Mediaboss Marketing

For centuries immigration has been synonymous with the United States, but what does the Constitution actually say about who can and cant enter the country? Law professors Christina Rodriguez and Ilya Somin talk about the ways in which the founding document could hinder or empower immigration policyreform.

The Constitution itself says very little about immigration [But]the power of Congress to regulate [immigration]is relatively uncontroversial today. Cristina Rodriguez, Yale University LawSchool

Cristina Rodriguez is a professor at Yale University Law School and author of The President and Immigration Law. She says to the founders and other early American lawmakers, immigration was not thought of in the same way as today.Immigration from the very beginning was used as a political tool to keep people thought not to be loyal to the United States from coming into the country, Rodriguezsays.

Rodriguez says with little constitutional intervention, immigration policy is mostly in the hands of the executive and legislative branches. The Constitution itself says very little about immigration [But]the power of Congress to regulate [immigration]is relatively uncontroversial today. Because immigration policy hasnt changed much in 40 years, Rodriguez says the U.S. isoperating out of a system that does not have the capacity to adapt to the changing world. There are very prescribed ways in which people can enter the United States Expanding the paths by which people might enter could improvefairness.

If we make it easier for people for people who want to live and work here to enter that would eliminate the illegal immigration problem. Ilya Somin,Antonin Scalia Law School atGeorge MasonUniversity

Ilya Somin is a professor at the George Mason Universitys Antonin Scalia Law School and author of Free to Move: Foot Voting, Migration, and Political Freedom. He says most of the earliest immigration policies in the U.S. were exclusionary rules adopted by state governments. Its notable that nowhere in the Constitution is there listed any power of the federal government to restrict immigration It was only in 1889 in the Chinese exclusion cases that the Supreme Court ruled that there was such apower.

Somin believes the executive branch needs to be limited in its power over immigration policy, because restrictions depend largely on who the president is at the time. I think the ultimate goal, which I dont think is going to be achieved any time soon, is to shift the system so that people should be allowed free entry. Illegal immigration to the United States is prevalent because its extremely difficult to enter any other way, which is why Somin says the system should be liberalized. If we make it easier for people for people who want to live and work here to enter that would eliminate the illegal immigrationproblem.

WDET strives to make our journalism accessible to everyone. As a public media institution, we maintain our journalistic integrity through independent support from readers like you. If you value WDET as your source of news, music and conversation, please make a gift today.

Donate today

See the original post here:
What the U.S. Constitution Says About Immigration - WDET