Liberals, get your story straight on single payer – The Week Magazine
Sign Up for
Our free email newsletters
Support for single-payer health care is on its way to becoming the consensus position in the Democratic Party.
This is particularly true after the debacle of the Republican health-care effort. Not only has the debate demonstrated that Americans are perfectly fine with the idea of government-provided health coverage, it has convinced Democrats that there's no point in trimming their political sails in the hope of getting buy-in from Republicans for whatever they advocate, so they might as well go all the way. When 500 or so Democrats run for president in 2020, we'll probably see many if not most of them drop the equivocation and come right out and say they favor single payer.
But before we get there, Democrats need to take a breath and do some thinking. Do they understand exactly what it is they want to advocate for?
Consider what has been going on in California. A bill to establish a single-payer plan in the state passed the state Senate there, but it was recently pulled in the Assembly by Speaker Anthony Rendon. Democrats have a super-majority in the legislature, so why didn't they go ahead? As Rendon argued, the bill would have created massive budget problems given other California laws; for instance, the state is required to spend 40 percent of its budget on education, so it would have had to come up with hundreds of billions of new dollars even beyond what it would spend on health care. It also would have required waivers from the Trump administration to divert money currently being spent by federal programs like Medicaid, waivers which of course would not have been forthcoming (David Dayen explains all the convoluted problems the bill would have created).
Nevertheless, some on the left treated Rendon's decision like the most perfidious treason against progressive principles. RoseAnn DeMoro, head of National Nurses United and a prominent Bernie Sanders supporter, tweeted out a picture of the California flag with a knife labeled "Rendon" sticking out of the bear's back, and characterized anyone who objected to the bill as in the pocket of insurance companies. When liberal blogger Kevin Drum criticized the bill as unrealistic, NNU's communication director sent him an email saying "the name of your magazine [should] be changed from Mother Jones who actually fought for working people to Milton Friedman, which would better reflect your class sympathies."
The truth is that establishing single payer in a single state is a nearly impossible challenge when the country as a whole continues to exist within our largely private system. It's why Vermont tried to do it and then abandoned the effort, why Colorado voters rejected it at the polls last year, and why it isn't going to work in California. Nevertheless, more and more in the future, single payer is going to be treated as a litmus test by which "true" progressives can be distinguished from establishment sellouts.
In the abstract, that's not such a terrible thing health care is a vitally important issue that affects all our lives in profound ways, and it's one of the major dividing lines between the two parties. There's no reason why Democratic voters shouldn't use health-care policy as a means to judge prospective candidates, for president or anything else.
But everyone who cares about it needs a very specific and clear answer to this question: When you say "single payer," what exactly do you mean?
I suspect that many people don't actually mean single payer when they say "single payer." Liberals like myself have long lamented the fact that alone among the world's advanced industrialized democracies, the United States doesn't have a system that provides universal health coverage. We look around with jealousy at other systems that manage to cover everyone and produce health results that are equal to or better than what we get, all at dramatically lower cost. But those systems vary widely in design, and none of them are truly single payer.
In a true single-payer system, there is only one insurer, the government. It pays for all health care, and is able to use its regulatory and market power to hold prices down and take advantage of bureaucratic efficiencies. The country that comes closest to single payer is Great Britain, with its National Health Service. You might recall that Britons are so proud of the NHS that the opening ceremony of the 2012 London Olympics included a tribute to it.
But even the British system has some private elements to it. And moving to a completely public system from our current mishmash of public and private insurance (and mostly private health providers) would require an extraordinarily costly, complex, and lengthy transition. But maybe that's fine with you you can argue that in the long run, that maximizes the benefits.
Or perhaps you would prefer a hybrid system like the one they have in France, where there's a universal government insurance program that covers everyone's basic needs, and then most people buy private but highly regulated supplemental insurance on top of it (Canada has something similar, but with much more control at the provincial level). That happens to be my preference, particularly since we can foresee a path to it from where we are now, by expanding Medicaid (which already covers almost 75 million Americans) and changing what private insurers provide but not eliminating them entirely. I think you'd have a hard time arguing that a hybrid system would be some kind of betrayal of progressive principles.
Or you might prefer a system like Germany's, where tax money goes to fund non-profit insurers ("sickness funds") that people can choose from. The point is, those are just a few of the options. Each country that has addressed this problem has come up with a slightly different solution (if you want to compare them, this is a terrific source), but what they have in common is that they all achieve universal coverage at a cost much lower than what we pay.
If we're going to remake the American health-care system and we should we're going to have to decide which of those models would work the best for us. But they're not "single payer."
I'll admit that like many people, in the past I've used the term "single payer" too loosely. And there's a rhetorical problem: We don't have a name that would refer to all the different kinds of universal health systems we might consider moving toward. It's hard to communicate what you're for in a simple and understandable way without such a name; it's much easier to say "I'm for single payer." But you probably aren't or at the very least, you're open to any number of styles of health system, so long as they cover everyone in a way that's equitable.
We're now finally approaching a point where something we call single payer can be considered politically feasible. So we'd better make sure we know what we're talking about.
More:
Liberals, get your story straight on single payer - The Week Magazine
- Opinion | The Happiness Gap Between Left and Right Isn't Closing - The New York Times - May 9th, 2024 [May 9th, 2024]
- Have liberals forgotten that the government cant fix everything? - The Hill - May 9th, 2024 [May 9th, 2024]
- Study finds liberals and conservatives differ on climate change beliefsbut are relatively united in taking action - Phys.org - May 9th, 2024 [May 9th, 2024]
- Columbia protests: I read the university president's old memoir-manifesto. Yikes. - Slate - May 9th, 2024 [May 9th, 2024]
- Opinion: Poilievre to business: stop sucking up to Liberals and start sucking up to me - The Globe and Mail - May 9th, 2024 [May 9th, 2024]
- Grocery giants paid for friendly Liberal, Tory policy with decades of donations The Breach - The Breach - May 9th, 2024 [May 9th, 2024]
- Opinion: The Liberals' delays on foreign interference carry profound costs - The Globe and Mail - May 9th, 2024 [May 9th, 2024]
- Gaza is the greatest test liberalism has faced since 1945. And it is failing - Middle East Eye - May 9th, 2024 [May 9th, 2024]
- NDP leader slams Liberals for giving nearly $26M to Costco, Loblaw in recent years - Yahoo News Canada - May 9th, 2024 [May 9th, 2024]
- 'Overconfident' Poilievre exposing vulnerabilities, but Liberals failing to capitalize on them, say pollsters and political ... - The Hill Times - May 9th, 2024 [May 9th, 2024]
- NDP leader slams Liberals for giving nearly $26-million to Costco, Loblaw in recent years - The Globe and Mail - May 9th, 2024 [May 9th, 2024]
- Evening Update: Liberals unveil foreign interference registry - The Globe and Mail - May 9th, 2024 [May 9th, 2024]
- Columbia crisis: Another massive failure of liberalism - Salon - May 1st, 2024 [May 1st, 2024]
- MAGA is obsessed with Viktor Orban; liberals should be, too - - May 1st, 2024 [May 1st, 2024]
- Opinion | Justin Trudeau May Be No Match for the New World of Polarization - The New York Times - May 1st, 2024 [May 1st, 2024]
- Liberals accuse Poilievre of planning to override charter rights with notwithstanding clause - CBC.ca - May 1st, 2024 [May 1st, 2024]
- Even if the Liberals win in 2026, dont count on a new deal for cities - TVO Today - May 1st, 2024 [May 1st, 2024]
- Howie Carr: Lets toll all smug liberals - Boston Herald - May 1st, 2024 [May 1st, 2024]
- Only 6% of vaccine injury claimants have been paid as Liberals earmark $36 million for program - True North - May 1st, 2024 [May 1st, 2024]
- PC opposition blasts Liberals over handling of mental health and drug crisis - Yahoo News Canada - May 1st, 2024 [May 1st, 2024]
- As Michael Cohen testifies against Trump, many liberals are still wary of him - The Washington Post - May 1st, 2024 [May 1st, 2024]
- Letters: Seven ways to kill the Canadian dream (courtesy of the Trudeau Liberals) - National Post - May 1st, 2024 [May 1st, 2024]
- How a former Edmonton cop became the hand behind the Liberals' proposed hate-crime law - The Logic - May 1st, 2024 [May 1st, 2024]
- Tories dismiss fishing harbour repairs by federal Liberals as 'electioneering' - CBC.ca - May 1st, 2024 [May 1st, 2024]
- Globe editorial: The Liberals' capital-gains tax hike punishes prosperity - The Globe and Mail - May 1st, 2024 [May 1st, 2024]
- Opinion: For the good of the Liberal party, Trudeau needs to think about his future - The Globe and Mail - May 1st, 2024 [May 1st, 2024]
- Freeland pushes back against suggestion Liberals are bending to NDP on disability benefit - iPolitics.ca - May 1st, 2024 [May 1st, 2024]
- 'Hell freezing over': Liberals shocked to agree with Jeanine Pirro on dead dog take - Raw Story - May 1st, 2024 [May 1st, 2024]
- 'Sopranos' Actress Says People In Hollywood Are Too 'Petrified' To Cross Liberals On Social Issues - The Daily Wire - May 1st, 2024 [May 1st, 2024]
- Liberals' plan to destroy super will drive up house prices - The New Daily - May 1st, 2024 [May 1st, 2024]
- Opinion: The foreign interference inquiry features a parade of senior Liberals protesting too much - The Globe and Mail - April 20th, 2024 [April 20th, 2024]
- How liberals killed Earth Day - Washington Times - April 20th, 2024 [April 20th, 2024]
- The Weekly Wrap: The Liberals lean all the way into class warfare - The Hub - April 20th, 2024 [April 20th, 2024]
- Liberals Are Trying to Make Trump's Age an Issue. It Won't Work. - The New Republic - April 20th, 2024 [April 20th, 2024]
- Israel Attacks, Trump Trial Rights, and Liberals Taking The Country Down - WBT - April 20th, 2024 [April 20th, 2024]
- Letter | Liberal tribalism led to downfall of phonics - The Capital Times - April 20th, 2024 [April 20th, 2024]
- Quebec Liberals will choose new leader during convention in June 2025 - Yahoo News Canada - April 20th, 2024 [April 20th, 2024]
- Globe editorial: The Liberals move from borrow and spend, to tax and spend - The Globe and Mail - April 20th, 2024 [April 20th, 2024]
- Other voices: Liberal bias at NPR, old-school journalism and the reluctance to admit a mistake - St. Paul Pioneer Press - April 20th, 2024 [April 20th, 2024]
- S&Ds contest harmful deal on the new EU retail investment law, brokered by liberals in cooperation with the far right - Socialists & Democrats - April 20th, 2024 [April 20th, 2024]
- Unpacking the Liberals Housing First Federal Budget - Move Smartly - April 20th, 2024 [April 20th, 2024]
- Budget 2024 sets up a hard year for the Liberals. Heres what to expect - Global News - April 20th, 2024 [April 20th, 2024]
- Jagmeet Singh says the Liberals and Conservatives are 'controlled' by corporate lobbyists. How true is that? - Toronto Star - April 20th, 2024 [April 20th, 2024]
- Liberals force banks to identify carbon rebates by name in direct deposits - True North - April 20th, 2024 [April 20th, 2024]
- Outspoken Liberal cabinet minister Iona Campagnolo earned a reputation for getting things done - The Globe and Mail - April 20th, 2024 [April 20th, 2024]
- Here's what the Liberals have already promised will be in today's federal budget - CP24 - April 20th, 2024 [April 20th, 2024]
- Quebec Liberals will choose new leader during convention in June 2025 - larongeNOW - April 20th, 2024 [April 20th, 2024]
- Did Macron and Tusk Just Chart a Path for Liberals Elsewhere on Immigration? - Just Security - March 18th, 2024 [March 18th, 2024]
- Freedom from Fear and the Specter of Perfection - Liberal Currents - March 18th, 2024 [March 18th, 2024]
- Trump praises 'very nice' Katie Britt SOTU response in Ohio rally - 1819 News - March 18th, 2024 [March 18th, 2024]
- Memo To Britain: Tories Have Acted Like A Light Version Of Liberals And Could Be In For A Wipeout - Forbes - March 18th, 2024 [March 18th, 2024]
- Liberal Media Loses It Over Trump's 'Bloodbath' Comments - WIBC - Indianapolis News & Politics - March 18th, 2024 [March 18th, 2024]
- The Case for Trump: Bullet Points to share with Liberals and RINO's by Joyce Kaufman 850 WFTL - 850 WFTL - March 18th, 2024 [March 18th, 2024]
- Liberals drop more hints that an $18B Honda expansion in Ontario is possible - Automotive News Canada - March 18th, 2024 [March 18th, 2024]
- Polls show 'across-the-board, generalized retreat' from Liberals, says Coletto - The Hill Times - March 18th, 2024 [March 18th, 2024]
- Ontario Liberals rule out carbon tax if they form government in 2026 - Global News - March 18th, 2024 [March 18th, 2024]
- Are EU liberals still progressive and pro-European? - EURACTIV - March 18th, 2024 [March 18th, 2024]
- Opinion: If the Trudeau Liberals are annihilated in an election, it will be over housing - The Globe and Mail - March 18th, 2024 [March 18th, 2024]
- Trump defended over bloodbath speech as conservatives claim liberals are twisting his words - MSN - March 18th, 2024 [March 18th, 2024]
- Liberals say Poilievre 'doesn't care' about the housing shortage and mock his record | RCI - Radio-Canada.ca - March 18th, 2024 [March 18th, 2024]
- An expected defeat was unexpectedly painful for Justin Trudeau's Liberals. That should set off alarm bells - Toronto Star - March 18th, 2024 [March 18th, 2024]
- Liberals say Poilievre 'doesn't care' about the housing shortage and mock his record - MSN - March 18th, 2024 [March 18th, 2024]
- Even when it criticizes Israel, the liberal world is not against us - opinion - The Jerusalem Post - March 18th, 2024 [March 18th, 2024]
- Socialists ramp up attacks on conservatives and liberals in EU election manifesto - POLITICO Europe - March 2nd, 2024 [March 2nd, 2024]
- Howard Levitt: Young people are rejecting the woke status quo and that spells trouble for the Liberals - Financial Post - March 2nd, 2024 [March 2nd, 2024]
- Six liberal conspiracy theories clouding politics | Business - Colorado Springs Gazette - March 2nd, 2024 [March 2nd, 2024]
- Carson Jerema: Don't believe the Liberals, online harms act targets free speech - National Post - March 2nd, 2024 [March 2nd, 2024]
- Howard Levitt: Young people are rejecting the woke status quo and that spells trouble for the Liberals - Yahoo Canada Finance - March 2nd, 2024 [March 2nd, 2024]
- The history of Section 13, the controversial hate speech law the Liberals just revived - National Post - March 2nd, 2024 [March 2nd, 2024]
- The Liberals are set to unveil an online harms bill today. Here's what you need to know - CBC.ca - March 2nd, 2024 [March 2nd, 2024]
- The Liberals and NDP say they have a pharmacare deal so what's left on their to-do list? - CBC.ca - March 2nd, 2024 [March 2nd, 2024]
- Liberals introduce online bill, Amanda Todds mother urges MPs to pass - Vancouver Sun - March 2nd, 2024 [March 2nd, 2024]
- Liberals accuse Poilievre of creating 'dysfunction' in bid to extend House hours - CTV News - March 2nd, 2024 [March 2nd, 2024]
- WA Liberals leader Libby Mettam tells Stateline how she plans to rebuild ahead of the state election - ABC News - March 2nd, 2024 [March 2nd, 2024]
- Liberals take first step toward pharmacare with bill for birth control, diabetes meds - Sylvan Lake News - March 2nd, 2024 [March 2nd, 2024]
- Best of the 'Media Buzz Meter': Liberal Pundits Increasingly Say Biden Can't Win, Should Bow Out at the Convention - FOX News Radio - March 2nd, 2024 [March 2nd, 2024]
- Georgian Dream is preparing a bill against ideology of pseudo-liberals and wilful propaganda of non-traditional ... - Democracy & Freedom Watch - March 2nd, 2024 [March 2nd, 2024]
- Dunkley by-election: First results show swing to Liberals - MSN - March 2nd, 2024 [March 2nd, 2024]
- Liberals vote against disclosure of ArriveCan costs as Opposition MPs accuse the government of filibustering - The Hill Times - March 2nd, 2024 [March 2nd, 2024]
- Liberals want to stop overnight voting with health breaks for MPs - Global News - March 2nd, 2024 [March 2nd, 2024]