Farmers Protest: Why Are Some Liberals Invoking the Legacy of Margaret Thatcher? – The Wire
Fully 30 years after she was eased out of her job by her own party, Indian admirers of Britains Iron Lady are sending up fervent prayers for Margaret Thatcher Redux. Hacks are flooding the media space with froth as they sing paeans to the dear departed lady. (Their ardent hope is to be delivered soon from the ignominy of too much democracy.) And they dont want their readers to remember that, alone among Britains many Oxford-educated prime ministers, it was Thatcher whom her alma mater refused to award an honorary doctorate. She was still very much in power, and her lobbyists had left few stones unturned in their efforts to secure for the PM that nearly routine honour from Oxford. And yet she was snubbed. And what a snub it was! The meeting of Congregation, Oxfords governing assembly, convened to consider the proposed degree to Thatcher, was the most crowded assembly of that august body that most of those present could remember. And what followed was a wounding blow to the PM:
The No exit at Sir Christopher Wrens Sheldonian Theatre was jammed like a London Tube station in the rush hour long after the Aye door had taken its last voter. Dons and senior administrators decided by 738 votes to 319 against giving Mrs Thatcher the scarlet and crimson gown and velvet bonnet of a doctor of civil law.
For the record, the only other important Oxonian to be denied that honorary degree in the 20th century was Z.A. Bhutto for his dreadful human rights record. Interestingly, Bhuttos report card at the Congregation hustings was way better than Thatchers: 191 for and 239 against. Indeed, in Thatchers case, a banner had even been slung across Somerville, the PMs old college at Oxford, saying, No degree for Mrs Thatcher, an honour denied to the Pakistan PM. About Thatchers abortive degree bid, The Guardian had noted at that time that
(t)he scale of the PMs defeat was due to a huge turnout by scientific and medical dons, who rarely take part in academic debates but have been roused by the effects of government economic curbs on their research.
That memorable put-down, delivered to a sitting PM, has since entered Oxfords folklore. Indeed, in her home country today, derisive references to Margaret Thatcher (a Marmite figure, La Pasionaria of Privilege, .) are far more common than benign ones, even among conservative circles. But in Britains former colony India, time seems to have stood still since Thatchers glory days. So we have a senior English language journalist grandly talking about Narendra Modis Thatcher or Anna moment, even as the Indian PM finds himself besieged by tens of thousands of farmers protesting at Delhis borders against his governments farm sector reforms. The Anna moment, in this journalists book, is a proxy for the Manmohan Singh moment, by which is meant capitulation and surrender: isnt Singh famous for how he caved in to the Anna Hazare movement against corruption? By contrast, the Thatcher moment
would mean when a big, audacious and risky push for reform, that threatens established structures and entrenched vested interests, brings an avalanche of opposition. (Emphasis added)
So Modi has a stark choice to make: either retreat like Manmohan Singh did under pressure, or push farm reforms in Margaret Thatcher style. And how Modi answers this question will determine national politics going ahead.
So far, so good. The scribe is stating his case. It is clear on which side his sympathies lie, but that can hardly be faulted. Indeed, it is a perfectly acceptable opinion piece by a journalist up until this point. But he signs off with an extraordinary flourish:
Our wish, of course, is that he [Modi] will choose Thatcher over Anna. It will be a tragedy if even Modi were to lose his nerve over his boldest reform. (Emphasis added)
This, to me, reads more like a political manifesto than a journalists despatch. (Note how the whole news portal has been deftly subsumed in that clever our wish. The message is: here are a couple of hundred votes to give you strength. Good luck and godspeed!) And this is not all. Elsewhere in the piece, even as he grudgingly concedes that farmers blockading the capital make for really bad pictures, the writer doesnt forget to tell us why this is bad optics: after all, these arent nutcases of Occupy Wall Street. This speaks to visceral contempt for organised mass action, the kind of contempt that underlies the now-famous Hard work versus Harvard witticism. The contempt is targeted in both these smart quotes at a common enemy: the Khan Market Gang (yes, gang with an upper-case G), or the tukde tukde Gang, if you like.
Farmers arrive in a tractor to attend a protest against the newly passed farm bills at Singhu border near New Delhi, India, December 14, 2020. Photo: Reuters/Adnan Abidi
And this is not a solo journalist waxing eloquent about the Thatcher/Modi likeness. Others are piping up, all of them in the same strain: this is the Modi governments make-or-mar Thatcher moment, and Modi can let go of this propitious moment only at his own i.e., his reforms peril. A quick scan of the last few days opinion pieces in various news media gives me access to another journalistic tirade on another news portal against protests from a select group of farmers, who have received a megaphone from the domestic and international press, as well as opportunistic support from opposition parties, which finally see a possible wedge issue to use against Modis government. (Megaphone, indeed! What happened to the sundry media platforms who were proving to be so loud a megaphone in the protesters hands that these same protesters were obliged to boycott them wholesale?) And this writer proudly reminds us that the Modis Thatcher moment tagline had occurred to him as early as March 2015 when he penned a learned essay on this same subject. He also closes his recent piece with this fond wish:
Modi in 2020 is a seasoned, powerful leader. Lets hope he fulfils the promise of the moment.
Amen!
Neither of these men deems it necessary to argue their i.e., Modis case. It must be self-evident to all but the Gang, so. But probe it a little and you will know that they are Crusaders against that pernicious phenomenon called subsidies. I remember having once watched the better-known of these two journalists in a TV discussion in which he frankly confessed that he found subsidies vulgar, antediluvian. Of course, he was referring only to the poor mens subsidies those attached to food and cooking gas and by no means those which are reserved for the rich ( tax breaks, for example, which are meant to unleash corporate animal spirits).
So, can we take a quick look at their iron-clad case against the one subsidy that is troubling their conscience most at this point? We will necessarily need to compare these subsidies with those given by rich countries to their farmers. Surely, developed (and efficient) economies dont entertain such antiquated, fossilized handouts as subsidies? And if they do, these must be no more than a trickle while the privileged protesters at Delhis borders wallow in a whole sea of them?
In a study compiled by professor Bharat Rameshwaram of IIT Delhi in March 2019 for the Fifteenth Finance Commission, he puts annual Central government subsidy to farmers at Rs 1,205 billion: made up of fertiliser subsidies (Rs 700 billion), price support (Rs 240 billion), credit subsidies (Rs 200 bilion) and crop insurance subsidy (Rs 65 billion). Parallelly, there are subsidies offered by the state governments which together work out to Rs 1,140 billion: power subsidies (Rs 900 billion), irrigation subsidies (Rs 175 billion) and crop insurance subsidies (Rs 65 billion). In addition, the state governments in 2017-18 had announced farm loan waivers of the order of Rs 1,220 billion. In all, then, farm subsidies add up approximately to Rs 3,500 billion, or to 2-2.25% of the countrys GDP. They also form about 20% of aggregate farm income, annually. Another study by the Centre for WTO Studies (part of the Indian Institute of Foreign Trade) estimates Indias per-farmer aggregate domestic support in 2018-19 at $282 (roughly Rs 20,000).
Also Read: Are the New Agriculture Ordinances an Extension of the WTOs Agenda?
Let us now place that number beside per-farmer subsidies provided by some other economies: $5,357 (Australia), $8,588 (EU countries), $11,437 (Japan), $13,010 (Canada), and $61,286 (the US). For China and South Korea, the numbers are $1,065 and $5,369 respectively. Even Brazil ($332) and Thailand ($367) provide more substantial support to their farmers than India. Those challenging the whole concept of subsidies can derive strength for their case by looking at Bangladesh ($11) and Indonesia ($139), but will a comparison with such countries give them comfort?
A closer look at the US numbers will do no harm. Why analyse an outlier, you ask? Well, isnt the US the neoliberals Mecca for all seasons? Indeed, the senior journalist we are referring to here had made quite a name for himself when, in 2003, he publicly counselled Vajpayee, Indias PM then, to send Indian troops to Iraq as part of a George Bush-Tony Blair-Vajpayee coalition. His rationale was simple: if India could once prove her bona fides as a serious democracy by joining that holy war, no one would ever again manage to drive a wedge between her and the US. Alas!Vajpayee was less than enchanted by the advice. But surely Modi can be trusted to do what Vajpayee couldnt?
So, what more do we know about what the US does for its farmers? An article published by Taxpayers for Common Sense on September 3, 2020 sheds some light. Direct US government payments to farmers during the current year are of the order of $37.2 billion. Plus, the Commodity Credit Corpn is spending another $14 billion. Together, these subsidies ($51.2 billion) form 43.8% of net farm income of the country. (Contrast this with Indias 20%.) And this is far from being the whole story. The HEROES Act passed in May 2020 provided additional COVID-19 funding of $16.5 billion to agriculture. And, in the second tranche of the COVID-19 funding by way of the HEALS Act which awaits Congressional approval another $20 billion in direct payments (cash subsidies) to the sector have been proposed. If this corpus is released, aggregate US farm sector subsidies this year will top $88 billion (or, Rs 6,600 bn, approximately, or roughly twice the government support to farming in India.) And that sum will cater to a community whose size is a little over 1% of Indias farming roll strength. Vulgar? Of course not. Its the US, stupid!
And yet, at the WTO, the developed economies regularly give India a piece of their collective mind on her undue support to agriculture. How this scandalous state of affairs persists to this day indeed, how much more heat is likely to be turned on India on this count in the coming years by the rich countries is a story for another day. But there can be little doubt that Indias governmental support to agriculture is a measly fraction of what richer countries routinely give to their own farmers.
A farmer works in his field. Photo: Jignesh Mistry/PAIGAM
So, are our anti-subsidy crusaders ill-informed? I dont think so. Their problem is not informational, but ideological. To these zealots of neoliberalism, all support to the ordinary citizen is odious, and poor subsidies are pure sacrilege. Such subsidies, they are convinced, create the culture of dependency (Thatchers words) while subsidies to the wealthy are productive support. No amount of additional information will disabuse neoliberals of these prejudices.
Margaret Thatcher once famously said there was no such thing as society: there were only individuals and there were families. In much the same breath, she added, (P)eople have got the entitlements too much in mind without the obligations. Her epigones in India, as elsewhere, have learnt these lessons by heart. As more farmers join the ongoing agitation in and around the national capital, therefore, we can be certain to witness more smarmy invocations of the spirit of the woman who had helped introduce to the UK what one commentator memorably described as casino capitalism.
Anjan Basu can be reached at basuanjan52@gmail.com.
See the article here:
Farmers Protest: Why Are Some Liberals Invoking the Legacy of Margaret Thatcher? - The Wire
- Globe editorial: The Liberals tilt the table for Stellantis, again - The Globe and Mail - November 19th, 2026 [November 19th, 2026]
- Superintelligent AI is on the way, what can liberals do about it? - ALDE Party - November 19th, 2026 [November 19th, 2026]
- Liberals expected to face House of Commons vote on Budget 2026 today - Calgary Journal - November 19th, 2026 [November 19th, 2026]
- Pick one or the other: Ontario Liberals slam former leader after accepting Ford government appointment - Global News - November 19th, 2026 [November 19th, 2026]
- Liberals expected to face House of Commons vote on Budget 2026 today - CityNews Toronto - November 19th, 2026 [November 19th, 2026]
- Victorian election launches: Labor, Liberals and One Nation committed to brutal austerity - World Socialist Web Site - November 19th, 2026 [November 19th, 2026]
- Ontario's Liberals have spent 8 years adrift. This weekends leadership race hints at a path back to power - Toronto Star - November 19th, 2026 [November 19th, 2026]
- Jesse Kline: Liberals should cut their losses rather than bribing Stellantis to stay - Yahoo News Canada - November 19th, 2026 [November 19th, 2026]
- Lithuanian liberals threaten no-confidence motion over Taiwan representative office name - LRT - November 19th, 2026 [November 19th, 2026]
- Liberals Opposition Day Motion Demands Students be Made Whole - Ontario Liberal Party - November 19th, 2026 [November 19th, 2026]
- Liberals expected to face House of Commons vote on Budget 2026 - Winnipeg Free Press - November 19th, 2026 [November 19th, 2026]
- Liberals hope to take Bloc stronghold in byelection but it wont be easy - Yahoo News Canada - November 19th, 2026 [November 19th, 2026]
- Motor Mouth: Why the Liberals can't win their Stellantis battle - Driving - November 19th, 2026 [November 19th, 2026]
- Liberals hope to take Bloc stronghold in byelection but it wont be easy - National Post - November 19th, 2026 [November 19th, 2026]
- Ontario Liberals request probe of whether Premier Doug Ford broke ethics rules in OSAP scandal - The Trillium - November 19th, 2026 [November 19th, 2026]
- Chuck Schumer gets mocked by liberals over new video: Gerontocracy - NJ.com - November 19th, 2026 [November 19th, 2026]
- Heres what you need to know as the Liberals prepare to table Budget 2026 - Toronto Star - November 5th, 2026 [November 5th, 2026]
- In the news today: Liberals table budget, blue wave reaction, Kutryk spacewalk - thecanadianpressnews.ca - November 5th, 2026 [November 5th, 2026]
- Christine Schueckler: The simple reason why liberals and conservatives don't understand each other - 1819 News - November 5th, 2026 [November 5th, 2026]
- Heres what you need to know as the Liberals prepare to table Budget 2026 - CityNews Toronto - November 5th, 2026 [November 5th, 2026]
- Conservatives Call on Liberals to Split MAID Bill - CPAC - November 5th, 2026 [November 5th, 2026]
- European liberals must not sacrifice their principles by hosting a divisive figure like Reza Pahlavi - EU Reporter - November 5th, 2026 [November 5th, 2026]
- Liberals to unveil 2026 budget amid ongoing economic and trade uncertainty - https://unpublished.ca/ - November 5th, 2026 [November 5th, 2026]
- In the news today: Liberals table budget, blue wave reaction, Kutryk spacewalk - The Spec - November 5th, 2026 [November 5th, 2026]
- Opinion | Liberals disappointed by Justin Trudeau leave Mark Carney little room for economic error - Toronto Star - November 5th, 2026 [November 5th, 2026]
- The Liberals are unveiling their budget this week. Ask us your questions - The Globe and Mail - November 5th, 2026 [November 5th, 2026]
- NSW Liberals hit with MP exodus amid surge in popularity for One Nation - ABC News & Headlines Australian Broadcasting Corporation - November 5th, 2026 [November 5th, 2026]
- Liberals out-fundraise Conservatives by almost $1M in third quarter of 2026 - Toronto Star - November 5th, 2026 [November 5th, 2026]
- Churchill Falls expected to be a key topic as Liberals prepare to table federal budget today - NTV News - November 5th, 2026 [November 5th, 2026]
- What the Liberals really need is a new spin-off brand - The Australian - November 5th, 2026 [November 5th, 2026]
- Here's what you need to know as the Liberals prepare to table Budget 2026 - Winnipeg Sun - November 5th, 2026 [November 5th, 2026]
- Liberals beat Conservatives in fundraising by almost $1-million in third quarter - The Globe and Mail - November 5th, 2026 [November 5th, 2026]
- MP Caputo hopes to see Liberals use Thursday budget to cut waste, reinvest in Canadians - CFJC Today Kamloops - November 5th, 2026 [November 5th, 2026]
- Liberals out-fundraise Conservatives by almost $1M in third quarter of 2026 - CTV News - November 5th, 2026 [November 5th, 2026]
- Haley Stevens, John Fetterman, And Why White Liberals Are More Dangerous Than MAGA - NewsOne - November 5th, 2026 [November 5th, 2026]
- The Liberals are still in a honeymoon, and its showing across the country: Nanos on byelections - CTV News - November 5th, 2026 [November 5th, 2026]
- The Liberals can outflank Labor by finally stopping their endless war against super - Crikey - November 5th, 2026 [November 5th, 2026]
- "The Liberals are the party of big business" - Toronto Sun - November 5th, 2026 [November 5th, 2026]
- This Dark New TV Ad Calls Liberals 'Full Of Hate' And The Reactions Are Shocking - Yahoo News Singapore - October 30th, 2026 [October 30th, 2026]
- Opinion | A right-wing ad says liberals are the new racists. What does that make the GOP? - MS NOW - October 30th, 2026 [October 30th, 2026]
- Stelco sale should have never been approved by Liberals: Lewis - Rabble.ca - October 30th, 2026 [October 30th, 2026]
- One Nation could save the NSW Liberals. Not so in Victoria - AFR - October 30th, 2026 [October 30th, 2026]
- Liberals introduce bill to restrict access to MAID for mental illness - CityNews Winnipeg - October 30th, 2026 [October 30th, 2026]
- Liberals table bill restricting access to MAID for mental illness - The Lethbridge Herald - October 30th, 2026 [October 30th, 2026]
- Concern of the liberals of the Eurochamber for the complaint of harassment against Comn - Diari ARA - October 30th, 2026 [October 30th, 2026]
- Liberals table bill to bar access to MAID for mental illness, allow advance requests - The Lethbridge Herald - October 30th, 2026 [October 30th, 2026]
- Conservatives and Liberals Agree on Many of These Policies. Do You, Too? - WSJ - October 28th, 2026 [October 28th, 2026]
- Liberals introduce bill to bar MAID for mental illness and decriminalize advance requests - National Post - October 28th, 2026 [October 28th, 2026]
- Could Slovakia be next? Liberals build their challenge to Fico - ALDE Party - October 28th, 2026 [October 28th, 2026]
- Victorian Liberals to ban 'globalise the intifada' chant if elected - ABC News & Headlines Australian Broadcasting Corporation - October 28th, 2026 [October 28th, 2026]
- Holt Liberals cutting committee oversight in half - CBC - October 28th, 2026 [October 28th, 2026]
- Bill Maher Says Trump Is Way Less of a Threat Than Liberals Think After Presidents Rant Against Him - Yahoo - October 28th, 2026 [October 28th, 2026]
- Liberals reach 48%, highest since April 2016, as approval for Carney government remains strong - Abacus Data - October 28th, 2026 [October 28th, 2026]
- Health Matters: Liberals table bill restricting access to MAID in cases of mental illness - Yahoo News Canada - October 28th, 2026 [October 28th, 2026]
- Bill Maher Says Trump Is 'Way Less' of a Threat Than Liberals Think After President's Rant Against Him - TheWrap - October 28th, 2026 [October 28th, 2026]
- Carneys high popularity, referendum win, and a new right-of-centre party could help Liberals win 10-15 more seats in Alberta in next election, say... - October 28th, 2026 [October 28th, 2026]
- N.L. Liberals, NDP want action from government during House of Assembly's fall sitting - CBC - October 28th, 2026 [October 28th, 2026]
- Liberals set to table bill restricting access to MAID in cases of mental illness - The Spec - October 28th, 2026 [October 28th, 2026]
- Liberals set to table bill restricting access to MAID in cases of mental illness - CityNews Toronto - October 28th, 2026 [October 28th, 2026]
- Liberals table bill to bar access to MAID for mental illness, allow advance requests - Vernon Matters - October 28th, 2026 [October 28th, 2026]
- Opinion Israeli liberals are funding the oppression of Haredi women - Haaretz - October 17th, 2026 [October 17th, 2026]
- NDP says it opened or expanded 250 schools while B.C. Liberals closed 250. Is that accurate? - Vancouver Sun - October 17th, 2026 [October 17th, 2026]
- Sharjeel Imams Islamist manifesto will be forgotten. The silence of liberals will not - ThePrint - October 17th, 2026 [October 17th, 2026]
- Why Liberals must win Victoria and Labor is hoping to lose - AFR - October 17th, 2026 [October 17th, 2026]
- Is Frydenberg the white knight the Liberals need? - AFR - October 17th, 2026 [October 17th, 2026]
- Not all Liberals are celebrating the Festival of Josh - AFR - October 17th, 2026 [October 17th, 2026]
- One Nations James Ashby and the Liberals: Why orange is the new blue - Independent Australia - October 17th, 2026 [October 17th, 2026]
- Globe editorial: The Liberals are right to restrict MAID - The Globe and Mail - October 10th, 2026 [October 10th, 2026]
- Blanger criticizes Liberals for voting against Conservative MAiD bill - Sudbury News - October 10th, 2026 [October 10th, 2026]
- Liberals look to amend 31 laws at once in attempt to reduce red tape - CBC - October 10th, 2026 [October 10th, 2026]
- Capital Dispatch: Is Canada in an affordability crisis? And why the Liberals took a stand on assisted dying this week - CTV News - October 10th, 2026 [October 10th, 2026]
- The Liberals and Greens appear to be heading in the same direction - ABC News & Headlines Australian Broadcasting Corporation - October 10th, 2026 [October 10th, 2026]
- Conservatives vote in favour of Liberals Bill C-39, but promise amendments to 'protect the rights of workers' - Yahoo News Canada - October 10th, 2026 [October 10th, 2026]
- Liberals poised to unveil next steps for MAID access - The Globe and Mail - October 10th, 2026 [October 10th, 2026]
- Quebec Liberals projected to win 4 of 5 Outaouais seats - CBC - October 10th, 2026 [October 10th, 2026]
- Liberals to outline plans on assisted dying ahead of mental illness expansion - CityNews Toronto - October 10th, 2026 [October 10th, 2026]
- Liberals 'shutting out the voices of Canadians' on major projects bill: NDP House leader - CBC - October 10th, 2026 [October 10th, 2026]
- Liberals ask Ontario auditor to probe spending, oversight of OSAP at career colleges - Global News - October 10th, 2026 [October 10th, 2026]
- Conservatives vote in favour of Liberals Bill C-39, but promise amendments to 'protect the rights of workers' - National Post - October 10th, 2026 [October 10th, 2026]
- Conservatives vote with Liberals as Bill C-39 heads to committee - CTV News - October 10th, 2026 [October 10th, 2026]