AG Landry offers no opinion on Rapides library children’s book policy – The Town Talk

Frances Madeson| Louisiana Illuminator

TikTok influencers visit Washington amid possible ban

A heavy public relations campaign involving TikTok influencers has come to the nation's capital as U.S. officials are considering banning the hugely popular video-sharing app over worries it poses risks to cybersecurity and data privacy. (March 22)

AP

ALEXANDRIA Louisiana Attorney General Jeff Landry has declined to weigh in on the constitutionality of an amendment to the Rapides Parish Librarys collection development policy, as requested in January. He offered no reason in his offices March 2, 2023, letter to the parishs Library Board of Control.

At issue is a policy change the Rapides Library Control Board considered in January. Board member James Morgan suggested the amendment after his 4-year-old son came across a copy of Pride Puppy in the childrens section of the library. Its an alphabet book that tells the story of a family losing then finding their puppy after it runs off the leash at a Pride parade.

Morgan, who the Rapides Police Jury appointed to the board in September, authored the proposed update to the librarys collection development policy.It reads: [Children and teen] collections shall not include materials containing obscenity, sexual content (including content regarding sexual orientation and gender identity), or any other material that is unsuitable for the children and teen collections. Library events and displays for children and teens shall be held to the same standard.

Library board counsel Greg Jones, experts at the Tulane First Amendment Law Clinic, and three local attorneys who weighed in during public comments at the December and January board meetings, all cautioned that Morgans language was unconstitutional. The parish library and elected leaders would not be able to defend themselves against the exposure to lawsuits to follow if the amendment is adopted , they said.

Storyteller, writer teaches Alexandria children the power of F-words

Tulane law professorKatie Schwartzmann, who directs the First Amendment Law Clinic, confirmed that position in an email to the Illuminator. The clinic also provides guidance to the Illuminator.

Its unfortunate that Attorney General Landry chose not to provide the guidance requested by Rapides Library Board of Control, Schwartzmann said. Rapides proposed book ban would be unconstitutional, but the Attorney General chose not to advise them as such. Louisianians (and local government bodies) need to be able to rely upon Landrys office to provide clear-eyed legal guidance.

The proper guidance would be to advise the library board that its proposed restrictions on books would violate the U.S. Constitution, she said. Landry has acknowledged previously that the First Amendment is broad and protects controversial books, evensexual content, Schwartzmann added.

Louisiana already has laws that criminalize obscenity and material harmful to minors, she said. If officials reach beyond those limits, they will be censoring protected speech and violating the Constitution.

Landry established a Protecting Minorstip linelast year for the public to report the taxpayer-subsidized sexualization of children at libraries. Through a public records request, the Illuminator reporter the line wasflooded with spam complaints.

At the January library board meeting, president LeAnza Jordan lamented that the troublesome verbiage had not been vetted by a board committee. Her comments came after hours of public comments from religious leaders and parents decrying nonexistent pornography in the childrens section.

Alexandria hospitals fail to comply with price transparency law, patient advocates say

At that meeting, in addition to seeking permission to contact the attorney generals office on the boards behalf, Jones suggested the members consider creating a board Policies and Reconsideration Committee. It could be dually charged with scrutinizing proposed amendments for lawfulness and redundancy, and it could serve as another layer in the librarys review procedures for reconsideration of material patrons find objectionable.

Morgan, in an email to the Illuminator at the time, stood behind his proposed changes.

I continue to believe that it is practical, legal and consistent with our current policy, and I think it would be a great addition to our librarys development policy, he said.

The board was to consider the new committee at Tuesdays meeting, but it was tabled until after the Louisiana Legislatures session in case relevant state policy is enacted. In his letter, Landry suggested the board monitor the session for bills enforcing library restrictions. Lawmakers will convene April 10 and must adjourn no later than June 8.

Sen. Heather Cloud, R-Turkey Creek, and Rep. Julie Emerson, R-Carenco, havepre-filed billsto restrict materials available to minors at libraries.

Jones advised it could be July before any legislation reaches the governors desk, where his options include a veto.

Morgan stunned attendees at Tuesdays library board meeting when he asked for a copy of its reconsideration procedures, saying he had never seen it.

Library patron Loren Ryland, who has attended and spoken at library board meetings since December, told the Illuminator after the meeting her communitys libraries are under attack by members of its board.

The only thing that I can consider, and Ive thought about this a lot, is that it seems like their ultimate goal is to gut the library from the inside, Ryland said.

TheLouisiana Illuminatoris an independent, nonprofit, nonpartisan news organization driven by its mission to cast light on how decisions are made in Baton Rouge and how they affect the lives of everyday Louisianians, particularly those who are poor or otherwise marginalized.

Read the original:
AG Landry offers no opinion on Rapides library children's book policy - The Town Talk

Related Posts

Comments are closed.