Mediaboss Marketing

Netanyahu is out and the latest round of violence with Hamas is over, but progressives willingness to criticize Israel is here to stay.

A dozen Jewish House Democrats responded with a statement blasting Omar for an offensive and misguided comparison that give[s] cover to terrorist groups; the top six House Democratic leaders also pushed back on Omar for drawing false equivalencies" while thanking her for clarifying her remark.

That friendly fire toward Omar prompted speculation that the House could move to punish her, but no tangible threat materialized. In fact, a notable number of colleagues including Jewish Democrats and the Congressional Black Caucus defended Omar and insisted that she was being unfairly targeted because she is a Muslim woman.

She is attracting much more scrutiny than anybody, like a person like me, would. People are ready to parse every word that she says. And I just think thats unfair, said Rep. John Yarmuth (D-Ky.), a septuagenarian Jewish American who contended that he wouldn't face similar backlash for his agreement with Omars comment.

The idea that you cant mention the U.S., Israel and Hamas in the same sentence without being accused of being anti-Semitic? Thats just stupid, Yarmuth added.

Rep. John Yarmuth, D-Ky., the ranking member of the House Budget Committee, discusses the Republican efforts to replace "Obamacare," during a news conference on Capitol Hill in Washington on July 20, 2017. | J. Scott Applewhite/AP Photo

Even as Republicans leaped to deride Omar as antisemitic, it quickly became clear that the majority of Democrats simply wanted to move on. The 12 lawmakers who initially condemned Omar didnt push the issue further, and Republicans have edged away from their initial flirtation with forcing a vote to kick her off the Foreign Affairs Committee.

A greater number of Democrats used the moment to emphasize that they don't see criticism of the Israeli governments policies on its own as biased against Jewish people.

Do you believe in accountability for human rights, for war crimes? How can you believe in it for everybody except yourself, or your friends? said Rep. Andy Levin (D-Mich.), a Jewish American. That is what Representative Omar was actually saying. And since Ive taken that position myself for many years, why does everybody jump on her when she says it?

The rising number of defenders marks a victory for Omar and fellow progressives, who say their messaging on Israel is getting stronger and attracting more support from across the caucus and the party.

There were more Jews who didnt sign that letter than did, Yarmuth noted, describing the anti-Omar statement as an "overreaction" by the 12 Democrats. Some of the people probably regret that they did it.

Progressives were initially furious that the upper rung of Democratic leadership was so quick to push back on Omars comments. Still, Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.) later declined to characterize that response as a "rebuke," and Republicans viewed the cooling-down as their opponents effectively ceding a potential political cudgel.

The Democrat Party does not support Israel anymore, and theyre fine with helping a terrorist organization. Thats where they are, said Florida Sen. Rick Scott, who chairs the upper chamber's GOP campaign arm. Its a good issue for us.

Republicans have long sought to tie vulnerable Democrats to Omar and use her rhetoric as a political cudgel to paint the entire party as radical. During the latest round of fighting between Israel and Hamas, some GOP lawmakers went as far as to accuse Democrats of supporting the terror group because they were openly pushing for a ceasefire in defiance of then-Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu.

Liberals counter that their position is favorable on the political and policy merits, as a generational divide within the Democratic Party has elevated younger lawmakers' calls for a recalibration in U.S. policy toward Israel. Democrats should consider a foreign-policy doctrine that takes into account the alleged human-rights abuses by U.S. allies, these younger members say, and a party leadership dominated by octogenarians should be encouraging that discussion.

Young people really look at this through a secular and non-ethnic or cultural or national point of view, Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-N.Y.) said in an interview. Young people are saying, why are we paying for this? Why are we supporting this?

Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-N.Y.) listens as House Speaker Nancy Pelosi announces the creation of the Select Committee on Economic Disparity and Fairness in Growth. | J. Scott Applewhite/AP Photo

Ocasio-Cortez, a longtime Omar ally who's advocated for a tougher posture with Israel, said she often hears from young Jewish Americans who were raised with one narrative about the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, and they do not want their identity tied to this injustice.

One of several progressives pressing to put conditions on U.S. military aid to Israel, which is critical for its survival in the region, Ocasio-Cortez noted that she has long called for conditioning American aid money to various countries that are suspected of human-rights abuses, not just Israel.

Some lawmakers will confront such issues firsthand in the coming weeks. Rep. Gregory Meeks (D-N.Y.), chair of the House Foreign Affairs Committee, will lead a congressional delegation to Israel as early as July 5, according to multiple sources. The number of members and who is going remains fluid, but one source told POLITICO that Reps. Ann Wagner (R-Mo.) and Adam Kinzinger (R-Ill.) will be joining Meeks first such trip as chair.

Meanwhile, progressives who want to keep reevaluating the U.S.-Israel relationship often add a social justice component to their messaging, underscoring that theirs is an anti-establishment tack. Progressives and young Democrats in particular view the foreign-policy establishment in Washington which has encompassed a majority from both parties as a destructive force.

And after a springtime conflict that saw more Democrats expressing deep reservations with President Joe Bidens strategy of quiet, intensive diplomacy as Israel waged retaliatory strikes against Hamas assets in Gaza, liberals sense more of an appetite for taking on the traditional breed of foreign policy that Biden embodies.

Its a generational shift of prioritizing human rights and having a human-rights focus in American foreign policy, said Rep. Ro Khanna (D-Calif.). And its definitely a recognition that those rights include Palestinian human rights.

Sarah Ferris and Laura Barron-Lopez contributed.

Read more:
Progressives count their foreign policy wins with Omar flap in rear view - POLITICO