Residual Obligations And The Morality of Libertarianism – Econlib
Dan Mollers Governing Least: A New England Libertarianism is one of my favorite books on libertarian philosophy. In it, he discusses one idea that I think is underrated, and deserves to be highlighted. The idea is what he calls residual obligations.
First, Mollers approach to libertarianism is not based on a hardline approach like many associate with Rand or Rothbard. Moller does not think in terms of exceptionless rules, or rights that are inviolable in all circumstances. He acknowledges that sometimes, rights violations can be justified. Suppose I find myself in the following scenario:
I am hiking on a mountain pass and have become trapped in a massive snowstorm. My life is in peril if I cannot find shelter and food. Luckily, I stumble across an unoccupied hunting cabin. The cabin is clearly marked with Keep Out and Private Property signs. However, I can easily break into the cabin and take shelter against the storm until it has passed, saving my life at the cost of causing some property damage to someone else.
People with an absolutist view of rights might argue that Im morally obligated to stay outside and freeze to death. Common sense morality, however, says this is a case where its permissible to violate someones property rights. However, Moller points out whats often overlooked is that a rights violation being justified isnt the end of the moral analysis. Too many people speak as if overriding a right necessarily means the same things as erasing the right altogether. But this is a mistake. As Moller puts it, an overridden right is not a deactivated right. A justified rights violation is still a rights violation. The reasons that exist to avoid harming someone, though overridden, have not ceased to exist, and harm was still caused to someone who did not deserve it.
As a result, Moller says, the overridden reason to avoid harming you still being in effect produces residual obligations for me. If you see that Ive broken your cabin window and taken some of the supplies you kept stored in there, would be wrong of me to merely shrug and say well, the emergency situation I was in overruled your property rights, so unfortunately for you, this is all your problem. Instead, I now have some residual obligations to you. Moller suggests these obligations include restitution if I caused $300 worth of damage to your cabin in order to break in, I should repay you for the damage. There is a further obligation of compensation to the extent that you are otherwise harmed by my actions, and I should take efforts to compensate you for those harms. I should express sympathy even though my action may have been justified, it was still regrettable, and it still caused harm to you, and for me to treat that as a matter of indifference would be wrong. And there is an obligation of responsibility which is not just backward looking, but forward-looking.
The forward-looking nature of responsibility is of particular interest. For example, if the mountain pass in the above thought experiment was widely known to be a hazardous place to hike, and I also knew that there was a major snowstorm coming in, and could have easily anticipated that taking a hike that day could place me in a situation where I might need to break into someone elses cabin in order to survive, that gives me a strong obligation to avoid putting myself in that scenario in the first place. As Moller puts it, If I can reasonably foresee that some action of mine will put me in the position of facing an emergency that will then render it permissible to harm you, I must take responsibility to avoid such actions of possible. I should not think that I have less reason to take responsibility because I can avoid harms by transferring them to you instead. And failing to take responsibility weakens my claim to impose costs on others when the time comes.
I think this is basically right. If I had been the hypothetical hiker above and was later trying to take moral inventory of my life, I wouldnt find myself thinking If only I had been a better, more moral person, Id actually be dead already. Id have had the decency to do the morally correct thing, and Id have frozen to death outside that cabin years ago. But if I failed to live up to my residual obligations, and never attempted to make things up to the cabin owner, I would feel like I had done something wrong to that extent. As Ive written before, I dont want to be the kind of person who feels comfortable with making others bear the costs of my choices, or of my misfortunes. As Moller phrased it, the core impulse isnt outrage about being asked to give, it is in the first instance a bewilderment at the suggestion that we are entitled to demand. And Moller goes on to argue, persuasively in my view, that if we recognize even modest strictures on making others worse off to improve our lot then we quickly run into a form of libertarianism.
A simple question we should all ask ourselves about any belief we hold is If I was wrong about this, how would I know it? What would it actually take to convince me that Im mistaken? If you cant answer that question, that should be a big red flag. This is hardly an original observation on my part, of course. Eliezer Yudkowsky, for example has written that a belief is only reallyworthwhileif you could, in principle, be persuaded to believe otherwise. If your retina ended up in the same state regardless of what light entered it, you would be blind. Similarly, if your mind ends up in the same state regardless of the evidence or arguments you encounter, then intellectually you have been blinded as effectively as by poking out your eyeballs. To illustrate the point, Yudkowsky goes on to say this holds true even for things as basic as 2+2 = 4, and that he finds it quite easy to imagine a situation which wouldconvinceme that 2 + 2 = 3.
So, what would it take to convince me I was wrong about the moral argument for libertarianism? Well, as mentioned, I dont think its right of me to demand and compel other people to carry the costs of my actions or my misfortunes. If someone could provide me with a convincing argument that I would become a better, more moral person if I did adopt such a belief and began to act in accordance with it, that would in turn convince me I was wrong about the moral argument for libertarianism.
What about you, EconLog readers? Whats a core belief you hold, and what would it take to convince you that you were mistaken about it?
Visit link:
Residual Obligations And The Morality of Libertarianism - Econlib
- Will the Trumpification of the Libertarian Party Actually Hurt Donald Trump? - The Dispatch - May 13th, 2024 [May 13th, 2024]
- 'The Zionists Always Get Their Way': Libertarian Party of Michigan Posts Antisemitic Cartoon Depicting Jews as Puppet ... - Algemeiner - May 13th, 2024 [May 13th, 2024]
- How FreedomWorks Paved the Way for Trumpismand for Its Own Demise - The New Republic - May 13th, 2024 [May 13th, 2024]
- The Tea Party Movement Died With a Whimper - The Dispatch - May 13th, 2024 [May 13th, 2024]
- R.F.K. Jr., Invited to Libertarian Convention, Seeks Trump Debate - The New York Times - May 13th, 2024 [May 13th, 2024]
- Knapp: No, Trump and Kennedy aren't Libertarian candidates - Bay to Bay News - May 13th, 2024 [May 13th, 2024]
- Long (Political) Covid - Kevin D. Williamson - The Dispatch - May 13th, 2024 [May 13th, 2024]
- No, Trump and Kennedy aren't libertarian candidates - Restoration NewsMedia - Restoration NewsMedia - May 13th, 2024 [May 13th, 2024]
- Libertarians at odds over Donald Trump headlining their convention - The Washington Post - The Washington Post - May 9th, 2024 [May 9th, 2024]
- Robert F. Kennedy Jr. challenges Donald Trump to debate at Libertarian Convention - The Associated Press - May 9th, 2024 [May 9th, 2024]
- Trump's MAGA takeover of the Libertarian Party - The Boston Globe - May 9th, 2024 [May 9th, 2024]
- The Libertarian Party Crackup - by Tyler Groenendal - The Bulwark - May 9th, 2024 [May 9th, 2024]
- Cartoon: The 24 Types of Libertarian - Daily Kos - May 9th, 2024 [May 9th, 2024]
- Trump should debate RFK Jr at the libertarian convention - Washington Examiner - May 9th, 2024 [May 9th, 2024]
- Four Obstacles Facing Libertarian Proponents of Border Controls The Future of Freedom Foundation - The Future of Freedom Foundation - May 9th, 2024 [May 9th, 2024]
- Trump and RFK Jr. are both set to address the Libertarian convention. Kennedy wants to debate. - MarketWatch - May 9th, 2024 [May 9th, 2024]
- Trump's Libertarian Convention Speech a 'Head-Scratcher'for the Libertarians - The American Conservative - May 9th, 2024 [May 9th, 2024]
- Trump Talks to Libertarians - Splice Today - May 9th, 2024 [May 9th, 2024]
- What was the tea party? What is Trumpism?: On populism and FreedomWorks - Washington Examiner - May 9th, 2024 [May 9th, 2024]
- Donald Trump Will Speak at the Libertarian Convention. It's Not as Weird as It Sounds. Mother Jones - Mother Jones - May 3rd, 2024 [May 3rd, 2024]
- Donald Trump courts an increasingly friendly Libertarian Party - Semafor - May 3rd, 2024 [May 3rd, 2024]
- Why is Trump really speaking at the Libertarian conference? RFK Jr's polls - The Independent - May 3rd, 2024 [May 3rd, 2024]
- Trump will speak at the Libertarian National Convention as he woos independent voters - The Associated Press - May 3rd, 2024 [May 3rd, 2024]
- Trump to address Libertarian Party convention - The Hill - May 3rd, 2024 [May 3rd, 2024]
- Is the Libertarian Party Too Bigoted Even for Trump? - The Daily Beast - May 3rd, 2024 [May 3rd, 2024]
- Trump will speak at the Libertarian National Convention as he woos independent voters - KEYT - May 3rd, 2024 [May 3rd, 2024]
- Trump to address Libertarian National Convention this month - SRN News - May 3rd, 2024 [May 3rd, 2024]
- Trump, Wooing Libertarian Voters, Agrees To Speak at Party's Convention as Concern Waxes on the Right Over RFK Jr. - The New York Sun - May 3rd, 2024 [May 3rd, 2024]
- Donald Trump speaking at Libertarian national convention Deseret News - Deseret News - May 3rd, 2024 [May 3rd, 2024]
- Trump to speak at Libertarian National Convention - Washington Examiner - May 3rd, 2024 [May 3rd, 2024]
- Trump will speak at the Libertarian National Convention as he woos independent voters - PinalCentral - May 3rd, 2024 [May 3rd, 2024]
- Trump will speak at the Libertarian National Convention, addressing a party linked to Kennedy Jr. - Indiana Gazette - May 3rd, 2024 [May 3rd, 2024]
- US libertarian party says Trump accepted invite to address national convention - United News of India - May 3rd, 2024 [May 3rd, 2024]
- Trump to speak at Libertarian National Convention - Just The News - May 3rd, 2024 [May 3rd, 2024]
- Trump will speak at the Libertarian National Convention, addressing a party linked to Kennedy Jr. - Times Daily - May 3rd, 2024 [May 3rd, 2024]
- Donald Trump Courts Libertarian Voters at National Convention - The Stock Dork - May 3rd, 2024 [May 3rd, 2024]
- The Spectacular Implosion of the Libertarian Party Mother Jones - Mother Jones - April 20th, 2024 [April 20th, 2024]
- RFK Jr. says he wont run as Libertarian - The Hill - April 20th, 2024 [April 20th, 2024]
- Opposing random searches and upholding Libertarian principles - The West Volusia Beacon - April 20th, 2024 [April 20th, 2024]
- UFC Fighter Delights Very Online Libertarians With Shoutout to Ludwig von Mises in Victory Speech - The New York Sun - April 20th, 2024 [April 20th, 2024]
- Is RFK Jr. a good fit for the Libertarian party? - UnHerd - March 28th, 2024 [March 28th, 2024]
- Robert F. Kennedy Jr. flirts with the Libertarian nomination - POLITICO - March 28th, 2024 [March 28th, 2024]
- One Hundred Days of Libertarian Populism in Argentina - The American Conservative - March 28th, 2024 [March 28th, 2024]
- RFK Jr. in talks to run on the Libertarian Party ticket to ease ballot challenges - Washington Examiner - March 28th, 2024 [March 28th, 2024]
- When Will the Libertarian Party Have Its Moment? - Econlib - March 28th, 2024 [March 28th, 2024]
- RFK Jr. in talks to run on the Libertarian Party ticket to ease ballot challenges - Colorado Springs Gazette - March 28th, 2024 [March 28th, 2024]
- Opinion | 100 Days of Javier Milei - The New York Times - March 24th, 2024 [March 24th, 2024]
- Libertarians and Socialists and Jill SteinOh, My! - The New Yorker - March 13th, 2024 [March 13th, 2024]
- The Libertarian Party: Too Principled to Win? - Econlib - March 13th, 2024 [March 13th, 2024]
- A Brief History of The Spark: A Journal of Contemporary Anarchist Thought - CounterPunch - March 13th, 2024 [March 13th, 2024]
- Libertarian Greg Tlapek provides alternative choice in District 147 House race - Southeast Missourian - March 13th, 2024 [March 13th, 2024]
- Review: Sheriff in 'Fargo' Gives Libertarians a Bad Name - Reason - March 13th, 2024 [March 13th, 2024]
- Libertarian legal nonprofit takes over New York lawsuit alleging discrimination against white men - Green Market Report - March 13th, 2024 [March 13th, 2024]
- Where Does the Term Libertarian Come From Anyway? | Jeffrey A. Tucker - Foundation for Economic Education - March 13th, 2024 [March 13th, 2024]
- Could the Libertarian Party nominate RKF Jr.? - NewsNation Now - March 13th, 2024 [March 13th, 2024]
- Libertarian Views / Father Amorth, Exorcist - Coast To Coast AM - March 13th, 2024 [March 13th, 2024]
- RFK JR still flirting with Libertarian Party run? Third parties seek ballot access - The Hill - March 13th, 2024 [March 13th, 2024]
- Nate Silver: Libertarians Are the Real Liberals - Reason - March 13th, 2024 [March 13th, 2024]
- The (Libertarian) Case for Slavery Reparations - Foundation for Economic Education - March 13th, 2024 [March 13th, 2024]
- Libertarian view of bill aimed at independent Kansas candidates: It's about GOP election losses - Kansas Reflector - January 31st, 2024 [January 31st, 2024]
- Learning From History: The Pitfalls of Prohibition Then and Now - Libertarian Party - January 31st, 2024 [January 31st, 2024]
- How Texans can vote in the Green or Libertarian party conventions - KSAT San Antonio - January 31st, 2024 [January 31st, 2024]
- Struggling To Get on Ballots, RFK Jr. Teases Running on a Libertarian Party Ticket - The New York Sun - January 31st, 2024 [January 31st, 2024]
- RFK Jr. Open To Libertarian Party Run - The Daily Wire - January 31st, 2024 [January 31st, 2024]
- Argentina's new libertarian president and unions are headed for a showdown - NPR - January 24th, 2024 [January 24th, 2024]
- The Libertarian Who Could Hold the Key to the Senate - Newsweek - January 24th, 2024 [January 24th, 2024]
- Chair of Lake County Libertarian Party appointed to St. John Economic Development Committee - The Times of Northwest Indiana - January 24th, 2024 [January 24th, 2024]
- 'Slum priests' slam new libertarian government in Pope's native Argentina - Crux Now - January 24th, 2024 [January 24th, 2024]
- A Police State Is Not Libertarian The Future of Freedom Foundation - The Future of Freedom Foundation - January 24th, 2024 [January 24th, 2024]
- Smug world elites should fear this chainsaw-wielding libertarian - he has exposed them - The Telegraph - January 24th, 2024 [January 24th, 2024]
- Matt Welch: What's Wrong With Populism? - Reason - January 20th, 2024 [January 20th, 2024]
- Libertarians form an official political party in Maine - Press Herald - January 20th, 2024 [January 20th, 2024]
- Libertarian party in Maine qualified for upcoming presidential elections - WGME - January 20th, 2024 [January 20th, 2024]
- Libertarian Party of Iowa Makes History with Presidential Straw Poll at Iowa Caucus - KSOM - January 20th, 2024 [January 20th, 2024]
- A Beacon of Activism and Liberty for Modern Libertarians - Libertarian Party - January 20th, 2024 [January 20th, 2024]
- Argentinas far-right libertarian president warns in Davos, the West is in danger - Peoples Dispatch - January 20th, 2024 [January 20th, 2024]
- Chase Oliver Libertarian Party Iowa caucus result - 11Alive.com WXIA - January 20th, 2024 [January 20th, 2024]
- Libertarian Party is confirmed as qualified party in Maine - FOX Bangor/ABC 7 News and Stories - January 20th, 2024 [January 20th, 2024]
- Libertarians in the desertan update - OnlySky Media - January 20th, 2024 [January 20th, 2024]
- Libertarian Party of Iowa announces the winner of its statewide Presidential caucus - KIMT 3 - January 20th, 2024 [January 20th, 2024]
Tags: