Analysis | The Supreme Court gets the stakes of presidential immunity backward – The Washington Post
It seems fitting that the Supreme Courts decision granting presidents read: Donald Trump robust immunity from criminal prosecution landed less than a day after Trump shared a social media meme suggesting that his critics should stand before a military tribunal on charges of treason. If Trump is reelected in November, the courts decision Monday would suggest that he would have enormous leeway in exacting revenge against those he dislikes without fear of criminal prosecution.
This isnt theoretical; in writing the majority opinion, Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr. offered this idea explicitly. It is one reason observers of threats to democracy saw a result like that in Trump v. U.S. as so dangerous. Yet in his opinion, Roberts gets that threat backward.
The President is not above the law, the opinion states. But and its a very big but under our system of separated powers, the President may not be prosecuted for exercising his core constitutional powers, and he is entitled to at least presumptive immunity from prosecution for his official acts.
Roberts dismisses criticisms offered in the dissents written by Justices Sonia Sotomayor and Ketanji Brown Jackson. The dissents, he writes, strike a tone of chilling doom that is wholly disproportionate to what the Court actually does today.
Whats more, he argues at a later point, Sotomayor and Jackson offer no constitutional basis for rejecting the idea that a president should have such immunity.
Conspicuously absent is mention of the fact that since the founding, no President has ever faced criminal charges let alone for his conduct in office, he notes. And accordingly no court has ever been faced with the question of a Presidents immunity from prosecution. He offers a slippery slope: Without immunity, such types of prosecutions i.e., centrally political ones of ex-Presidents could quickly become routine. The result would be an enfeebling of the Presidency and our Government.
These are hard to reconcile: If this hasnt happened before, why would they happen routinely in the future? Solely because Trump pressed the issue, seeking protection against prosecutions rooted in his efforts to retain power after losing in 2020? In essence, the majority opinion accepts an argument that the exceptional occurrence here was the prosecution of Trump, not Trumps actions that led to the prosecution.
This was a distinction elevated by special counsel Jack Smith in an April filing with the court.
This prosecution is a historical first not because of any assumption about immunity but instead because of the singular gravity of the alleged conduct, he wrote. Trump did something that no other president had done, crossing an uncrossed line, and criminal prosecution was a result.
The risk the Supreme Court majority identifies and seeks to address is that others might be prosecuted, not that others or reelected presidents might feel confident in ignoring the law. Instead of addressing whats happening, they excuse it by theorizing about what might.
Roberts offers a president targeting his opponents as an example of something thats protected: The President may discuss potential investigations and prosecutions with his Attorney General and other Justice Department officials to carry out his constitutional duty to take Care that the Laws be faithfully executed. With that sentence, Roberts apparently intended to excise one of the charges that Trump faces in his D.C. indictment. Trump allies may read that line as a subtle excoriation of what they perceive President Biden to have done. But a Donald Trump who takes office on Jan. 20, 2025, will read it as carte blanche.
Sotomayors dissent is particularly sharp in criticizing the majority opinion, in keeping with her recent public comments about dire court opinions yet to come.
Todays decision to grant former Presidents criminal immunity reshapes the institution of the Presidency, her dissent begins. It makes a mockery of the principle, foundational to our Constitution and system of Government, that no man is above the law.
She offers examples when contrary to Robertss suggestion that this situation is novel the question of presidential criminality has emerged previously. Past special counsels have considered whether criminal charges might be brought, for example. Richard M. Nixon accepted a pardon from President Gerald Ford that rested on the understanding that the former President faced potential criminal liability. The result after Watergate was not a cascade of partisan attempts at prosecution.
The majoritys main concern could be that Presidents will be deterred from taking necessary and lawful action by the fear that their successors might pin them with a baseless criminal prosecution a prosecution that would almost certainly be doomed to fail, if it even made it out of the starting gate, Sotomayor writes, having articulated (as she has in the past) the systems checks against unfair prosecution. The Court should not have so little faith in this Nations Presidents.
But Sotomayor clearly has her own concerns about future presidents, and her warnings to that end are repeatedly pointed. The decision now lies about like a loaded weapon for any President that wishes to place his own interests, his own political survival, or his own financial gain, above the interests of the Nation, she writes. At another point, she states that in every use of official power, the President is now a king above the law.
This is the outcome most concerning to political scientists and other experts when surveyed earlier this year. Presented with several ways the legal system might put the democratic system at risk, a finding of presidential immunity was the one that experts viewed as the most obvious and dangerous threat.
In the majority opinion, Roberts attempts to separate the decision from Trump. (Unlike the political branches and the public at large, he writes, we cannot afford to fixate exclusively, or even primarily, on present exigencies.) But the decision is inextricable from Trump, in the immediate sense that it all but ensures that Trump wont face prosecution for his efforts to overturn the 2020 election before Novembers election and in the sense that it offers Trump clear guidelines on the power he might assume should he win.
It is further a decision that comes in the moment that allowed Trump to attain power. One reason Watergate didnt trigger a partisan backlash was that partisanship was not as toxic and divided then as it is now. And, again, a reason that no president has previously been criminally charged with trying to retain power despite losing an election is that no president has previously engaged in such an effort to retain power despite losing an election.
In her dissent, Jackson notes the ways in which the majoritys decision will slot into the system as it exists.
A majority of this Court, applying an indeterminate test, will pick and choose which laws apply to which Presidents, she writes, by labeling his various allegedly criminal acts as core, official, or manifestly or palpably beyond the Presidents authority. Theres no standard offered in determining what constitutes an official act. It is like so many other things in this courts estimation something that will be decided by the courts and, ultimately, should they choose, by the Supreme Court.
A president who engages in even extreme actions in the guise of his official duties faces obvious sanction. If a president orders the Navys Seal Team 6 to assassinate a political rival, to use one of Sotomayors examples, he is immune from prosecution. He might be impeached, but as Trump showed more than once, removal from office is unlikely barring a dramatic shift in the composition of the Senate.
Roberts is right that the question was triggered now because of exceptional circumstances. He seems to be wrong about those circumstances. And those circumstances may arise again in about seven months.
Never in the history of our Republic has a President had reason to believe that he would be immune from criminal prosecution if he used the trappings of his office to violate the criminal law, Sotomayors opinion concludes. Moving forward, however, all former Presidents will be cloaked in such immunity.
With fear for our democracy, she writes, I dissent.
Go here to see the original:
Analysis | The Supreme Court gets the stakes of presidential immunity backward - The Washington Post
- Cartoon: The meeting of Donald Trump, Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin - The Economist - November 19th, 2026 [November 19th, 2026]
- Xi Jinping, Donald Trump and Vladimir Putin have held trilateral talks but what did they achieve? - DW.com - November 19th, 2026 [November 19th, 2026]
- Opinion | Donald Trump and Jensen Huang Have the Same Tragic Flaw - WSJ - November 15th, 2026 [November 15th, 2026]
- Donald Trump will get a warm welcome in the Philippines - The Economist - November 15th, 2026 [November 15th, 2026]
- Why Donald Trump needs to be fired from office - Monadnock Ledger-Transcript - November 15th, 2026 [November 15th, 2026]
- How Donald Trump and Jensen Huang Forged Their Powerful Alliance - WSJ - November 15th, 2026 [November 15th, 2026]
- Biden Reveals What Angela Merkel Really Thought of Donald Trump - Newsweek - November 15th, 2026 [November 15th, 2026]
- Dana White-Donald Trump press secretary episode doubles as promotion for UFC 334 - The Athletic - The New York Times - November 15th, 2026 [November 15th, 2026]
- Donald Trump breaks silence on nationwide grounding of all flights, blames Biden - The Jerusalem Post - November 15th, 2026 [November 15th, 2026]
- Not Only Did President Donald Trump Fail to Keep His Social Security Promise, but He May Have Accelerated the Program's Path to Insolvency - Yahoo... - November 15th, 2026 [November 15th, 2026]
- Supreme Court Will Review Case Challenging Donald Trump's "Invasion" Executive Order - Reason Magazine - November 15th, 2026 [November 15th, 2026]
- Donald Trump has an unusual chance to make progress - The Economist - November 13th, 2026 [November 13th, 2026]
- Donald Trump Says He Wants to Get Cuba Done Before 2028 - The New Republic - November 13th, 2026 [November 13th, 2026]
- Very notable here is the timing: Kalshi tellingly dumps Donald Trump Jr. as Republicans lose power - Yahoo Finance - November 13th, 2026 [November 13th, 2026]
- Donald Trump really wants Tim Cook to run Nvidia - The Verge - November 13th, 2026 [November 13th, 2026]
- Its impeachment season! After the attempt on Pete Hegseth, will Donald Trump be next? | Arwa Mahdawi - The Guardian - November 13th, 2026 [November 13th, 2026]
- Donald Trump is in a hurry for peace in Ukraine. Vladimir Putin is not - The Economist - November 10th, 2026 [November 10th, 2026]
- Exclusive Interview: President Donald Trump speaks with 12 News - KWCH - October 19th, 2026 [October 19th, 2026]
- President Donald Trump to hold rally at the Sioux Gateway Airport - KTIV - October 19th, 2026 [October 19th, 2026]
- Skydance CEOs Pressed On Layoffs & Donald Trump Interference As They Outline Future At Town Hall - Deadline - October 6th, 2026 [October 6th, 2026]
- President Donald Trump announces $90 payments for seniors on Medicare ahead of midterm elections - Chicago Tribune - October 6th, 2026 [October 6th, 2026]
- Washington Post. . Protesters rallied near Arlington National Cemetery against President Donald Trumps proposed 250-foot arch. Trump has said it could... - October 2nd, 2026 [October 2nd, 2026]
- Donald Trump Jr.'s wedding celebration was partially funded by Russian oligarch, the couple confirms - AP News - September 15th, 2026 [September 15th, 2026]
- Russian oligarch close to Putin paid for part of Donald Trump Jrs lavish wedding - The Guardian - September 15th, 2026 [September 15th, 2026]
- Russian Businessman With Putin Ties Paid for Donald Trump Jr.s Wedding Party - The New York Times - September 15th, 2026 [September 15th, 2026]
- Donald Trump Jr.s Bahamas Wedding Was Secretly Bankrolled by Russian Oligarch Close to Putin - ProPublica - September 15th, 2026 [September 15th, 2026]
- What we know about the Putin ally who allegedly funded Donald Trump Jr.'s wedding - Axios - September 15th, 2026 [September 15th, 2026]
- Donald Trump Jr. acknowledges Russian oligarch with ties to Putin hosted his lavish island wedding celebration - NBC News - September 15th, 2026 [September 15th, 2026]
- Who is Umar Kremlev, the Russian oligarch who reportedly helped pay for Donald Trump Jrs wedding? - The Guardian - September 15th, 2026 [September 15th, 2026]
- Donald Trump Jr and Bettina Trump say Putin ally paid for some wedding festivities as a 'gift' - BBC - September 15th, 2026 [September 15th, 2026]
- Donald Trump Jr.'s wedding in the Bahamas sponsored by Russian businessman - Le Monde.fr - September 15th, 2026 [September 15th, 2026]
- Donald Trump Jr.s wife defends wedding gift from Russian oligarch - The Hill - September 15th, 2026 [September 15th, 2026]
- Donald Trump Jr.'s wife says Russian oligarch hosted post-wedding festivities as a "gift" - CBS News - September 15th, 2026 [September 15th, 2026]
- Donald Trump Rejects Calls For AI Slowdown. That Changes the Game for Nvidia and AMD - Yahoo Finance - September 15th, 2026 [September 15th, 2026]
- Donald Trump Jr.'s wedding celebration was partially funded by Russian oligarch, the couple confirms - Los Angeles Times - September 15th, 2026 [September 15th, 2026]
- The Future of Western Sahara Runs Down the Donald J. Trump Highway - Politico - September 13th, 2026 [September 13th, 2026]
- President Donald Trump Will Not Attend The US Open Final Featuring Ben Shelton vs Alexander Zverev: Reports - Yahoo Sports - September 13th, 2026 [September 13th, 2026]
- Donald Trump says he would love to see united Ireland - The Guardian - September 13th, 2026 [September 13th, 2026]
- Opinion | Donald Trump Is Not Going Anywhere - The New York Times - September 13th, 2026 [September 13th, 2026]
- David M. Shribman: The winding road from old-school conservatism to Donald Trump - post-gazette.com - September 13th, 2026 [September 13th, 2026]
- Forget President Donald Trump's $5,000 Dividend Promise. Investors Can Start Earning Passive Income Right Now With These 3 Fantastic Dividend Stocks... - September 13th, 2026 [September 13th, 2026]
- Donald Trump says he loved backlash to Irish unity remarks - the-independent.com - September 13th, 2026 [September 13th, 2026]
- President Donald Trump honors first responders, FDNY on The Ellipse near the White House in honor of 9/11 anniversary - ABC7 New York - September 8th, 2026 [September 8th, 2026]
- President Donald Trump honors 9/11 victims and first responders during 25th anniversary ceremony - FOX 5 DC - September 8th, 2026 [September 8th, 2026]
- Donald Trump, 80, Sparks Confusion With Dramatic New Hairdo - The Daily Beast - September 6th, 2026 [September 6th, 2026]
- President Donald Trump Claims the U.S. "Should Have the Lowest Interest Rates Anywhere in the World," but Trumpflation and the AI Revolution... - September 6th, 2026 [September 6th, 2026]
- 52 of the most stupid things Donald Trump has ever said - Indy100 - September 6th, 2026 [September 6th, 2026]
- What game theory teaches Canada about negotiating with an untrustworthy Donald Trump - The Conversation - August 31st, 2026 [August 31st, 2026]
- Tariffs, the price of ground beef, and Donald Trump - The Washington Post - August 31st, 2026 [August 31st, 2026]
- Donald Trump reacts after Supreme Court allows White House ballroom work to continue - for now - Sky News - August 22nd, 2026 [August 22nd, 2026]
- I Did a Deep Dive Into Natalie Harps Letters to Donald Trump. One Particular Line Will Haunt Me. - slate.com - August 22nd, 2026 [August 22nd, 2026]
- Donald Trump and Michael Cohen bury the hatchet - NBC News - August 22nd, 2026 [August 22nd, 2026]
- Donald Trump to present Space Medal of Honor to Artemis II crew at Johnson Space Center in Houston - Click2Houston - August 22nd, 2026 [August 22nd, 2026]
- Midterms, Actually: The real electability question is about Donald Trump - vox.com - August 18th, 2026 [August 18th, 2026]
- This Cycle's Primary Ads Featured One Star, Regardless of Party: Donald Trump - Cook Political Report - August 18th, 2026 [August 18th, 2026]
- Donald Trump says it would be a terrible mistake to replace Fifas Gianni Infantino - The Guardian - August 11th, 2026 [August 11th, 2026]
- Donald Trump and the Folly of Hubris - The Dispatch - August 5th, 2026 [August 5th, 2026]
- Donald Trump has made US$2.2 billion in his second term. How does that stack up against other US presidents? - The Conversation - August 5th, 2026 [August 5th, 2026]
- Donald Trump blames Canada for wildfire smoke but global warming is loading the wildfire dice - The Conversation - July 28th, 2026 [July 28th, 2026]
- Donald Trump is stalling for time in the war with Iran - The Economist - July 28th, 2026 [July 28th, 2026]
- Santa Cruz teen lifeguard who saved boy from massive waves to receive invited to White House, President Donald Trump says - ABC7 Los Angeles - July 28th, 2026 [July 28th, 2026]
- Donald Trump has launched another Red Scare in the US its a favourite tactic of the right - The Conversation - July 28th, 2026 [July 28th, 2026]
- Donald Trump says decision on massive attack against Iran is close - The Guardian - July 24th, 2026 [July 24th, 2026]
- Donald Trump is deeply unpopular. Why aren't Democrats doing better in the race for Congress? - YouGov - July 24th, 2026 [July 24th, 2026]
- Donald Trump has stopped caring about the midterms - Salon.com - July 24th, 2026 [July 24th, 2026]
- Football Daily | Donald Trump gives himself starting role in the bigliest occasion of all - The Guardian - July 18th, 2026 [July 18th, 2026]
- Donald Trump bizarrely tells Gianni Infantino to host next World Cup in the US with China - Yahoo Sports - July 18th, 2026 [July 18th, 2026]
- Opinion | The Odyssey, by Donald Trump - The New York Times - July 18th, 2026 [July 18th, 2026]
- Donald Trump urged to intervene after Bryson DeChambeaus controversial Open penalty - Yahoo Sports - July 18th, 2026 [July 18th, 2026]
- Donald Trump calls for FBI investigation into Michigan election claims; Benson, Nessel push back - ClickOnDetroit | WDIV Local 4 - July 18th, 2026 [July 18th, 2026]
- Homeland Security chief and Donald Trump appear at odds over ICE traffic stop pause - Bangor Daily News - July 16th, 2026 [July 16th, 2026]
- Belgium trolls USA, FIFA, Donald Trump after dominant World Cup win: 'Overturn this' - Yahoo Sports - July 7th, 2026 [July 7th, 2026]
- Donald Trump's 4-word response to Ryder Cup mockery resurfaces after Belgium's World Cup taunt - Yahoo Sports - July 7th, 2026 [July 7th, 2026]
- Belgium mock Donald Trump after knocking USA out of World Cup: Overturn this - Yahoo Sports - July 7th, 2026 [July 7th, 2026]
- 'Overturn this' - Belgium mock US President Donald Trump and FIFA after USA World Cup exit - Sky Sports - July 7th, 2026 [July 7th, 2026]
- Belgium Just Trolled Donald Trump Soooo Hard After Beating The US - Yahoo Sports - July 7th, 2026 [July 7th, 2026]
- Overturn this: Belgian team and fans mock Donald Trump and FIFA - Euronews.com - July 7th, 2026 [July 7th, 2026]
- Donald Trump Pays Tribute To The Village People's Victor Willis - Deadline - July 1st, 2026 [July 1st, 2026]
- Donald Trump Has Officially Lost the Plot - The New Yorker - July 1st, 2026 [July 1st, 2026]
- Donald Trump hijacked Americas 250 and turned it into a theatre of the absurd - The Guardian - July 1st, 2026 [July 1st, 2026]