A careful rethinking of the Iraq War – MIT News
The term fog of war expresses the chaos and uncertainty of the battlefield. Often, it is only in hindsight that people can grasp what was unfolding around them.
Now, additional clarity about the Iraq War has arrived in the form of a new book by MIT political scientist Roger Petersen, which dives into the wars battlefield operations, political dynamics, and long-term impact. The U.S. launched the Iraq War in 2003 and formally wrapped it up in 2011, but Petersen analyzes the situation in Iraq through the current day and considers what the future holds for the country.
After a decade of research, Petersen identifies four key factors for understanding Iraqs situation. First, the U.S. invasion created chaos and a lack of clarity in terms of the hierarchy among Shia, Sunni, and Kurdish groups. Second, given these conditions, organizations that comprised a mix of militias, political groups, and religious groups came to the fore and captured elements of the new state the U.S. was attempting to set up. Third, by about 2018, the Shia groups became dominant, establishing a hierarchy, and along with that dominance, sectarian violence has fallen. Finally, the hybrid organizations established many years ago are now highly integrated into the Iraqi state.
Petersen has also come to believe two things about the Iraq War are not fully appreciated. One is how widely U.S. strategy varied over time in response to shifting circumstances.
This was not one war, says Petersen. This was many different wars going on. We had at least five strategies on the U.S. side.
And while the expressed goal of many U.S. officials was to build a functioning democracy in Iraq, the intense factionalism of Iraqi society led to further military struggles, between and among religious and ethnic groups. Thus, U.S. military strategy shifted as this multisided conflict evolved.
What really happened in Iraq, and the thing the United States and Westerners did not understand at first, is how much this would become a struggle for dominance among Shias, Sunnis, and Kurds, says Petersen. The United States thought they would build a state, and the state would push down and penetrate society. But it was society that created militias and captured the state.
Attempts to construct a well-functioning state, in Iraq or elsewhere must confront this factor, Petersen adds. Most people think in terms of groups. They think in terms of group hierarchies, and theyre motivated when they believe their own group is not in a proper space in the hierarchy. This is this emotion of resentment. I think this is just human nature.
Petersens book, Death, Dominance, and State-Building: The U.S. in Iraq and the Future of American Military Intervention, is published today by Oxford University Press. Petersen is the Arthur and Ruth Sloan Professor of Political Science at MIT and a member of the Security Studies Program based at MITs Center for International Studies.
Research on the ground
Petersen spent years interviewing people who were on the ground in Iraq during the war, from U.S. military personnel to former insurgents to regular Iraqi citizens, while extensively analyzing data about the conflict.
I didnt really come to conclusions about Iraq until six or seven years of applying this method, he says.
Ultimately, one core fact about the country heavily influenced the trajectory of the war. Iraqs Sunni Muslims made up about 20 percent or less of the countrys population but had been politically dominant before the U.S. took military action. After the U.S. toppled former dictator Saddam Hussein, it created an opening for the Shia majority to grasp more power.
The United States said, Were going to have democracy and think in individual terms, but this is not the way it played out, Petersen says. The way it played out was, over the years, the Shia organizations became the dominant force. The Sunnis and Kurds are now basically subordinate within this Shia-dominated state. The Shias also had advantages in organizing violence over the Sunnis, and theyre the majority. They were going to win.
As Petersen details in the book, a central unit of power became the political militia, based on ethnic and religious identification. One Shia militia, the Badr Organization, had trained professionally for years in Iran. The local Iraqi leader Moqtada al-Sadr could recruit Shia fighters from among the 2 million people living in the Sadr City slum. And no political militia wanted to back a strong multiethnic government.
They liked this weaker state, Petersen says. The United States wanted to build a new Iraqi state, but what we did was create a situation where multiple and large Shia militia make deals with each other.
A captains war
In turn, these dynamics meant the U.S. had to shift military strategies numerous times, occasionally in high-profile ways. The five strategies Petersen identifies are clear, hold, build (CHB); decapitation; community mobilization; homogenization; and war-fighting.
The war from the U.S. side was highly decentralized, Petersen says. Military captains, who typically command about 140 to 150 soldiers, had fairly wide berth in terms of how they were choosing to fight.
It was a captains war in a lot of ways, Petersen adds.
The point is emphatically driven home in one chapter, Captain Wright goes to Baghdad, co-authored with Col. Timothy Wright PhD 18, who wrote his MIT political science dissertation based on his experience and company command during the surge period.
As Petersen also notes, drawing on government data, the U.S. also managed to suppress violence fairly effectively at times, particularly before 2006 and after 2008. The professional soldiers tried to do a good job, but some of the problems they werent going to solve, Petersen says.
Still, all of this raises a conundrum. If trying to start a new state in Iraq was always likely to lead to an increase in Shia power, is there really much the U.S. could have done differently?
Thats a million-dollar question, Petersen says.
Perhaps the best way to engage with it, Petersen notes, is to recognize the importance of studying how factional groups grasp power through use of violence, and how that emerges in society. It is a key issue running throughout Petersens work, and one, he notes, that has often been studied by his graduate students in MITs Security Studies Program.
Death, Dominance, and State-Building has received praise from foreign-policy scholars. Paul Staniland, a political scientist at the University of Chicago, has said the work combines intellectual creativity with careful attention to on-the ground dynamics, and is a fascinating macro-level account of the politics of group competition in Iraq. This book is required reading for anyone interested in civil war, U.S. foreign policy, or the politics of violent state-building."
Petersen, for his part, allows that he was pleased when one marine who served in Iraq read the manuscript in advance and found it interesting.
He said, This is good, and its not the way we think about it, Petersen says. Thats my biggest compliment, to have a practitioner say it make them think. If I can get that kind of reaction, Ill be pleased.
Continue reading here:
A careful rethinking of the Iraq War - MIT News
- US OKs potential sale of aircraft support to Iraq, Pentagon says - The Jerusalem Post - April 16th, 2024 [April 16th, 2024]
- FBI charges arms dealers for conspiring to send weapons to Sudan, Iraq - USA TODAY - April 16th, 2024 [April 16th, 2024]
- Biden cheat sheet for Iraq PM meeting caught on camera -- including instructions to 'pause' - New York Post - April 16th, 2024 [April 16th, 2024]
- The Met, Amid an Audit of its Holdings, Returns an Ancient Statue to Iraq - The New York Times - April 16th, 2024 [April 16th, 2024]
- Iraq Hopes to Expand Economic Relationship With the U.S. - OilPrice.com - April 16th, 2024 [April 16th, 2024]
- US and UK forces help shoot down Iranian drones over Jordan, Syria and Iraq - The Guardian - April 16th, 2024 [April 16th, 2024]
- Footage shows Iranian Shahed 136 drone flying over Iraq en route to Israel - The Times of Israel - April 16th, 2024 [April 16th, 2024]
- Kataib Hezbollah is Part of Iraq's PMF - The Washington Institute - April 16th, 2024 [April 16th, 2024]
- Denmark will close down embassy in Iraq - The Jerusalem Post - April 16th, 2024 [April 16th, 2024]
- Iraq reopens airspace after Iran's strikes on Israel - The New Arab - April 16th, 2024 [April 16th, 2024]
- Biden to host Iraq's leader after Iran's attack on Israel spurs chaos across the Middle East - Yahoo! Voices - April 16th, 2024 [April 16th, 2024]
- Iraq Needs a New Kind of Partnership With the United States - Foreign Affairs Magazine - April 16th, 2024 [April 16th, 2024]
- Iraq denies any drones or missiles were launched from its territory during Iran attack - The Times of Israel - April 16th, 2024 [April 16th, 2024]
- Jordan, Iraq and Lebanon reopen airspace after Iran attacks - The Jerusalem Post - April 16th, 2024 [April 16th, 2024]
- Iraq postpones vote on bill including death penalty for same-sex acts - The Times of Israel - April 16th, 2024 [April 16th, 2024]
- Stroudsburg man sentenced to 70 years for torturing employee in Iraq - 69News WFMZ-TV - April 16th, 2024 [April 16th, 2024]
- Iraq's struggle, divided between the US and Iran - The Jerusalem Post - April 16th, 2024 [April 16th, 2024]
- Iraqi Airways announces the resumption of flights between Iraq and Iran - Reuters - April 16th, 2024 [April 16th, 2024]
- Who are Iran's proxies threatening Israel? - The Jerusalem Post - April 16th, 2024 [April 16th, 2024]
- Wreckage of Iranian missiles and drones bound for Israel found in Iraq - The National - April 16th, 2024 [April 16th, 2024]
- Iraqi PM tells US President that Iraq is shifting from a military alliance to economic ties with the US - Iraqi News - April 16th, 2024 [April 16th, 2024]
- Iraq PM arrives in Washington - Arab News - April 16th, 2024 [April 16th, 2024]
- Defense relationship part of US-Iraq talks in Washington next week, US official says - Reuters - April 16th, 2024 [April 16th, 2024]
- Ex-Sen. Bob Graham of Florida dies at 87; led Intelligence Committee after 9/11 and opposed Iraq invasion - The San Diego Union-Tribune - April 16th, 2024 [April 16th, 2024]
- How an Iraq War veteran coped with PTSD by using taste mindfulness and bourbon - Fox News - April 16th, 2024 [April 16th, 2024]
- Jordan, Iraq and Lebanon reopen airspace after Iran attacks - Deccan Herald - April 16th, 2024 [April 16th, 2024]
- Prime Minister Sudani's Pivotal US Visit and Its Implications for Iraq's Future - Wilson Center - April 16th, 2024 [April 16th, 2024]
- George Michael Took a Stand Against the Iraq War - Jacobin magazine - April 16th, 2024 [April 16th, 2024]
- Iraq to enhance air fleet with $140m US aircraft support deal - Airforce Technology - Airforce Technology - April 16th, 2024 [April 16th, 2024]
- Investigating Torture: FBI-HSI Investigation Leads to U.S. Citizen's Conviction for Human Rights Violations in Iraq FBI - Federal Bureau of... - April 16th, 2024 [April 16th, 2024]
- Iraq's "Resistance" Factions Shift to Major Crackdown on Media Spaces - The Washington Institute - March 2nd, 2024 [March 2nd, 2024]
- Couple Travels to Iraq After Vowing to Visit All 195 Countries Their Experience Goes Viral (Exclusive) - Yahoo Entertainment - March 2nd, 2024 [March 2nd, 2024]
- The devastation of Gaza was inevitable: A comparison to US operations in Iraq and Syria - The Times of Israel - March 2nd, 2024 [March 2nd, 2024]
- Iraq War veteran struggles to access VA care in rural area - DAV - March 2nd, 2024 [March 2nd, 2024]
- Maintaining the best thing the US built in Iraq: Continued support to the Iraqi Counterterrorism Service - Middle East Institute - March 2nd, 2024 [March 2nd, 2024]
- Couple Travels to Iraq After Vowing to Visit All 195 Countries Their Experience Goes Viral (Exclusive) - PEOPLE - March 2nd, 2024 [March 2nd, 2024]
- Iraq's Twenty Years of Carnage | Joshua Hammer - The New York Review of Books - March 2nd, 2024 [March 2nd, 2024]
- Thousands of Ugandans may sue over U.S. security work in Iraq, Afghanistan - Semafor - March 2nd, 2024 [March 2nd, 2024]
- Book Review: The Achilles Trap, by Steve Coll - The New York Times - March 2nd, 2024 [March 2nd, 2024]
- Iraq/KRI: Further Information: Journalist Released After Three Years Imprisonment: Guhdar Zebari - Amnesty International - March 2nd, 2024 [March 2nd, 2024]
- He saw the horrors of PTSD after serving in Iraq. Now this former Goldman Sachs analyst has a startup aimed at improving mental health treatment -... - March 2nd, 2024 [March 2nd, 2024]
- Cafe in Iraq allows customers to play with cats - WNCT - March 2nd, 2024 [March 2nd, 2024]
- Iraq Attracts Wave of Saudi and Gulf Investments for the First Time - The Media Line - March 2nd, 2024 [March 2nd, 2024]
- FEMA employees brought government devices abroad without authorization, including to China and Iraq, document ... - FedScoop - March 2nd, 2024 [March 2nd, 2024]
- Iraq War failures can be boiled down to miscommunications, according to this author - WLRN - March 2nd, 2024 [March 2nd, 2024]
- Steve Coll discusses collaboration with RCFP attorneys for new book, "The Achilles Trap" - Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press - March 2nd, 2024 [March 2nd, 2024]
- The National Guard's quiet role in Iraq, Syria and Jordan - Yahoo! Voices - March 2nd, 2024 [March 2nd, 2024]
- Two killed in Turkish drone strike in northern Iraq - Al Arabiya English - March 2nd, 2024 [March 2nd, 2024]
- Iraq to close all IDP camps by July 30 - Mission Network News - March 2nd, 2024 [March 2nd, 2024]
- President of the Republic: Iraq's oil production increased twofold to 4.7 million barrels in the past decade - Shafaq News - Shafaq News - March 2nd, 2024 [March 2nd, 2024]
- Third Edition of Antalya Diplomacy Forum Opens with Participation of Iraq Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the Republic of ... - - March 2nd, 2024 [March 2nd, 2024]
- Opinion: American airstrikes in Iraq, Syria, Yemen solidify a concerning reality - UT Daily Beacon - March 2nd, 2024 [March 2nd, 2024]
- Home Iraq Stories Rebuilding Social bonds through Baking - United Nations Development Programme - March 2nd, 2024 [March 2nd, 2024]
- Iraq's Central Bank sells over $1 billion in one week - Iraqi News - February 23rd, 2024 [February 23rd, 2024]
- Iraq's Alssad parters with Saudi Arabia's Al Rabie and Switzerland's Tetra Pak to tackle Iraq's food security - Iraqi News - February 23rd, 2024 [February 23rd, 2024]
- Iraq's positive trajectory serves as a beacon of hope - Arab News - February 23rd, 2024 [February 23rd, 2024]
- Iran-backed militias in Iraq claim to have targeted Israeli gas rig in Mediterranean - The Times of Israel - December 23rd, 2023 [December 23rd, 2023]
- I fought in Iraq, Israel has a sacred obligation to protect innocents that all those in uniform share - Fox News - December 23rd, 2023 [December 23rd, 2023]
- US troops in Iraq and Syria have faced over 100 attacks since October - Military Times - December 23rd, 2023 [December 23rd, 2023]
- Is Iraq really divided on resistance operations against US targets? - The Cradle - December 23rd, 2023 [December 23rd, 2023]
- Acting Deputy Secretary of State Nuland's Travel to Jordan and Iraq - United States Department of State - Department of State - December 23rd, 2023 [December 23rd, 2023]
- US must prepare for a long battle with Houthi rebels. Remember Iraq-Iran Tanker War in 1980s? - ThePrint - December 23rd, 2023 [December 23rd, 2023]
- Nikki Haley is correct that fentanyl deaths top casualties from 3 wars combined - The Dallas Morning News - December 23rd, 2023 [December 23rd, 2023]
- How Iraq is managing the Israel-Gaza crisis | Brookings - Brookings Institution - December 23rd, 2023 [December 23rd, 2023]
- Tragedies Born of Negligence in Iraq - Human Rights Watch - December 23rd, 2023 [December 23rd, 2023]
- No US troops injured in latest rocket strike at Iraq base - Stars and Stripes - December 23rd, 2023 [December 23rd, 2023]
- Senators Coons, Cruz introduce resolution to condemn attacks by Iranian military proxies on U.S. troops in Iraq and Syria - Senator Chris Coons - December 23rd, 2023 [December 23rd, 2023]
- Iraq and Turkey boost security ties in Ankara talks - The New Arab - December 23rd, 2023 [December 23rd, 2023]
- Iraqi militia attempts Eilat drone attack, was intercepted over Jordan - The Jerusalem Post - December 23rd, 2023 [December 23rd, 2023]
- Iraq heads to provincial elections, first in ten years - The Jerusalem Post - December 23rd, 2023 [December 23rd, 2023]
- Three Turkish soldiers killed in attack in northern Iraq ministry - Arab News - December 23rd, 2023 [December 23rd, 2023]
- 6 Turkish soldiers killed in terror attack in northern Iraq - Mehr News Agency - English Version - December 23rd, 2023 [December 23rd, 2023]
- WHO EMRO | WHO tackles low immunization challenges in Iraq | News | Iraq site - WHO Regional Office for the Eastern Mediterranean - December 23rd, 2023 [December 23rd, 2023]
- Iraq arrests fugitive wanted in connection with Speicher massacre - Rudaw Media Network - December 23rd, 2023 [December 23rd, 2023]
- Trkiye, Iraq agree on expulsion of PKK terrorist group | Daily Sabah - Daily Sabah - December 23rd, 2023 [December 23rd, 2023]
- Trudeau government to spend nearly $10M to support unemployed youth in Iraq - Toronto Sun - December 23rd, 2023 [December 23rd, 2023]
- Korea to face Iraq in final tuneup before Asian Cup in January - - December 23rd, 2023 [December 23rd, 2023]
- Iraq, Turkiye FMs meet to discuss security, water issues - Middle East Monitor - December 23rd, 2023 [December 23rd, 2023]
- 6 Turkish soldiers killed in terror attack in northern Iraq - News.Az - December 23rd, 2023 [December 23rd, 2023]
- Head of Iraq's National Wisdom Movement congratulates President Sisi for new term of presidency - Egypt Today - December 23rd, 2023 [December 23rd, 2023]
Tags: