The danger of turning ‘brain death’ and organ donation into culture war issues – America: The Jesuit Review
Advances in medicine over the past 50 years represent a shining example of the power of combining humanism and science to save lives and foster love. St. John Paul II celebrated these developments and emphasized the need to use them responsibly when he stated in 2000:
When those limits are followed, medicine can serve its goal of defending and promoting human dignity and, when appropriate, acceptance of the human condition in the face of death (Evangelium vitae, No. 65).
This brings us to the complicated dynamics of declaring death in an increasingly technologically complicated set of clinical circumstances. The Catholic Church, as always, is offering a significant contribution to this ethical conversation, and we believe it is time to offer clarification in light of some well-intended but misguided advice from voices within the church. Such clarification is based on our collective expertise as members of the clergy, clinicians and ethicists because understanding the issues at hand requires a multidisciplinary approach that is both theoretically and practically well-informed.
The authors and signatories of a recently published document called Catholics United on Brain Death and Organ Donation: A Call to Action have condemned the use of neurological criteria for determining that patients have died and the view that it is ethically permissible to recover their vital organs in these circumstances if they or their loved ones have consented to donation. Their statement concludes that Catholics should conscientiously refuse permission for such neurological testing and that Catholic health care practitioners should refuse to use such criteria to declare someone dead. Consequently, they also call upon Catholics to refuse to be organ donors.
First of all, the documents title is a misnomer. Far from promoting unity within the church, it will undoubtedly create disunity, confusion and even scandal among the faithful. For example, there is widespread public confusion regarding the colloquial termbrain death. The use of this term often incorrectly conflates those declared dead using neurological criteria with patients in a persistent vegetative state, like Terri Schiavo, whose death in 2005 followed intense debate both within and outside of the church. Her brother, Bobby Schindler, is one of the statements signatories. The misappropriation of the term brain death, even by medical professionals, leaves many vulnerable to being exploited by fear.
Moreover, although the list of signatories includes several health care professionals, we are aware of Catholic neurologists, critical care and transplant physicians, and ethicists working in Catholic health care who were approached and explicitly chose not to sign the document because they adamantly disagreed with it on medical and bioethical grounds. There is an evident lack of insight in the statement regarding the realities of clinical practice and how determination of death by neurological criteria and organ recovery actually works in hospitals. There is a strong difference between theory and practice.
At the centerpiece of the statement is the concern that the current Uniform Determination of Death Act, the model legislation first crafted in 1981 and thereafter adopted by every U.S. state and territory, is being routinely violated because it requires irreversible loss of all functions of the entire brain. If, as the statement notes, more than half of patients declared dead using neurological criteria have persistent neuroendocrine function via the hypothalamus, then, they argue, the U.D.D.A. criterion is not being met. However, from the beginning this criterion has never been understood to entail that every single part of the brain must have irreversibly ceased functioning for death to be declared. As neurologist James Bernat and others have argued since the early 1980s, specific critical functions of the brain need to remain intact for a human body to be alive.
If we stipulate that every last neuron in the brain must cease firing before we declare someone dead, we would have to abandon even traditional cardiopulmonary means of determining death andawait the onset of putrefaction. This cannot be what St. John Paul II meant when he said, in an address to the International Congress of the Transplantation Society in 2000, complete cessation of brain activity is morally required. He said as much himself in that address when he acknowledged that scientific approaches to ascertaining death had shifted from cardio-respiratory signs to neurological criterion:
This has long been the understanding of the U.D.D.A.s requirement regarding all functions of the entire brain. It was always meant to clarify that both the cerebrum and the brain stem must be dead, and that being in a persistent vegetative state does not constitute death.
Discussions about including the hypothalamus and other parts of the diencephalon in brain death testing were well known at the time of St. John Paul IIs statement in 2000, as well as thelegal clinical mismatch between what the U.D.D.A. requires for death to be declared by neurological criteria and what is done in clinical practice, where testing for hypothalamic function has never been required for determination of death. Why is this the case? It is because the hypothalamus does not play a central role in preserving the human organisms integrative unity. The hypothalamus produces hormones related to reproduction and puberty, and it tells the body to manage its fluid homeostasis, temperature, satiety, sleep and blood pressure. These are vegetative functions but not functions fundamental for life in the way that brain-stem-coordinated circulation of oxygenated blood and respiration are.
Indeed, people can live well without a hypothalamus (e.g., after removal from surgery due to a tumor extraction) with exogenous hormonal replacement. The brains other structures can be irreversibly destroyed (with no potential for recovery) and the hypothalamus can be preserved because of collateral blood flow from blood vessels external to the brain if organ support is maintained via IV fluids and a ventilator to stabilize blood pressure and oxygen levels. This is similar to medical technology that allows aheart to beat in a box outside the body, as in cardiac transplantation. Clearly a heart outside of a body is not a living person, yet the hearts tissue and neural pathways can be stimulated to make the heart beat.
Thus, while it is the case anatomically with hypothalamic function preserved that not all functions of the entire brain have ceased, it is the case functionally that patients determined to be dead by neurological criteriawill never regain consciousness or breathe independently again, irrespective of whether neuroendocrine function is present or not.
If St. John Paul II meant to include the hypothalamus in the above listing for brain death, or similar neuroendocrine structures like the pituitary gland, surely he would have done so. Instead, he went on to say, With regard to the parameters used today for ascertaining deathwhether the encephalic signs or the more traditional cardio-respiratory signsthe Church does not make technical decisions (Address to the 18th International Congress of the Transplantation Society, No. 5). The pope here reflects the wisdom of St. Augustine when he warned, in his Literal Commentary on the Book of Genesis, against Christians speaking about scientific matters outside of their expertise, lest they be laughed at and the faith be scandalized (Book I, Chapter 19, Paragraph 39).
We thus come to the crucial question of the role of the hypothalamus with respect to the integrative unity of a living human body. Does the hypothalamus fulfill a critical function in terms of bodily integration, control or behavior? For the reasons outlined above, it is evident it does not. While undoubtedly playing an important role in the vegetative effects of the brain, there is no evidence that hypothalamic function is either necessary or sufficient for the persistent integrative life of a mature human organism.
In fact, it is not substantively different from the function of other endocrine glands like the adrenal glands that lie above the kidneys, yet no one believes testing for adrenal function is relevant for determining death.
Thus, the authors of the statement Catholics United on Brain Death and Organ Donation: A Call to Action seem to mistake the hypothalamuss location as being more relevant than its function. This is why some other legal jurisdictions, such as the United Kingdom, require only irreversible cessation ofbrainstem function, given its unique and irreplaceable role in preserving and regulating cardiopulmonary function.
It is also worth highlighting, as the statements authors note, that assessing hypothalamic function has not been included as a requirement for determining death going back to the 1995 guidelines from the American Academy of Neurology. So why has attention now been drawn to this small area of the brain? One speculative explanation is the increasingly deep-seated attitudes that inform Americas current culture wars, leading to an overarching hermeneutic of suspicion regarding the A.A.N. criteria and the medical profession in general. The scrupulous fear that giving the gift of oneself through organ donation to extend the lives of others will prematurely cause ones own death ends up fomenting fear, discord and disunity within the church.
The arguments against the use of neurological criteria have yet to prove persuasive to either the medical community or the churchs magisterium after multiple studies in the 1980s and 2000s by thePontifical Academy of Sciences. Thus, while we agree that the current neurological criteria should continue to be critically examined and refined where needed, and that there needs to be legal and moral accountability to ensure the integrity of how death is ascertained, it is inappropriate to reject the clinical use of neurological criteria altogether and sow distrust between Catholics and their health care providers, as well as Catholic hospitals and society as a whole, by calling for conscientious refusal of neurological determination of death and organ donation.
The potential ramifications of such confusion and distrust are manifold, not only with respect to organ donationabout 2 percent of all in-hospital deaths are declared using neurological criteria; only about 20 percent of the patients declared dead using neurological criteria become organ donorsbut more especially regarding family decision-making concerning continued technological intervention to sustain vegetative operations. Rather than accepting the reality that natural death has occurred and maintaining faithful hope in a future resurrection, families may feel compelled to cling to the false hope of their loved ones technologically mediated recovery, as witnessed in the recent case of Jahi McMath.
Promoting such false hope, by making brain death the latest battlefront in the ongoing culture wars, places an undue burden on families at a time of immense grief when they are most in need of clear pastoral guidance and the healing that comes from accepting our mortality while faithfully acknowledging that death is not finalthis is the churchs unified Gospel message.
Jason T. Eberl is the Hubert Mder chair in health care ethics, professor of health care ethics and philosophy, and director of the Albert Gnaegi Center for health care ethics at Saint Louis University. He is the editor of Contemporary Controversies in Catholic Bioethics (Springer, 2017).
Becket Gremmels is system vice president for theology and ethics at CommonSpirit Health.
The Most Rev. Michael F. Olson is the bishop of Fort Worth. He is a member of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops Committee on Doctrine and serves as the chair of that committees Subcommittee on Health Care Issues.
E. Wesley Ely is the founder and co-director of the Critical Illness, Brain Dysfunction, Survivorship Center and the Grant W. Liddle Endowed Chair of Medicine and Critical Care at Vanderbilt University Medical Center and the associate director of aging research at the Tennessee Valley Geriatric Research Education Clinical Center.
The Rev. John J. Raphael is a priest of the Diocese of Nashville, staff chaplain/specialist for Catholic ministry and bedsideethics consultant at Ascension Saint Thomas Hospital West. He is a contributing author to Catholic Health Care Ethics: A Manual for Practitioners (3rd edition, National Catholic Bioethics Center.)
Allen J. Aksamit is professor and consultant in neurology at Mayo Clinic, Rochester, Minn. He has served asthe education division chair in neurology and has subspecialty expertise in neurovirology and neurosarcoidosis. He sits on committees of the American Neurological Association and the American Academy of Neurology.
Laura B. Webster serves as the vice president of ethics in the northwest region of CommonSpirit Health, is an affiliate faculty member at the University of Washington School of Medicine in the Department of Bioethics and Humanities, and is a volunteer community nurse. She worked as a nurse in the neuroICU and the emergency department of a level-one trauma center for over a decade.
The views expressed here are the authors own and do not necessarily represent the policy and practice of their affiliated organizations.
Go here to see the original:
The danger of turning 'brain death' and organ donation into culture war issues - America: The Jesuit Review
- When a Culture War Becomes a Truth War The European Conservative - The European Conservative - May 15th, 2024 [May 15th, 2024]
- The Conservatives have chosen culture wars over climate consensus - The New Statesman - May 15th, 2024 [May 15th, 2024]
- Q&A: Kaya Henderson on Teaching Black History During the Culture Wars - Future-Ed - May 15th, 2024 [May 15th, 2024]
- 431. Nellie Bowles Reporting From the Frontlines of the Culture Wars - Skeptic Magazine - May 15th, 2024 [May 15th, 2024]
- Britons dont like culture wars, but that doesnt mean the woke mob messaging will stop - The Guardian - April 24th, 2024 [April 24th, 2024]
- Editorial: Wentzville superintendent is the latest to exit the culture-war battlefield - St. Louis Post-Dispatch - April 24th, 2024 [April 24th, 2024]
- 'Crazy Plane Lady' Tiffany Gomas Has Begun Weighing in on America's Culture War and We'll Be Better for It - Barstool Sports - April 24th, 2024 [April 24th, 2024]
- I Will Not Be Fighting Culture Wars: UK Shadow Culture Secretary Seeks To Draw Dividing Line Between Labour & ... - imdb - April 24th, 2024 [April 24th, 2024]
- Literature and the New Culture Wars: Triggers, Cancel Culture, and the Teacher's Dilemma - Reformed Journal - April 24th, 2024 [April 24th, 2024]
- I Will Not Be Fighting Culture Wars: UK Shadow Culture Secretary Seeks To Draw Dividing Line Between Labour & Conservatives As She Sets Out Stall... - April 24th, 2024 [April 24th, 2024]
- Review: 'Democracy and Solidarity' by James Davison Hunter - The Gospel Coalition - April 24th, 2024 [April 24th, 2024]
- Library System of Lancaster County board doesn't traffic in culture wars. Partisan appointees should take heed. [editorial] - LNP | LancasterOnline - April 24th, 2024 [April 24th, 2024]
- Sunak accused of making mental illness another front in the culture wars - The Guardian - April 24th, 2024 [April 24th, 2024]
- Drag queen Sasha Velour stars in Season 4 of Max's 'We're Here' - The Washington Post - The Washington Post - April 24th, 2024 [April 24th, 2024]
- Whether you side with Arj Barker or the breastfeeding mum, real life is more nuanced than our tit-for-tat culture wars - ABC News - April 24th, 2024 [April 24th, 2024]
- Land, Livestock and Darfurs 'Culture Wars' - MERIP - April 11th, 2024 [April 11th, 2024]
- Finn McRedmond: Nothing is new under the sun: the solar eclipse became the latest shiny object in the culture wars - The Irish Times - April 11th, 2024 [April 11th, 2024]
- Abbreviated Pundit Roundup: Arizona embraces the culture wars on the losing side - Daily Kos - April 11th, 2024 [April 11th, 2024]
- William Kolbe: Culture wars have a new recruit - Eagle-Tribune - April 11th, 2024 [April 11th, 2024]
- Smartphone addiction, culture wars and low birth rates are all byproducts of the Western world's modern success. - The Australian Financial Review - April 11th, 2024 [April 11th, 2024]
- Georgia Garvey: The ultimate culture clash at the root of rural rage - Northern Virginia Daily - April 11th, 2024 [April 11th, 2024]
- On abortion culture wars, Britain takes a different path - POLITICO Europe - April 9th, 2024 [April 9th, 2024]
- U.S. culture wars reach anime with targeting of translators - Nikkei Asia - April 8th, 2024 [April 8th, 2024]
- Diversity programs vanishing from U.S. campuses amid culture wars - Japan Today - April 8th, 2024 [April 8th, 2024]
- How NYC Schools Became a Battlefront in the Culture Wars - The New York Times - April 8th, 2024 [April 8th, 2024]
- Don't Let Electricity Become the New Front in the Culture Wars - Cato Institute - April 8th, 2024 [April 8th, 2024]
- Culture Wars and an Embattled Utah Monument Sierra Nevada Ally - The Sierra Nevada Ally - April 8th, 2024 [April 8th, 2024]
- Letters: Mel Stride's comments show Tory culture wars have gone too far - The Big Issue - April 8th, 2024 [April 8th, 2024]
- Amid post-Easter culture wars, Jesus still asks, 'But who do you say that I am?' - Fox News - April 8th, 2024 [April 8th, 2024]
- Diversity Programs Slowly Disappear From US Campuses Amid Culture Wars - NDTV - April 8th, 2024 [April 8th, 2024]
- After CEO Bob Iger Claims He's Removed The Company From The Culture War, Disneyland Announced Disneyland ... - That Park Place - April 8th, 2024 [April 8th, 2024]
- Editorial: Defeat of culture-war board candidates hints that a political fever is breaking - St. Louis Post-Dispatch - April 8th, 2024 [April 8th, 2024]
- Culture War Bills Mostly Fizzle on the Georgia Legislature's Last Day in Session - Flagpole - Flagpole Magazine - April 8th, 2024 [April 8th, 2024]
- The Roadblocks to Biden's Electric Vehicles Plan - The New York Times - March 24th, 2024 [March 24th, 2024]
- Culture Wars and the Easter Bunny: One Author Fights Back - FOX News Radio - March 24th, 2024 [March 24th, 2024]
- Fiery debate over TikTok ban puts Americas culture wars in spotlight - South China Morning Post - March 24th, 2024 [March 24th, 2024]
- The Metamodern Shift in the Culture Wars - Quillette - March 24th, 2024 [March 24th, 2024]
- Messenger: Is Francis Howell school board election about teachers or culture wars? - St. Louis Post-Dispatch - March 24th, 2024 [March 24th, 2024]
- DeSantis faces pushback in Florida as voters tire of war on woke - The Washington Post - March 9th, 2024 [March 9th, 2024]
- Default masculine. How the Russian language has become a battleground in the countrys culture wars - . - March 9th, 2024 [March 9th, 2024]
- Local Lightning Rods: Social media, national partisan divisions, culture wars have changed tone and tenor of local ... - Wyoming Tribune - March 9th, 2024 [March 9th, 2024]
- Wright City schools manage to 'stay above the fray' of culture wars - Warren County Record - March 9th, 2024 [March 9th, 2024]
- Hannah Gadsby on culture wars, pot-stirring and Picasso: I created that circus. I dont need to watch it - The Guardian - March 9th, 2024 [March 9th, 2024]
- London Fidgets in the Culture Wars as Buenos Aires Reframes the Game - The New York Sun - March 9th, 2024 [March 9th, 2024]
- Sydney Sweeney's 'SNL' Stint Has Become an Unlikely Focal Point in the Culture Wars - The Mary Sue - March 9th, 2024 [March 9th, 2024]
- Are funerals the new culture war frontier? - The Catholic Weekly - March 9th, 2024 [March 9th, 2024]
- Changing church, culture wars: NCR's top 10 opinion articles of 2023 - National Catholic Reporter - December 30th, 2023 [December 30th, 2023]
- Top 10 stories that shaped 2023: Trumps mug, Vogtles sticker shock and raging culture wars - Georgia Recorder - December 30th, 2023 [December 30th, 2023]
- 2023s Inland Empire weird news: yellow dogs, Dodger tackles, culture wars - Inland Valley Daily Bulletin - December 30th, 2023 [December 30th, 2023]
- Top 10 stories that shaped 2023: Trump's mug, Vogtle's sticker shock and raging culture wars - Henry Herald - December 30th, 2023 [December 30th, 2023]
- Top 10 stories that shaped 2023: Trump's mug, Vogtle's sticker shock and raging culture wars - Rockdale Newton Citizen - December 30th, 2023 [December 30th, 2023]
- Bud Light and Target were hit with culture war backlash in 2023, but there are ways corporate America can navigate the consumer minefield in a pivotal... - December 30th, 2023 [December 30th, 2023]
- Explosive DeSantis-Newsom Debate Reflects Nations Culture Wars - KFF Health News - December 2nd, 2023 [December 2nd, 2023]
- Bob Iger of Disney on Culture Wars and Streaming - The New York Times - December 2nd, 2023 [December 2nd, 2023]
- Outrageous: The History of Comedy, Culture Wars, and Kissing Contestants - The Saturday Evening Post - December 2nd, 2023 [December 2nd, 2023]
- Two New Books Consider Comedy and the Culture Wars - The New York Times - December 2nd, 2023 [December 2nd, 2023]
- Endless Culture Wars: On Kliph Nesteroffs Outrageous - lareviewofbooks - December 2nd, 2023 [December 2nd, 2023]
- Sclerotic America The European Conservative - The European Conservative - December 2nd, 2023 [December 2nd, 2023]
- Ohio Fails to Pass Restrictions on College Teaching About Climate ... - InsideClimate News - December 2nd, 2023 [December 2nd, 2023]
- What Sandra Day O'Connor Could Teach Today's Supreme Court - POLITICO - December 2nd, 2023 [December 2nd, 2023]
- Book Review: 'Outrageous: A History of Showbiz and the Culture Wars' argues history repeats itself - AOL - November 28th, 2023 [November 28th, 2023]
- As the culture wars shift to school book fairs, please protect kids' joy ... - LNP | LancasterOnline - November 28th, 2023 [November 28th, 2023]
- Letter: Let's keep public libraries out of the right-wing culture wars - St. Louis Post-Dispatch - November 28th, 2023 [November 28th, 2023]
- The Red State Brain Drain Isn't Coming. It's Happening Right Now. - The New Republic - November 28th, 2023 [November 28th, 2023]
- Do the right thing, like Tim Scott | Guest Commentary - Santa Maria Times - November 28th, 2023 [November 28th, 2023]
- Ashley Carter: Changing culture through simple acts at home - 1819 News - November 28th, 2023 [November 28th, 2023]
- Sex, Lies, and Science Wars SAPIENS - SAPIENS - November 28th, 2023 [November 28th, 2023]
- Responsible ESG investing in the Global South requires overcoming ... - The Conversation - November 28th, 2023 [November 28th, 2023]
- The lasting legacy of the education culture wars may be a familiar one: school choice - The Boston Globe - November 13th, 2023 [November 13th, 2023]
- When Republicans target K-12 parents in culture wars, they don't know who they're dealing with - Daily Kos - November 13th, 2023 [November 13th, 2023]
- Pennsylvania Voters Rejected the Culture Wars in School Board ... - Mother Jones - November 13th, 2023 [November 13th, 2023]
- The culture war, version 2.0 - Inside Higher Ed - November 13th, 2023 [November 13th, 2023]
- Musk and AI: Less culture wars, more Star Wars - POLITICO - November 13th, 2023 [November 13th, 2023]
- Whats at stake in the culture wars? | Nigel Biggar - The Critic - November 13th, 2023 [November 13th, 2023]
- Kings Speech a culture wars dog whistle - Times Higher Education - November 13th, 2023 [November 13th, 2023]
- Rep. Vining: We can do better, and we should. - WisPolitics.com - November 13th, 2023 [November 13th, 2023]
- The Election Day lessons of Polis, Youngkin and Coffman | HUDSON - coloradopolitics.com - November 13th, 2023 [November 13th, 2023]
- Around Town: siblings reunite, an electricity milestone and a ... - Palo Alto Online - November 13th, 2023 [November 13th, 2023]
- Last year's Kansas elections previewed results this year. Voters ... - Kansas Reflector - November 13th, 2023 [November 13th, 2023]
- Educators Celebrate Reelection of Kentucky Governor Andy ... - National Education Association - November 13th, 2023 [November 13th, 2023]
Tags: