Mediaboss Marketing

Do elite liberals want to take this flag down and turn the barn into an abortion clinic? Photo: Jim Watson/AFP/Getty Images

One of the most regular conservative arguments about politics and culture, which has been around at least since Spiro T. Agnew but has had a huge renaissance in the Trump era, is that liberal elites clustered in big cities, especially on the East and West Coasts, look down on, or at a minimum dont understand, the plain and mostly white folk of the Great American Heartland.

Some members of the liberal elite deny the charge, while others glory in it; most do make the point that if the 2016 presidential elections are any indication, there are at least as many Americans in one camp as in the other (though all those underpopulated red spaces are a problem for Democrats who would like to control the Senate or a majority of state governments someday). The distinguished liberal journalist Mike Tomasky is the latest to echo the charge. Lets consider it on the merits at this particular and particularly fraught moment in American political history.

Tomaskys point of departure is this:

Unlike coastal liberals, he continues, people in the heartland go to church; have things that interest them more than politics; are not averse to owning guns or admiring the military or global corporations; and are reflexively patriotic.

These are, as Tomasky knows, overgeneralizations, not just of heartland people but of the coastal elites that supposedly despise them. Although he self-effacingly places himself in the ranks of the clueless and the insensitive, Mike Tomasky is actually a native of West Virginia, probably ground zero for the estrangement of white Middle Americans from the national brand of liberal politics in recent years. I happen to know he has plenty of things other than politics he cares about, including college football; I know this because I share that passion. Indeed, as a Heartland native (though now living in the Central Coast of California), I avoid talking or even thinking about politics when Im around folks who have nonpolitical day jobs; have no problem understanding why people, especially in rural areas, own guns, or why the biggest employer in many towns is as likely to be regarded as a benefactor as a villain. I even go to church very regularly. There are more people like Tomasky, and even like me, in the ranks of coastal liberal elites than he lets on.

And while you can always find professional or armchair liberal observers who have the attitudes Tomasky condemns, they are not really found that often among people in the business of running for office you know, the liberal politicians Middle America is presumed to hate. I cant recall ever hearing a Democratic politician spit contempt at people for being religious. Democrats have gone far out of their way to express support for the Second Amendment, and now regularly talk about gun safety rather than gun control. And conspicuous displays of patriotism and of respect for the military were as common at the coastal-elite-dominated 2016 Democratic National Convention as at the aggressively Middle American GOP confab.

Yes, contemporary liberals are sometimes inflexible and tone deaf, but the examples Tomasky cites are questionable:

Intra-Democratic infighting on the exact level of minimum-wage increases subsided with the end of the Sanders/Clinton presidential nominating fight, and many culture-war battles are the product not of liberal dogma but of conservative efforts to find wedge issues. After all, it was the North Carolina GOPs bathroom bill that ignited the transgender rights controversy, and we wouldnt be arguing over municipal Christmas decorations if not for Fox News annual War on Christmas meme. You cant really blame these sources of cultural tension on intolerant liberals who would generally prefer to talk about other issues.

While the disease Tomasky deplores may not be as all-ravaging as he suggests, I guess theres nothing wrong with administering a particularly strong inoculation. There is a species of coastal-elite liberal media that writes and talks strictly for people like themselves and wouldnt know Kentucky from Timbuktu, though its not as large a segment of the media as often imagined.

But there is another problem Tomasky does not address: There are sometimes reasons other than elitism, and the very opposite of indifference to Middle America, that dictate fighting the heartlands political representatives vigorously.

The fight against Trumpcare is about many things, but none is so important as the fight to keep the state and local governments of Middle America from shirking the needs of their poorer and sicker citizens. If coastal elites really didnt give a damn about anyone else, theyd probably accept a deal from Susan Collins and Bill Cassidy to let the states keep or kill Obamacare as they wished, and let those red-state African-Americans and hillbillies suffer the consequences. Similarly, there is probably nothing that would lower the cultural temperature of American politics more than some sort of grand bargain on abortion, such as letting different places have different policies. There have been liberals who have urged that kind of compromise for years. But it would be a betrayal of the reproductive rights of women who happen to live in inconvenient places the very places liberals are thought to dislike and abhor.

Its always a good idea to make some effort to understand people with different backgrounds, different views, different life circumstances, and yes, even different prejudices than our own. But to the extent that liberals genuinely believe their policies are best for the whole country you know, the country they are suspected of loving too little then arguing that the Heartland is worse for their absence is an act not of elite disdain but of communal affection.

She denies her paid speeches for Wall Street audiences represented special treatment. Its probably true, but hard to prove.

Were increasingly divided between people who think Trumps doing a fine job, and people who think Congress should take steps to impeach him.

Sergeant Hugh Barry was indicted nearly six months after fatally shooting 66-year-old Deborah Danner.

U.S. officials released a video that shows the simulated ICBM being shot down.

The committee issued seven subpoenas Wednesday: four related to the Russia investigation, and three concerning the unmasking controversy.

The SpaceX and Tesla CEO has joined scores of other businesspeople speaking out in favor of the agreement.

She also slagged the DNC and addressed the possibility of running for office again.

Al Franken continues to trash talk his Senate colleague.

The firms knowingly misled doctors and patients about the risks inherent to opioid painkillers, the lawsuit alleges.

As the First Daughter keeps her head down, her dads decisions call into question how much pull she really has.

The president enlists his 11-year-old son Barron to express his outrage in the aftermath of the controversial Kathy Griffin photo shoot.

The right plans to seed damaging narratives about Warren early just as it did with Clinton. But that task will be much harder this time around.

Theresa May figured a snap election would strengthen her hand in Brexit talks. But the Tory lead is shrinking and Jeremy Corbyns doing well.

There is fresh evidence that African-American turnout sagged notably in 2016, and is not rebounding so far in 2017, either.

The former FBI director could appear before the Senate as soon as next week, CNN reports.

Liz Spayd, the papers sixth public editor, will also be its last.

The firm also attempted to hide its role in the film, which constituted the bulk of work it did on behalf of Turkeys government.

After months of deliberation, Trump has reportedly decided to undermine global cooperation on climate change and Americas diplomatic clout.

The student was supposed to be graduating from nursing school, but instead spent two hours stuck underground.

Go here to read the rest:
Do Coastal Liberals Hate Middle America? - New York Magazine