Supreme Court: Can Mexican citizens sue Border Patrol agents in cross-border killings? – AZCentral.com
Jose Antonio Elena Rodriguez, 16, was shot 10 times in the back and head the night of Oct. 10, 2012, by one or more agents firing through the border fence into Nogales, Sonora. Agents said they were assaulted by rock throwers. The Republic
A Texas case going before the U.S. Supreme Court on Feb. 21, 2017, could determine whether the family of a teenager killed in Nogales, Mexico, will be able to sue the Border Patrol agent who fired the fatal shot through the border fence. Here, two of many bullet holes are circled on the emergency medical office building in Nogales, Sonora, where Jose Antonio Elena Rodriguez, 16, died after being shot by a. Border Patrol agent on the other side of the fence.(Photo: Charlie Leight/The Republic)
A Texas case going beforethe U.S. Supreme Court on Tuesdaycould determinewhether the family of a teenager killed in Nogales, Mexico, will be able to sue the Border Patrol agent who fired the fatal shot through the border fence.
The high court will hear oral arguments in Hernandez vs.Mesa, a case involving the 2010 killing of Sergio Adrian Hernandez Guereca, 15, in Juarez, Mexico. A Border Patrol agent firing from the U.S. side of the border killedthe teen as he peered out from behind a train trestle on the Mexican side.
A definitive rulingby the Supreme Court would determine whether people standing inMexico and killed by U.S. Border Patrol agents have a constitutional right to sue for damagesin the U.S.
The circumstances of the Texas case are similar to a 2012 shooting in Nogales, Mexico, where Jose Antonio Elena Rodriguez, 16, was shot 10 times in the back and head by Border Patrol Agent Lonnie Swartz. Swartzfired through the slats in the border fence from Nogales, Arizona. Swartz saidrocks were being thrown, prompting him to fire numerous times,reload his gun and fire again.
After the shooting, Swartz began to vomit and said, "I shot and there's someone dead in Mexico," according to court filings. Witnesses said no rocks were thrown.Theformerassistant commissionerof Customs and Border Protection'sOffice of Internal Affairs said the same in a deposition, also noting that it wasimplausible for rocks thrown from Mexico to hit someone on the U.S. side of the fence becausethe Mexican side is about 25 feet lower in the area where the shooting took place.
Swartz has been charged with second degree murder in federal court.
Elena Rodriguez's family also filed a civil suit against Swartz in U.S. District Court in Tucson. In July2015, U.S. District Court Judge Raner Collins ruledElena Rodriguezwas entitled to protections of the Fourth Amendment "even as a non-citizen standing on foreign soil."The Fourth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution prohibits unreasonable search and seizure.
An appeal of that decisionwas heard in October by a three-judge panel of the 9thU.S. Circuit Court of Appeals.
Appellate Judge Milan Smithsaid that because of the similar legal issuesin the Nogales and Juarez cases, the 9th Circuit ordinarily would have waited for the Supreme Court to rule in the Juarez case. However, Smith saidit was necessary for the 9th Circuit to move ahead with oral arguments in the Nogales case in casethe Supreme Court'sdecision in the Texas caseresults ina 4-4 tie.
The Supreme Court has had just eight justicessince the death last yearof Justice Antonin Scalia.
Autoplay
Show Thumbnails
Show Captions
The cases "involve almost identical legal issues," said attorney Sean Chapman, who represents Swartz in both the criminal and civil cases." That's what is interesting about it. ... It's incredibility similar to the Rodriguez case in Arizona. I'm waiting to see what theydo."
If the Supreme Court deadlocks,the 5th U.S.Circuit Court of Appealsruling that Guereca's family cannotsue the Border Patrol agent in the U.S. would stand in the 5th Circuit.Then the 9th Circuit could rule on the Elena Rodriguez case, Chapmansaid.
"I think the 9th Circuit is waiting to see what happens on Hernandez," he added.
If the Supreme Court were to deadlockand the 9th Circuit rulesthat Elena Rodriguez's family does have the right to sue, then the issue likely would head back to the Supreme Court because two appellatecourts would have divergent rulings, Chapman said.
However, if the Supreme Court does not deadlock and rules definitively for or against, it "presumably is going to set the law for these cross-border shootings for at least several generations," said Steve Shadowen, an attorney for the Guereca family, whosecase is before the Supreme Court.
The parents of Sergio Adrian Guereca, a Mexican teenager killed in Juarez in 2010 by a Border Patrol agent shooting across the U.S.-Mexico border, speak out about their son's death in a 2014 interview. Nick Oza/azcentral.com
There have been at least six such cross-border shooting cases since 2010, including the cases in Juarez and Nogales.
Once the Supreme Court rules, "it takes a long time, if ever, for the law to change," Shadowen said.
Both the 5th and 9th Circuit courtshave argued over whether the case should be brought under the Fourth or Fifth amendments to the Constitution.
In the Texas case,a 5th Circuit panel ruled the family had a right to sue the agent under the Fifth Amendment but not under the Fourth Amendment. That ruling was later reversed.
The 9th Circuit judges asked questions alongsimilar lines as the5th Circuit panel. They said theFourth Amendment refers to the right of the people, which is interpretedas rights of U.S. citizens. Butthe Fifth Amendment refers more broadly to any person,making it easier toapply to a non-citizen standing in Mexico.
Shadowen said he feels confident in the Juarez case that will be argued Tuesday before the Supreme Court.
"From the beginning we knew we were in the right legally and morally and we still feel that way," Shadowen said.
Border fence in Nogales, Arizona.(Photo: Nick Oza/azcentral)
Read or Share this story: http://azc.cc/2ljBcDp
Read this article:
Supreme Court: Can Mexican citizens sue Border Patrol agents in cross-border killings? - AZCentral.com
- Hillary Clinton Claims Trump Pardon Could Strip Elon Musk's Fifth Amendment Shield Before Congress - International Business Times UK - November 9th, 2026 [November 9th, 2026]
- Relax, We Cant Invoke the Twenty-Fifth Amendment Every Time a President Offers to Let an Enemy Bomb an American City - McSweeneys Internet Tendency - October 6th, 2026 [October 6th, 2026]
- Fauci's decision to invoke the Fifth Amendment tees up a legal debate and a contempt vote - Dayton Daily News - August 31st, 2026 [August 31st, 2026]
- Prichard police detectives bag of money, Fifth Amendment invocation form basis of new trial demand in homicide - fox10tv.com - August 22nd, 2026 [August 22nd, 2026]
- Fauci refuses Senate appearance after invoking Fifth Amendment more than 100 times in COVID probe - New York Post - August 22nd, 2026 [August 22nd, 2026]
- Letter to the Editor: Trump and the Fifth Amendment double standard - courierherald.com - August 22nd, 2026 [August 22nd, 2026]
- Fauci refuses Senate appearance after invoking Fifth Amendment more than 100 times in COVID probe - Fox News - August 16th, 2026 [August 16th, 2026]
- Trump sued on First and Fifth Amendment grounds over paid Truth Social access - Scripps News - August 16th, 2026 [August 16th, 2026]
- Fauci invokes Fifth Amendment over 100 times at Senate hearing - newuniversity.org - August 16th, 2026 [August 16th, 2026]
- Fauci walks away when pressed on Fifth Amendment, pandemic regrets - New York Post - August 4th, 2026 [August 4th, 2026]
- Pat McAfee pokes fun at Anthony Fauci pleading the Fifth Amendment live on ESPN - Fox News - August 4th, 2026 [August 4th, 2026]
- Here's how many times Trump invoked Fifth Amendment in civil fraud trial, according to a judge - Snopes - August 4th, 2026 [August 4th, 2026]
- Fauci invokes the Fifth Amendment at Senate hearing on COVID-19 pandemic origins - Scripps News - August 4th, 2026 [August 4th, 2026]
- What It Means to Plead the Fifth Amendment - Time Magazine - August 4th, 2026 [August 4th, 2026]
- Aaron Rodgers calls Fauci coward, criminal for invoking the Fifth Amendment - WJTV - August 4th, 2026 [August 4th, 2026]
- Fauci Invokes Fifth Amendment More Than 100 Times in Bitter Senate Hearing - The New York Times - August 4th, 2026 [August 4th, 2026]
- In the News: Mark Osler on Anthony Faucis Fifth Amendment Claim - Newsroom | University of St. Thomas - August 4th, 2026 [August 4th, 2026]
- Dr. Fauci invokes his Fifth Amendment right not to testify at Senate hearing - NBC News - August 4th, 2026 [August 4th, 2026]
- Fauci invokes Fifth Amendment and declines to testify in Republican-led COVID-19 Senate hearing - Oregon Public Broadcasting - OPB - August 4th, 2026 [August 4th, 2026]
- Fauci invokes Fifth Amendment in Senate hearing about COVID-19 pandemic - Live 5 News - August 4th, 2026 [August 4th, 2026]
- CBS News | Legal Analysis on Whether Dr. Anthony Fauci Can Be Punished for Invoking Fifth Amendment - Loyola Marymount University - August 4th, 2026 [August 4th, 2026]
- The scope of Faucis Fifth Amendment invocation may have to be settled in court - MS NOW - August 4th, 2026 [August 4th, 2026]
- Hawley trolls Fauci's blanket Fifth Amendment claims exposing 'contempt for this body' - Fox News - August 4th, 2026 [August 4th, 2026]
- Fauci invokes Fifth Amendment in Senate hearing about COVID-19 pandemic - WDAM-TV - August 4th, 2026 [August 4th, 2026]
- Fauci invokes fifth amendment and declines to testify in Senate Covid hearing - The Guardian - August 4th, 2026 [August 4th, 2026]
- Fauci invokes Fifth Amendment in Senate hearing about COVID-19 pandemic - WTVM.com - August 4th, 2026 [August 4th, 2026]
- Dr. Anthony Fauci invokes Fifth Amendment in heated COVID-19 hearing - WTAE - August 4th, 2026 [August 4th, 2026]
- Faucis legal protection from pardon, Fifth Amendment is an open question - The Hill - July 30th, 2026 [July 30th, 2026]
- Anthony Fauci Invokes Fifth Amendment in Rand Paul Senate Hearing NPR - Geisel School of Medicine at Dartmouth - July 30th, 2026 [July 30th, 2026]
- Fauci invokes Fifth Amendment in Senate hearing about COVID-19 pandemic - WBKO - July 30th, 2026 [July 30th, 2026]
- Washington Post. . Anthony Fauci repeatedly invoked the Fifth Amendment during a Senate hearing Wednesday where Republicans pressed the retired... - July 30th, 2026 [July 30th, 2026]
- Dr. Fauci invokes the Fifth Amendment at Senate hearing on COVID pandemic - CBS News - July 30th, 2026 [July 30th, 2026]
- Fauci invokes Fifth Amendment in Senate hearing about COVID-19 pandemic - fox8live.com - July 30th, 2026 [July 30th, 2026]
- Fauci invokes Fifth Amendment in Senate hearing about COVID-19 pandemic - WCTV - July 30th, 2026 [July 30th, 2026]
- Fauci invokes Fifth Amendment in Senate hearing about COVID-19 pandemic - KEYC News Now - July 30th, 2026 [July 30th, 2026]
- Fauci invokes Fifth Amendment in Senate hearing about COVID-19 pandemic - WEEK | 25 News Now - July 30th, 2026 [July 30th, 2026]
- Fauci Threatened With Contempt Of Congress After Invoking Fifth Amendment - Forbes - July 30th, 2026 [July 30th, 2026]
- Fauci invokes Fifth Amendment in Senate hearing about COVID-19 pandemic - Cleveland 19 News - July 30th, 2026 [July 30th, 2026]
- Fauci invokes Fifth Amendment in Senate hearing about COVID-19 pandemic - ABC7 WWSB - July 30th, 2026 [July 30th, 2026]
- Fauci invokes Fifth Amendment in Senate hearing about COVID-19 pandemic - WSAW - July 30th, 2026 [July 30th, 2026]
- Fauci invokes Fifth Amendment in Senate hearing about COVID-19 pandemic - WCAX - July 30th, 2026 [July 30th, 2026]
- Fauci invokes Fifth Amendment in Senate hearing about COVID-19 pandemic - WSFA - July 30th, 2026 [July 30th, 2026]
- Anthony Fauci invokes Fifth Amendment at fiery Senate hearing on Covid-19 - Financial Times - July 30th, 2026 [July 30th, 2026]
- Fauci invokes Fifth Amendment in Senate hearing about COVID-19 pandemic - WTHI-TV - July 30th, 2026 [July 30th, 2026]
- Fauci invokes Fifth Amendment in Senate hearing about COVID-19 pandemic - KOLN | Nebraska Local News, Weather, Sports | Lincoln, NE - July 30th, 2026 [July 30th, 2026]
- Fauci invokes the Fifth Amendment over 100 times - CNN - July 30th, 2026 [July 30th, 2026]
- Fauci invokes Fifth Amendment in Senate hearing about COVID-19 pandemic - WPTA | 21Alive | Fort Wayne, IN - July 30th, 2026 [July 30th, 2026]
- Fauci invokes Fifth Amendment in Senate hearing about COVID-19 pandemic - WVLT - July 30th, 2026 [July 30th, 2026]
- Fauci invokes Fifth Amendment in Senate hearing about COVID-19 pandemic - wflx.com - July 30th, 2026 [July 30th, 2026]
- Fauci invokes Fifth Amendment in Senate hearing about COVID-19 pandemic - KOLD - July 30th, 2026 [July 30th, 2026]
- Opinion | Why I will use my Fifth Amendment rights before Congress today - The Washington Post - June 12th, 2026 [June 12th, 2026]
- ActBlue C.E.O. Invokes Fifth Amendment Repeatedly in Testimony to Congress - The New York Times - June 12th, 2026 [June 12th, 2026]
- ActBlue CEO invokes Fifth Amendment repeatedly in testimony to Congress - The Seattle Times - June 12th, 2026 [June 12th, 2026]
- ActBlue CEO Will Invoke Fifth Amendment At Congressional Hearing - Campaigns & Elections - June 12th, 2026 [June 12th, 2026]
- ActBlue CEO invokes Fifth Amendment in House hearing over illegal foreign donations - Fox Business - June 12th, 2026 [June 12th, 2026]
- 'Okay, wow, didn't expect that one': Rep. Loudermilk stunned by ActBlue CEO's Fifth Amendment answer - The Economic Times - June 12th, 2026 [June 12th, 2026]
- Urban Outfitters Inc Enters Into Fifth Amendment To Credit Agreement On May 19, 2026 - TradingView - May 27th, 2026 [May 27th, 2026]
- Principals who invoked their Fifth Amendment rights during CRCT investigation identified - Albany Herald - May 22nd, 2026 [May 22nd, 2026]
- User Clip: Clip: Use of the Fifth Amendment - C-SPAN - May 22nd, 2026 [May 22nd, 2026]
- Is the Twenty-fifth Amendment Really an Option? - The New Yorker - May 7th, 2026 [May 7th, 2026]
- Does the Fifth Amendment Protect You From Turning Over Documents (with Tiffany H. Eggers) - Dykema - May 1st, 2026 [May 1st, 2026]
- We have the Twenty-Fifth Amendment. Now is the time to use it. - lawdork.com - April 12th, 2026 [April 12th, 2026]
- Herald Tribune Events - The Fifth Amendment - Sarasota Herald-Tribune - March 26th, 2026 [March 26th, 2026]
- A full and perfect equivalent : Just Compensation and the Fifth Amendment - Pacific Legal Foundation - February 22nd, 2026 [February 22nd, 2026]
- Jeffrey Epstein's accomplice, Ghislaine Maxwell, pleaded the Fifth Amendment during the House Oversight Committee's deposition. - Facebook - February 14th, 2026 [February 14th, 2026]
- Elie Honig Explains How Maxwell May Have Inadvertently Waived Her Fifth Amendment Protection - AOL.com - February 14th, 2026 [February 14th, 2026]
- Epstein invoked the Fifth Amendment for nearly every question during his depositions. If he had nothing to hide, why stay silent? He used the same... - February 11th, 2026 [February 11th, 2026]
- Jeffrey Epstein Associate: Why is Ghislaine Maxwell Invoking the Fifth Amendment in a Congressional Probe? - The Sunday Guardian - February 11th, 2026 [February 11th, 2026]
- Maxwell invokes the Fifth Amendment at closed virtual House Oversight deposition - Rural Radio Network - February 11th, 2026 [February 11th, 2026]
- Ghislaine Maxwell expected to invoke Fifth Amendment in congressional deposition - Washington Examiner - February 11th, 2026 [February 11th, 2026]
- Epstein accomplice Ghislaine Maxwell cowardly pleads the Fifth Amendment during deposition - Sky News Australia - February 11th, 2026 [February 11th, 2026]
- Fifth Amendment to Agreement for Browns Mills Shopping Center Redevelopment OKd, Enabling Parties to Pursue Closing of Tract - Pine Barrens Tribune - February 7th, 2026 [February 7th, 2026]
- More Historical Evidence Showing that the Public Use Clause of the Fifth Amendment Does Not Allow Takings that Transfer Property to Private Parties -... - January 30th, 2026 [January 30th, 2026]
- Government Notifies CGST (Fifth Amendment) Rules, 2025; Inserts Rule 31D on Retail Sale PriceBased Valuation and Adds New Clause (f) in Rule 86B,... - January 6th, 2026 [January 6th, 2026]
- The fifth amendment: A path back to the people? - The Jakarta Post - December 7th, 2025 [December 7th, 2025]
- Evertec Inc - On Nov 25, Enters Into Fifth Amendment To Credit Agreement - SEC Filing - TradingView - December 7th, 2025 [December 7th, 2025]
- Brooklyn mom of missing 11-year-old autistic boy invokes Fifth Amendment in Family Court - New York Daily News - December 7th, 2025 [December 7th, 2025]
- Stepmother Cites Fifth Amendment, Says FBI Probe Could Target Minor in Teen Cruise Ship Mystery Death - LAmag - November 24th, 2025 [November 24th, 2025]
- Officer invokes Fifth Amendment in trial of former SAPD officers - WOAI - October 19th, 2025 [October 19th, 2025]
- BREAKING: Appellate Court finds one of Patrick Tate Adamiaks convictions violated Double Jeopardy Clause of the Fifth Amendment - Second Amendment... - October 15th, 2025 [October 15th, 2025]