There Is a Major Rift Dividing the White Working Class And Democrats Are Clueless – POLITICO
As a scholar studying working-class and rural whites, I have written about this subtle but consequential divide. I have also lived it. I grew up working-class white, and I watched my truck driver father and teachers aide mother struggle mightily to stay on the settled side of the ledger. They worked to pay the bills, yes, but also because work set them apart from those in their community who were willing to accept public benefits. Work represented the moral high ground. Work was their religion.
We lived in an all-white corner of the Arkansas Ozarks, so my parents werent fretting about the Black folks Ronald Reagan would later denigrate with the welfare queen stereotype. They were talking about their lazy neighbors. They called these folks white trash, the worst slur they knew.
Though Vance described this divide in Hillbilly Elegy, readers unfamiliar with the white working class may not have picked up on it. Vances beloved grandparents, Mamaw and Papaw, represented hard work. Papaw had a steady job at the Armco steel millone good enough to draw him and hundreds like him out of the Appalachian Kentucky hills to Middletown, Ohio. Indeed, it was such a good job that Mamaw could stay home and take care of the kids. Though they were crass and unconventional by polite, mainstream standards, Papaw and Mamaws work ethic positioned them in the settled working class.
Vance (bottom) grew up in the shadow of the steel mills in Middletown, Ohio (top), where he became very familiar with two distinct groups of working-class whites. Academics refer to these groups as the settled working class and the hard living.|Al Behrman/AP Photo and Drew Angerer/Getty Images
From that perch, Vances grandparents harshly judged neighbors who didnt work. They even judged their daughter, Vances mother, Bev. Though shed trained for a good job, as a nurse, Bevs drug use and frequent churn of male partners led to the instability associated with the hard living. Indeed, at one point Vance uses that very term to refer to his mother: Moms behavior grew increasingly erratic, Vance writes. She was more roommate than parent, and of the three of us Mom, [my sister], and me Mom was the roommate most prone to hard living as she partied and stayed out til the wee hours of the morning.
Given the childhood trauma associated with his mothers behavior, its perhaps not surprising that Vance came to emulate his grandparents judgmental stance toward the hard living. This is illustrated by his condemnation of shirking co-workers at a warehouse job and those who used food stamps (SNAP) to pay for the groceries he bagged as a teenager. (It seems that Vance also inherited his familys pugilistic tendencies, which have come in handy with his conversion to Trumpism; words like scumbag and idiot, which readers of Hillbilly Elegy can easily imagine coming out of Mamaws mouth, have become staples of Vances campaign vocabulary).
Ultimately, of course, Vance traveled far from his modest roots to graduate from Yale Law School and become a venture capitalist. For this success, he credited the hard work and boot-strapping mentality he learned from his grandparents. What Vance didnt credit not explicitly, anyway were the structural forces that benefitted him and his grandparents. For Vance, these included an undergraduate degree from an excellent public university (Ohio State) and opportunities in the military. For his grandparents, these included that good union job at Armco Steeleven as Papaw complained about the union. (A significant faction of workers believe that hard-working people like themselves dont need unions, that unions simply protect slackers from hard work. My own fathers pet peeve was unionized loading dock employees whose generous breaks delayed getting his truck loaded or unloaded and thus back on the road earning money. The naming of right-to-work laws plays to this mindset.)
Like Vance, settled white workers tend to see themselves living a version of the American dream grounded primarily if not entirely in their own agency. They believe they can survive, even thrive, if they just work hard enough. And some of them are doing just that. Because they lean into the grit of the individual, they tend to downplay structural obstacles to their quest to make a living, e.g., poor schools and even crummy job markets, just as they downplay structural benefits. They also discount white privilege because giving skin color credit for what they have achieved devalues the significance of their work. This mindset is also the reason that when Obama said in 2012, if youve got a business, you didnt build that, the remark landed so badly among the settled working class. Theyre not accustomed to sharing credit for what they have perhaps especially when they dont have much.
Vance and my parents are mere anecdotes, yes, but scholars have documented the phenomenon they represent. Kathryn Edin of Princeton University, Jennifer Sherman of Washington State University and Monica Prasad of Northwestern University have studied folks like them in both urban and rural locales. What settled and hard living express as cultural phenomena, Edin and colleagues express quantitatively as the second-lowest income quintile dissociating from the bottom quintile the very place from whence many had climbed. Edin described that disassociation as a virulent social distancing suddenly, youre a worker and anyone who is not a worker is a bad person.
Journalists have also brought us illustrations of the settled working class. Alec MacGillis did so in a 2015 New York Times essay, introducing us to Pamela Dougherty of Marshalltown, Iowa, a staunch opponent of safety net programs. As a teenaged mother who divorced young, Pamelas own journey had been rocky, and she had benefitted from taxpayer-funded tuition breaks at community college to become a nurse. But at the dialysis center where Pamela worked and where Medicare covered everyones treatment regardless of age, she noticed that very few patients had regular jobs. Pamela resented this. She thought the patients should have hoops to jump through to get the treatment, just as shed had to keep up her grades when she was getting assistance with college. She thought they should have some skin in the game.
Atul Gawande brought us a similar tale in a 2017 New Yorker article about whether health care should be a right. He introduced us to Monna, a librarian earning $16.50 an hour in Athens, Ohio. After taxes and health insurance premiums were deducted, Monna was taking home less than $1,000 a month, and her health insurance annual deductible was a whopping $3,000. It was her retired husbands pension, military benefits, and Medicare all benefits considered earned, not handouts that kept them afloat. In spite of this struggle, Monna didnt support health care as a right because it was another way of undermining responsibility. Noting that she could quit her job and get Medicaid for free like some of her neighbors were doing, Monna explained that she was old school and not really good at accepting anything I dont work for.
Exit polls from 2016 also reflect this division, with the lowest-income voters supporting Clintonand therefore safety-net programs associated with Democratsby the greatest margin, 53 percent to 41 percent over Trump. It was folks earning $50,000 to $99,000, those who depending on region and family size might be considered settled working class, who preferred Trump by the greatest margin of all income brackets 50 percent to 46 percent.
Continued here:
There Is a Major Rift Dividing the White Working Class And Democrats Are Clueless - POLITICO
- Full List of Democrats Targeted by GOP's Trump-Backed Texas Redistricting - Newsweek - July 30th, 2025 [July 30th, 2025]
- Booker blows up at Democrats on Senate floor: Willing to be complicit with Trump - The Hill - July 30th, 2025 [July 30th, 2025]
- Something Has Shifted for Democrats on Israel - New York Magazine - July 30th, 2025 [July 30th, 2025]
- Booker confronts fellow Democrats over bipartisan police bills - Politico - July 30th, 2025 [July 30th, 2025]
- Democrats implore Trump to step up role in addressing suffering and starvation in Gaza - AP News - July 30th, 2025 [July 30th, 2025]
- Mecklenburg Democrats who joined GOP to weaken carbon goals have history of Duke Energy donations - Axios - July 30th, 2025 [July 30th, 2025]
- Democrats vow to fight Trump climate action rollback - E&E News by POLITICO - July 30th, 2025 [July 30th, 2025]
- Texas Democrats are fundraising to potentially leave the state to block GOP-backed redistricting - The Texas Tribune - July 30th, 2025 [July 30th, 2025]
- Senate Democrats try to force DOJs hand on Epstein files - Politico - July 30th, 2025 [July 30th, 2025]
- Iowa Democrats face long odds to regain their top spot ahead of the 2028 primaries - CNN - July 30th, 2025 [July 30th, 2025]
- New York Democrats unveil their own mid-decade redistricting scheme, targeting future elections - NBC News - July 30th, 2025 [July 30th, 2025]
- Democrats clash over police funding in heated debate - MSNBC News - July 30th, 2025 [July 30th, 2025]
- Some Democrats warn that Epstein is a 'distraction' from Trump's unpopular big bill - NBC News - July 30th, 2025 [July 30th, 2025]
- Opinion | Lucky for Democrats, they picked the least-worst time to be unpopular - The Washington Post - July 30th, 2025 [July 30th, 2025]
- Roy Cooper may have found the winning issue for Democrats in 2026 | Opinion - Charlotte Observer - July 30th, 2025 [July 30th, 2025]
- Charlotte lawmaker rebuked by fellow Democrats after speech on immigration bill - Charlotte Observer - July 30th, 2025 [July 30th, 2025]
- JB Pritzker asks North Carolina Democrats Are you ready to fight? amid 2028 speculation - NC Newsline - July 30th, 2025 [July 30th, 2025]
- Abundance in OrbitThe Case for Democrats Reclaiming NASA's Bold Vision | Opinion - Newsweek - July 30th, 2025 [July 30th, 2025]
- Nebraska Democrats have outraised the Nebraska GOP since 2022. Does it matter? - Nebraska Examiner - July 30th, 2025 [July 30th, 2025]
- Seven House Democrats making day trip to New Mexico amid redistricting battle - The Texas Tribune - July 30th, 2025 [July 30th, 2025]
- Opinion | How Democrats Can Win on Immigration - The Wall Street Journal - July 30th, 2025 [July 30th, 2025]
- Political analyst says Democrats are already worried about the 'big problem' of winning back voters for 2028 - Fox News - July 30th, 2025 [July 30th, 2025]
- NC Democrats asked Republicans to join in asking for Epstein files to be released. None did - WRAL.com - July 30th, 2025 [July 30th, 2025]
- Congressional plan would flip five seats from Republicans to Democrats - Dallas News - July 30th, 2025 [July 30th, 2025]
- Democrats demand Trump cut funding for controversial Gaza aid organization - The Guardian - July 28th, 2025 [July 28th, 2025]
- Roy Cooper entrance gives Democrats hope more Senate recruiting wins are on the way - The Hill - July 28th, 2025 [July 28th, 2025]
- After Mamdani and Gaza, are Democrats turning against Israel? - The Forward - July 28th, 2025 [July 28th, 2025]
- Trump lands trade deal with EU. And, Pete Buttigieg on what's next for Democrats - NPR - July 28th, 2025 [July 28th, 2025]
- Buttigieg Is Right: Democrats Must Reinvent Government After Trump - New York Magazine - July 28th, 2025 [July 28th, 2025]
- Democrats use new tactic to highlight Trumps gutting of Medicaid: billboards in the rural US - The Guardian - July 28th, 2025 [July 28th, 2025]
- The whole thing was a fake: Trump says Democrats could have put things in the Epstein file - The Independent - July 28th, 2025 [July 28th, 2025]
- For Democrats, governors races are an opportunity to create momentum - Roll Call - July 28th, 2025 [July 28th, 2025]
- Democrats and the media are trying to run the same grift on the same marks, Jonathan Turley says - Fox News - July 28th, 2025 [July 28th, 2025]
- Why gym selfies are the new key campaign tool for Democrats - The Times - July 28th, 2025 [July 28th, 2025]
- Democrats: The 2028 race has begun - The Week - July 28th, 2025 [July 28th, 2025]
- Bounce-back emails and no-replies: IRS and Social Security workforce reductions are hurting constituent service, House Democrats argue - Government... - July 28th, 2025 [July 28th, 2025]
- South Carolina Democrats will fight to keep 'first in the nation' primary status in 2028 - NBC News - July 28th, 2025 [July 28th, 2025]
- What if anything have the Democrats learned since 2016? | Opinion - The Portland Press Herald - July 28th, 2025 [July 28th, 2025]
- Exclusive | Democrats Get Lowest Rating From Voters in 35 Years, WSJ Poll Finds - The Wall Street Journal - July 27th, 2025 [July 27th, 2025]
- Democrats' 2028 presidential race is going fast and furious - Axios - July 27th, 2025 [July 27th, 2025]
- Democrats rally in Texas over Trump order to redraw districts: The only way they can keep power is to cheat - The Guardian - July 27th, 2025 [July 27th, 2025]
- Democrats Fight Against Republican Funding Bill that Raises Utility Bills and Energy Prices, Slashes Resources for the Arts and National Parks -... - July 27th, 2025 [July 27th, 2025]
- Elon Musk is threatening to put third-party candidates on the ballot. Democrats are giddy. - Politico - July 27th, 2025 [July 27th, 2025]
- Can Texas Democrats Stop the Redistricting By Breaking Quorum? - Democracy Docket - July 27th, 2025 [July 27th, 2025]
- Texas Democrats Confer With California and Illinois Governors on Redistricting - The New York Times - July 27th, 2025 [July 27th, 2025]
- Rep. Ro Khanna thinks the Epstein files could help Democrats 'fight Trump effectively' - NBC News - July 27th, 2025 [July 27th, 2025]
- Iowa Democrats kick off canvassing campaign ahead of upcoming elections - KTIV - July 27th, 2025 [July 27th, 2025]
- Democrats request copy of Epstein birthday book that reportedly contains Trump poem - The Guardian - July 27th, 2025 [July 27th, 2025]
- Texans, Democrats condemn GOP redistricting plans at first public hearing - The Texas Tribune - July 27th, 2025 [July 27th, 2025]
- Are the Democrats Getting Better at the Internet? - newyorker.com - July 27th, 2025 [July 27th, 2025]
- Scoop: Democrats think they can get their hands on Epstein's birthday book - Axios - July 27th, 2025 [July 27th, 2025]
- Former Governor Roy Cooper speaks to NC Democrats during annual Unity Dinner ahead of likely 2026 Senate run - ABC11 - July 27th, 2025 [July 27th, 2025]
- An early report on the Kansas governor's race: Heavyweight Republicans and low-key Democrats - Kansas Reflector - July 27th, 2025 [July 27th, 2025]
- Wave of young Pa. Democrats engaging in politics as party debates its future - Pittsburgh Post-Gazette - July 27th, 2025 [July 27th, 2025]
- Democrats Chances of Flipping the Senate Just Went Up - New York Magazine - July 27th, 2025 [July 27th, 2025]
- Democrats Should Use Shutdown Threat as 'Leverage' to Oppose Cuts, Says Rep. Subramanyam - Bloomberg.com - July 24th, 2025 [July 24th, 2025]
- In Epstein, Democrats Find Weapon Against Trump and Republicans - The New York Times - July 24th, 2025 [July 24th, 2025]
- Wisconsin Democrats launch push to take the majority in the Senate after years in the shadows - Milwaukee Journal Sentinel - July 24th, 2025 [July 24th, 2025]
- Two Democrats Are Bolting From a Bipartisan Governors Group - The Atlantic - July 24th, 2025 [July 24th, 2025]
- Democrats Are Running Circles Around Republicans on Epstein - Politico - July 24th, 2025 [July 24th, 2025]
- Democrats Have Few Tools to Counter G.O.P. Redistricting - The New York Times - July 24th, 2025 [July 24th, 2025]
- We learned some lessons: How Chuck Schumer and Democrats are gearing up for the next funding fight with Trump - CNN - July 24th, 2025 [July 24th, 2025]
- Some Democrats may finally be ready to play dirty over redistricting - vox.com - July 24th, 2025 [July 24th, 2025]
- Democrats Havent Failed to Fight Trump. Theyve Failed to Win. - New York Magazine - July 24th, 2025 [July 24th, 2025]
- VIDEO: Blackburn Slams Democrats for Obstructing President Trumps Agenda and Will of the American People - Senator Marsha Blackburn (.gov) - July 24th, 2025 [July 24th, 2025]
- NCUA Meeting Seats In Limbo: Will Reinstated Democrats Show Up Or Sit Out? - CU Today - July 24th, 2025 [July 24th, 2025]
- Senate Democrats agree to advance military construction, VA spending bill - The Hill - July 24th, 2025 [July 24th, 2025]
- 2024: How Trump Retook the White House and the Democrats Lost America - KALW - July 24th, 2025 [July 24th, 2025]
- Opinion | Are the Democrats Dead or Alive? - The New York Times - July 22nd, 2025 [July 22nd, 2025]
- Opinion | James Carville: My Fix for the Confused and Leaderless Democrats - The New York Times - July 22nd, 2025 [July 22nd, 2025]
- One year after Biden's unprecedented exit from 2024 race, Democrats poll numbers at rock bottom - Fox News - July 22nd, 2025 [July 22nd, 2025]
- US protesters call for Democrats to face Trump and fight, fight, fight with every tool available - The Guardian - July 22nd, 2025 [July 22nd, 2025]
- 'Flood' of ICE agents is coming to cities run by Democrats, according to the White House - USA Today - July 22nd, 2025 [July 22nd, 2025]
- Pennington County Democrats host town hall discussing veterans issues - kotatv.com - July 22nd, 2025 [July 22nd, 2025]
- These Democrats could be targeted in the GOP's Texas redistricting push - Houston Chronicle - July 22nd, 2025 [July 22nd, 2025]
- Republicans and Democrats Call for More Information on Epstein Case - The New York Times - July 22nd, 2025 [July 22nd, 2025]
- Opinion | There Is Hope for Democrats. Look to Kansas. - The New York Times - July 22nd, 2025 [July 22nd, 2025]
- 'Flood' of ICE agents is coming to cities run by Democrats, White House warns - USA Today - July 22nd, 2025 [July 22nd, 2025]
- Day 1 of Texas special session starts with Democrats signaling they could flee over redistricting - ABC13 Houston - July 22nd, 2025 [July 22nd, 2025]
- Trump blames Epstein files on Democrats and Comey but the timeline tells a different story - Poynter - July 22nd, 2025 [July 22nd, 2025]