The PM sees votes in a culture war over trans rights, but this issue must transcend party politics – The Guardian
Last Sunday saw one of the biggest protests outside Downing Street in years.
It wasnt over Ukraine, or the soaring heating bills some fear will eventually push us into social unrest, or even the growing crisis in British hospitals. It was over what should have been a small, if sensitive, legislative change improving a relative handful of lives, which has somehow been blown up into the kind of mutually destructive culture war that burns everyone it touches. And thereby hangs a tale about how not to fight the next general election, for all our sakes.
This particular protest was over the governments long-promised ban on conversion practice, a grim form of quackery involving trying to cure LGBT people of their orientation or identity. Threats to dump it from the forthcoming Queens speech triggered such a backlash in Tory ranks that a U-turn was announced within hours but only for lesbian, gay and bisexual people. Trans people will be excluded, at least in England, pending further examination of claims that a loosely worded ban might deter therapists from properly exploring childrens reasons for questioning their gender identity. (Scotland is expected to proceed with a full ban, and Wales is examining options for doing so.)
Such claims deserve to be taken seriously but theyre not new, having been raised by the Equality and Human Rights Commission this January and long before that by gender-critical campaigners. The British Medical Association, plus other professional bodies that regulate counselling, supports a full ban and ministers have repeatedly argued that any concerns could be resolved in the usual way by careful wording when the bill is drafted.
Yet Downing Street still changed its mind at the 11th hour without even consulting its own equalities ministers, shattering the already fragile trust in its intentions. The result is a flagship LGBT rights policy that has offended and distressed many LGBT people attempts to split trans rights from gay ones are widely interpreted as an attempt to divide and conquer, leaving trans people vulnerable and isolated. A backbench rebellion is now brewing among Tory MPs who are tired of never quite knowing where they stand.
Whatever happened to the new year shake-up of Downing Street that had been meant to bring order to the chaos? Even a planned summit on LGBT rights this summer a Tory manifesto commitment designed to encourage progressive change in countries where homosexuality is still shrouded in taboos had to be scrapped after British gay rights groups withdrew support in protest.
Many are suspicious, too, of a U-turn announced on the eve of difficult local elections. As the Conservative MP for Rutland and Melton Alicia Kearns put it: This ban isnt some new woke frontier for politicians to weaponise in some culture war they think is vote-winning.
The governments LGBT business champion resigned and some predicted the prime ministers personal envoy on LGBT rights, the former Tory MP Nick Herbert, would follow. But instead he released a thoughtful, if exasperated, statement that deserves a wider hearing, calling for a cross-party independent royal commission on trans rights issues to stop them being further weaponised for political advantage.
Some may tell the government that this is a political opportunity for a wedge issue, but this would be deeply unwise, he wrote, noting pointedly that opinion polling shows Britons are tired of ideological punch-ups over trans rights and want to see politicians respond with kindness and practical solutions. But Herbert was equally critical of what he called Stonewalls penchant for boycotts and shouty protests, reflecting frustration among some Tories with a style of activism they think alienates potential allies. His conclusion is that a judge-led commission, free to go wherever the evidence takes it on issues such as teenagers transitioning or the inclusion of trans women in elite female sport, may now be Britains best hope of avoiding a viciously full-blown American-style culture war.
Ironically, thats what many hoped Herbert himself would do when he was appointed last May. Back then, Johnson had been convinced that aggressive culture wars were turning moderate voters off. Working alongside the openly gay equalities minister Mike Freer and then No 10 aide Henry Newman to rebuild bridges with the LGBT community, Herbert came tantalisingly close to brokering a truce; behind the scenes they had powerful backing from Carrie Johnson, a longstanding advocate of LGBT rights who delivered a rare public speech last autumn declaring her husbands commitment to the cause. But in January, the rug was pulled out from under them.
Fearing a leadership challenge after revelations of lockdown-busting parties inside Downing Street, Boris Johnson agreed to a shake-up that saw Carries influence curtailed, Newman exiled, and a new team installed that is frankly uninterested in the niceties of millennial identity politics. Led by policy unit chief Andrew Griffith, chief of staff Steve Barclay and spin doctor Guto Harri, the new regime has positioned Johnson as the voice of the middle-aged bloke down the pub.
Last week, he kickstarted the local election campaign by declaring that biological males shouldnt be allowed to compete in womens sport, a helpful distraction from tax rises coming into force. If it works, expect to see the same tactic, but on steroids, in a general election. Which is why some will see Herberts proposed royal commission as, at best, a nice idea doomed to fail; at worst, kicking things into the long grass.
But where similar schemes have worked as with Dame Mary Warnocks 1980s inquiry into the then pioneering field of human fertilisation and embryology, sensationally portrayed by tabloids as Frankenstein science they have defused public anxiety about the novel and unfamiliar, opening the space for bold leaps forward.
Walking people methodically through complex ethical arguments takes time, but since scientific research on the impact of transitioning on athletes performance is still in its infancy, conclusive answers to some issues of trans inclusion are probably years away anyway. If Boris Johnson ignores the idea although oddly it might suit him given the strange elusiveness of his own views on the subject Keir Starmer should pick it up.
For whether or not hes right about the exact mechanism, Herbert is right about the urgency of lifting this issue above toxic party politics. Hes right that nobody wins a culture war and right that those most harmed will be trans people who already feel stigmatised who deserve greater kindness than todays politics will permit.
Its depressing to think our current political system cant be trusted to handle this maturely. But not half as depressing as looking back in five years time and realising those years were wasted, doing the same thing over and over, and being surprised each time it failed.
Gaby Hinsliff is a Guardian columnist
Politics Weekly UK liveJoin John Harris, Lisa Nandy MP and Gaby Hinsliff in a livestreamed event discussing partygate, the upcoming local elections, the cost of living crisis and more on Tuesday 3 May, 8pm BST. Book tickets here
Go here to see the original:
The PM sees votes in a culture war over trans rights, but this issue must transcend party politics - The Guardian
- Fox News is already starting the culture wars over the new Grand Theft Auto VI - Yahoo - November 17th, 2026 [November 17th, 2026]
- Republicans went all in on culture wars. Texas Democrats changed the subject. - Austin American-Statesman - November 17th, 2026 [November 17th, 2026]
- Woke One was crazy: Why Democrats are leaving the culture wars behind - The Irish Times - November 17th, 2026 [November 17th, 2026]
- Fox News is already starting the culture wars over the new Grand Theft Auto VI - AOL.co.uk - November 17th, 2026 [November 17th, 2026]
- Transgender Rights Beyond the Culture Wars - Countercurrents - November 17th, 2026 [November 17th, 2026]
- Affordability, not culture wars - The Star - November 17th, 2026 [November 17th, 2026]
- Woke One was crazy: Why Democrats are leaving the culture wars behind - BreakingNews.ie - November 17th, 2026 [November 17th, 2026]
- Why Democrats Should Stop Using the Phrase Culture Wars - The New Republic - September 29th, 2026 [September 29th, 2026]
- Once Again, the Rossmoor Retirement Community Is Having Some Culture Wars - SFist - September 29th, 2026 [September 29th, 2026]
- Culture wars, Qatar money and rising antisemitism: ALL CAPS connects the dots - Ynetnews - September 29th, 2026 [September 29th, 2026]
- Shove it with your culture wars: Hinojosa urges Democrats to focus on economy ahead of November and 2028 - Politico - September 29th, 2026 [September 29th, 2026]
- With measles outbreaks, the culture wars have turned deadly (Editorial) - dailycamera.com - September 29th, 2026 [September 29th, 2026]
- MILLIGAN: The nerds won the pop culture wars, so why can't we stop complaining about it? - WaltonTribune.com - September 29th, 2026 [September 29th, 2026]
- Review: The Humanities looks away from the campus culture wars it purports to interrogate - Chicago Sun-Times - September 29th, 2026 [September 29th, 2026]
- Azerbaijans Identity Crisis and the Political Need for Culture Wars - EVN Report - September 29th, 2026 [September 29th, 2026]
- How the WNBA became a political prop in the culture wars - NPR - September 15th, 2026 [September 15th, 2026]
- WEEKEND READ:Nike Is Leaving the S&P 100. Culture Wars Didnt Do This Strategy Did - European Business Magazine - September 15th, 2026 [September 15th, 2026]
- Growing concern inside Pentagon over Hegseths focus on culture wars - 11Alive.com - September 6th, 2026 [September 6th, 2026]
- Feminism is a death cult: How culture wars infiltrated the Lindsay Clancy case - MS NOW - September 6th, 2026 [September 6th, 2026]
- Theater top 10 for fall 2026: Culture wars, campus controversies and epic change - Chicago Tribune - September 4th, 2026 [September 4th, 2026]
- Braun says affordability, not culture wars, should drive GOP | Opinion - IndyStar - September 4th, 2026 [September 4th, 2026]
- Growing concern inside Pentagon over Hegseths focus on culture wars - CNN - September 4th, 2026 [September 4th, 2026]
- The 1926 International Eucharistic Congress: When the Catholic Church triumphed despite gangsters, culture wars and the KKK - America Magazine - September 4th, 2026 [September 4th, 2026]
- Impact of Contemporary Culture Wars on Religious Discrimination Claims and Defenses - Race, Racism and the Law - September 4th, 2026 [September 4th, 2026]
- Jason Arday: A Casualty of the Culture Wars - Next Century Foundation - September 4th, 2026 [September 4th, 2026]
- David Adams: Culture wars are designed to keep us divided - The Irish News - September 4th, 2026 [September 4th, 2026]
- Growing concern inside Pentagon over Hegseths focus on culture wars | CNN Politics - edition.cnn.com - September 4th, 2026 [September 4th, 2026]
- Dolly Parton vs Jelly Roll: How celebs can avoid culture wars by articulating their values - Substack - August 31st, 2026 [August 31st, 2026]
- Natasha Cloud stands firm in protecting WNBA against political or culture wars - Awful Announcing - August 31st, 2026 [August 31st, 2026]
- Cambridge, the Culture Wars, and the Unforgiving Politics of Academic Scrutiny - TheWire.in - August 31st, 2026 [August 31st, 2026]
- Inside Italy: Forget culture wars, Italy has bigger problems with air conditioning - The Local Italy - August 31st, 2026 [August 31st, 2026]
- WNBA will become an unstoppable force when it unites, outlasts culture wars - The New York Times - August 27th, 2026 [August 27th, 2026]
- Culture wars take the court. Plus: Ogwumike is peaking. Why is she retiring? - The New York Times - August 27th, 2026 [August 27th, 2026]
- Womens basketball becomes embroiled in the culture wars - The Economist - August 27th, 2026 [August 27th, 2026]
- WNBA: Can the league survive the culture wars? - The Week - August 27th, 2026 [August 27th, 2026]
- Culture Wars Won by the Extremes on Both Sides of an Issue - Red River Farm Network - August 27th, 2026 [August 27th, 2026]
- Why the Right Is Going All-in on Stoking the WNBA Culture Wars - Talking Points Memo - August 27th, 2026 [August 27th, 2026]
- The WNBA Is The Ground Zero For Culture Wars - AM 870 The ANSWER - August 27th, 2026 [August 27th, 2026]
- Will the Culture Wars Kill the WNBA? - The Free Press - August 14th, 2026 [August 14th, 2026]
- How can we talk about this extreme weather now that its a battleground in the culture wars? | Andy Beckett - theguardian.com - August 14th, 2026 [August 14th, 2026]
- Its All Fake and Dishonest Viral Stat Ignites Debate Over Whether Fox News Is Weaponizing WNBA for Culture Wars - Yahoo Sports - August 14th, 2026 [August 14th, 2026]
- Money, teachers and culture wars: Where Orange County School Board Chair candidates diverge - WKMG - August 12th, 2026 [August 12th, 2026]
- The WNBA Cant Escape the Culture Wars - The Ringer - August 12th, 2026 [August 12th, 2026]
- Teachers Stories From the Culture Wars - National Education Association | NEA - August 12th, 2026 [August 12th, 2026]
- AM Show Hr 3 | Politics, Culture Wars & Texas Identity - The Michael Berry Show - iHeart - August 12th, 2026 [August 12th, 2026]
- How Black Pudding Throwing championships became the latest front in culture wars - Brian Monteith - The Scotsman - August 12th, 2026 [August 12th, 2026]
- People are scared their neighbours will call the police on them: how the hosepipe ban got caught up in the culture wars - The Guardian - July 24th, 2026 [July 24th, 2026]
- Opinion: The culture wars come for The Odyssey and miss - The Globe and Mail - July 24th, 2026 [July 24th, 2026]
- The Odyssey Backlash Is Another Ridiculous Example Of The Culture Wars Placing Politics Above Art - Forbes - July 24th, 2026 [July 24th, 2026]
- The Odyssey is a massive hit- but the weekly movie culture wars need to stop - Substack - July 24th, 2026 [July 24th, 2026]
- Six great reads: flight attendant confessions, culture wars and Sam Neills final interview - The Guardian - July 24th, 2026 [July 24th, 2026]
- Murphys Law: The Caitlin Clark culture wars are missing the point - WHO13.com - July 24th, 2026 [July 24th, 2026]
- PM hits out at One Nation and attention-seeking culture wars - The New Daily - July 24th, 2026 [July 24th, 2026]
- What Netflixs Little House On The Prairie remake says about todays culture wars - The Conversation - July 1st, 2026 [July 1st, 2026]
- Monday briefing: Will the heatwave spark action, or further inflame the culture wars? - The Guardian - July 1st, 2026 [July 1st, 2026]
- I will show you fear in a rainbow baseball cap: the rights culture wars come to MLB | Howard Bryant - The Guardian - June 28th, 2026 [June 28th, 2026]
- How Isaac Butlers The Perfect Moment explains the rise of the culture wars - San Francisco Chronicle - June 28th, 2026 [June 28th, 2026]
- Culture wars on the baseball field - Evangelical Focus - June 28th, 2026 [June 28th, 2026]
- The Culture Wars Feel Inescapable. It Wasn't Always This Way. - contrariannews.org - June 28th, 2026 [June 28th, 2026]
- Texas' Bible reading plan is the latest front in America's classroom culture wars - The Times of India - June 28th, 2026 [June 28th, 2026]
- Culture wars dividing the nation - FOX 13 Tampa Bay - June 22nd, 2026 [June 22nd, 2026]
- The UK has the means to avoid climate policy being driven by culture wars - The Conversation - June 16th, 2026 [June 16th, 2026]
- Texas Democratic gubernatorial candidate Hinojosa is making education the priority over culture wars - CBS News - June 16th, 2026 [June 16th, 2026]
- Opinion | Culture wars arent the only problem with two new Smithsonian museums - The Washington Post - June 16th, 2026 [June 16th, 2026]
- Opinion | Trumps culture wars will chase Team USA at the World Cup. Run. - The Washington Post - June 14th, 2026 [June 14th, 2026]
- Pope Leo wades into Spain's culture wars over soccer and the Catalan language in Barcelona - KVUE - June 14th, 2026 [June 14th, 2026]
- Why the Dems need to bring common sense to the culture wars - National Catholic Reporter - June 14th, 2026 [June 14th, 2026]
- Pope Leo XIV wades into Spain's culture wars over soccer and the Catalan language in Barcelona - Idaho Press - June 14th, 2026 [June 14th, 2026]
- Pope Leo wades into Spain's culture wars over soccer and the Catalan language in Barcelona - KSAT - June 14th, 2026 [June 14th, 2026]
- Pope Leo wades into Spain's culture wars over soccer and the Catalan language in Barcelona - Messenger-Inquirer - June 14th, 2026 [June 14th, 2026]
- Pope Leo wades into Spain's culture wars over soccer and the Catalan language in Barcelona - Eagle-Tribune - June 14th, 2026 [June 14th, 2026]
- Pope Leo wades into Spains culture wars over football and the Catalan language - BreakingNews.ie - June 14th, 2026 [June 14th, 2026]
- Pope Leo wades into Spain's culture wars over soccer and the Catalan language in Barcelona - MSN - June 14th, 2026 [June 14th, 2026]
- School board culture wars caused the most upheaval in purple districts, a new study finds - Inquirer.com - June 5th, 2026 [June 5th, 2026]
- Mapplethorpe nudes, the NEA and the birth of Americas culture wars - The Art Newspaper - June 5th, 2026 [June 5th, 2026]
- TV tonight: a major new culture wars drama from the great Russell T Davies - The Guardian - June 5th, 2026 [June 5th, 2026]
- Port: Could the culture wars bite legislative incumbents on their back sides? - InForum - May 27th, 2026 [May 27th, 2026]
- Culture wars vie with GOP economic message at Trump rally in New York - The Washington Post - May 27th, 2026 [May 27th, 2026]
- Op-Ed: Seth Oranburg: End the crypto culture wars with CLARITY - Washington Reporter - May 16th, 2026 [May 16th, 2026]
- Culture wars are hitting the art world in Venice - Modern Ghana - May 16th, 2026 [May 16th, 2026]