How Low Can Taxes Go? Outside Washington, Republicans Find … – New York Times
The debate promises to test the enduring relevance of one of the most fundamental principles of modern conservatism supply side economics, the idea that if you cut taxes far enough, the economy will expand to the point that it generates new tax revenue.
With the federal deficit growing and economic growth sputtering along in the low single digits, the Republican Party is facing questions from within over what many see as a blind faith in the theory that deep tax cuts are the shot of economic adrenaline a languid economy needs.
Tax cuts good. And thats about as much thinking that goes into it, said Chris Buskirk, a radio host and publisher of American Greatness, a conservative online journal. Now, he said, Republicans in Washington seem to be in an arms race to the lowest rates possible.
Everybody is trying to overbid each other, Mr. Buskirk said. How much more can we cut?
Outside Washington, Republicans are discovering there are limits.
In South Carolina, Republicans overrode their governors veto and a blocked a filibuster to increase the gas tax. They also rejected a series of broader tax cuts on the grounds that they were too expensive and voted instead to create a smaller tax incentive for low-income families.
The Republican governor of Tennessee, Bill Haslam, signed into law the first increase in the states gas tax in almost three decades. He defied conservative groups that said a state with a $1.1 billion budget surplus had no business asking people to hand over more of their money.
And in the most striking rebuke of conservative tax policy in recent memory, Republicans in Kansas have undone much of the tax overhaul that Gov. Sam Brownback held up as a model for other states and the federal government to emulate.
A fantastic way to go, he said this year, urging Mr. Trump and Congress to follow suit with deep reductions to corporate and individual rates. But Republican lawmakers in Kansas decided that they could cut only so much without doing irreparable harm to vital services and voted to increase taxes by $1.2 billion last month. Mr. Brownback vetoed the plan, but Republicans overrode him.
Much of the devotion to tax cuts as an inviolable Republican principle stems from the success that President Ronald Reagan and Congress had in 1981 when they agreed to an economic recovery package that included a rate cut of about 25 percent for individuals.
But at that time, the highest marginal tax rates approached 70 percent, leaving much more to cut and a much larger chunk of money to be injected back into the economy. At some point, economists said, tax policy that is too aggressive leaves too little money to inject to make a difference.
Bruce Bartlett, who advised Reagan on the 1981 tax cuts, chastised Republicans for what he described as their reflexive desire to drive rates lower.
The essence of what the supply-siders were trying to accomplish was accomplished by the end of the Reagan administration, Mr. Bartlett said.
Yet, he added, Republican policy still mimics what was done under Reagan. Theyve got to keep pressing ahead no matter what, he said.
The situation in Kansas was, for at least some conservatives, a jolting realization that tax cuts can be too blunt an economic instrument.
After Mr. Brownback took office in 2011, he pursued a plan that included cuts and, in some cases, an outright elimination of taxes for businesses and individuals to help invigorate the states underperforming economy. He described it as an experiment in conservative governance that could demonstrate what Republicans were capable of if they controlled legislative and executive branches across the country. (He is Kansas first Republican governor since 2003.)
The conservative movement got behind him. The plan was approved with the lobbying muscle of the billionaire Koch brothers political network, which is overseen from Wichita, where one of the brothers, Charles G. Koch lives. It had the blessing of prominent conservative economists like Stephen Moore and Arthur Laffer, the Republican Partys foremost supply-side evangelist.
In urging the Kansas Legislature to act, Mr. Laffer and Mr. Moore said the cuts would have a near immediate positive impact on the economy. Mr. Brownback said the plan would pay for itself.
That is where the parallels with Washington start to trouble those who are critical of the plan the Trump administration has laid out. The plan would slash the rate paid by businesses to 15 percent and shrink the number of individual income tax brackets from seven to three 10, 25 and 35 percent.
Mr. Laffer and Mr. Moore, a Heritage Foundation economist, have both helped shape the presidents tax policy.
Steven T. Mnuchin, the Treasury secretary, said the Trump tax cuts would pay for themselves with the economic growth they would inevitably create.
In Kansas, the predicted economic bloom did not materialize. Employment and economic growth have lagged far behind the rest of the nation. The state treasury had so little money to spread around that the Kansas Supreme Court found that the states spending on public education was unconstitutionally low.
If there were three words I could say to Congress right now, said Stephanie Clayton, a Republican state representative from a district in the Kansas City area, they would be, Dont do it.
She criticized what she said was a desire by her party to be more faithful to the principle than to the people Republicans were elected to help. Mr. Brownback and many conservatives, she said, overpromised on the tax cuts as a sort-of Ayn Rand utopia, a red-state model, citing the author whose works have influenced the American libertarian movement.
And I loved Ayn Rand when I was 18 before I had children and figured out how the world really works, Ms. Clayton added. Thats not how it works, as it turns out.
Mr. Trump and Republicans in Washington are undeterred. Kansas, they argue, is not an economic microcosm for the country, with its unique dependence on energy, agriculture and aircraft manufacturing. And lawmakers there never could reduce spending enough to correspond to the much lower level of tax revenue coming into the state treasury.
Many conservatives who support a tax overhaul said they anticipated considerable growth with a reduction in corporate rates, which are among the highest in the world. If those are lowered to 15 percent, down from the current 35 percent, businesses will not only reinvest in the United States but relocate here, they said.
At 15 percent, Swiss bankers will move here, said Grover Norquist, president of Americans for Tax Reform.
But restraining federal spending is still going to be a key part of the equation. What you need is not an explosion of spending, Mr. Norquist added. And you need the economy to grow faster than the size of the government.
In a world in which Mr. Trumps deconstruction of the administrative state reduces the size and cost of the government, the tax cuts make sense. But if lawmakers do not have the nerve to find savings somewhere, like in the social safety net for retirees, the outcome could end up resembling something close to Kansas failed experiment.
The question is whether you can put together some kind of revenue-neutral tax reform, said N. Gregory Mankiw, a professor of economics at Harvard and chairman of the Council of Economic Advisers under President George W. Bush. I dont see the political will to do that right now. Certainly not in this environment.
A version of this article appears in print on July 3, 2017, on Page A10 of the New York edition with the headline: Cut Taxes? In States, G.O.P. Goes Other Way.
Read more:
How Low Can Taxes Go? Outside Washington, Republicans Find ... - New York Times
- Republican Con Artist From Queens Reports to Prison - Mother Jones - July 27th, 2025 [July 27th, 2025]
- Federal utility assistance program on the chopping block, but this Kentucky Republican has glowing reviews - WUKY - July 27th, 2025 [July 27th, 2025]
- Guess Which Texas Republican Was Just Accused of Paying for Abortions? - Yahoo Home - July 27th, 2025 [July 27th, 2025]
- Pa. Republican House members office vandalized with vulgar graffiti - PennLive.com - July 27th, 2025 [July 27th, 2025]
- Red River Republican Women hear from 8 Republican Congress candidates - Clarksville Now - July 27th, 2025 [July 27th, 2025]
- Here are the likely Democratic and Republican contenders for Wisconsin governor in 2026 - Milwaukee Journal Sentinel - July 24th, 2025 [July 24th, 2025]
- 'Shirts and Skins': How one Republican bridged the gap to pass Trump's 'big, beautiful bill' - Fox News - July 24th, 2025 [July 24th, 2025]
- This Republican senator wants Congress to have more oversight of D.C. - The Washington Post - July 24th, 2025 [July 24th, 2025]
- An Inland Empire Republican lawmaker wants to update rules for immigrant workers. Will Trump listen? - CalMatters - July 24th, 2025 [July 24th, 2025]
- RAW: Republican Rep. Comer plans to move "quickly" with issuing subpoena to DOJ on Epstein, Clintons - WAAY 31 News - July 24th, 2025 [July 24th, 2025]
- Congressman Flood named chair of the Republican Main Street Caucus in Congress - KTIV - July 24th, 2025 [July 24th, 2025]
- House Republican introduces companion bill to end China's buying of American farmland - Fox News - July 24th, 2025 [July 24th, 2025]
- Its really theft: the Republican plan to redraw Texas maps and grab more power - The Guardian - July 22nd, 2025 [July 22nd, 2025]
- Trump Flips Out at Republican Lawmaker Exposing the Party on Epstein - Yahoo Home - July 22nd, 2025 [July 22nd, 2025]
- Republican divide over Fed renovation grows - Semafor - July 22nd, 2025 [July 22nd, 2025]
- Opinion | Heres the most baffling part of the Republican budget bill - The Washington Post - July 22nd, 2025 [July 22nd, 2025]
- Exclusive | NY Young Republican Club urges Congress to disqualify Mamdani from NYC mayoral race accuses him of giving US enemies aid and comfort -... - July 22nd, 2025 [July 22nd, 2025]
- A Fourth Candidate, And First Republican, Ruth Bittner, Joins The Race To Fill Late Rep. Hortmans Vacant House Seat - Patch - July 22nd, 2025 [July 22nd, 2025]
- Republican Rep. Slams Mike Johnson Over Epstein Files As House Is Shut Until September To Block Vote - Latin Times - July 22nd, 2025 [July 22nd, 2025]
- Hernando County Republican Blaise Ingoglia sworn in as Florida CFO - Creative Loafing Tampa Bay - July 22nd, 2025 [July 22nd, 2025]
- Trump Flips Out at Republican Lawmaker Exposing the Party on Epstein - The New Republic - July 22nd, 2025 [July 22nd, 2025]
- Sarah McBride's first bill just passed Congress & not one Republican voted against it - Yahoo Home - July 22nd, 2025 [July 22nd, 2025]
- Pallone slams Republican cuts to beach replenishment funding: 'Theyre pulling the sand out from under us' - Insider NJ - July 22nd, 2025 [July 22nd, 2025]
- Murray, UW Medicine & Harborview CEOs Sound Alarm on How Republican Medicaid Cuts Will Devastate Hospitals, Threaten Specialty Care People in... - July 22nd, 2025 [July 22nd, 2025]
- DAVID MARCUS: Stephen Colberts character is the latest never-Trump Republican to fall - Fox News - July 20th, 2025 [July 20th, 2025]
- Inside the House Republican-led plot to defy Trump on the Epstein files - Axios - July 20th, 2025 [July 20th, 2025]
- One WA Republican chisels at the MAGA wall on immigration - The Seattle Times - July 20th, 2025 [July 20th, 2025]
- Republican rumblings: on Trump and the Epstein files - The Hindu - July 20th, 2025 [July 20th, 2025]
- What Musk's fracture with Trump means for GOPs future: Beating heart of the Republican Party - Fox News - July 20th, 2025 [July 20th, 2025]
- Whats in the Republican bill cutting $9 billion from public broadcasting and foreign aid - Hot Springs Sentinel Record - July 20th, 2025 [July 20th, 2025]
- Republican Miller, Democrat Berry discuss priorities ahead of Aug. 5 special election for 20th House district - Bay to Bay News - July 20th, 2025 [July 20th, 2025]
- Letters to the editor: Republican debt solution, response to Epstein - Macomb Daily - July 20th, 2025 [July 20th, 2025]
- Republican lawmakers trying to repeal governor's 400-year funding veto - WKOW - July 20th, 2025 [July 20th, 2025]
- Jill Biden aide invokes Fifth to decline testimony in Republican investigation - ABC News - July 20th, 2025 [July 20th, 2025]
- Tensions over Epstein files complicate Republican plan to vote on cuts bill - The Guardian - July 18th, 2025 [July 18th, 2025]
- Jill Biden aide invokes Fifth to decline testimony in Republican investigation - AP News - July 18th, 2025 [July 18th, 2025]
- 2004 to 2024, Part Two: When Each State Was at its Most Republican - Center For Politics - July 18th, 2025 [July 18th, 2025]
- Republican Scott Jensen to run for governor again in 2026, says state budgeting has been 'irresponsible' - 5 EYEWITNESS NEWS - July 18th, 2025 [July 18th, 2025]
- What's in the Republican bill cutting $9 billion from public broadcasting and foreign aid - yourvalley.net - July 18th, 2025 [July 18th, 2025]
- They took it to the next level: Emmer breaks down the Republican crypto rebellion - Semafor - July 18th, 2025 [July 18th, 2025]
- Whats in the Republican bill cutting $9 billion from public broadcasting and foreign aid - WOWK 13 News - July 18th, 2025 [July 18th, 2025]
- Republican Tax Bill Is a Losing Deal for Gamblers - The New York Times - July 18th, 2025 [July 18th, 2025]
- Mike Johnson Reacts to Republican Blowback Over Jeffrey Epstein - Newsweek - July 18th, 2025 [July 18th, 2025]
- JD Vance urges Republican voters to 'talk to your friends' about the 'big, beautiful bill' - NBC News - July 18th, 2025 [July 18th, 2025]
- Key Senate Republican thinks deal in the offing over FBI HQ location dispute - Politico - July 16th, 2025 [July 16th, 2025]
- Georgia's Raffensperger calls for return of donations after Republican donor accused of Ponzi scheme - Colorado Newsline - July 16th, 2025 [July 16th, 2025]
- Three Republican senators break with Trump to vote against codifying DOGE spending cuts - The Independent - July 16th, 2025 [July 16th, 2025]
- Moore taps Carroll County Republican, Army vet to head veterans department - Maryland Matters - July 16th, 2025 [July 16th, 2025]
- Key Senate Republican to meet with Trump on funding clawback request - Politico - July 16th, 2025 [July 16th, 2025]
- Gov. Kelly Ayotte vetoes Republican-backed bill aimed at banning certain books in schools - WMUR - July 16th, 2025 [July 16th, 2025]
- The Republican senators to watch on cutting PBS, NPR and foreign aid funding - Axios - July 16th, 2025 [July 16th, 2025]
- This small House Republican caucus held US stablecoin bill hostage until Trump cracked the whip - CryptoSlate - July 16th, 2025 [July 16th, 2025]
- Why more of Hobbs Arizona agency director nominees won Republican approval this year - KJZZ - July 16th, 2025 [July 16th, 2025]
- Homeland Security's Noem says in talks with five Republican-led states to build detention site - Reuters - July 14th, 2025 [July 14th, 2025]
- 'Danger of Musks potential third party is [splitting] Republican votes: Tanden - ABC News - Breaking News, Latest News and Videos - July 14th, 2025 [July 14th, 2025]
- Herridge to resign as West Virginia Republican chairman, focus on cabinet role - News and Sentinel - July 14th, 2025 [July 14th, 2025]
- Rep. Brendan Boyle: You need four Republican Senators to stand up and have the courage to vote, no - MSN - July 14th, 2025 [July 14th, 2025]
- The Frederick County Republican Central Committee wants to appoint candidates for the upcoming municipal elections in Frederick. But the filing... - July 14th, 2025 [July 14th, 2025]
- Raabe: On Monday, Remember The Greenwich Republican Party IS the National Republican Party - Greenwich Free Press - July 14th, 2025 [July 14th, 2025]
- 'Sacred Covenant' How the Paxton divorce rocks the bruising Republican Senate primary in Texas - Fox News - July 12th, 2025 [July 12th, 2025]
- Wisconsin businessman and Navy SEAL Bill Berrien launches Republican campaign for governor - WPR - July 12th, 2025 [July 12th, 2025]
- Redrawing Texas: the Republican plan to stack the decks for the midterms - The Guardian - July 12th, 2025 [July 12th, 2025]
- After recent vetoes, it's time for DeWine to restore Republican Party | Letters - Yahoo News - July 12th, 2025 [July 12th, 2025]
- Exclusive | The Republican Strategy to Win Without Trump on the Ballot - WSJ - The Wall Street Journal - July 12th, 2025 [July 12th, 2025]
- The Big Bad Republican Bill Wasnt Regressive Enough for the Anti-Tax Crusaders - Mother Jones - July 12th, 2025 [July 12th, 2025]
- Can the National Education Association Win Over Republican Members? - Education Week - July 12th, 2025 [July 12th, 2025]
- Texas keeps getting slammed by extreme weather catastrophes, but its Republican rulers remain contemptuous of climate science - Northwest Progressive... - July 12th, 2025 [July 12th, 2025]
- Exclusive | The Republican Strategy to Win Without Trump on the Ballot - WSJ - July 10th, 2025 [July 10th, 2025]
- Another Republican enters race to succeed Andy Barr in U.S. House - Kentucky Lantern - July 10th, 2025 [July 10th, 2025]
- Republican tax and spending cut megabill expected to take billions from Oregon Health Plan - Oregon Capital Chronicle - July 10th, 2025 [July 10th, 2025]
- Up Close with Bill Ritter: Republican nominee Curtis Sliwa on race for NYC mayor; Democrats try to unite behind Zohran Mamdani - ABC7 New York - July 10th, 2025 [July 10th, 2025]
- Exclusive / Moreno set to replace Tillis on Republican whip team - Semafor - July 10th, 2025 [July 10th, 2025]
- Chairman of Randall County Republican Party arrested for election fraud - KVII - July 10th, 2025 [July 10th, 2025]
- Republican Backs Push to Repeal Part of Trump Bill Days After Voting For It - Newsweek - July 10th, 2025 [July 10th, 2025]
- Republican The View Co-Host Admits to Crying Backstage at Least Half a Dozen Times - The Daily Beast - July 10th, 2025 [July 10th, 2025]
- Wisconsin Republican compares himself to Trump as he launches his bid for governor - AP News - July 10th, 2025 [July 10th, 2025]
- Opinion | Jeff Flake: The Republican Fever Must Break - The New York Times - July 8th, 2025 [July 8th, 2025]
- Two women accuse Republican state lawmaker of making unwanted sexual advances. He denies the allegations. - The Colorado Sun - July 8th, 2025 [July 8th, 2025]
- 1988: A year that echoes in Georgia Republican politics to this day - SaportaReport - July 8th, 2025 [July 8th, 2025]
- Manassas Republican Party Headquarters vandalized over July 4 weekend - Washington Times - July 8th, 2025 [July 8th, 2025]