Taxing Nudity: Discriminatory Taxes, Secondary Effects, and Tiers of … – Reason
Previously, I blogged the abstract and introduction of my new article, Taxing Nudity: Discriminatory Taxes, Secondary Effects, and Tiers of Scrutiny, which has just been published in the Journal of Free Speech Law. It's based on my work with the Georgia Association of Club Executives v. Riley case, where we challenged a Georgia tax on adult entertainment establishments on First Amendment/free speech grounds.
In this post, I'll give you Part I, "Erotic-Expression Taxes vs. Nudity Taxes", which canvasses the different kinds of taxes in different states. (The article obviously has a lot of footnotes go to the article itself if you want to see those.)
* * *
I. Erotic-Expression Taxes vs. Nudity Taxes
A. Erotic-Expression Taxes
Several states have adopted taxes targeting adult entertainment businesses. In Georgia, for instance, the Safe Harbor/Rachel's Law Act imposes a tax, equal to $5000 or 1% of gross revenue, whichever is greater, on every "adult entertainment establishment." The covered entities include, among other categories:
any place of business or commercial establishment where alcoholic beverages of any kind are sold, possessed, or consumed wherein . . . [t]he entertainment or activity therein consists of nude or substantially nude persons dancing with or without music or engaged in movements of a sexual nature or movements simulating sexual intercourse, oral copulation, sodomy, or masturbation.
The money collected goes into the Safe Harbor for Sexually Exploited Children Fund, the purpose of which is to provide (among other things) "care, rehabilitative services, residential housing, health services, and social services, including establishing safe houses, to sexually exploited children."
Note a few features of this statute, which are found in some other states' statutes as well. The set of covered businesses is defined in some way that includes nudity (or substantial nudity). The set of covered businesses is further limited to those that serve or allow the consumption of alcohol. And the money collected is to be used to fund (among other things) programs related to sex crimes.
Here are a few other examples:
I'll refer to such taxes by the general label of "erotic-expression taxes." The ones listed above target not just nudity, and not just eroticism, but particular performative expressionwhether referred to generally as "entertainment" or more specifically as "dancing," and possibly also incorporating particular erotic content, for instance "specified sexual activities" or "movements of a sexual nature."
Such statutes require analysis under the First Amendment: nude dancing communicates an erotic message, and is thus expressive conduct.Indeed, when a Supreme Court plurality in Barnes v. Glen Theatre, Inc. upheld a requirement that dancers wear pasties and G-strings, it didn't rely on any theory that nude dancing was non-communicative. Rather, it wrote that such a requirement "does not deprive the dance of whatever erotic message it conveys; it simply makes the message slightly less graphic."
One may argue that nude dancing and similar activities are non-expressive or valueless and are therefore not a matter for the First Amendment, but that view would require a major change in doctrine. That these activities have been characterized as being "within the outer perimeters of the First Amendment," or "within the outer ambit of the First Amendment's protection," is irrelevant: whether outer or inner, the First Amendment still applies. In fact, as I argue below,these taxes not only require First Amendment analysis but also turn out to be unconstitutional: because they turn on what sort of content is presented, they're content-discriminatory and should therefore be analyzed under strict scrutinya standard that they fail.
B. Nudity Taxes
Other states have what I'll call "nudity taxes"the focus is still nudity and/or eroticism, but not necessarily particular expressive activity that conveys an erotic message.
The distinction between erotic-expression taxes and nudity taxes, while important, isn't necessarily very sharp. The Utah statute seems to fall more on the nudity side, because the nude services covered by the statute include not just dancing but also non-expressive activities like waitressing or massage.
One could say the same of the Illinois statute; activities could "appeal primarily to an interest in nudity or sex" without being expressive. But it's a tougher case: the inclusion of "entertainment" within the defined term, and the listing of "a striptease club" as one of the covered categories, could support an inference, based on standard methods of statutory interpretation, that the definition is meant to primarily cover expressive performances. Moreover, for both of these statutes, we need to look at the government's practice of enforcement to see whether it primarily targets expressive businesses.
Still, for purposes of this Article, the theoretical difference between a tax that targets erotic expression and a tax that targets nudity is significant. The Supreme Court has said that nudityunlike nude dancingisn't inherently expressive. A properly phrased and evenhandedly enforced nudity tax would therefore be analyzed under intermediate scrutiny. I argue that such taxes are likely unconstitutional even under this lower standard,but at least on its face the standard seems easier to meet.
C. Tax Exemptions
There are also taxes on erotic dancing that that are embedded within tax exemptions. That is, there's some general tax; there's an exemption from that tax for performances; but the exemption doesn't cover erotic dancing. So erotic dancing, unlike other performances, ends up being covered by the general tax.
For instance, the City of Chicago and Cook County had tax ordinances that taxed amusements, which they amended to provide exemptions for "live theatrical, live musical or other live cultural performances" taking place in small venues. But that category of "live ... performances" was defined to specifically exclude "performances conducted at adult entertainment cabarets," and such cabarets were defined in terms of whether topless dancers "[d]isplay or simulate the display of 'specified anatomical areas'" or "[e]ngage in, or engage in simulation of, 'specified sexual activities.'"The state of New York, similarly, taxed "place[s] of amusement," exempted "dramatic or musical arts performances," but did not include exotic dancing at an adult "juice bar" in the exemption.
These tax exemptions stand on a different footing than the taxes discussed above, because tax exemptions are subject to a different First Amendment regime than taxes. Even when a tax exemption is content-based, the Supreme Court has conceptualized tax exemptions as subsidies, and "the government can make content-based distinctions when it subsidizes speech."
Perhaps this distinction between discriminatory taxes and discriminatory tax exemptions doesn't make sense, but it's longstanding blackletter law.Perhaps it ought to be questioned, but that's beyond the scope of this Article. So I'll just note that these content-discriminatory tax exemptions exist and have been assumed to be constitutional. If tax exemptions were judged on the same basis as actual taxes, they would be subject to all the arguments I make in the rest of this Article; but I won't mention them any further.
More here:
Taxing Nudity: Discriminatory Taxes, Secondary Effects, and Tiers of ... - Reason
- EDITORIAL: Misusing the First Amendment Will Catch Up With Us - Adventist Today - November 1st, 2026 [November 1st, 2026]
- Judge Throws Out Trump's Epstein Lawsuit Against Wall Street Journal in Brutal First Amendment Rebuke - MeidasTouch News - November 1st, 2026 [November 1st, 2026]
- Execution secrecy tests the public's First Amendment rights - USA Today - November 1st, 2026 [November 1st, 2026]
- OPINION: Is the First Amendment limited by faith? - Moscow-Pullman Daily News - November 1st, 2026 [November 1st, 2026]
- Conservative political activist Riley Gaines slammed LeBron for weaponizing the First Amendment to disrespect the flag - Basketball Network - November 1st, 2026 [November 1st, 2026]
- 'Read the First Amendment!' Joe Scarborough starts shouting as GOP 'shreds' Constitution - Raw Story - November 1st, 2026 [November 1st, 2026]
- Ninth Circuit Holds that Californias Captive-Audience Ban Violates the First Amendment - Littler Mendelson P.C. - October 30th, 2026 [October 30th, 2026]
- Watchdog accuses Texas State of 'egregious' First Amendment breach over paid advertisement - San Antonio Current - October 30th, 2026 [October 30th, 2026]
- From Armbands to T-Shirts: Student Speech and the First Amendment - The National Constitution Center - October 30th, 2026 [October 30th, 2026]
- CNN, MS NOW and Politico Ask Court To Make Trump Access Order Permanent - First Amendment Watch - October 30th, 2026 [October 30th, 2026]
- OUR VIEW: The First Amendment keeps you out of jail. It doesnt keep you employed. - Herald-Zeitung - October 30th, 2026 [October 30th, 2026]
- Federal judge hears argument from FIU students involved in alleged racist group chat who say their First Amendment rights were violated - WSVN - October 30th, 2026 [October 30th, 2026]
- 'Have these people READ the First Amendment?' REACTION to GOP leaning into Islamophobic attacks - Modern Ghana - October 30th, 2026 [October 30th, 2026]
- Editorial: A frantic GOP attacks the First Amendment and the truth - Orlando Sentinel - October 24th, 2026 [October 24th, 2026]
- Tom Costello on the First Amendment and the Future of Free Speech - NBCU Academy - October 24th, 2026 [October 24th, 2026]
- To Chill or Not to Chill: The First Amendment Beyond the Presidents Press Room - JURIST News - October 24th, 2026 [October 24th, 2026]
- UMD Athletics agrees to First Amendment training after student journalists questioned by police - The Baltimore Banner - October 24th, 2026 [October 24th, 2026]
- Judge Orders Trump To Sit for a Deposition in His Defamation Lawsuit Against the BBC by Dec. 11 - First Amendment Watch - October 24th, 2026 [October 24th, 2026]
- Florida GOP lawsuit to censor TV stations fails Sunshine State and First Amendment - Freedom of the Press Foundation - October 24th, 2026 [October 24th, 2026]
- A Trump Appointee Says the President Likely Violated the First Amendment by Banishing Disfavored Journalists (opinion) - Yahoo - October 17th, 2026 [October 17th, 2026]
- Journal of Free Speech Law: "How Matal v. Tam Became a First Amendment Case: The Record and the Reality" by Simon Tam - Reason Magazine - October 17th, 2026 [October 17th, 2026]
- Judge blocks Trump's White House ban targeting CNN, MS NOW and Politico, saying it likely violated First Amendment - CBS News - October 17th, 2026 [October 17th, 2026]
- The Future of the First Amendment: Young Adults - Ipsos - October 17th, 2026 [October 17th, 2026]
- The Future of the First Amendment: Young Adults - Knight Foundation - October 17th, 2026 [October 17th, 2026]
- Litigators of the Week: A First Amendment Win for CNN, Politico and MS NOW Against White House Press Ban - Law.com - October 17th, 2026 [October 17th, 2026]
- BBC Asks Judge To Force Trump To Sit for Deposition in His Own Lawsuit Against the Channel - First Amendment Watch - October 17th, 2026 [October 17th, 2026]
- Penn Carey Law hosts discussion on DEI and First Amendment after closing equity office - Campus Reform - October 17th, 2026 [October 17th, 2026]
- Broward Teachers Union president alleges First Amendment violation after meeting removal - WPLG Local 10 - October 17th, 2026 [October 17th, 2026]
- Judge prohibited First Amendment defense in trial over naked Shrek image - Axios - October 17th, 2026 [October 17th, 2026]
- Judge: Trump likely violated First Amendment by banning new outlets from White House - Straight Arrow - October 17th, 2026 [October 17th, 2026]
- A Trump appointee says the president likely violated the First Amendment by banishing disfavored journalists - Reason Magazine - October 17th, 2026 [October 17th, 2026]
- Ousted Publisher Says Hegseths Pentagon Ordered Him To Fire Journalists, Made Clear You Have No First Amendment Rights - Mediaite - October 4th, 2026 [October 4th, 2026]
- Letter to the Editor: Trump continues his assaults on the First Amendment - Chico Enterprise-Record - October 4th, 2026 [October 4th, 2026]
- LETTER: Trump and the First Amendment - Las Vegas Review-Journal - October 4th, 2026 [October 4th, 2026]
- The First Amendment at the stadium gate: Who controls speech on a public stage? - Daily Journal - October 4th, 2026 [October 4th, 2026]
- The Trump White House Keeps Treating the First Amendment as More of a Suggestion - Balls and Strikes - October 4th, 2026 [October 4th, 2026]
- OPINION: The First Amendment belongs to all of us - DerbyInformer.com - October 4th, 2026 [October 4th, 2026]
- Why the First Amendment is first - The Tryon Daily Bulletin - October 4th, 2026 [October 4th, 2026]
- An attorney with ties to North Dakota is leading a high-stakes First Amendment battle against Trump - kvrr.com - October 4th, 2026 [October 4th, 2026]
- Ousted Publisher Says Hegseth's Pentagon Ordered Him To Fire Journalists, Made Clear 'You Have No First Amendment Rights' - yahoo.com - October 4th, 2026 [October 4th, 2026]
- Man sues Kingsport, police over 2022 arrest, claims First Amendment rights violation - WJHL - September 24th, 2026 [September 24th, 2026]
- Editorial: Trumps news outlet ban stands in opposition to the First Amendment - The Virginian-Pilot - September 24th, 2026 [September 24th, 2026]
- What is the First Amendment and why did 3 news outlets sue Trump? - nbcmiami.com - September 24th, 2026 [September 24th, 2026]
- Dont you just love the First Amendment! - - Smoky Mountain News - September 24th, 2026 [September 24th, 2026]
- Restoring Judicial Review Under the Freedom of Information Act - | Knight First Amendment Institute - September 24th, 2026 [September 24th, 2026]
- CNN, Politico, MS NOW Sue Trump Administration Over White House Access: First Amendment Analysis - Freedom Forum - September 24th, 2026 [September 24th, 2026]
- 251. Newsgathering, the First Amendment, and the White House - One First | Steve Vladeck | Substack - September 24th, 2026 [September 24th, 2026]
- 5 Ways DHS Agents Intimidated Americans Using Their First Amendment Rights - Common Cause - September 24th, 2026 [September 24th, 2026]
- CNN, MS NOW, Politico Sue Over Denied White House Access, Citing First Amendment - WTTW News - September 24th, 2026 [September 24th, 2026]
- Does the presidents White House media ban violate the First Amendment? Lawyer explains - WATE 6 On Your Side - September 24th, 2026 [September 24th, 2026]
- UWEC Professor teaches about first amendment law amid media outlet ban from White House - WEAU - September 24th, 2026 [September 24th, 2026]
- A record number of Americans think the First Amendment goes too far - WAMU - September 24th, 2026 [September 24th, 2026]
- United States: CNN, MS NOW, and Politico file First Amendment lawsuit over White House access ban - ipi.media - September 24th, 2026 [September 24th, 2026]
- Californias Addictive Feeds Law Violates Teens First Amendment Rights - eff.org - September 24th, 2026 [September 24th, 2026]
- On Constitution Day, is the US fumbling the First Amendment? - nmsuroundup.com - September 24th, 2026 [September 24th, 2026]
- Trump has not beaten the First Amendment, try as he might - The Seattle Times - September 24th, 2026 [September 24th, 2026]
- EDITORIAL: President Violates the First Amendment, Mainstream Publications Get a Taste of What the Black Press Has Long Experienced Exclusion - The... - September 24th, 2026 [September 24th, 2026]
- Student journalist sues University of Texas at Dallas for First Amendment violations - Dallas Observer - September 24th, 2026 [September 24th, 2026]
- Detroit Free Press. . First amendment reporter BrieAnna Frank explains how President Trumps ban on several news outlets from the White House will test... - September 24th, 2026 [September 24th, 2026]
- Opinion | Trumps attacks on the First Amendment go well beyond just freedom of the press - ms.now - September 24th, 2026 [September 24th, 2026]
- The Wolf Came As A Wolf: Trump and the First Amendment - Civil Discourse with Joyce Vance - September 24th, 2026 [September 24th, 2026]
- The First Amendment gives Americans a superpower: Petitioning the government to right wrongs - The Seattle Times - September 13th, 2026 [September 13th, 2026]
- The war on terror weakened the first amendment. Now we desperately need it | Jameel Jaffer - The Guardian - September 13th, 2026 [September 13th, 2026]
- CBS Argues First Amendment Protections in Bid to Dismiss Matlock Writer Lawsuit Over Allegedly Racist Comments - The Hollywood Reporter - September 13th, 2026 [September 13th, 2026]
- Kentucky leads 14-state coalition to SCOTUS on First Amendment rights - Eyewitness News (WEHT/WTVW) - September 13th, 2026 [September 13th, 2026]
- The First at 250: A Conversation on the First Amendment - Knight Foundation - September 13th, 2026 [September 13th, 2026]
- The Forever War and the First Amendment, Thu, Sep 10, 2026, 9am - 5pm - Community Calendar - ABC7 New York - September 13th, 2026 [September 13th, 2026]
- Kid Cudi Says First Amendment Protected Firing M.I.A. From Tour, Wants $2.8 Million Lawsuit Tossed - Law Commentary - September 13th, 2026 [September 13th, 2026]
- Police have dual role in protecting public and First Amendment rights | Op-Ed - The Seattle Times - September 13th, 2026 [September 13th, 2026]
- Democrats obliterated the First Amendment right to assembly: RFK Jr - Yahoo - September 13th, 2026 [September 13th, 2026]
- Trump Cant Call Ballots Mail and Escape the First Amendment - Jurist.org - September 8th, 2026 [September 8th, 2026]
- Judge Refuses To Block Pentagon From Firing Stars and Stripes Staffers Over CBS Interview - First Amendment Watch - September 8th, 2026 [September 8th, 2026]
- Uniform doesnt come with First Amendment waiver - oleantimesherald.com - September 8th, 2026 [September 8th, 2026]
- UW to pay $600,000 to professor after losing First Amendment fight over his parody land acknowledgment - Alaska Story - September 8th, 2026 [September 8th, 2026]
- First Amendment auditor convicted of trespassing at Conn. officers home - Police1 - September 8th, 2026 [September 8th, 2026]
- Labor Day: Brought to You by the First Amendment - Freedom Forum - September 8th, 2026 [September 8th, 2026]
- At FIU stop, DeSantis discusses First Amendment rights in wake of federal judge ruling in favor of anti-ICE protesters - WSVN - August 27th, 2026 [August 27th, 2026]
- Commentary: The First Amendment is more than the right to speak - Lake Oswego Review - August 27th, 2026 [August 27th, 2026]
- Trumps Unholy War on the First Amendment - Progressive.org - August 27th, 2026 [August 27th, 2026]
- Stars and Stripes staffers sue Pentagon over firings alleging First Amendment violations - The Independent - August 27th, 2026 [August 27th, 2026]