‘We wanted democracy’: is Hong Kong’s two-systems experiment over? – The Guardian
For President Xi Jinping, the 20th anniversary of Hong Kongs return to China is a moment to toast the reunification of a nation and hail its unstoppable rise. But for activists such as Eddie Chu, one of the leading lights of a new generation of pro-democracy politicians, it has become an occasion for something quite different.
Boot-licking. Unprecedented boot-licking! he says, a smile breaking across his face as he reflects on how many members of the local elite have chosen to mark two decades of Chinese rule by plastering their homes and businesses with patriotic slogans and red flags in the hope, he suspects, of currying economic favour.
That is quite the opposite of what Hong Kong people wanted to see in 1997. We wanted to see democracy. Democracy is not boot-licking.
On Saturday morning, Chinas authoritarian ruler, who is making a rare three-day tour of the former British colony, will lead celebrations of two decades of Chinese control alongside Hong Kongs incoming chief executive, Carrie Lam.
At a flag-raising ceremony just down the road from where the umbrella revolution happened an unprecedented eruption of dissent in the autumn of 2014 the pair will remember the moment this city of 7.3 million residents returned to China after 156 years of colonial rule. A flypast and a sea parade will follow. By night, the skies over Victoria harbour, from where the royal yacht Britannia departed on 1 July 1997, will be illuminated by a spectacular 23-minute blaze of fireworks.
The moving occasion of Hong Kongs return to the motherland like a long-separated child coming back to the warm embrace of his mother, is still vivid in our memory, Xi told a dinner on Friday night.
But for members of Hong Kongs democracy movement, the anniversary is accompanied by a profound sense of uncertainty and trepidation.
Twenty years after Britains departure thrust this hyperactive lair of capitalism into the hands of a Leninist dictatorship, campaigners such as Chu fear Beijing is preparing to up the ante in its battle for control.
Ten pro-democracy legislators, of which he is one, are at risk of losing their jobs as a result of government-backed legal challenges against them. There are fears that under Hong Kongs new leader, who was elected by a tightly controlled selection committee, there will be a renewed push to enact controversial anti-subversion legislation.
And while Xi has sought to strike an upbeat tone during his visit, recent comments by another senior Communist party figure who vowed to consolidate Chinas control of the former colony has put activists on edge.
The relationship between the central government and Hong Kong is that of delegation of power, not power-sharing, Zhang Dejiang, Chinas number three official, said, adding that Hong Kong could only be governed by those who posed no threat to [its] prosperity and stability.
Feeding into activists sense of foreboding is the feeling that many western governments have now cut them loose for fear of damaging their economic relationships with the worlds second largest economy.
The foreign secretary, Boris Johnson, issued a carefully worded statement about the anniversary on Thursday, saying it was vital that Hong Kongs autonomy be preserved. But Johnson made no direct mention of growing fears about the erosion of Hong Kongs freedoms, or even of Beijings alleged abduction of a local bookseller who held a British passport.
The British government is just awful. Im afraid I cannot find any kind words to say about that, says Martin Lee, a 79-year-old barrister who is the elder statesman of Hong Kongs democracy movement.
Like many, Lee is convinced that China is gradually stripping away the freedoms promised to Hong Kongs citizens under the one country, two systems formula and that Britain has done nothing to intervene.
On Friday, a spokesperson for Chinas foreign ministry appeared to confirm those fears, telling reporters that the joint declaration, a deal negotiated by London and Beijing guaranteeing Hong Kongs way of life for 50 years, was a historical document that no longer had any practical significance.
Suzanne Pepper, a veteran chronicler of the citys quest for democracy, says campaigners can no longer count on London or Washington for support: As long as there is not blood in the streets, they dont care.
Not everybody is lamenting Saturdays landmark anniversary, however. The streets around Xis waterfront hotel are dotted with clusters of pro-government supporters and decorated with banners that read I love Hong Kong and One country, two systems has the strong vitality. Lilac posters hanging from bridges and lampposts carry the celebrations official catchline: Together. Progress. Opportunity. Skyscrapers have been decked out in bright red banners and neon displays that read: Warmly celebrate the 20th anniversary of Hong Kongs return to China.
Amid the omnipresent propaganda, there is also genuine patriotic fervour. Hong Kong people should be proud of the achievements of the motherland and all the progress our country has made, enthused Li Li, a guide at a government-sponsored exhibit about Chinas space programme that has been erected in Victoria Park to coincide with this weeks party.
Many more have greeted the anniversary and the presidential visit with nonchalance.
Chu estimated that about a third of the population was split between pro-democracy and pro-government supporters. The rest couldnt care less about the anniversary, and were most worried about the traffic jams caused by the massive security operation to protect Xi.
Swaths of the citys waterfront are sealed off with towering white and blue barricades, with agents patrolling the streets with assault rifles in their hands. Too many police! jokes one of hundreds of officers patrolling the area, sweat beading on his neck.
Lee says the lack of interest many young people are showing in Xis visit underline how disconnected they feel from mainland China and how Beijings policies have lost their hearts and souls.
Oh, this is the ruler of a neighbouring country thats what they feel, he says, pointing to a recent poll suggesting that only 3% of 18-to-29-year-olds consider themselves Chinese, the lowest rate since 1997. The young people want democracy. They dont want to be brainwashed.
For all the indifference and uncertainty, Hong Kongs protest movement appears in buoyant mood. Tens of thousands are expected to turn out on Saturday afternoon for an annual march marking the return to China. Their rallying cry will be Twenty years of lies. [It] was going to be Communist party officials, get out of Hong Kong, but they decided that was a bit too provocative, says Pepper.
Last September, a record number of young anti-Beijing activists were elected to Hong Kongs legislative council, or Legco, in what one victor called a democratic miracle. However, many of them could now be forced from office, mostly because of government legal challenges over protests the activists took part in while being sworn in last year.
If two to three of them lose their seats, then the whole political balance will change totally, and then Beijing will have absolute control of this legislature, warns Chu, who was to shout Democracy and self-determination and Tyranny must die while taking his oath.
Pepper said she was not optimistic that Beijing would offer concessions to activists, even though Hong Kongs incoming leader has pledged to heal the divide and build bridges. This is a bridge between democracy and dictatorship, said Pepper. How she is going to bridge that, I dont know.
Chris Patten, Hong Kongs last governor, has offered a more upbeat appraisal of the city he once ran, saying he was encouraged by the really profound sense of citizenship of its young activists. Above all, I think I am pleased about the way in which Hong Kong people themselves are the reason for it still being a cause of optimism rather than pessimism.
Lee, who is famed for an impassioned defence of democracy that he gave after Britains withdrawal, says he is an eternal optimist about his movements chances under a new, young leadership. These young people are our hope for the future. Im very proud of them.
Sitting in his chambers between a bust of Winston Churchill and a statuette of the Goddess of Democracy, the symbol of the 1989 Tiananmen Square protests, Lee remembers strolling through the umbrella movements main camp, a sprawl of tents and political debate, three days before police finally cleared it, in December 2015.
There were two little birds singing on the ground. [It was as if they were saying:] I wish I were free, you know? The air was fresh, he reminisces. I miss those days.
Additional reporting by Benjamin Haas and Wang Zhen.
Read this article:
'We wanted democracy': is Hong Kong's two-systems experiment over? - The Guardian
- The era of trillionaires will be dire for democracy. Here is how we can fight back | Gabriel Zucman - The Guardian - June 17th, 2026 [June 17th, 2026]
- Georgia Republicans backtracked on gerrymandering because they feared a showdown over Black voting rights - Democracy Docket - June 17th, 2026 [June 17th, 2026]
- Europes fractured politics and what they reveal about democracy - Brookings - June 17th, 2026 [June 17th, 2026]
- Two Declarations, One Democracy: On Freedom, Exclusion, and the American Project - Nonprofit Quarterly - June 17th, 2026 [June 17th, 2026]
- Democracy needs more than just opinions - EBU - June 17th, 2026 [June 17th, 2026]
- Defending Democracy in the 2026 Midterms: What Public Health Needs to Know - American Public Health Association - June 17th, 2026 [June 17th, 2026]
- The Point Is to Spread Fear: DOJ Charges 15 with Conspiracy for Anti-ICE Protests in Minnesota - Democracy Now! - June 17th, 2026 [June 17th, 2026]
- Democracy, Under Construction: Kettering Fellows on Americas 250th Anniversary - Kettering Foundation - June 17th, 2026 [June 17th, 2026]
- Right-wing legal group sues to obtain Oklahomas voter rolls - Democracy Docket - June 17th, 2026 [June 17th, 2026]
- Opinion | Hickenlooper: I will continue to fight for you, our future and our democracy, if elected - SkyHiNews.com - June 17th, 2026 [June 17th, 2026]
- Americans split over future of democracy as 250th anniversary nears - Muslim Network TV - June 17th, 2026 [June 17th, 2026]
- Trita Parsi on What May Be in the U.S.-Iran Peace Deal & Being Threatened with Deportation - Democracy Now! - June 17th, 2026 [June 17th, 2026]
- Americans are more dissatisfied with how their democracy is working than people in other high-income countries - Pew Research Center - June 12th, 2026 [June 12th, 2026]
- Democracy Forward Sues the FBI and DOJ for Records Related to Director Kash Patel - Democracy Forward - June 12th, 2026 [June 12th, 2026]
- Ask an Expert: How Can the Science Community Protect Science and Democracy? - The Equation - Union of Concerned Scientists - June 12th, 2026 [June 12th, 2026]
- Democracy as the practice of loving our neighbors - Baptist News Global - June 12th, 2026 [June 12th, 2026]
- Protecting voter privacy and the integrity of U.S. elections - Protect Democracy - June 12th, 2026 [June 12th, 2026]
- [Webinar] America at 250: Competing Visions of Democracy and National Identity - PRRI - June 12th, 2026 [June 12th, 2026]
- Cracking Down on Pass-Throughs - Democracy Journal - June 12th, 2026 [June 12th, 2026]
- Myths About Israel, Debunked: Why Iranian Democracy Is the Path to Peace - The Times of Israel - June 12th, 2026 [June 12th, 2026]
- World Cup Kicks Off in Mexico Amid Protests Against Austerity and Forced Disappearances - Democracy Now! - June 12th, 2026 [June 12th, 2026]
- Talking about media and democracy with the League of Women Voters - Media Nation - June 12th, 2026 [June 12th, 2026]
- Civics and Democracy Program at the Sam Rayburn House on June 19th - Herald Democrat - June 12th, 2026 [June 12th, 2026]
- LGBTQ+ activist Ed Lally mobilizes Tampa Bay for inclusion and democracy - Watermark Out News - June 12th, 2026 [June 12th, 2026]
- I Was Just Forced to Resign from NASAs Jet Propulsion Laboratory: Climate Scientist Peter Kalmus - Democracy Now! - June 12th, 2026 [June 12th, 2026]
- Opinion | Alabamas redistricting reversal is a warning for American democracy - The Crimson White - June 12th, 2026 [June 12th, 2026]
- South Carolina, Nevada and Maine primaries put the stakes of democracy in focus. Heres what were watching - Democracy Docket - June 10th, 2026 [June 10th, 2026]
- Fresh Food and Local Democracy Bloom: City Officials and Community Celebrate Grand Opening of The Peoples Market in the International District - City... - June 10th, 2026 [June 10th, 2026]
- Feminist Lessons from 2020 to Present: The Fight for Democracy Is Far From Over - Ms. Magazine - June 10th, 2026 [June 10th, 2026]
- Exhibition Exploring Democracy Across America Opens June 16 in Smithsonians Arts and Industries Building - Smithsonian Institution - June 10th, 2026 [June 10th, 2026]
- Nevada Democracy Groups Warn the SAVE Act Would Undermine Voting Rights - The Fulcrum - June 10th, 2026 [June 10th, 2026]
- Merton Redux: Re-Confronting the Norms of Science in Democracy - Issues in Science and Technology - June 10th, 2026 [June 10th, 2026]
- European Democracy under Pressure - Impulses from Poland, Perspectives for the Future - European Committee of the Regions - June 10th, 2026 [June 10th, 2026]
- GUEST COLUMN: A nation worth striving for: The unfinished story of democracy - Rogue Valley Times - June 10th, 2026 [June 10th, 2026]
- The revenge of context in the Democratic Republic of Congo: Administrative reforms under the weight of the past - Democracy in Africa - June 10th, 2026 [June 10th, 2026]
- If Colombias Left Loses, Will It Accept the Verdict of Democracy? - The City Paper Bogot - June 10th, 2026 [June 10th, 2026]
- Opinion | If California's race for governor is a stress test for democracy, it's failing - CalMatters - June 10th, 2026 [June 10th, 2026]
- Is Direct Democracy The Solution To The Looming Global Debt Crisis? - The Common Sense - June 10th, 2026 [June 10th, 2026]
- Ron Lora: Great wealth disparity and our eroding democracy - LimaOhio.com - June 10th, 2026 [June 10th, 2026]
- Gov't resumes awarding state honors to democracy martyrs after 4-year suspension - The Korea Times - June 10th, 2026 [June 10th, 2026]
- Israel, as a democracy, should be held to higher standards than surrounding regimes - The Irish Times - June 10th, 2026 [June 10th, 2026]
- To Save Democracy, We Need to Reimagine the Economy - Time Magazine - June 3rd, 2026 [June 3rd, 2026]
- Wheres Democracy Headed? TED Talks to Ponder Founding Futures - The Pew Charitable Trusts - June 3rd, 2026 [June 3rd, 2026]
- Oregon Leads in Democracy but Falls Behind in Mental Health, Report Finds - Willamette Week - June 3rd, 2026 [June 3rd, 2026]
- How a democracy survives 1,561 days and counting of war - International IDEA - June 3rd, 2026 [June 3rd, 2026]
- Report warns attacks on workers rights are weakening democracy - Democracy Without Borders - June 3rd, 2026 [June 3rd, 2026]
- 5Qs: McQuades New Book Details The Fix for Democracy in the US - University of Michigan Law School - June 3rd, 2026 [June 3rd, 2026]
- Filmmaker Ken Burns: "The Bulwark against Enemies of Democracy Is Threatened" - DER SPIEGEL - The German View - June 3rd, 2026 [June 3rd, 2026]
- Our democracy is run by two private clubs: can a pro-hunting Democrat lead a blue wave in Iowa? - The Guardian - June 3rd, 2026 [June 3rd, 2026]
- Meet the Moment: Colombias Presidential Election and the Future of Peace, Democracy & Climate Action - Georgetown Institute for Women, Peace and... - June 3rd, 2026 [June 3rd, 2026]
- This Philadelphia art gallery looks at the state of American democracy through printmaking - CBS News - June 3rd, 2026 [June 3rd, 2026]
- Turkish democracy on trial: how Erdoans rule has undermined justice and weakened his rivals - The Conversation - June 3rd, 2026 [June 3rd, 2026]
- Democracy, Divinity and the Inherent Challenge of the Image of God - Jewish Journal - June 3rd, 2026 [June 3rd, 2026]
- Dr. Adam Hamawy, Who Volunteered in Gaza, Wins Democratic Nomination for New Jersey House Seat - Democracy Now! - June 3rd, 2026 [June 3rd, 2026]
- Defending democracy from the global war on reality - The Japan Times - June 3rd, 2026 [June 3rd, 2026]
- Election deniers, vote suppressors, and democracy defenders are running in California's primary. Here's what we're watching - Democracy Docket - June 3rd, 2026 [June 3rd, 2026]
- Lack of contested legislative races and overflow of ballot questions reflect democracy in decline - CommonWealth Beacon - June 3rd, 2026 [June 3rd, 2026]
- Argumentation and public service: dialogue as the foundation of democracy - Universit della Svizzera italiana | USI - June 3rd, 2026 [June 3rd, 2026]
- Trump appoints Bill Pulte, unqualified loyalist who targeted his foes, as acting intel chief - Democracy Docket - June 3rd, 2026 [June 3rd, 2026]
- A Promising Democracy That Cant Stop Fighting Itself - The Atlantic - June 1st, 2026 [June 1st, 2026]
- United States added to Watchlist as attacks on workers' freedoms accelerate the erosion of democracy: ITUC Global Rights Index 2026 - International... - June 1st, 2026 [June 1st, 2026]
- The challenge of rebuilding the collective to strengthen Latin American democracy - Latinoamrica 21 - June 1st, 2026 [June 1st, 2026]
- Ethiopias 7th Election: Scale, Pluralism, and Transitional Democracy in the Horn - horn review - June 1st, 2026 [June 1st, 2026]
- Postal Service moving forward with Trumps attack on mail voting - Democracy Docket - June 1st, 2026 [June 1st, 2026]
- A yearlong democracy exchange lands SPIA students in the UK - University of Pittsburgh - June 1st, 2026 [June 1st, 2026]
- How To Treat The Disinformation 'Virus' Undermining Health And Democracy - Health Policy Watch - June 1st, 2026 [June 1st, 2026]
- Judge temporarily halts Trumps $1.8 billion weaponization slush fund - Democracy Docket - June 1st, 2026 [June 1st, 2026]
- Our Democracy Will Survive If You Fight - The Harvard Crimson - June 1st, 2026 [June 1st, 2026]
- Tibetan Democracy and the Central Tibetan Administration in a Changing Global Political Landscape - International Campaign for Tibet - June 1st, 2026 [June 1st, 2026]
- Alabama keeps telling us what it thinks democracy should look like - Democracy Docket - June 1st, 2026 [June 1st, 2026]
- The Pro-Democracy and Climate Movements Just Scored a Win In an Unexpected Place - In These Times - June 1st, 2026 [June 1st, 2026]
- Letter to the editor: Becky Edwards, Russ Cleveland will champion democracy - Bozeman Daily Chronicle - June 1st, 2026 [June 1st, 2026]
- Tribute to Professor WADE, Teacher of Democracy and Alternation in Senegal - Financial Afrik - June 1st, 2026 [June 1st, 2026]
- Is the Supreme Court actively dismantling democracy? The rulings that made voter suppression easier. - The Fulcrum - June 1st, 2026 [June 1st, 2026]
- Jury Awards Family $50M for Daughters Death in Boeing Crash as Mother Vows to Keep Fighting - Democracy Now! - June 1st, 2026 [June 1st, 2026]
- U.N. Warns Global Heating Is on Track to Exceed 1.5C Threshold by 2030 - Democracy Now! - June 1st, 2026 [June 1st, 2026]
- Callais just gutted the promise of equal representation. But we need to keep fighting for multiracial democracy - Democracy Docket - June 1st, 2026 [June 1st, 2026]
- Can Mansour Abbas save Israeli democracy? - The Times of Israel - June 1st, 2026 [June 1st, 2026]
- [Interview] Civil society leader to EU: Stop the witch hunt on NGOs before its too late for democracy - EUobserver - June 1st, 2026 [June 1st, 2026]
- Ex-Proud Boy leader wants millions for trying to destroy our democracy | Opinion - Miami Herald - June 1st, 2026 [June 1st, 2026]