Mediaboss Marketing

Until just the other day, Republicans and conservative media loved, just loved talking about the price of gasoline. Indeed, Remember how cheap gas used to be under Trump? became a sort of all-purpose answer to everything. Is there now overwhelming evidence that the former president conspired in a violent attempt to overthrow the 2020 election? Real America doesnt care about the January 6th Committee. Gas is over $5 a gallon! declared Representative Jim Jordan.

But now gas prices are falling. Theyre down more than 50 cents a gallon at the pump; wholesale prices, whose changes normally show up later in retail prices, are down even more, suggesting that prices will keep falling for at least the next few weeks. And theres a palpable sense of panic on Fox News, which has been reduced to whining about how the White House is taking a victory lap.

Actually, from what I can see, Biden administration officials are being remarkably restrained in pointing out the good news (which is probably a result of a slowing global economy). The larger point, however, is that Republican politicians focus on gas prices is profoundly stupid. And if its coming back to bite them, thats just poetic justice.

Why is focusing on gas prices stupid? Let me count the ways.

First, while presidential policy can have big effects on many things, the cost of filling your gas tank isnt one of them. For the most part, gasoline prices reflect the price of crude oil and crude prices are set on world markets, which is one reason inflation has soared around the world, not just in the United States. Government spending in the Biden administrations early months may have contributed to overall U.S. inflation we can argue about how much but has hardly anything to do with gas prices.

Second, while gas was indeed cheap in 2020, it was cheap for a very bad reason: Global demand for oil was depressed because the world economy was reeling from the effects of the Covid-19 pandemic.

Third, even before the pandemic struck, gas prices were unsustainably low.

Little-known fact: Prices at the pump plunged during President Barack Obamas second term, falling from about $3.70 a gallon in mid-2014 around $4.50 in 2022 dollars to $2.23 on the eve of the 2016 election. News reports at the time marveled at Obamas diffidence about claiming credit.

What happened? Mostly a boom in fracking, which increased U.S. oil production so much that it drove prices down around the world. As it turned out, however, that production boom didnt make financial sense. Energy companies borrowed huge sums to invest in new drilling but never generated enough revenue to justify the cost. The fracking industry lost hundreds of billions even before the pandemic struck.

So high gas prices werent President Bidens fault, and given the disappearance of the forces that used to keep gas cheap, its hard to think of any policy short of creating a global depression that would bring prices down to $2 a gallon, or even $3 a gallon. Not that Republicans are offering any real policy proposals anyway.

But the G.O.P. nonetheless went for the cheap shot of trying to make the midterm elections largely about prices at the pump. And this focus on gas is now giving the party a bellyache, as gas prices come down.

It is, after all, hard to spend month after month insisting that Biden deserves all the blame for rising gas prices, then deny him any credit when they come down. The usual suspects are, of course, trying, but its not likely to go well.

Some right-wing commentators are trying to pivot to a longer view, pointing out that gas prices are still much higher than they were in 2020. This happens to be true. But so much of their messaging has depended on voter amnesia on their supporters not remembering what was really going on in 2020 that I have my doubts about how effective this line will be.

More broadly, many Wall Street analysts expect to see a sharp drop in inflation over the next few months, reflecting multiple factors, from falling used car prices to declining shipping costs, not just gas prices. Market expectations of near-term inflation have come way down.

If the analysts and the markets are right, were probably headed for a period in which inflation headlines are better than the true state of affairs; its not clear whether underlying inflation has come down much, if at all. But thats not an argument Republicans, who have done all they can to dumb down the inflation debate, are well placed to make.

This has obvious implications for the midterm elections. Republicans have been counting on inflation to give them a huge victory, despite having offered no explanation of what theyd do about it. But if you look at the generic ballot which probably doesnt yet reflect falling gas prices rather than Bidens approval rating, the midterms look surprisingly competitive.

Maybe real Americans do care about violent attacks on democracy, overturning Roe v. Wade and so on after all.

If we continue to get good news on inflation, November may look very different from what everyone has been expecting.

Go here to read the rest:
Opinion | Why Republicans Are Having Gas Pains - The New York Times