As migrant workers prepare to leave megacities, fixing gaps in PDS and DBT will be key to preventing… – Firstpost
I dont see the pandemic but the hunger and starvation that comes with it as the reason for large scale unrest, says Manaswini Bhalla, an associate professorof Economics at IIM Bangalore.
The context was the sorry plight of migrant and daily wage labourers stuck in the bigger cities due to the coronavirus lockdown.
Now the migrants can go home, says the government
With most migrant workers confined to shelters and dependent on charity for survival, the Union governments belated realisation that they should be allowed to get home is no doubt welcome. But there is much that is inexplicable about the Centres guidelines on how this is to happen.
Migrant workers take a break as they walk during a nationwide lockdown from Hyderabad to their village in Maharashtra. AP
It is good in principle, but I am not sure enough thought has been given to the modalities of this migration, says Divya Ravindranath, researcher at the Indian Institute of Human Settlements (IIHS).
The timing is the most inexplicable of all. Though lockdown has been extended, industry all over the country is being told to restart. Other measures and lockdown relaxations to slowly restart other segments of the economy are also in the works in all states. After weeks of idleness and no income, the migrant workers, hailing mainly from the eastern states and spread largely across the south and west of the country, could possibly at last see some hope of being able to start earning again, as a restarting economy is going to need this labour in the coming weeks.
Yet, after ignoring their sorry plight for nearly two months, the Centre is now suddenly telling the workers they can go home if they want to, with no guideline on how or from where industry will get the replacement labour they need to restart if migrant labour leaves.
This has led, for instance, to Karnatakachief minister BS Yeddyurappa appealing to migrant workers to stay back, but refraining from any mention of how the state will help them with food and/or money in the meantime.
The guidelines are also silent on how labourers stuck in high containment zones like Mumbai, Chennai, Ahmedabad, Surat and Delhi will be allowed to leave.
In the past week or so, the railways have run a few shramik (labourer) trains from places like Kerala, Telangana, Mumbai and Nashik to destinations in Jharkhand, Madhya Pradesh, Odisha, Uttar Pradesh and Bihar. But permission to get on those trains are ridden with so many ifs and buts, it would make anyones head spin.
A hazy future
What after these people reach home? That, again, is a question that has not been given any thought at all. My biggest concern is about what happens when they get back, said Divya.
What awaits these workers back home is not a better life and jobs, but being sent to quarantine centres of dubious quality before they can head to their villages.
The city is a place of economic stability, the village is the place for social security, is the reason given by Prof Chinmay Tumble of IIM Ahmedabad and author of India Moving: History of Migration, for the desperation among migrant workers to get back home.
Given that these journeys cost money that many of these workers can ill afford, the unintended effect of this decision to get migrants back home could be a feeling among them of insult being piled on injury. To what extent, and to what effect, the feeling will manifest itself is the question.
How life pans out for them in the next few weeks will provide the answer. And the first flashpoint could well be the kind of welcome workers sent on forced leave get when they return to their old places of work and on whether they get any part of their lost wages.
Every trade and industry association has said that they cannot pay workers the April salaries, or even restart their establishments, without substantial government bailouts. Which means going back to their shanties and temporary shelters and, hopefully, some dry ration packets.
Mitigating hunger
In Bengaluru, provision of cooked food is being stopped from 5 May, but no state authority is talking about how the workers are expected to survive without such help. That, despite all this, there have been only sporadic instances of unrest among migrant workers in Surat, Telangana, Chennai, Pune and Bangalore, but that is no indication that it will not spread or get more intense.
While angry reactions may have surfaced in some places, I would refrain from labelling them in any way, says Divya.
Migrant workers wait to board a special train to Agra in Uttar Pradesh at a railway station in Ahmedabad in Gujarat. AP
But as Professor Mahalaya Chatterjee, Centre for Urban Economic Studies, Calcutta University, points out, Social violence can arise from poorer sections of non-migrants too.
As lockdown eases, Professor Chatterjees view is that the problem needs to be looked at from three time spans: just after the lockdown is lifted, the next three months and the long run.
The PDS system needs to be strengthened immediately to ensure essential items reach the entire poorer sections with local bodies helping in identifying and reaching the needy, says Professor Chatterjee.
Soon after lockdown is lifted, there could be reverse flow of people in both directions those stuck in the cities will take the first chance to go back while people who can return, will rush to reclaim their old jobs, he says.
Professor Chatterjees prognosis for the long run is not optimistic.
There are chances that most small traders/manufacturers will be unable to open their business as before. So, loss of livelihood and mass unemployment may result in social unrest, she says.
Noted economist and former Reserve Bank Governor Raghuram Rajan too expressed a similar sentiment in his conversation with former Congress President Rahul Gandhi, saying India should use its DBT network to protect livelihoods and keep people from going into the streets protesting.
Outside the ambit of state welfare
While many people Citizen Matters spoke with preferred to wait and watch how the situation develops post 4 May, all pointed to the shortcomings in the present system for providing relief to the poor and the potential fallout from those left out of these relief packages for whatever reason.
The numbers of such workers run into thousands, if not lakhs, in every major city. There is no official system anywhere to count them or record their presence.The Aadhar card has become an enigma as are other identification instruments like ration cards, etc, says Professor Chatterjee.
If food riots happen, it will not be because of scarcity but due to maldistribution and lack of money in the hands of the needy, he warns.
Getting money into the hands of the poor
There is no shortage of suggestions from citizens and business federations on how to put money in the hands of the needy, though. The governments own recent garib kalyan package deposits a paltry amount monthly in Jan Dhan accounts. But the scheme ignores the fact that many migrant and daily wage labourers do not have such accounts which qualify for the transfer.
Rules have been framed to register such workers so as to enable them to access government schemes. But the rules dont work as a rule, as Divya points out: To give one example, every migrant construction worker is required to renew his registration with the construction welfare board annually (which entails a fee plus a daunting process). Why would a migrant worker want to renew that when he gets nothing by registering in the first place?
The biggest issue, in the end, is the trust deficit between the poor and the marginalised and the government, which this pandemic could reinforce in unexpected ways.
Hunger and poverty have been present in India for long without necessarily resulting in violent protests, said Chandan Gowda, faculty member at Azim Premji University, Bengaluru. But the signs of unrest among the millions of migrant workers under lockdown has made visible the massive problems of rural India, which largely induced many to move into cities as migrant workers in the first place.
A more serious crisis in the making?
Those problems are not going to go away any time soon. And little anecdotal evidence of the experience of those who have managed to get back to their villages has as yet filtered back to the cities.
If and how the economy reboots in the cities, and the kind of employment it will generate, is anybodys guess. But what is clear is that the workers left behind in the cities are not looking for charity. Sure, they accept it to survive, but what they really crave is the dignity of earning a living, which the coronavirus has snatched from them without warning.
The best hope for the migrant and daily wage workers to get back their livelihood in some measure remains in the metros, as it has been for many years. The problems that large-scale reverse migration will create in the rural areas is yet to be considered. Conditions everywhere have changed beyond recognition, and competition for jobs and resources will be fierce, in the cities in particular.
Migrant workers wait for transportation to take them back to their home states in Ahmedabad. AP
There have been instances of returning residents being refused entry into their own villages, with signs saying outsiders are not welcome. This indicates another, as yet unrealised, potentially volatile factor thrown into the mix of search for jobs and livelihoods, especially in urban areas: locals versus outsiders.
When too many people compete for the same limited economic resource, the first instinct is to find a scapegoat for ones problems. The vulnerable migrant worker presents an easy target.
Unfortunately, the cities where they worked and settled have always been indifferent to their wellbeing. They were just cheap labour. Now, if poverty and hunger make them want to go back, the general attitude is that it is their problem. The shramik special trains can take a few thousand of them back. For the rest, whose numbers will still be considerable, their main problem, as lockdown continues, will be hunger, not the virus, and a further deepening of existing social and income inequalities.
This has always been a recipe for unrest. Given the statistics on rising income inequality in the country, social unrest is a real possibility, says Manaswini Bhalla.
One solution Professor Manaswini suggests is creation of a national-level migrant register and record of migrants across the country. Skill mapping of migrant workers is another idea that is floating around, but with no details on the hows, whos and wheres of such an exercise.
While some talk of migrant labour being able to bargain for a better wage for themselves in the face of the predicted labour shortage. If this happens, it could well spark another kind of schism, between those who returned and those who stayed back.
According to Professor Bhalla, the lack of a binding force, a leader or an institution to channel these feelings makes me sceptical of any sort of uprising at this point in time".
Which is not the same as saying that it will not happen as hunger can push anyone into action they would not contemplate otherwise.
In this lockdown that has extended for overeight weeks, the salary a casual labourer has lost is Rs 7,680, says Professor Manaswini.
It is appalling that just Rs 500 a month has been promised to them.
This article was first published inCitizen Matters, a civic media website and is republished here with permission. (c)Oorvani Foundation/Open Media Initiative.
Updated Date: May 05, 2020 20:45:15 IST
Tags : BIhar, Coronavirus Lockdown, CriticalPoint, DBT, Direct Benefit Transfer, Economy, Food Riots, Hunger, Income Inequality, Indian Industries, Jharkhand, Kerala, Labourers, Lockdown, Madhya Pradesh, Migrant Labourers In India, Migrant Workers, Migrant Workers Crisis, Migrants Crisis, Odisha, PDS, Poverty, Public Distribution System, Ration Cards, Rural India, Rural Poor, Rural-Urban Divide, Shramik Trains, Social Unrest, Telangana, Urban India, Uttar Pradesh
- The migrant crisis worsening next to UK tourists getting their winter sun - The i Paper - November 13th, 2026 [November 13th, 2026]
- Migrant crisis: Thousands of migrants arrive in Spanish tourist hotspot as authorities declare emergency - GB News - November 13th, 2026 [November 13th, 2026]
- WATCH: Hundreds of protesters wearing Guy Fawkes masks stage striking five-minute silence in Ceuta over migrant crisis - Olive Press News Spain - November 9th, 2026 [November 9th, 2026]
- Migrant crisis: Andy Burnham says 'it is difficult to say whether migration is too high' as he stops short of ruling out cap - GB News - November 3rd, 2026 [November 3rd, 2026]
- Migrant crisis: Andy Burnham's small boats total hits 10,000 as crossings surge over weekend - GB News - November 3rd, 2026 [November 3rd, 2026]
- Migrant crisis: Hundreds of illegal immigrants cross Channel after three weeks of bad weather finally clears - GB News - November 3rd, 2026 [November 3rd, 2026]
- Spain and Italy agree to end border checks after dispute over Ceuta migrant crisis - Olive Press News Spain - October 17th, 2026 [October 17th, 2026]
- King Felipe and Queen Letizia visit Ceuta for the first time since ascending the throne, following the migrant crisis - Informat.ro - October 15th, 2026 [October 15th, 2026]
- Thousands of protesters take to the streets in Madrid over Ceuta migrant crisis - Yahoo - September 29th, 2026 [September 29th, 2026]
- With Harrowing Migrant Crisis Doc Rescue, Director Sine Plambech Has Never Received So Much Hate - IMDb - September 29th, 2026 [September 29th, 2026]
- Thousands of protesters take to the streets in Madrid over Ceuta migrant crisis - euronews.com - September 29th, 2026 [September 29th, 2026]
- Ceuta Migrant Crisis: What It Means For Spain And The Rest Of The EU Analysis - Eurasia Review - September 24th, 2026 [September 24th, 2026]
- Expansion | Snchez links the Ceuta crisis to disinformation and asks not to turn the migrant into an enemy - Demcrata - September 24th, 2026 [September 24th, 2026]
- Spains Ceuta migrant crisis is cutting through to Real Madrid and the 2030 World Cup - The Athletic - The New York Times - September 15th, 2026 [September 15th, 2026]
- Signs Russia, Israel spread disinformation over Ceuta migrant crisis, says Spanish PM - The Straits Times - September 2nd, 2026 [September 2nd, 2026]
- Spains PM Pedro Sanchez says no evidence of Morocco being involved in Ceuta migrant crisis - Olive Press News Spain - September 2nd, 2026 [September 2nd, 2026]
- Spanish PM accuses Russia and Israel of spreading disinformation over Ceuta migrant crisis - lke Haber Ajans - September 2nd, 2026 [September 2nd, 2026]
- Spain moves to overhaul asylum and immigration laws after Ceuta migrant crisis - EUalive - August 27th, 2026 [August 27th, 2026]
- Tories: Govt are ' dragging their feet' over migrant crisis - ITN - August 27th, 2026 [August 27th, 2026]
- The Tiny Spanish Territory of Ceuta Is Grappling With a New Migrant Crisis - WSJ - August 25th, 2026 [August 25th, 2026]
- Middle England is finally waking up to the migrant crisis - The Spectator - August 25th, 2026 [August 25th, 2026]
- The Tiny Spanish Territory of Ceuta Is Grappling With a New Migrant Crisis - wsj.com - August 18th, 2026 [August 18th, 2026]
- Editorial: Illinois spent big during COVID and the migrant crisis. Who was watching the bills? - chicagotribune.com - August 18th, 2026 [August 18th, 2026]
- Car parks, football pitches, beaches: Is Spain losing control of Ceutas migrant crisis? | Videos - Hindustan Times - August 18th, 2026 [August 18th, 2026]
- Revealed: The three ways France 'locks down' its own borders while Britain battles migrant crisis alone - GB News - August 12th, 2026 [August 12th, 2026]
- Spain Threatens Italy With Traveller Restrictions Over Ceuta Migrant Crisis: how 12 outlets framed it - NewsCord - August 9th, 2026 [August 9th, 2026]
- Europes migrant crisis is opening the door for the far-right at a critical moment - The i Paper - August 9th, 2026 [August 9th, 2026]
- Spain and Italy Step Up Border Control Fight Over Migrant Crisis - Bloomberg.com - August 7th, 2026 [August 7th, 2026]
- European ministers hold crunch talks on Ceuta migrant crisis as tensions grow between Spain and Italy - the-independent.com - August 7th, 2026 [August 7th, 2026]
- Top Islamist Theologian Accuses Zionists of Orchestrating Spains Migrant Crisis - Middle East Forum - August 7th, 2026 [August 7th, 2026]
- South Africa's textile industry in crisis after migrant workers fled the country - France 24 - August 7th, 2026 [August 7th, 2026]
- European ministers hold crunch talks on Ceuta migrant crisis as tensions grow between Spain and Italy - Yahoo News New Zealand - August 7th, 2026 [August 7th, 2026]
- The rights exploitation of the Ceuta migrant crisis almost guarantees that it will happen again | Ruben Andersson - The Guardian - August 5th, 2026 [August 5th, 2026]
- Spain's Ongoing Migrant Crisis and the Ties to the US, Israel and the Iran War - Military.com - August 5th, 2026 [August 5th, 2026]
- Europe races to contain Ceuta migrant crisis as tens of thousands cross into Spain from Morocco - lemonde.fr - August 5th, 2026 [August 5th, 2026]
- After weathering fires, Spain PM caught out by migrant crisis - The Japan Times - August 5th, 2026 [August 5th, 2026]
- Migrant crisis pushes Italy to restore border checks with Spain, testing Europe's open-border system - Fox News - August 5th, 2026 [August 5th, 2026]
- France and Italy tighten border controls over migrant crisis in Spain's Ceuta - France 24 - August 5th, 2026 [August 5th, 2026]
- Ceuta migrant crisis explained: Why 60,000 people risked everything to reach Spain from Morocco - The Times of India - August 5th, 2026 [August 5th, 2026]
- Ceuta migrant crisis: Far-right govts 'ridiculously using these images' to stoke fear for votes - France 24 - August 5th, 2026 [August 5th, 2026]
- France and Italy tighten border controls amid Spanish migrant crisis - The Times of Israel - August 5th, 2026 [August 5th, 2026]
- What you need to know about Ceuta as deadly migrant crisis hits Spanish enclave - The Independent - August 5th, 2026 [August 5th, 2026]
- Ceuta shows how the worldwide migrant crisis has been weaponised by propagandists. - Middle East Monitor - August 5th, 2026 [August 5th, 2026]
- Ukrainians protest removal of defense minister, Bangladeshs new wall could exacerbate migrant crisis, Networks mull whether to air Trump speech -... - July 18th, 2026 [July 18th, 2026]
- South Africas migrant crisis Christian Hospitality, Repentance and the Celebration of Diversity - Anglican Ink - July 18th, 2026 [July 18th, 2026]
- Dubai job crisis: How the Iran war is hitting Indian and migrant workers - The Indian Express - July 18th, 2026 [July 18th, 2026]
- Adams said the migrant crisis would ruin NYC. His top aides allegedly reaped a windfall. - Gothamist - June 28th, 2026 [June 28th, 2026]
- The Channel illegal migrant crisis cant be blamed on Brexit - The Telegraph - June 22nd, 2026 [June 22nd, 2026]
- Inside Sherwood: How a Durban hall became the centre of a migrant crisis - IOL - June 22nd, 2026 [June 22nd, 2026]
- Migrant crisis: Crackdown on gangs operating small boats leads to surge in arrests - GB News - May 17th, 2026 [May 17th, 2026]
- Why the Migrant Child Crisis Is Roiling the California Governor Race - The New York Times - May 16th, 2026 [May 16th, 2026]
- Timeline of the Channel migrant crisis - Wandsworth Times - May 11th, 2026 [May 11th, 2026]
- Evaluating The English Channel Migrant Crisis A Timeline Of Policy Failures - streamlinefeed.co.ke - May 9th, 2026 [May 9th, 2026]
- Small boat migrant arrivals set to hit 200,000 eight years after crisis began with just 7,612 deported - The Sun - May 7th, 2026 [May 7th, 2026]
- Migrant Crisis: Small boat arrivals on track to hit 200,000 TODAY with less than 8,000 deported in eight years - GB News - May 7th, 2026 [May 7th, 2026]
- Migrant crisis: Two people arrested amid investigation into asylum seekers pretending to be gay to remain in Britain - GB News - May 7th, 2026 [May 7th, 2026]
- INSIGHT | Ramaphosa walks tightrope over migrant crisis tensions and diplomacy - Daily Dispatch - May 7th, 2026 [May 7th, 2026]
- Were a sovereign country! Lord Redwood fumes over will of the people being denied on migrant crisis - GB News - May 7th, 2026 [May 7th, 2026]
- Should the government do more to help migrant crisis as arrivals hit 200k? VOTE - The Irish Sun - May 7th, 2026 [May 7th, 2026]
- India to release venomous snakes and crocodiles onto its border to thwart its own migrant crisis - GB News - April 10th, 2026 [April 10th, 2026]
- Migrant crisis: Runner who trained with Mo Farah accused of sexually assaulting teen after waiting for her to be left alone at bus stop - GB News - April 10th, 2026 [April 10th, 2026]
- Crowded platforms tell stories of migrant workers returning home amid LPG crisis - The Times of India - April 10th, 2026 [April 10th, 2026]
- Migrant crisis bombshell as new report reveals Britain is 'importing extremism' - Daily Express - April 7th, 2026 [April 7th, 2026]
- Are Bihar Migrant Workers Returning Back Due To LPG Crisis? Here Why - Oneindia - April 7th, 2026 [April 7th, 2026]
- LPG crisis hits T hotel industry, migrant workers bear the brunt - The Times of India - April 5th, 2026 [April 5th, 2026]
- Bushwick Farm Padlocked Amid Migrant Crisis, Fines and Fed-Up Owner - THE CITY - NYC News - March 26th, 2026 [March 26th, 2026]
- Migrant crisis: Number of asylum seekers housed in taxpayer-funded accommodation for over a year surges by nearly half as over 37,000 staying for over... - March 26th, 2026 [March 26th, 2026]
- Migrant crisis: Downing Street insists France and UK united on small boats as deal nears expiry - The Independent - March 24th, 2026 [March 24th, 2026]
- Migrant crisis: Channel patrol deal with France in jeopardy as Shabana Mahmood seeks tougher terms - GB News - March 24th, 2026 [March 24th, 2026]
- Migrant crisis: Viktor Orban warns Christian roots are 'dying out' across the West after migration surge - GB News - March 24th, 2026 [March 24th, 2026]
- PM Modi Calls On States For Vigilance On Migrant Workers; Cautions Of Long-Term Impact Of West Asia Crisis - Ommcom News - March 24th, 2026 [March 24th, 2026]
- Migrant crisis: Reform council to vote to declare small boats crisis 'terrorist threat' - GB News - March 17th, 2026 [March 17th, 2026]
- The migrant crisis organized by Lukashenka is it over? Here's what the numbers show - - March 15th, 2026 [March 15th, 2026]
- Europe braces for ANOTHER migrant crisis with millions prepared to flee Middle East amid US-Iran war as Donald Trump warns: Time is running out! - GB... - March 2nd, 2026 [March 2nd, 2026]
- Ministers stubbornness on English for migrant drivers risks yet another crisis - ThePost.co.nz - February 18th, 2026 [February 18th, 2026]
- How Mamdani Aims to Keep NYCs Migrant Crisis Alive Forever - Manhattan Institute - February 11th, 2026 [February 11th, 2026]
- Migrant crisis as council spending hits 134m nearly tripled in just 5 years - Daily Express - February 2nd, 2026 [February 2nd, 2026]
- Migrant crisis terror as small boat smugglers try stoning and burning police to death - Daily Express - February 1st, 2026 [February 1st, 2026]
- Hope Director Maria Sdahl Talks Seeing the Migrant Crisis From a Privileged Scandinavian Pov in Gteborg Winner The Last Resort - IMDb - February 1st, 2026 [February 1st, 2026]
- Labour claims it's solving UK migrant crisis - the truth will make your blood boil - Daily Express - January 26th, 2026 [January 26th, 2026]