A Chaotic Display of Conservatism at the First Republican Debate – The New Yorker
An hour into Wednesday nights Republican Presidential debate, which took place without the front-runner, Donald Trump, a simple, altogether predictable question unsettled the proceedings. If former President Trump is convicted in a court of law, Fox News Bret Baier asked the candidates, Would you still support him as your partys choice? Please raise your hand if you would.
Ron DeSantis, the governor of Florida, looked left, then right, seeming unsure; Mike Pence, on whom the complications of Trumps alleged crimes hang heaviest, hesitated, too. After a moment, both raised their hands, a grudging show of support for their President and rival. In the end, of the eight candidates who qualified for the debate stage, only Asa Hutchinson, the former governor of Arkansas, kept his hand down. Chris Christie, the former governor of New Jersey, half raised an index finger, which he flicked in the air while shaking his head, a gesture, he later said, meant to ask the moderators for a chance to explain why he would not support Trump. For a generation, Republican politicians have appeared on Fox News and known what to say to their base. But, in last nights debate, there was uncertainty on Ukraine, climate change, even abortion. The Presidential candidates no longer seemed so sure that they knew what their voters wanted them to say.
The line going into the evening had been that the assembled Presidential candidates looked a little small and lacking in star wattage without Trump. Could you really imagine any of them winning this thing? Maybe the real action was on Tucker Carlsons X account, where a pre-recorded video of Trump being very gently interviewed was aired as counterprogramming. But a more interesting possibility emergedthat Trump had opened up fissures in conservatism that neither he nor any of his rivals really knew how to close. An early question about climate change (which the hosts introduced by giving a brief but admirable rundown of this summers extreme weather events) gave an indication of how the night would go. Vivek Ramaswamy, a biotech entrepreneur turned anti-woke crusader, declared that the climate-change agenda is a hoax. Nikki Haley, who was formerly Trumps U.N. Ambassador and the governor of South Carolina, counterpunched: Is climate change real? Yes, it is.
Those two candidates formed the debates poles. Ramaswamywho seemed to personally annoy just about everyone else on the stage (Christie, at one point, dismissed him as a guy who sounds like ChatGPT)gleefully took up the MAGA banner. Haley, who seemed to sense a vacuum, went after Trump for hypocrisy on spending and for being the most disliked politician in America. On abortion, DeSantiss defense of Floridas six-week abortion ban, and Mike Pences unsupported insistence that seventy per cent of the country backed a national pro-life agenda were met by Haleys get-a-grip realism. But seventy per cent of the Senate does not, she said.
It wasnt as if all of the Republican talking points had disappeared (there was general enthusiasm for a literal war on drug cartels), but, on certain high-profile issues, a genuine debate unfolded. After Ramaswamy made the case for ending U.S. support for Ukraine, Christie gave a characteristically gruesome evocation of the horrors of Russian war crimes. Thousands of Ukrainian children, Christie said, have been abducted, stolen, ripped from their mothers and fathers, and brought back to Russia to be programmed to fight their own families. They have gouged out peoples eyes, cut off their ears, and shot people in the back of the headmenand then gone into those homes and raped the daughters and the wives who were left as widows and orphans. The most unexpected thought entered my head. Was this, against all odds, a good debate? And the truth is, without any of the candidates especially impressing, it sort of was.
All seven men onstage wore dark-blue suits with white shirts and red tiesin costume, at least, Trump was everywhere. In the center of the stage were DeSantis and Ramaswamy, running second and third in the polls, though each far behind Trump. Both are fast talkers, tending toward one and a quarter speed, and terrible smilers: Ramaswamy oversmiles, all teeth and gums, and DeSantis sort of winces. The stakes were perhaps the highest for DeSantis, once considered Trumps co-front-runner, whose position has been eroding since he announced in May. His speeches, which seemed the most rehearsed of anyones onstage, groped for an audience that he could never quite find. The old crowd-pleasers failed him. At one point, DeSantis practically shouted George Soros, drawing only a smattering of applause. When he tried to pivot away from a politically tricky question about January 6th by thundering, We need to end the weaponization of these federal agents, Baier and his co-moderator, Martha MacCallum, bellowed back, Thats not the question! The Florida governor said, a little meekly, I know.
Both DeSantis and Ramaswamy are young politicians (forty-four and thirty-eight years old, respectively) who have surged to the front of the field by rhyming their politics with Trumps. Last night, they were flanked by older, more obviously scarred Republicans, many of whom had twined their fates with Trump earlier in his history and come to regret it. Pence, most scarred of all, got a nice moment when the moderators asked whether he had done the right thing by standing up to Trump on January 6th. Absolutely, he did the right thing, Senator Tim Scott, of South Carolina, said. Christie added, Mike Pence stood for the Constitution, and he deserves not grudging credithe deserves our thanks as Americans. But Pences worn applause lines landed as flatly as some of DeSantiss. When he criticized Democrats for defunding the police, there were crickets. Haleys opening remarks, which attacked the Trump Administration for having swelled the deficit, seemed to capture the pathos of Pences position. He, despite having broken with his former boss, was the one forced to defend the Trump Administrations bad policies, while Trump himself, routing the field, had simply decided not to attend.
Ever since Trumps ascent, nearly a decade ago, both his supporters and opponents have entertained a fantasy vision of the Republican Party, in which the conflict between the MAGA-verse and Trumps opponents would be firmly settled, with one side taking over the Party for good. But Trumps success has been partialenough to raise doubts about the old consensus, on everything from foreign policy to deficits, without really establishing a new one. And so, beneath the iron grip that Trump has on the polls is the interesting mess of a party on display in last nights debate, in which everyone vowed himself a staunch conservative but no one seemed to really agree on what conservatism means.
In the run-up to the debate, there had been reminders of the worse fates that Pence, Haley and Christie had ducked: more than a dozen of Trumps co-conspirators were indicted in Georgia, alongside the former President, for allegedly participating in his scheme to reverse the outcome of the 2020 Presidential election; earlier in the day, Rudy Giuliani was photographed apparently headed into a bail bondsmans office. Perhaps fortified by those images, the Republican candidates were, as a group, more openly critical of Trump than leaders in their party have been in a very long time. But they also showed that they havent yet managed the critical next step: articulating a plausible different direction.
See original here:
A Chaotic Display of Conservatism at the First Republican Debate - The New Yorker
- Mike Pence says GOP voters didnt turn left but were turned off in midterms: Full interview - NBC News - November 15th, 2026 [November 15th, 2026]
- Mike Pence is raising SERIOUS QUESTIONS about potential conflicts of interest in the Trump admin... His criticisms include: A reported $1 BILLION... - November 15th, 2026 [November 15th, 2026]
- Mike Pence surprisingly turns against 'rejected' Donald Trump with 2028 run - Daily Express US - November 15th, 2026 [November 15th, 2026]
- Mike Pence Says Democratic Win in Midterms was a 'Reckoning': 'We Stopped Short and Didn't Finish It' - OK Magazine - November 15th, 2026 [November 15th, 2026]
- Former VP Mike Pence blames Trump, tariffs, for Dems midterm blue wave - Boston Herald - November 13th, 2026 [November 13th, 2026]
- Jimmy Fallon Lights Up Mike Pence With Scathing Heated Rivalry Gay Joke - TheWrap - November 13th, 2026 [November 13th, 2026]
- Trump's Former VP Mike Pence Issues Warning Over JD Vance's Stance on Israel and Ukraine as He Urges Prez to 'Finish the Job' in Iran - RadarOnline - November 13th, 2026 [November 13th, 2026]
- Jon Kyl waiting to be sworn-in by Vice President Mike Pence during a reenactment ceremony on Sept. 5, 2018, in Washington. Sen. Kyl was officially... - September 24th, 2026 [September 24th, 2026]
- Mike Pence says he has 'no plans' to run for president in 2028 - IndyStar - September 17th, 2026 [September 17th, 2026]
- Mike Pence warns this Trump move would send a deafening message to Putin - Fox News - September 17th, 2026 [September 17th, 2026]
- Watch Mike Pence reacts to Donald Trump's warning on Ukrainian strikes - The Story - FOX One - September 17th, 2026 [September 17th, 2026]
- Exclusive: Nancy Pelosi and Mike Pence shared an emotional embrace at the Yale Leadership Institute - fortune.com - September 17th, 2026 [September 17th, 2026]
- MIKE PENCE: Remember the fallen and the generation that defended America since 9/11 - Fox News - September 17th, 2026 [September 17th, 2026]
- 'True American hero': Former VP Mike Pence receives Foley Award in Spokane for actions during capitol insurrection - The Spokesman-Review - September 17th, 2026 [September 17th, 2026]
- Mike Pence reveals Trump's brutal two-word reply after he told him he would pray for him post-Jan. 6 - AOL.com - September 17th, 2026 [September 17th, 2026]
- Mike Pence Warns Trump 'The Last Thing We Need' Is a Canada Trade War, Says Tariffs Could Hurt American Families and Businesses - Yahoo - August 29th, 2026 [August 29th, 2026]
- See Mike Pence through the years, from Indiana governor to vice president - IndyStar - August 25th, 2026 [August 25th, 2026]
- Mike Pence, Keith Kellogg join International Forum of Conservative Politics in Kyiv - Ukrinform - August 25th, 2026 [August 25th, 2026]
- See Mike Pence through the years, from Indiana governor to vice president - Yahoo - August 25th, 2026 [August 25th, 2026]
- Mike Pence Warns Trump 'The Last Thing We Need' Is a Canada Trade War, Says Tariffs Could Hurt American F - Benzinga - August 25th, 2026 [August 25th, 2026]
- Mike Pence says trade tensions with Canada are hurting American families, economy - WPLG Local 10 - August 25th, 2026 [August 25th, 2026]
- Mike Pence warns Trump hell have to go in and finish the job in Iran - AOL.com - August 25th, 2026 [August 25th, 2026]
- Why This CNN Host Slobbered All Over Mike Pence This Weekend - KSLM Radio - August 25th, 2026 [August 25th, 2026]
- Former VP Mike Pence to return to Western Pa. college for third year - WTAE - August 23rd, 2026 [August 23rd, 2026]
- Mike Pence warns Trump hell have to go in and finish the job in Iran - the-independent.com - August 23rd, 2026 [August 23rd, 2026]
- Mike Pence will speak, autograph books in Indy. Here's how to get tickets - IndyStar - August 23rd, 2026 [August 23rd, 2026]
- Its in the U.S.s national interest: Mike Pence promised in Kyiv to urge Americans to support Ukraine - shelter.in.ua - August 23rd, 2026 [August 23rd, 2026]
- Mike Pence to Return to Grove City College this Fall - Erie News Now - August 23rd, 2026 [August 23rd, 2026]
- Tix on sale for TU Patriotic Constitution Day Luncheon Featuring Mike Pence - Citizen Tribune - August 18th, 2026 [August 18th, 2026]
- Former VP Mike Pence to teach in Colorado as visiting faculty member - KKTV - August 11th, 2026 [August 11th, 2026]
- Indiana Historical Society to host talk, book signing with Mike Pence - dailyjournal.net - August 11th, 2026 [August 11th, 2026]
- Vice President Mike Pence to Travel to the Republic of Korea, Japan, Indonesia, Australia, and Hawaii - pacom.mil - August 5th, 2026 [August 5th, 2026]
- Mike Pence Confident Trump Will Eventually Snap on Iran - Yahoo - August 5th, 2026 [August 5th, 2026]
- OPINION: WSUs decision to honor Mike Pence is a slap in the face and a stab in the back - The Daily Evergreen - July 24th, 2026 [July 24th, 2026]
- Mike Pence to receive WSU Foley award in Spokane - The Daily Evergreen - July 24th, 2026 [July 24th, 2026]
- MIKE PENCE: Here's where we should look for the leadership America needs now more than ever - Fox News - July 21st, 2026 [July 21st, 2026]
- Mike Pence says Trump was right on Iran ahead of Spokane event - NonStop Local KHQ - July 21st, 2026 [July 21st, 2026]
- Former Vice President Mike Pence to visit Spokane to receive WSU's Thomas S. Foley Award - The Spokesman-Review - July 18th, 2026 [July 18th, 2026]
- Foley Distinguished Public Service Award to be received by former Vice President Mike Pence - WSU Insider - July 18th, 2026 [July 18th, 2026]
- Mike Pence to receive Foley Award at Gonzaga on Sept. 10 - KXLY.com - July 18th, 2026 [July 18th, 2026]
- Former VP Mike Pence to receive award in Spokane - KXLY.com - July 18th, 2026 [July 18th, 2026]
- Mike Pence calls Lindsey Graham an American patriot and a voice for freedom - Yahoo - July 18th, 2026 [July 18th, 2026]
- Mike Pence to visit Spokane in September to receive award - NonStop Local KHQ - July 18th, 2026 [July 18th, 2026]
- MIKE PENCE: The next generation needs faith in God and confidence in the American ideal - Fox News - July 6th, 2026 [July 6th, 2026]
- The American Experiment Interviews Revealed: What Hillary Clinton and Mike Pence Say in Netflix Documentary - IMDb - June 26th, 2026 [June 26th, 2026]
- The MOU 'falls far short' of what the US should be 'demanding': Mike Pence - Fox News - June 22nd, 2026 [June 22nd, 2026]
- VIDEO: Former Vice President Mike Pence on His New Book, Party Politics, and Texas - The Texan - June 22nd, 2026 [June 22nd, 2026]
- Why Mike Pence disagrees with Trump on his Iran strategy - The Hill - June 22nd, 2026 [June 22nd, 2026]
- Mike Pence Torches Trumps Ill-Advised Peace Deal With Iran: Much Bigger Than a Mistake - Yahoo - June 22nd, 2026 [June 22nd, 2026]
- Mike Pence turns on Trump over Iran appeasement - The Telegraph - June 22nd, 2026 [June 22nd, 2026]
- Mike Pence is done running for president but hes not done fighting for the soul of the GOP - Washington Examiner - June 16th, 2026 [June 16th, 2026]
- Ex-VP Mike Pence casts doubt on US and Iran peace deal | The Hill Sunday - NewsNation - June 16th, 2026 [June 16th, 2026]
- What Conservatives Believe: Vice President Mike Pence Shares His Vision for the Future of the GOP - Richard Nixon Foundation - June 12th, 2026 [June 12th, 2026]
- Mike Pence: Conservatives Have Forgotten What They Believe - The Free Press - June 12th, 2026 [June 12th, 2026]
- Bill Maher Confronts Mike Pence Over Death Threats From Jan. 6 Rioters - HuffPost - June 12th, 2026 [June 12th, 2026]
- Mike Pence says Jan. 6 rioters who assaulted police "never should have been pardoned" on 'Real Time With Bill Maher' - decider.com - June 12th, 2026 [June 12th, 2026]
- Mike Pence criticizes Trump's 'lawfare' fund that may help Jan. 6 rioters - IndyStar - May 25th, 2026 [May 25th, 2026]
- Mike Pence criticizes Trump's 'lawfare' fund that may help Jan. 6 rioters - myupnow.com - May 25th, 2026 [May 25th, 2026]
- Fact Check: No Male Prostitute Was Found Dead In Home Of Mike Pence -- Fake Story From Facebook 'Comedian' - Yahoo - May 25th, 2026 [May 25th, 2026]
- Mike Pence criticizes Trump's 'lawfare' fund that may help Jan. 6 rioters - Elko Daily Free Press - May 25th, 2026 [May 25th, 2026]
- Mike Pence Warns Trump Has Turned the GOP Into a Populist Party and Brings Receipts - Latin Times - May 13th, 2026 [May 13th, 2026]
- Mike Pence eyes the future as kingmaker, not candidate - MS NOW - May 3rd, 2026 [May 3rd, 2026]
- Mike Pence says Trump should back off the Pope, offensive Jesus pics - The Independent - April 25th, 2026 [April 25th, 2026]
- President Trumps Former VP Mike Pence Claims Hes Never Spoken to JD Vance: Hes Changed His Views - Globe Magazine - April 25th, 2026 [April 25th, 2026]
- College Station man arrested at Texas A&M after shouting profanities at former VP Mike Pence - KBTX News 3 - April 25th, 2026 [April 25th, 2026]
- Mike Pence Advises Trump to Back Down in Pope Feud After Blasting Offensive Jesus Meme - Yahoo News UK - April 25th, 2026 [April 25th, 2026]
- Mike Pence Breaks Silence With Tough Message To Trump Over Tariffs And Jesus Image - The Kenya Times - April 25th, 2026 [April 25th, 2026]
- Mike Pence warns JD Vance to avoid Obama-style Iran deal as nuclear talks set to begin in Pakistan - Fox News - April 10th, 2026 [April 10th, 2026]
- Mike Pence urges Trump to 'finish the job' as pressure mounts on Iran - Fox News - April 10th, 2026 [April 10th, 2026]
- Mike Pence warns JD Vance to avoid Obama-style Iran deal as nuclear talks set to begin in Pakistan - AOL.com - April 10th, 2026 [April 10th, 2026]
- Mike Pence Warns JD Vance To Avoid Obama-Style Iran Deal As Nuclear Talks Set To Begin In Pakistan - wowo.com - April 10th, 2026 [April 10th, 2026]
- From rivals to allies, Mike Pence and Jeff Flake advocate for conservative values - Deseret News - March 28th, 2026 [March 28th, 2026]
- Mike Pence criticizes Jan. 6, but not Trump himself, in ASU remarks - azcentral.com and The Arizona Republic - March 28th, 2026 [March 28th, 2026]
- Mike Pence To Speak At UChicagos Institute Of Politics In April - Block Club Chicago - March 26th, 2026 [March 26th, 2026]
- Staff revolts, secret meetings: Inside the tense fight between Mike Pence and the Heritage Foundation - CNN - March 26th, 2026 [March 26th, 2026]
- Former VP Mike Pence On War In Iran: Finish the job once and for all | NewsNation - PIX11 - March 17th, 2026 [March 17th, 2026]
- Former VP Mike Pence On War In Iran: Finish the job once and for all | NewsNation - wspa.com - March 17th, 2026 [March 17th, 2026]
- MIKE PENCE: Trump and our incredible military are ending 47 years of Iranian terror - Fox News - March 13th, 2026 [March 13th, 2026]
- Mike Pence: History will record Trump 'made the right call' - CNN - March 7th, 2026 [March 7th, 2026]
- Debating the Ex-IDF Spokesman About the War in Iran on Piers Morgan's Show, with Mike Pence - Glenn Greenwald | Substack - March 7th, 2026 [March 7th, 2026]