Mediaboss Marketing

It hurts to think back to election night. After a few hours of watching the votes come in with the people Id spent countless hours on the campaign trail with, the results were becoming clear.

The room felt suffocating, so I decided to take a walk alone. For a few minutes, I strolled along the Charles River, watching the soft glow from Weeks Bridge as an existential dread formed in my stomach. I walked in a heavy silence, thinking about the organizing and campaigning wed done, realizing that, although ultimately not enough, wed given it our all.

Katy Perry had a different election night, one that marked the end of her superficial campaign effortsan uninspiring performance at the Democratic National Convention, some selfies, and bizarre attempts to get her fans to vote. She held Lady Gagas hand in the Javits Center as the results came in, and said it was traumatizing when she heard that Senator Hillary R. Clinton would not be arriving to give an acceptance speech. She claims that the night was an awakening for her and that shes tried reflecting that in her new album, Witness.

A senior editor at Pitchfork wrote in a review of the album that [Katy Perrys] stated goal of making woke pop is, depending on how cynical you are, either admirable or shameless (or both), but either way, its not terribly effective. The album fails because Perry does not follow through on her commitment to social justice; she simply uses it as a selling point. On the album, shes featured homophobic artists, which seems to be in line with a career marked by anti-gay lyrics and blatant cultural appropriation. Katy Perry uses the so-called Resistance as a way of updating her brand, marketing her music, and making money.

When Katy Perrys performanceincluding painfully unoriginal statements on freedom on the Fourth of Julyisnt accepted as genuine, she gets frustrated and accuses critics of issuing vindictive clapbacks for the sake of conflict. Instead of focusing on what she can do for social justice, she worries about why people arent believing her act.

President Donald Trump is an easy punching bageven Perry has taken her shotswhich has made it easy to shirk personal responsibility to social justice while also claiming to care about progressive causes. Denouncing Trump is easy. Actively working against the sexism, xenophobia, and racism that fueled his political success is much harder and doesnt happen as often. The Womens Marches in January were powerful acts of protest, but they were still very white and cisgender. The impressive attendance at them was marred by the sense that some were only there for the the photo-op. Theres been a spike in these performative progressives, who strive to say the right thing without taking substantive action.

Katy Perry is one of the most high-profile examples of this phenomenon, but shes far from the only one. Kendall Jenner commodified the protests sweeping the country in an attempt to sell Pepsi. A recent SNL sketch depicted men at a bar who flirt with a woman by uttering popular feminist phrases before calling that woman a bitch when she rejects their advances. In New York Citys Washington Square Park last weekend, I saw a woman selling $3 Pins for the Resistance, and people lined up to buy them. The political movement for equality has slowly transformed itself into an aesthetic that allows people to be progressive on paper while upholding the status quo in person.

At Harvard, this attitude is clearest among discussions about final clubs. Although membership processes premised on gender exclusion and wealth generally select for a more conservative ideology, many final club members identify as progressive. They support progressive causes online and through membership in political groups on campus, but their performance ends as soon as they join a club. Their actions support institutions that foster class exclusion, gender discrimination, and unhealthy social dynamics on campus. Theyre progressive, but incredibly selective in their causes, which makes their work feel like a show.

The faculty recommendation to phase out social groups brought another set of performative progressives to the forefront. These individuals are progressive in most cases, writing passionately on Facebook about gender, sexuality, and racial equality, but turn a blind eye when discussing the exclusionary culture surrounding final clubs. Perhaps its because their social lives center around Mount Auburn St. Maybe they have friends in clubs who they see as good people, which blinds them to the structural issues that plague clubs. Maybe the idea of social exclusion doesnt seem antithetical to their progressive ideals, as if elitism werent founded on power imbalances. They say the right things, but then turn around and defend institutions that represent everything progressive movements aim to change.

The Resistance, the movement, the causeuse your term of choiceis not about individual gain or bolstering personal image. The ultimate goal should be the betterment of the oppressedcriminal justice reform, curtailment of sexism, equality in both principle and practice. Performative and selective progressives, with their hollow words and convenient blind spots, do nothing to bring us closer to these goals. Its time we stop performing our politics and instead head to the streets as organizers, protesters, and community builders dedicated to making real progress.

Ruben E. Reyes Jr. 19, a Crimson Editorial Chair, is a History and Literature concentrator in Leverett House. His column appears on Mondays.

PROF. HART A CANDIDATE

Professor Albert Bushnell Hart '80, of the department of Government, was nominated for the Massachusetts Senate on the Progressive ticket

Progressive Rally Tonight

A meeting of New England Progressives will be held in Tremont Temple this evening at 8 o'clock. Charles Sumner 'Bird

SUFFRAGE TALK IN EMERSON

Miss Helen Todd, of San Francisco, will lecture ion Emerson D this evening at 8 o'clock. She will speak under

On the Shelf

The current issue of the Harvard Progressive is by all odds the best of the three thus far published. Pessimists

Recap: You Get What You Need Devastating and Magnificent

Read the original post:
Performative Progressives | Opinion | The Harvard Crimson - Harvard Crimson