Progressive wins in Virginia are limited as long as Dillon’s Rule is on the books – scalawagmagazine.org
Last weeks elections delivered an overwhelming victory for progressives in Virginia, where Democrats solidified a majority in the General Assembly and candidates in local races followed suit. In Charlottesville, where the deadly white nationalist Unite the Right rally took place two years ago, voters elected a slate of progressive candidates to the city council, including an activist, Michael Payne, who is endorsed by the Democratic Socialists of America.
But the gap between electing progressive officials and enacting progressive policies is a wide one. An ongoing court battle over the Confederate statues at the center of the white nationalist rally shows how a little-known legal rule has been used to hamstring local democracy across the state.
On September 13, 2019, Charlottesville, Virginia Circuit Court Judge Richard Moore overruled the Charlottesville City Councils decision to remove its public statues of the Confederate generals Robert E. Lee and Stonewall Jackson.
The council had voted to remove the Lee statue in February 2017 and later voted to remove the Jackson statue. As the council voted to remove the monuments, the racist legacy of the Southern generals came into focus.
A national movement to remove Confederate monuments was gaining momentum after Dylann Roofs 2015 Confederacy-inspired massacre at the African American Mother Emanuel AME Church in Charleston. Following the white supremacist killings, statutes of Lee were targeted for removal. Many of the monuments had been erected by reactionaries in the early 1900s, by a movement to justify the Confederacy and reframe the Souths defeat in the Civil War. However, the myth that Lee somehow abhorred slavery has by now been intensely challenged. A piece in the The Atlantic in 2017 effectively debunked the myth, by making clear he held white supremacist views and treated his slaves brutally.
Two months after the councils decision to remove the Lee statute, a small group of local residents sued the city of Charlottesville, arguing the local government had overstepped its authority.
That August, white nationalists violently marched on the city at the Unite the Right rally to defend the statue. The rally would lead to the death of 32-year-old protester Heather Heyer, and two state officers who died in a helicopter crash while patrolling the rally.
In this context, Judge Moores ruling dealt an obvious blow to those seeking to challenge the rising tide of white supremacy. But theres another, critical implication that has received less attention. This lawsuit reaffirms a rule thats been thwarting progressive policy-making by cities and counties across the country.
Under Dillons Rule, there is no check on how far a state can go in usurping local democracy.
A lesser-known element of the lawsuit against the city is its argument that the city resolutions violated a century-old legal doctrine referred to in Virginia, as the Dillon Rule. That rule, also referred to as Dillons Rule, is named after a corporate railroad attorney and eventual judge named John F. Dillon. To this day, he is credited with pioneering a judicial attack on municipalities at the peak of post-Civil War Reconstructiona time of heightened African American electoral participation following the emancipation of slaves and expansion of suffrage to African American men.
Dillon became well-known for a legal treatise he wrote in 1873 called The Law of Municipal Corporations which raised alarms about local governments that were trying to redistribute wealth and expand democratic participation in local public services. Populations of urban immigrants were booming. At the time, there were numerous legal battles over local governments powers to tax property owners who were overwhelmingly whiteand set labor standards for city contractors. In a Yale University lecture, Dillon called laws that tax property discrimination legislation that infringes on property rights, and urged his audience to fear and guard against the despotism of the many,of the majority.
Similar arguments that upheld the rightful enjoyment of property, as he wrote, were at the time also being used to protect property owners rights to discriminate in private places, and shield them from taxation. His treatise arguedin reactionary fashionthat local governments only possess those powers which states explicitly grant them.
This idea has morphed into a legal doctrine that blankets the nation.
In 1891, the U.S. Supreme Court effectively applied Dillons Rule to all American communities by citing it in a ruling that said an Indiana town didnt have the authority to sell bonds. The Court later reaffirmed and broadened Dillons Rule in 1907. Since then, its been used to undermine community democracy in many states.
Just as it was used in the late 1800s, Dillons Rule was a tool the State of Michigan used to successfully defend dissolving the power of half a dozen majority African American city governments after the financial crisis of 2008 (including Detroit and Flint). It has been used to defend the Alabama State Legislatures restrictions on the governing powers of Birmingham, a majority-African American city, and other cities. Everywhere, it defines fundamental power dynamics. The rule is rigorously defended by the American Legislative Exchange Council, a conservative corporate-led, state-level policy network.
In communities across the nation, local movements are stymied from raising the minimum wage, governing the fossil fuel industry, heightening civil rights protections, and otherwise weighing in on key societal questions.
Some states, such as Michigan, identify as Home Rule states. There, local governments enjoy some assumed local self-governing authority. However, this authority is superficial compared to the deeper influence Dillons Rule wields, which allows state legislators to unilaterally redefine and restrict what those Home Rule powers are, at their whim. Home Rule did not protect the power of the Detroit and Flint city councils from being gutted.
Thats because, under Dillons Rule, there is no check on how far a state can go in usurping local democracy.
The impact of Dillons Rule in Charlottesville is not limited to the fight over statues. Following the white nationalist Unite the Right rally there was an effort to ban assault weapons in public spaces. That too was prohibited by Dillons Rule.
A local movement also successfully lobbied the city to pursue racial justice reforms. This activism led the city to consider affordable housing reforms that were seen as a benefit to the African American community. It was a concrete response to the white nationalist rally.
But, according to Dillons Rule, the city had limited power to enact meaningful affordable housing measures. The Virginia General Assembly hadnt granted the city authority to pass something as simple as an inclusionary zoning ordinance to require developers set aside a percentage of new developments as affordable. That reformmuch less anything strongeralso never went forward.
Charlottesville community members also mobilized to establish a stronger civilian review panel to process complaints against local police officers. These efforts were also stymied by the legislature, which, thanks to Dillons Rule, does not allow subpoena powers for Charlottesvilles review board.
This form of repression is not unique to Virginia, Alabama, or Michigan. In communities across the nation, local movements are stymied from raising the minimum wage, governing the fossil fuel industry, heightening civil rights protections, and otherwise weighing in on key societal questions.
However, despite the racially-disproportionate impacts of Dillons Rule, demands for more local democracy are often misunderstood and confused with demands for racist libertarianism. Thats why communities that work with Community Environmental Legal Defense Fund (CELDF), which I work for, challenges Dillons Rule in a way that maintains a commitment to state and federal protections for civil and human rights, while fighting for local communities rights to increase and expand those protections.
CELDF works with local governments and local grassroots groups that aim to make fundamental change to state constitutional law, including abolishing Dillons Rule. This means redefining state law as a floor that local governments have a right to build upon, in order to heighten protections for civil and human rightsjust as federal law acts as a floor upon which states can increase protections. It means recognizing some constitutional democratic powers for local democracy, and moving away from the system we have todaywhere states remain unconstrained in their repression of local laws.
This means redefining state law as a floor that local governments have a right to build upon, in order to heighten protections for civil and human rights.
CELDF has worked with nearly 200 municipalities and Native nations across ten states that have adopted laws that embody this vision. Our partners are advancing state constitutional change and have passed and advanced local laws that challenge Dillons Rule.
Opposition to Dillons Rule is gaining some momentum in Virginia, where CELDF has organized with communities. The new Democratic majority has made some promises about allowing local governments more authority to take down racist statues. However, its support for structural change to reverse Dillons Rule is far from clear. And it will take more than a simple electoral majority to make such transformative change.
In Charlottesville, the battle over statues continues. Supporters of the Confederate monuments are pressing the city to spend money to protect the statues from vandalism. The city on the other hand is now appealing Judge Moores ruling, arguing the statues send a racist message. They will likely get some help from the new legislature.
One Charlottesville activist I spoke to told me, I wish a thousand locals and [University of Virginia] students would put a chain over [the statutes] and pull them down.
Originally posted here:
Progressive wins in Virginia are limited as long as Dillon's Rule is on the books - scalawagmagazine.org
- Progressives want Ayanna Pressley, not Hakeem Jeffries, as the next House speaker - TheGrio - November 15th, 2026 [November 15th, 2026]
- California billionaire tax rejected in major setback for Bernie Sanders and progressives - The News International - November 15th, 2026 [November 15th, 2026]
- Most Progressives Want Chuck Schumer Replaced as Dem Leader. Over Half Want Hakeem Jeffries Out Too. - Yahoo - November 15th, 2026 [November 15th, 2026]
- AT THE MEDIA PRESENTATION OF FROM REFORMS TO PROSPERITY, ALL PROGRESSIVES CONGRESS 2027 PRESIDENTIAL CAMPAIGN - The State House, Abuja - November 15th, 2026 [November 15th, 2026]
- Why do progressives want to replace Hakeem Jeffries as speaker? Israel, Medicare for All and money - Nacionale - November 15th, 2026 [November 15th, 2026]
- What Greta Thunberg and US progressives can teach the indy movement - The National Scot - November 15th, 2026 [November 15th, 2026]
- Progressives are on the rise nationally. Will the midterms help them regain ground in S.F.? - San Francisco Chronicle - November 3rd, 2026 [November 3rd, 2026]
- Establishment Democrats And Progressives Can Agree On 1 Thing: Haley Stevens Is A Traitor - HuffPost UK - November 3rd, 2026 [November 3rd, 2026]
- When Fresno Progressives Look in the Mirror, Do They See Donald Trump? - GV Wire - November 3rd, 2026 [November 3rd, 2026]
- Progressives Embrace of Socialism Portends Chaos and Decline - The Daily Signal - November 3rd, 2026 [November 3rd, 2026]
- Ulsan Democrats and progressives denounce court over luxury handbag lobbying ruling, call for Kim Gi-hyeon to resign - - November 3rd, 2026 [November 3rd, 2026]
- Establishment Democrats And Progressives Can Agree On 1 Thing: Haley Stevens Is A Traitor - HuffPost - November 3rd, 2026 [November 3rd, 2026]
- NY progressives have found a way to vote for Hochul, with an asterisk - Gothamist - November 1st, 2026 [November 1st, 2026]
- What progressives see in Central Florida for the midterms and beyond - Politico - November 1st, 2026 [November 1st, 2026]
- Progressives must show parents their vision for home-based childcare - The Washington Post - November 1st, 2026 [November 1st, 2026]
- Olivia Chow elected as Toronto mayor for second term in victory for progressives - The Guardian - November 1st, 2026 [November 1st, 2026]
- Progressives pile on Kean with new stock-trading attack ad - New Jersey Globe - November 1st, 2026 [November 1st, 2026]
- At rally with Villegas, AOC, local progressives are hopeful - Hanford Sentinel - November 1st, 2026 [November 1st, 2026]
- Conservatives and progressives alike believe in the importance of providing young people with a quality education - Cleveland.com - November 1st, 2026 [November 1st, 2026]
- 3 moments from Troy Jackson and Elizabeth Warrens latest appeal to progressives - Bangor Daily News - November 1st, 2026 [November 1st, 2026]
- Flowers: Bishop believes he sinned against progressives - Delco Times - November 1st, 2026 [November 1st, 2026]
- Progressives celebrate Lulas win, while the right spits out its dummy (again) - Left Foot Forward - November 1st, 2026 [November 1st, 2026]
- US midterms: Progressives rally behind war criminal Obamas attacks on Trump - Middle East Eye - November 1st, 2026 [November 1st, 2026]
- Road to the Midterms: Rise of the progressives in Michigan - AOL.com - November 1st, 2026 [November 1st, 2026]
- US midterms: Progressives, moderates and the future of MAGA - CNA - November 1st, 2026 [November 1st, 2026]
- Some Progressives Tried To Abolish the Tipped Minimum Wage. Now They're Backtracking. - Reason Magazine - October 17th, 2026 [October 17th, 2026]
- As Rubio Heads to India, US Progressives Sound Alarm About Repression and Surveillance of Protests - Common Dreams - October 17th, 2026 [October 17th, 2026]
- Progressives, AIPAC and the future of the Democratic Party - Al Jazeera - October 17th, 2026 [October 17th, 2026]
- Progressives Are Backing Puerto Rican Independence. Its About Time. - Yahoo - October 17th, 2026 [October 17th, 2026]
- Calmatters: Big Tech And Big Business Are Spending Millions To Block Progressives On The California Ballot - SFGATE - October 17th, 2026 [October 17th, 2026]
- Progressives Dont Necessarily Deliver on Transportation at the State Level, Either - Streetsblog USA - October 17th, 2026 [October 17th, 2026]
- As Progressives Prosper, Centrist Democrats Are Moving the Goalposts - The New Republic - October 17th, 2026 [October 17th, 2026]
- No Such Thing as Progressives: The Coming-Out of the Korean-Style Left - - October 17th, 2026 [October 17th, 2026]
- Bernie Sanders and other progressives are coming to Florida to campaign with Democrat Angie Nixon - WLRN - October 17th, 2026 [October 17th, 2026]
- Mamdani Orders a Review of NYPD's Use-Of-Force Policies as Progressives Call for Greater Change - U.S. News & World Report - October 17th, 2026 [October 17th, 2026]
- Progressives Are Backing Puerto Rican Independence. Its About Time. - The Nation - October 17th, 2026 [October 17th, 2026]
- Minneapolis progressives turn on George Floyd-era public safety overhaul, push to dismantle office - Fox News - October 17th, 2026 [October 17th, 2026]
- A Progressives Guide to the Ballot by Eric Kirk: Yes, No, and Why - Redheaded Blackbelt - October 17th, 2026 [October 17th, 2026]
- Mamdani orders a review of NYPD's use-of-force policies as progressives call for greater change - Henry Herald - October 17th, 2026 [October 17th, 2026]
- Progressives, AIPAC & the future of the Democratic Party: Neera Tanden & Mehdi Hasan | Head to Head - Modern Ghana - October 17th, 2026 [October 17th, 2026]
- 'If Abdul can win in Michigan, anyone can win anywhere': Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez outlines stakes for progressives at NYC fundraiser - ABC News -... - October 6th, 2026 [October 6th, 2026]
- Progressives Performative Billionaire-Bashing Hurts the Cities They Govern - National Review - October 6th, 2026 [October 6th, 2026]
- Can Football Help Illinois Progressives Achieve Their Policy Goals? What Does the Magic 8 Ball Say? - River Cities' Reader - October 6th, 2026 [October 6th, 2026]
- Meet the 20-Somethings Raising Money for Top Progressives - Campaigns & Elections - October 6th, 2026 [October 6th, 2026]
- Progressives Saw Wins in DNC, But Battle for the Future of the Party Continues - Truthout - October 6th, 2026 [October 6th, 2026]
- Progressives Performative Billionaire-Bashing Hurts the Cities They Govern National Review - Wirepoints - October 6th, 2026 [October 6th, 2026]
- Matthew Syed: Condemn settlers, yes, but beware progressives sinister coalition - The Times - October 4th, 2026 [October 4th, 2026]
- For Progressives, Big Tech is Becoming the New Big Oil - theamericanconservative.com - October 4th, 2026 [October 4th, 2026]
- Progressives need their own story of national renewal Interviews - IPS Journal - October 4th, 2026 [October 4th, 2026]
- Michigan and California Races Test Progressives Broad Appeal - Bloomberg Government News - October 4th, 2026 [October 4th, 2026]
- What a year 2022 has been. So, now what progressives? Tell us your thoughts! - actionnetwork.org - October 4th, 2026 [October 4th, 2026]
- Good Morning, News: Mayor Campaigns Against Progressives, Cyclists Protest Moda Deal, and Trump Uses YOUR Money to Spread Hate - Portland Mercury - October 4th, 2026 [October 4th, 2026]
- Abdul El-Sayed Is Making Headway But Not Just With Progressives - Arab America - October 4th, 2026 [October 4th, 2026]
- The 'Progressives' are not yet ready to work in opposition or in the ruling coalition - Inbox.eu - October 4th, 2026 [October 4th, 2026]
- Progressives' party member expelled over nature of relations with minor / Article - LSM - October 4th, 2026 [October 4th, 2026]
- In North America, the most votes in the Saeima elections were cast for the 'Progressives', 'New Unity', and 'United List' - Inbox.lv - October 4th, 2026 [October 4th, 2026]
- So What Are Progressives Supposed to Do About Public Education? - Slate Magazine - September 28th, 2026 [September 28th, 2026]
- Opinion | Real progressives go to the library - The Pitt News - September 22nd, 2026 [September 22nd, 2026]
- Nikole Hannah-Jones and the hard bigotry of progressives - The Spectator - September 22nd, 2026 [September 22nd, 2026]
- The Kirkaversary speaks to the sickness of progressives - spiked-online.com - September 17th, 2026 [September 17th, 2026]
- Chicago mayor bets progressives will turn out for him in announcing reelection bid - Politico - September 17th, 2026 [September 17th, 2026]
- Republicans talk about the national debt. Its up to progressives to fix it. - ajc.com - September 17th, 2026 [September 17th, 2026]
- Mayor Johnson embarks on reelection bid, says hes best choice in race between real progressives and posers - Chicago Sun-Times - September 17th, 2026 [September 17th, 2026]
- Progressives Supply the Vocabulary. Islamists Supply the Narrative - The Times of Israel - September 17th, 2026 [September 17th, 2026]
- Hasan Piker cheerleads progressives as 80-year-old senator wins six more years - Fox News - September 8th, 2026 [September 8th, 2026]
- DNC Chair Ken Martin on progressives growing the Democratic coalition - Yahoo - September 8th, 2026 [September 8th, 2026]
- Bernie and Mamdani did it, can the rest of the progressives? Democracy and society - IPS Journal - September 8th, 2026 [September 8th, 2026]
- Merkur brings linked progressives and new cabinets to G2E 2026 - Yogonet - September 8th, 2026 [September 8th, 2026]
- Policy Pro: Council progressives push fall housing agenda - The Real Deal - September 8th, 2026 [September 8th, 2026]
- Transcript: How Progressives Can Revive the Police Reform Movement - The New Republic - September 8th, 2026 [September 8th, 2026]
- Progressives are learning the hard way how to survive Fox News - Politico - August 31st, 2026 [August 31st, 2026]
- Senator Markey fields national progressives to make his case in primary race against Moulton - The Boston Globe - August 31st, 2026 [August 31st, 2026]
- Progressives Warn Democrats Endlessly Invoking Hasan Piker to 'Get Their Shit Together' - Common Dreams - August 31st, 2026 [August 31st, 2026]
- In the Age of Trump, Progressives Should Stand Up for Sovereignty - Inkstick Media - August 27th, 2026 [August 27th, 2026]
- Aspiring politician? NJ progressives are actively recruiting candidates for 2027. - Gothamist - August 27th, 2026 [August 27th, 2026]
- Democrats and progressives wrestle with the Woke 1.0 era - Yahoo - August 27th, 2026 [August 27th, 2026]
- Democrats and progressives wrestle with the Woke 1.0 era - The Week - August 27th, 2026 [August 27th, 2026]
- Mass. primary is pitting new progressives against old-school organized labor - Spectrum News - August 27th, 2026 [August 27th, 2026]
- Are Too Many Vancouver Progressives Running for Mayor? - The Tyee - August 27th, 2026 [August 27th, 2026]
- Two Black Progressives Made History Tuesday Night. Neither Waited for Permission. - The Root - August 27th, 2026 [August 27th, 2026]