lithuania hits out at Russia disinformation over spy claims as it happened - The Guardian - May 5th, 2024 [May 5th, 2024]
- US forgot what it means to fight a real war: veteran in Ukraine - Business Insider - May 5th, 2024 [May 5th, 2024]
- The Kremlin brands comments on Ukraine by France's Macron and Britain's Cameron as 'dangerous' - Yahoo! Voices - May 5th, 2024 [May 5th, 2024]
- A NATO country says it could join Ukraine's war with Russia if 2 conditions are met - Yahoo! Voices - May 5th, 2024 [May 5th, 2024]
- Most of US aid will be delivered to Ukraine in several months NYT - Ukrainska Pravda - May 5th, 2024 [May 5th, 2024]
- Ukraine loss of crucial Chasiv Yar only matter of time: intel chief - Business Insider - May 5th, 2024 [May 5th, 2024]
- Confident Russia displays Western war trophies ahead of Victory Day - The Washington Post - May 5th, 2024 [May 5th, 2024]
- Ukraine May Have Deployed One Its Best Brigades To Try To Save Avdiivka - Forbes - February 12th, 2024 [February 12th, 2024]
- Ukraine-Israel Aid Bill Clears Critical Hurdle in the Senate - The New York Times - February 12th, 2024 [February 12th, 2024]
- US F-16s are exceeding the expectations of Ukraine's pilots: Report - Business Insider - February 12th, 2024 [February 12th, 2024]
- Opinion | Speaker Johnson should see what I just saw in Ukraine - The Washington Post - February 12th, 2024 [February 12th, 2024]
- Ukraine Says Russia Is Using Starlink at the Front Line, Prompting Pushback From Elon Musk - The Wall Street Journal - February 12th, 2024 [February 12th, 2024]
- Russia is using Starlink in occupied areas, Ukraine says - Reuters - February 12th, 2024 [February 12th, 2024]
- Ukraine's new army chief signals new momentum, but huge problems stand in the way - The Associated Press - February 12th, 2024 [February 12th, 2024]
- Russian soldier cites 'nowhere to live' as motivation for invading Ukraine - Yahoo News - February 12th, 2024 [February 12th, 2024]
- Russia no longer perceived as top threat by Germans - POLITICO Europe - February 12th, 2024 [February 12th, 2024]
- FSB Investigates Illegal Sale of Aircraft to Ukraine and Other 'Unfriendly States' - Kyiv Post - February 12th, 2024 [February 12th, 2024]
- Short on Soldiers, Ukraine Debates How to Find the Next Wave of Troops - The New York Times - February 12th, 2024 [February 12th, 2024]
- The Senate is pushing past far-right objections to aiding Ukraine. But next steps are uncertain - The Associated Press - February 12th, 2024 [February 12th, 2024]
- What's inside the Senate's $95 billion bill to aid Ukraine and Israel and counter China - The Associated Press - February 12th, 2024 [February 12th, 2024]
- Outgunned and exhausted: what hope for Ukraine if US military aid dries up? - The Guardian - February 12th, 2024 [February 12th, 2024]
- Opinion | Ukraine supporters need to find a way around the MAGA obstructionists - The Washington Post - February 12th, 2024 [February 12th, 2024]
- Moldova destroyed explosives found in a Shahed drone that strayed from the war in Ukraine - Yahoo News - February 12th, 2024 [February 12th, 2024]
- Russia's Aviation Body Allegedly Allowed Aircraft Export to Ukraine Izvestia - The Moscow Times - February 12th, 2024 [February 12th, 2024]
- Ukraine's Victory at Sea: How Kyiv Subdued the Russian Fleetand What It Will Need to Build on Naval Success - Foreign Affairs Magazine - February 12th, 2024 [February 12th, 2024]
- Ukraine says Elon Musks Starlink is used by Russian forces near the frontline: This is starting to become systemic - Fortune - February 12th, 2024 [February 12th, 2024]
- Tucker Carlson exposed Putin's true war motive: For Russia to own Ukraine - The Washington Post - February 12th, 2024 [February 12th, 2024]
- Close to criminal neglect: Biden calls on Congress to secure Ukraine aid - Axios - February 12th, 2024 [February 12th, 2024]
- Putin Calls on U.S. to 'Negotiate' on Ukraine in Tucker Carlson Interview - The New York Times - February 12th, 2024 [February 12th, 2024]
- Damaged cultural sites in Ukraine verified by UNESCO - UNESCO - February 12th, 2024 [February 12th, 2024]
- US Senate Rejects Border Security Measure Linked to Ukraine, Israel Aid - Voice of America - VOA News - February 8th, 2024 [February 8th, 2024]
- The Senate Moved to Salvage Ukraine Aid - The New York Times - February 8th, 2024 [February 8th, 2024]
- Ukraine war: 28 killed after shelling hits bakery in Russian-occupied Ukraine - The Associated Press - February 8th, 2024 [February 8th, 2024]
- These are vessels in Russia's Black Sea Fleet that Ukraine wiped out - Business Insider - February 8th, 2024 [February 8th, 2024]
- Tucker Carlson Says His Putin Interview Will Be Shown on Thursday - The New York Times - February 8th, 2024 [February 8th, 2024]
- Russia Throwing Large Numbers of Troops at Ukraine's Avdiivka, Mayor Says - The Moscow Times - February 8th, 2024 [February 8th, 2024]
- EU pledges more than a million military shells to Ukraine - Euronews - February 8th, 2024 [February 8th, 2024]
- Russia attacks targets across Ukraine with missiles and drones as EUs top diplomat visits Kyiv - ABC News - February 8th, 2024 [February 8th, 2024]
- US, NATO Reaffirm Need to Support Ukraine - Voice of America - VOA News - February 8th, 2024 [February 8th, 2024]
- Tucker Carlson to interview Russia's Putin - BBC.com - February 6th, 2024 [February 6th, 2024]
- Congress in chaos over border deal, Israel and Ukraine - NPR - February 6th, 2024 [February 6th, 2024]
- Biden Tells Republicans to 'Show Some Spine' Against Trump on Border Deal - The New York Times - February 6th, 2024 [February 6th, 2024]
- Border Security: Biden Blames Trump for Faltering Effort to Address Immigration and Ukraine Aid - The New York Times - February 6th, 2024 [February 6th, 2024]
- Tucker Carlson Says He'll Interview Putin About Ukraine War - Bloomberg - February 6th, 2024 [February 6th, 2024]
- Ukraine-Born Miss Japan Renounces Title After Her Affair with Married Man Gets Revealed: 'I Am Truly Sorry' - PEOPLE - February 6th, 2024 [February 6th, 2024]
- Here's What's in the Senate's $118 Billion Ukraine and Border Deal - The New York Times - February 6th, 2024 [February 6th, 2024]
- In Huge Reversal, GOP Poised To Kill The Border-Ukraine Package It Demanded - HuffPost - February 6th, 2024 [February 6th, 2024]
- Biden urges Congress to pass border deal that includes aid for Ukraine and Israel - BBC.com - February 6th, 2024 [February 6th, 2024]
- Growing number of Conservative voters think Canada gives 'too much support' to Ukraine, poll suggests - Yahoo News Canada - February 6th, 2024 [February 6th, 2024]
- With Demise of Border Deal, No Clear Path for Ukraine and Israel Aid in Congress - The New York Times - February 6th, 2024 [February 6th, 2024]
- McConnell faces career-defining test in Trump battle over Ukraine, border - The Hill - February 6th, 2024 [February 6th, 2024]
- Key highlights of proposed bipartisan Senate package for border security and Ukraine - The Associated Press - February 6th, 2024 [February 6th, 2024]
- Ukraine war: Baby killed in Russian strike on Kharkiv hotel - BBC.com - February 6th, 2024 [February 6th, 2024]
- "Miss Japan" winner from Ukraine renounces title amid scandal - Yahoo News - February 6th, 2024 [February 6th, 2024]
- Russian General may face 10 to 15 years in prison for personally ordering seizure of Ukraine's Kherson Oblast - Yahoo News - February 6th, 2024 [February 6th, 2024]
- Peace in Ukraine - The New York Times - February 6th, 2024 [February 6th, 2024]
- How Russia exploits footage of Ukraine's air defense systems, and how Ukraine can prevent it - Yahoo News - February 6th, 2024 [February 6th, 2024]
Tags: