Mediaboss Marketing

Its taken the Liberal government two tries and more than two years to get Bill C-11 through the legislative process. If the Senate doesnt fight the government on removing a number of amendments senators previously added to the bill, Bill C-11 could receive royal assent shortly after Parliament comes back from break next week.

This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below.

We apologize, but this video has failed to load.

But once the bill is law, that doesnt mean we know how the government will actually regulate online streaming, whether its from big studio content to homemade video blogs . It actually means the work on the specifics is just beginning.

Bill C-11 sets up the CRTC to regulate streaming platforms like Netflix and YouTube. The idea is that under new rules, theyll have to participate in the Canadian content system the way traditional radio and TV broadcasters and cable providers have had to.

Digital platforms are now exempt from that system, which requires broadcasters to spend 30 per cent of their revenue on Canadian content, and cable and satellite TV providers to contribute five per cent of their revenues.

The legislation doesnt get into the details of how the CRTC will bring digital platforms into the system, but the Liberal government will provide more specifics in a document called a policy direction.

This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below.

The government could use the policy direction to address the most controversial parts of the bill, namely the powers the CRTC will have over user-generated content, such as videos posted on YouTube or TikTok by digital creators and everyday Canadians.

We dont know yet.

The government isnt releasing the policy direction until after the bill becomes law. Laura Scaffidi, a spokesperson for Heritage Minister Pablo Rodriguez, said the government wants to work in collaboration and will consult with all interested stakeholders before issuing a policy direction on Bill C-11 to the CRTC.

For the first version of the bill that died on the order paper when the 2021 election was called, the government did release a draft ahead of time. It told the CRTC to ensure digital platforms contribute appropriately to supporting and promoting Canadian programming and Canadian creators.

This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below.

That was before the government removed the original exemption for user content from the bill, sparking a wave of controversy which slowed down the passage of the legislation for two years.

So it will be important to watch this time what the policy direction has to say about user content.

Under the bill as it stands, the CRTC wont have the power to control what Canadians post or choose to watch online. But it will have regulatory authority over recommendations the movies, TV shows, videos and music platforms like Netflix, YouTube or Spotify suggest to their users.

The idea is that the CRTC will use that power to force platforms to promote what it deems to be Canadian content, ensuring that it is more easily discoverable by users.

This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below.

An amendment the Senate added to the bill would have excluded social media content, but that was rejected by Rodriguez. The government said at the time it rejected the amendment because it would have affected the governments ability to publicly consult on, and issue, a policy direction to the CRTC to appropriately scope the regulation of social media services with respect to their distribution of commercial programs.

Scaffidi said in the statement: User-generated content uploaded onto YouTube will not be captured by this bill. Only platforms that broadcast commercial content are in scope.

This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below.

Some opponents point to freedom of expression concerns and say a government regulator has no business picking and choosing what content Canadians are presented with when they use a digital service.

Several prominent creators have said they are worried that it will harm digital creators themselves. If the CRTC forces platforms like YouTube or TikTok to highlight their content to users in Canada who arent interested in it, the algorithms could then downrank that content globally, which is a market where many make the majority of their income.

Previous CRTC chair Ian Scott has said the regulator could mandate algorithmic outcomes, such as requiring more Canadian content. It wont interfere with algorithms themselves the bill says the CRTC cant require the use of a specific algorithm.

This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below.

But the idea that a government regulator could look directly at the constantly-changing algorithms used by tech giants, some of which might operate in a black box, and require specific changes in real time, probably isnt a realistic option.

CRTC chair Vicky Eatrides has promised the CRTC will listen to the opinions of Canadians while it considers how to implement the legislation.

The CRTC will launch a public consultation, but it remains to be seen how easy it will be for the public to participate. Asked for more information about what that process will look like, including whether the regulator will take any steps to make it easier for Canadians to take part, a CRTC spokesperson declined comment until the bill becomes law.

This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below.

CRTC proceedings are public, but arent always user-friendly. The language can be technical and lawyerly, the website can be confusing to navigate, and process is often dominated by those used to the environment, such as lawyers working for telecom or broadcast companies or a few specific advocacy groups.

Canadians will have a chance to submit written comments to the consultation. A proceeding of this significance will also almost certainly involve a public hearing. If previous CRTC hearings are any guide, thats likely to be two or three weeks in which CRTC commissioners gather in a windowless hearing room in Gatineau, Que. to hear from interested parties.

You can expect the proceeding to run the gamut from hours of incredibly technical discussions to potential fireworks between key witnesses and the commissioners questioning them.

This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below.

A 2014 proceeding looking at the future of TV saw previous CRTC chair Jean-Pierre Blais clash with Netflix when that company refused to hand over requested information. Industry-watchers (and the assembled media) will be keeping an eye for more dramatic moments between commissioners and platforms resistant to some of the proposed regulations.

The previous policy direction told the CRTC it expected the regulator to wrap up the process in nine months an ambitious timeline given the regulators proceedings can take years from start to finish.

But even then, CRTC decisions can be appealed, including in the Federal Court of Appeal. If a party has a problem with the decision the regulator ends up issuing, and its appeal is accepted by the courts, the final outcome may not be settled for years to come.

View post:
Liberals' controversial online streaming bill could soon be law. Here's what to expect - National Post