Jury: Tenant’s Eviction Was Retaliatory Violation of 1st Amendment – FlaglerLive.com
Les Abend with his plane at the county airport, from where the county attempted to evict him in retaliation, a jury said, for Abends opinions. ( Les Abend for FlaglerLive)
It started as an eviction case. It ended as a First Amendment case. The First Amendment won. Flagler County government lost.
After deliberating 90 minutes Tuesday, a jury of four men an two women found that Flagler County had improperly sought to evict a tenant from a hangar at the county airport, and was doing so only in retaliation for the tenants criticism of Roy Sieger, the airport director, violating the tenants First Amendment rights.
It was a remarkable case on several levels: It invalidated the countys eviction. It tied back into a controversy over the airport advisory board that the county arbitrarily disbanded in 2020, when the advisory board was raising issues of noise and overspending at the airport. It validated by jury verdict allegations of imperiousness on the part of the airport director. And it did so in a County Court trial, when First Amendment cases are usually handled in federal or circuit court.
The county filed its eviction suit at the end of January, thinking thats all it would be. But that turned out to be a culmination of long-simmering animus between Sieger and Les Abend, the tenant.
Revenge is a dish best served cold, Dennis Bayer, Abends attorney, told the jury, arguing that Sieger was essentially taking his revenge on Abend with the eviction, more than two years after their previous clashes. The jury agreed.
Sieger, a county employee, is the director of Flagler Executive Airportstill more colloquially known, to his chagrin, as Flagler County Airport.
Abend is a licensed pilot for 49 years and a flight instructor whos flown everything from gliders to the Boeing 777. He writes for various aviation journals and is an on-air analyst on aviation on various media, including CNN, NBC, MSNBC and FOX. He served on then briefly chaired the Flagler County Airport Advisory Board. Hed been renting a hangar at the county airport for his blue and white Piper Arrow plane for $321 a month since March 2018.
Tensions began to rise between the advisory board and Sieger not long after that. Then board members took their complaints to the County Commission, openly criticizing Sieger there as authoritarian and dismissive of their recommendations, especially on noise issues that neighbors wanted addressed. They subsequently criticized him for building what they considered to be an unnecessary Taj Mahal of a terminal in an airport that doesnt have the traffic to support it. Sieger has always advocated for a terminal in an airport without one.
On Sept. 9, 2020, the County Commission didnt think it needed the boards advice anymore. It disbanded it. Abend saw Siegers fingerprints on the move. The county would later argue that Sieger had no authority to disband the advisory board, that it was entirely the purview of the County Commission. On paper, thats true. In reality, the countys claim is somewhat disingenuous: Sieger has always wielded authoritative control of the airport, with the administrations blessing. I and the commissioners have full confidence in Mr. Siegers operation of the Airport, Petito wrote Abend last December. I dont typically involve myself in his daily affairs or any other department heads for that matter. Commissioners were barely involved in the scrapping of the advisory board, and only on a ratifying basis when it voted to have it disbanded at the urging of then-Administrator Jerry Cameron.
A year passed. On Sept. 26, 2022, the county declared a state of emergency ahead of Hurricane Ian. Three days later, some 1,500 utility workers, contractors and others associated with recovery efforts staged at the airport in what amounted to an instant makeshift city, including sleeping quarters, dining and showering facilities, in addition to trucks, heavy equipment and fueling stations, in the countys description.
The storm had left 46,000 customers, or 70 percent of the countys population, without power. Some 2.1 million customers lost power across the state. But the airport had not closed: planes were still landing and taking off, as shown in the flight logs for the relevant period of time, court papers note. Two schools were continuing their flight lessons. Paying tenants had a harder time. One pilot complained to the Airplane Owners Pilot Association about difficulties accessing hangars. (The county claims the association found its handling of the emergency to have been superb.)
Abend had for six months planned to fly his plane to a wedding around that time. Hurricane Ian cleared the area the night of Sept. 29. The next day, two days ahead of Abends planned trip, he went to the airport to prepare. He noticed a few vehicles in the way, and had a friendly conversation with an FPL official, who said the vehicles would be moved by the time he needed to fly 48 hours later. Abend also texted and emailed Sieger, summarizing the conversation with the FPL official.
Sieger never responded (he would later claim that hed been texted to his personal phone), though 24 hours later, Sieger emailed all tenants, asking them not to fly if they could help it, but that it would be arranged if they needed to. Do not attempt to taxi your aircraft without assistance from airport personnel and do not interfere with the emergency response crews working on the field, he wrote. In fact, emergency crews were not working on the field, only staging, or parking, their equipment there while they rested and waited for dispatching orders, as even pictures distributed by the county illustrated. The county at the time boasted about its role as a host of the big operation.
Nine weeks later, Sieger terminated Abends lease, giving him until last Jan. 13 to leave.
Abend was floored. He asked why, taking up the matter with Petito, who told him no reason need be given. Abend smelled something fishy, like that dish his attorney would later mention to the jury. He retained Dennis Bayer, the Flagler Beach attorney, and informed the county that he would contest the eviction.
Sieger has shown a propensity to not accept and to resent any recommendations for airport operations from third parties, including the duly appointed volunteer advisory board, Abend would argue in court, through his attorney. Sieger has engaged in actions towards Abend that could be deemed hostile and retaliatory. Sieger has advised third parties that he thought Abend was seeking to have Sieger fired by the County.
Assistant County Attorney Sean Moylan handled the case for the county. (He could not be reached before this article initially published.) The county categorically denied that Sieger was hostile or retaliatory, and reasserted the language of the lease: Nothing in the lease agreement provides for a challenge to the 30-day termination, much less to do so by wrongfully retaining possession of public property, Moylan wrote Bayer. Mr. Abends indication of his intent to breach the agreement and follow whatever unwritten terms he unilaterally conjures demonstrates a haughty disdain for the Airport and for fair dealing.
Bayer filed a motion to dismiss, arguing that the county should have stated a cause of action more precise than the vague allegations that Abend had interfered with workers at the airport. The county countered that it didnt have to give an explanation, since the lease language gave either side the right to end the month-to-month arrangement with 30 days notice, and without further rationales. County Judge Andrea Totten denied the motion.
The county is right so far as the lease language goes: it didnt have to give a reason. But it admitted that in the entire history of the airport, it had never unilaterally terminated a lease for no cause. And its retaliatory actions were not veiled: it doubled the rent on Abend.
The Countys decision to terminate cannot be exercised in a manner that is either retaliatory, discriminatory, or unlawful, Bayer argued. In this instance, the termination is retaliatory and discriminatory towards [Abend] based upon Abends lawful exercise of his First Amendment right of free speech. When combined with the way that [Sieger] eliminated the advisory board due, in large part to Abends advocacy, the termination here was taken for purposes of retaliation against Abends exercise of free speech.
Disarmed by its own historythat lack of evictions without causethe county emphasized Abends interaction with the FPL official, characterizing it as interfering with the emergency. Abend called it a fabrication, and an attempt by the county to back-fill a reason to evict him.
While the airport had restricted access to tenants like Abend, a restriction that violate their lease, Bayer argued, tenants still flew their planes but did not see their leases questioned or terminated.
My argument to them was whywhy was my client selected to be the first to be treated this way, Bayer said. And the evidence pointed to being retaliation for his criticism of how Mr. Sieger was operating the airport. The county tried to make it sound like it was a result of interfering with operations after storm, but Abend testified that he followed all the protocols established by the county. The connection with that history over the advisory board was unavoidable.
The jury in the two-day civil trial before Judge Totten had to answer two questions: Did the Plaintiff, Flagler County, properly terminate [Abends] hangar lease? The jury said No. (The case was actually against Abends company, Pen and Pilot, but he and his wife are the only principals.)
Did the Plaintiff, Flagler County, improperly terminate the lease with [Abend] in retaliation for [Abend] exercising [his] right to free speech under the First Amendment to the United States Constitution? The jury said yes.
Sieger, Petito and Charles Weaver, the FPL manager whod handled the staging, testified for the county. Abend and Daryl Hickman, a former chairman of the airport advisory board, testified in defense.
Abend gets to keep his lease at the hangar (the county has 130 people on its waiting list for hangar space). But the terms are unclear.
Certainly I won this for me, but in a way I won this for all the other tenants, Abend said today, though he remains dismayed over the way the county handled, then ignored, then disbanded the advisory board even as the same issues of concern then continue today, not least among them noise.
Its just a shame the county didnt take the advice of numerous people with numerous backgrounds that were trying to make the airport better, and they were doing it without compensation, Abend said. All they were trying to do is make the airport better and to make Roy Sieger look good, but it just fell on deaf ears. Two years went by and Roy found a reason to get rid of me, and the jury agreed.
See original here:
Jury: Tenant's Eviction Was Retaliatory Violation of 1st Amendment - FlaglerLive.com
- More on the New York Trump Case and the First Amendment - Reason - May 5th, 2024 [May 5th, 2024]
- Campus encampment bans rarely violate the First Amendment. Here's why. - Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression - May 5th, 2024 [May 5th, 2024]
- Students were primed for First Amendment talk. This Pierce County district backed out - Tacoma News Tribune - May 5th, 2024 [May 5th, 2024]
- Campus chaos vindicates the American system and the First Amendment - The Hill - May 5th, 2024 [May 5th, 2024]
- Trump's Trial and the First Amendment - Reason - May 5th, 2024 [May 5th, 2024]
- Can Texas public universities remove protesters from campus? First Amendment experts explain - Austin American-Statesman - May 5th, 2024 [May 5th, 2024]
- Are gag orders constitutional? SCOTUS says it depends - VERIFYThis.com - May 5th, 2024 [May 5th, 2024]
- Donald Trump Has a First Amendment Right to Pay Hush Money to Support his Electoral Ambitions - Reason - May 5th, 2024 [May 5th, 2024]
- "Antisemitism Awareness Act of 2023" (Which Just Passed the House) Could Suppress First-Amendment-Protected ... - Reason - May 5th, 2024 [May 5th, 2024]
- What the First Amendment Means for Campus Protests - The New York Times - May 5th, 2024 [May 5th, 2024]
- ACLU of Wisconsin Emphasizes the Importance Of Student's First Amendment Rights Ahead of Protests Planned at UW ... - ACLU of Wisconsin - May 5th, 2024 [May 5th, 2024]
- Indiana University Officials Need to Follow Community's Lead on Commitment to First Amendment - ACLU of Indiana - May 5th, 2024 [May 5th, 2024]
- An American-Israeli Caught Between Antisemitism and The First Amendment - The Times of Israel - May 5th, 2024 [May 5th, 2024]
- Citizens United, campaign finance, and the First Amendment - Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression - May 5th, 2024 [May 5th, 2024]
- Studios Warn Of First Amendment Implications For SAG-AFTRA-Backed AI Bill To Require Consent For Digital Voice And Likeness - Deadline - May 5th, 2024 [May 5th, 2024]
- Norman Siegel: A lifetime of protecting the First Amendment - Spectrum News NY1 - May 5th, 2024 [May 5th, 2024]
- ACLU and First Amendment Coalition Challenge Cal Poly Humboldt's Campus Closure and Press Restrictions - Redheaded Blackbelt - May 5th, 2024 [May 5th, 2024]
- 13 seconds of bloodshed: Community shares themes of activism, First Amendment with upcoming May 4 commemoration - Kent Wired - May 5th, 2024 [May 5th, 2024]
- Day 2 of pro-Palestinian protests on Wisconsin campuses, First Amendment expert weighs in - WISN Milwaukee - May 5th, 2024 [May 5th, 2024]
- First Amendment under attack: How the Police State muzzles our right to speak truth to power - Washington Times - May 5th, 2024 [May 5th, 2024]
- UngagTrump The Fight for First Amendment: The Leader in Freedom Fundraising. - GiveSendGo - May 5th, 2024 [May 5th, 2024]
- What the First Amendment Means for Campus Protests - myheraldreview.com - May 5th, 2024 [May 5th, 2024]
- What to do if you get arrested? What to know about the First Amendment amid Tennessee campus protests - Knoxville News Sentinel - May 5th, 2024 [May 5th, 2024]
- What rights do protesters at the U of M encampment have? - KARE11.com - May 5th, 2024 [May 5th, 2024]
- Sen. Vance worries college protests are moving beyond First Amendment and into chaos for local communities - WTRF - May 5th, 2024 [May 5th, 2024]
- New Stablecoin Bill Faces Criticism for Stifling Innovation and Breaching First Amendment Regulation Bitcoin News - Bitcoin.com News - April 22nd, 2024 [April 22nd, 2024]
- TikTok ready to move to the courts to prevent ban in US - Ars Technica - April 22nd, 2024 [April 22nd, 2024]
- Say 'Yes' to the First Amendment Minding The Campus - Minding The Campus - April 22nd, 2024 [April 22nd, 2024]
- SCOTUS won't review decision that ratchets up legal risk at protests - Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press - April 22nd, 2024 [April 22nd, 2024]
- OPINION | Tulane must commit to upholding First Amendment - Tulane Hullabaloo - April 22nd, 2024 [April 22nd, 2024]
- Parsons' Attorney Michael Judd Participates As Panelist At First Amendment Society Event - Mondaq News Alerts - April 22nd, 2024 [April 22nd, 2024]
- Does BVU know the first amendment? The Tack Online - BVU The Tack Online - April 22nd, 2024 [April 22nd, 2024]
- Weber State University students using their first amendment rights - The Signpost - April 22nd, 2024 [April 22nd, 2024]
- Pennsylvania Court Lets Suit Over Removal of Columbus Statue Go Forward - Reason - April 22nd, 2024 [April 22nd, 2024]
- Elon Musk to fund new First Amendment campaign to combat 'relentless attacks on free speech' - Fox News - April 20th, 2024 [April 20th, 2024]
- Elon Musk's Plan To Fund National Signature Campaign In Support Of First Amendment Met With Praise - Yahoo! Voices - April 20th, 2024 [April 20th, 2024]
- Don't Panic About the Supreme Court's Right to Protest RulingYet - The New Republic - April 20th, 2024 [April 20th, 2024]
- Supreme Court Is Apparently Fine with the Assault on the First Amendment That Is Mckesson v. Doe - Esquire - April 20th, 2024 [April 20th, 2024]
- NPR boss once called the First Amendment a 'challenge' and 'reverence for the truth' a distraction - Fox News - April 20th, 2024 [April 20th, 2024]
- Kerrville Residents File First Amendment Lawsuit In Federal Court Against City - The Texan - April 20th, 2024 [April 20th, 2024]
- NPR Against the First Amendment - The New York Sun - April 20th, 2024 [April 20th, 2024]
- Civics lesson: First Amendment rights are broad, but there are limits - Tennessean - April 20th, 2024 [April 20th, 2024]
- The Supreme Court effectively abolishes the right to mass protest in three US states - Vox.com - April 20th, 2024 [April 20th, 2024]
- Media Miss by the Left: Elon Musk to fund new First Amendment campaign to combat 'relentless attacks on free speech' - Straight Arrow News - April 20th, 2024 [April 20th, 2024]
- Supreme Court allows police officers suit to move forward against Black Lives Matter leader - The Hill - April 20th, 2024 [April 20th, 2024]
- Tom Cotton Clearly Hates The First Amendment - Betches - April 20th, 2024 [April 20th, 2024]
- A new Supreme Court case threatens to take away your right to protest - Vox.com - January 27th, 2024 [January 27th, 2024]
- No, Blocking Traffic Is Not Protected by the First Amendment - Reason - January 27th, 2024 [January 27th, 2024]
- Cable Giants Insist That Forcing Them To Make Cancellations Easier Violates Their First Amendment Rights - Above the Law - January 27th, 2024 [January 27th, 2024]
- Know Your Rights: Students in Higher Education & the First Amendment - New York Civil Liberties Union - January 27th, 2024 [January 27th, 2024]
- Star-Spangled Fascism: Extremists and the First Amendment - GBH News - January 27th, 2024 [January 27th, 2024]
- SPJ co-authors legal brief supporting First Amendment right to record and publish livestreamed court hearings - Society of Professional Journalists - January 27th, 2024 [January 27th, 2024]
- Star-Spangled Fascism: Extremists and the First Amendment - KPBS - January 27th, 2024 [January 27th, 2024]
- Letter writer reminds others about intent behind the First Amendment - Call Newspapers - January 27th, 2024 [January 27th, 2024]
- FCC's Jessica Rosenworcel On Trump Broadcast License Threats: First Amendment Guides Us. - Insideradio.com - January 27th, 2024 [January 27th, 2024]
- Faith-based school chaplains would test First Amendment - Fort Wayne Journal Gazette - January 27th, 2024 [January 27th, 2024]
- Arrested citizen journalist wasn't 'martyr' for journalism, 5th Circuit says in tossing her First Amendment suit - ABA Journal - January 27th, 2024 [January 27th, 2024]
- First Amendment Bowled Over by Lanham Act Again - The National Law Review - January 27th, 2024 [January 27th, 2024]
- Florida House passes HB 1 to ban kids 16 and under from having social media accounts - NBC 6 South Florida - January 27th, 2024 [January 27th, 2024]
- Lawmakers debate whether mostly banning mugshots violates the First Amendment - My Buckhannon - January 27th, 2024 [January 27th, 2024]
- Lizzo Accusers Say First Amendment Is No Reason To Throw Out Assault, Sexual Harassment & Discrimination Suit Against Grammy Winner - Yahoo... - November 13th, 2023 [November 13th, 2023]
- Trump Appeals Gag To Protect First Amendment Right To Intimidate ... - Above the Law - November 13th, 2023 [November 13th, 2023]
- Chemerinsky: 'I am a 70-year-old Jewish man, but never in my life ... - Foundation for Individual Rights in Education - November 13th, 2023 [November 13th, 2023]
- Prosecutors Mock Trump Attempt To Get Election Case Dismissed ... - Above the Law - November 13th, 2023 [November 13th, 2023]
- New bill to criminalize flying unauthorized flags on public property ... - Alabama Daily News - November 13th, 2023 [November 13th, 2023]
- This First Amendment Attack is Designed to Reduce Gun Ownership ... - America's 1st Freedom - November 13th, 2023 [November 13th, 2023]
- SGA Amendment to Make Amendments Easier Passes; Will Move to ... - PantherNOW - November 13th, 2023 [November 13th, 2023]
- Civil rights leaders cannot be held liable for acts of rogue protestors - Foundation for Individual Rights in Education - November 13th, 2023 [November 13th, 2023]
- Justice Department Announces Investigation of the City of Lexington ... - Department of Justice - November 13th, 2023 [November 13th, 2023]
- Danny De Gracia: Don't Fall For Fake Election News This Year ... - Honolulu Civil Beat - November 13th, 2023 [November 13th, 2023]
- Mike Johnson: The Christian Nationalist Speaker Daily Montanan - Daily Montanan - November 13th, 2023 [November 13th, 2023]
- AI and a marketplace of illusion and confusion - The Fulcrum - November 13th, 2023 [November 13th, 2023]
- Increased efforts to require party labels in Ohio races - Spectrum News 1 - November 13th, 2023 [November 13th, 2023]
- Louisiana's 'In God We Trust' Law May Violate Establishment Clause Of The First Amendment - TPM - November 7th, 2023 [November 7th, 2023]
- Coalition of Baptist leaders will file amicus brief challenging NAMB's view of First Amendment - Baptist News Global - November 7th, 2023 [November 7th, 2023]
- Legal Docket: Facebook and the First Amendment - WORLD News Group - November 7th, 2023 [November 7th, 2023]
- How First Amendment protections are limiting our ability to ensure ... - Slate - November 7th, 2023 [November 7th, 2023]
- The right to disagree matters | WORLD - WORLD News Group - November 7th, 2023 [November 7th, 2023]
- Woodland Park teachers win their fight to restore First Amendment ... - Colorado Public Radio - November 7th, 2023 [November 7th, 2023]
- Flagler County judge dismisses traffic tickets against 'First ... - Palm Coast Observer and Ormond Beach Observer - November 7th, 2023 [November 7th, 2023]