Stuart Kyle Duncan: the Trump-appointed judge working to ban Louisiana abortions – The Guardian
A landmark US supreme court ruling expected before the end of June could shutter most of Louisianas abortion clinics and precipitate clinic closures in more than a dozen other states.
The case, June Medical Services v Russo, is one of the most high-profile supreme court cases of the year, after Donald Trump appointed two justices who tipped the balance of the court to a conservative majority. And it might never have reached the supreme court without the aid of another Trump-appointed judge, Stuart Kyle Duncan.
The Louisiana case centers on law that would force abortion doctors to gain permission to admit and treat patients at nearby hospitals, known as admitting privileges a bureaucratic hurdle that has been shown to shut down a large swath of abortion clinics.
The supreme court ruled an almost identical Texas law unconstitutional in 2016, but Louisiana is arguing that what is unconstitutional in Texas can still be constitutional across the state border.
Duncan fought the Louisiana case while in private practice until the spring of 2018, when he was confirmed as one of Trumps five lifetime appointments to the fifth circuit court of appeals.
This year, several states have sought to severely restrict a womans right to abortion by designating it an elective treatment that is not necessary during the coronavirus pandemic. Though appeals courts largely refused to uphold these bans, Duncan was one of two judges on the fifth circuit court who repeatedly upheld Texass ban in a series of rulings that threw abortion access into weeks of disarray.
In just three years, the Trump administration has stacked federal courts with an army of conservative judges: 143 district court judges, 51 appeals court judges and two supreme court justices. Trumps lasting legacy may be stuffing Americas most important courts with largely white, male, conservative justices who will rule over important social and cultural issues such as reproductive rights, LGBTQ issues and immigration for the next three or four decades.
One-fifth of the federal trial judges now owe their seat to Trump, as do one-fourth of appellate judges. According to the progressive research group Data for Progress, Trumps cohort are also ideologically to the right of previously appointed Republican judges.
With the election looming in November, the Senate majority leader, Mitch McConnell, vowed to push ahead with nomination hearings and leave no vacancy behind.
And nowhere will Trumps impact be felt greater than in the states that lie under the jurisdiction of the nations most conservative appeals courts. The fifth circuit, for example, covers the Republican strongholds of Texas, Louisiana and Mississippi, making it the likely final arbiter on the constitutionality of a slew of conservative laws.
For the overwhelming number of cases, the constitutional rights of the people in Texas, Louisiana and Mississippi will be made by Kyle Duncan and the other ultra-conservatives on the fifth circuit, said Daniel Goldberg, legal director at the progressive judicial non-profit the Alliance for Justice.
Five of the 17 active judges on the fifth circuit are Trump appointees, making an already right-leaning appeals court arguably one of the most, probably the most, conservative in the nation, Goldberg added.
The mantle is significant. While most attention tends to fall on the supreme court, that court hears only about 100 cases in a year. Appeals courts collectively handle in the range of 50,000. The nations 94 district courts are geographically organized into 12 circuits, which hear the bulk of appeals, and from those cases, the US supreme court chooses just a fraction.
It was a fifth circuit panel that ruled to uphold Louisianas admitting privileges law in 2018, despite the fact the Texas law had been struck down two years prior. In early 2019, the full bench of the fifth circuit voted to refuse to rehear the case, forcing the supreme courts hand and setting the stage for this summers looming decision. Since he had represented Louisiana, Duncan abstained from the courts decision.
But Trumps other four appointees were among the nine judges that upheld Louisianas law. One, James Ho, has since made headlines for decrying the the moral tragedy of abortion in an opinion. Others have criticized the Voting Rights Act a civil-rights era law that forced states with histories of violent voter suppression to obtain approval from the justice department over changes to elections, a law that conservatives on the supreme court gutted in 2013.
Duncan is a lawyer with proven culture wars credentials, said Amanda Bursky-Hollis, author of Ideas with Consequences: The Federalist Society and the Conservative Counterrevolution.
The vote to confirm his appointment to the fifth circuit bench split along party lines, 50-47, and his bid was aided by the conservative Judicial Crisis Network an ally of the Federalist Society, a conservative group that has aided Trump by selecting judges for him to nominate. The Judicial Crisis Network spent tens of thousands of dollars on TV ads in Louisiana praising Duncan after Senator John Kennedy expressed skepticism at giving a seat conventionally held for a Louisianian to a Washington lawyer. By the time of Duncans nomination hearing, Kennedy hailed Duncan as staunchly and vociferously pro-life and pro-religious liberty.
Duncan, a married father of five, was born in Baton Rouge in 1972.
Religious liberty is Duncans specialty, going back to his time in the mid-2000s as a professor of law at the University of Mississippi, where his scholarship centered on the separation of church and state. Duncan has argued alongside the religious liberty powerhouse the Alliance Defending Freedom (ADF) and taught at its Blackstone Legal Fellowship, a kind of career boot camp for elite Christian lawyers that the ADF calls a ministry.
Duncan made his name in 2014 at the boutique religious rights firm the Becket Fund for Religious Liberty, when he was the lead counsel on the victorious supreme court contraception case Burwell v Hobby Lobby Stores. That pivotal decision laid the groundwork for corporations to opt out of providing birth control for employees based on religious objections, and it preceded another major contraception case the court heard this spring, one that could further favor the religious and moral objections of employers over the rights of their employees to access healthcare.
Duncan is a devout Catholic. Before his appointment to the fifth circuit, on mornings before he was scheduled to argue before the supreme court, he would recite the rosary to calm himself.
A large part of his career as an appellate court specialist was spent defending Republican state laws popular with the religious right and social conservatives. He fought to keep Louisianas same-sex marriage ban: the matter belongs in the states, would have unforeseen consequences, and LGBTQ rights have nothing (his empasis) to do with civil rights cases, he argued. He defended a North Carolina anti-trans bathroom law and a similar Virginia school board policy. And he argued in favor of a North Carolina voter ID regulation that the fourth circuit found targeted African Americans with almost surgical precision.
Paul Baier, a law professor at LSU who never taught Duncan, supported his nomination despite having argued against him in the same-sex marriage case at the Louisiana supreme court. Duncan is a superb advocate and a very careful, painstaking judge, he said. He described Duncans reasoning in his opinion to uphold Texass coronavirus-related abortion ban as an exemplar of the studious judge judging.
The Federalist Society acts as an alternative to the American Bar Association with a monopoly on Republican nominees, Hollis-Brusky said, strategically placing people like Duncan who cant be dismissed as a crazy Christian or Bible-thumper.
Over the course of his nomination process in 2017, the Democratic senator Dianne Feinstein questioned him about some of the arguments he had made in past controversial cases. Duncan responded by stating that in representing clients I do not advance my personal views, but the interests of my clients.
During his nomination hearing, Duncan presented himself as fair-minded and reasonable. He strove especially to reassure the Democratic Senator Dick Durbin over his record of advancing religious rights above all others.
Where do we draw the line with your right as an individual, asked Durbin, as opposed to my right to assert religious liberty?
Its a balance, its gotta be a balance, Duncan replied.
He referenced the Hobby Lobby case, describing it as a close case because women would be deprived of contraception.
Three years earlier, Duncan had used opposite terms. We find ourselves in the midst of what we see, and what we see correctly, as one of the most flagrant attacks on religious liberty that that weve ever seen in this country, Duncan told a panel in 2014.
And most importantly, from our point of view, its not about striking the appropriate balance, he went on. The first amendment has struck the balance for us, and that balance is in favor of religious liberty.
Few Trump appointees have survived the nomination process without outrage from progressive groups. Duncan is no exception.
The specific judges the Federalist Society supported are selected by the president to implement his agenda of dismantling health care, eliminating civil, women and workers rights and shielding his wealth and actions from public scrutiny, said Nan Aron, the founder of the Alliance for Justice.
Duncan summed up his lifes work in 2014, in an article for the Ivy League Christian Observer. All I really want to do, he said, is what God wants me to do with the talents he gave me.
Originally posted here:
Stuart Kyle Duncan: the Trump-appointed judge working to ban Louisiana abortions - The Guardian
- Britons dont like culture wars, but that doesnt mean the woke mob messaging will stop - The Guardian - April 24th, 2024 [April 24th, 2024]
- Editorial: Wentzville superintendent is the latest to exit the culture-war battlefield - St. Louis Post-Dispatch - April 24th, 2024 [April 24th, 2024]
- 'Crazy Plane Lady' Tiffany Gomas Has Begun Weighing in on America's Culture War and We'll Be Better for It - Barstool Sports - April 24th, 2024 [April 24th, 2024]
- I Will Not Be Fighting Culture Wars: UK Shadow Culture Secretary Seeks To Draw Dividing Line Between Labour & ... - imdb - April 24th, 2024 [April 24th, 2024]
- Literature and the New Culture Wars: Triggers, Cancel Culture, and the Teacher's Dilemma - Reformed Journal - April 24th, 2024 [April 24th, 2024]
- I Will Not Be Fighting Culture Wars: UK Shadow Culture Secretary Seeks To Draw Dividing Line Between Labour & Conservatives As She Sets Out Stall... - April 24th, 2024 [April 24th, 2024]
- Review: 'Democracy and Solidarity' by James Davison Hunter - The Gospel Coalition - April 24th, 2024 [April 24th, 2024]
- Library System of Lancaster County board doesn't traffic in culture wars. Partisan appointees should take heed. [editorial] - LNP | LancasterOnline - April 24th, 2024 [April 24th, 2024]
- Sunak accused of making mental illness another front in the culture wars - The Guardian - April 24th, 2024 [April 24th, 2024]
- Drag queen Sasha Velour stars in Season 4 of Max's 'We're Here' - The Washington Post - The Washington Post - April 24th, 2024 [April 24th, 2024]
- The danger of turning 'brain death' and organ donation into culture war issues - America: The Jesuit Review - April 24th, 2024 [April 24th, 2024]
- Whether you side with Arj Barker or the breastfeeding mum, real life is more nuanced than our tit-for-tat culture wars - ABC News - April 24th, 2024 [April 24th, 2024]
- Land, Livestock and Darfurs 'Culture Wars' - MERIP - April 11th, 2024 [April 11th, 2024]
- Finn McRedmond: Nothing is new under the sun: the solar eclipse became the latest shiny object in the culture wars - The Irish Times - April 11th, 2024 [April 11th, 2024]
- Abbreviated Pundit Roundup: Arizona embraces the culture wars on the losing side - Daily Kos - April 11th, 2024 [April 11th, 2024]
- William Kolbe: Culture wars have a new recruit - Eagle-Tribune - April 11th, 2024 [April 11th, 2024]
- Smartphone addiction, culture wars and low birth rates are all byproducts of the Western world's modern success. - The Australian Financial Review - April 11th, 2024 [April 11th, 2024]
- Georgia Garvey: The ultimate culture clash at the root of rural rage - Northern Virginia Daily - April 11th, 2024 [April 11th, 2024]
- On abortion culture wars, Britain takes a different path - POLITICO Europe - April 9th, 2024 [April 9th, 2024]
- U.S. culture wars reach anime with targeting of translators - Nikkei Asia - April 8th, 2024 [April 8th, 2024]
- Diversity programs vanishing from U.S. campuses amid culture wars - Japan Today - April 8th, 2024 [April 8th, 2024]
- How NYC Schools Became a Battlefront in the Culture Wars - The New York Times - April 8th, 2024 [April 8th, 2024]
- Don't Let Electricity Become the New Front in the Culture Wars - Cato Institute - April 8th, 2024 [April 8th, 2024]
- Culture Wars and an Embattled Utah Monument Sierra Nevada Ally - The Sierra Nevada Ally - April 8th, 2024 [April 8th, 2024]
- Letters: Mel Stride's comments show Tory culture wars have gone too far - The Big Issue - April 8th, 2024 [April 8th, 2024]
- Amid post-Easter culture wars, Jesus still asks, 'But who do you say that I am?' - Fox News - April 8th, 2024 [April 8th, 2024]
- Diversity Programs Slowly Disappear From US Campuses Amid Culture Wars - NDTV - April 8th, 2024 [April 8th, 2024]
- After CEO Bob Iger Claims He's Removed The Company From The Culture War, Disneyland Announced Disneyland ... - That Park Place - April 8th, 2024 [April 8th, 2024]
- Editorial: Defeat of culture-war board candidates hints that a political fever is breaking - St. Louis Post-Dispatch - April 8th, 2024 [April 8th, 2024]
- Culture War Bills Mostly Fizzle on the Georgia Legislature's Last Day in Session - Flagpole - Flagpole Magazine - April 8th, 2024 [April 8th, 2024]
- The Roadblocks to Biden's Electric Vehicles Plan - The New York Times - March 24th, 2024 [March 24th, 2024]
- Culture Wars and the Easter Bunny: One Author Fights Back - FOX News Radio - March 24th, 2024 [March 24th, 2024]
- Fiery debate over TikTok ban puts Americas culture wars in spotlight - South China Morning Post - March 24th, 2024 [March 24th, 2024]
- The Metamodern Shift in the Culture Wars - Quillette - March 24th, 2024 [March 24th, 2024]
- Messenger: Is Francis Howell school board election about teachers or culture wars? - St. Louis Post-Dispatch - March 24th, 2024 [March 24th, 2024]
- DeSantis faces pushback in Florida as voters tire of war on woke - The Washington Post - March 9th, 2024 [March 9th, 2024]
- Default masculine. How the Russian language has become a battleground in the countrys culture wars - . - March 9th, 2024 [March 9th, 2024]
- Local Lightning Rods: Social media, national partisan divisions, culture wars have changed tone and tenor of local ... - Wyoming Tribune - March 9th, 2024 [March 9th, 2024]
- Wright City schools manage to 'stay above the fray' of culture wars - Warren County Record - March 9th, 2024 [March 9th, 2024]
- Hannah Gadsby on culture wars, pot-stirring and Picasso: I created that circus. I dont need to watch it - The Guardian - March 9th, 2024 [March 9th, 2024]
- London Fidgets in the Culture Wars as Buenos Aires Reframes the Game - The New York Sun - March 9th, 2024 [March 9th, 2024]
- Sydney Sweeney's 'SNL' Stint Has Become an Unlikely Focal Point in the Culture Wars - The Mary Sue - March 9th, 2024 [March 9th, 2024]
- Are funerals the new culture war frontier? - The Catholic Weekly - March 9th, 2024 [March 9th, 2024]
- Changing church, culture wars: NCR's top 10 opinion articles of 2023 - National Catholic Reporter - December 30th, 2023 [December 30th, 2023]
- Top 10 stories that shaped 2023: Trumps mug, Vogtles sticker shock and raging culture wars - Georgia Recorder - December 30th, 2023 [December 30th, 2023]
- 2023s Inland Empire weird news: yellow dogs, Dodger tackles, culture wars - Inland Valley Daily Bulletin - December 30th, 2023 [December 30th, 2023]
- Top 10 stories that shaped 2023: Trump's mug, Vogtle's sticker shock and raging culture wars - Henry Herald - December 30th, 2023 [December 30th, 2023]
- Top 10 stories that shaped 2023: Trump's mug, Vogtle's sticker shock and raging culture wars - Rockdale Newton Citizen - December 30th, 2023 [December 30th, 2023]
- Bud Light and Target were hit with culture war backlash in 2023, but there are ways corporate America can navigate the consumer minefield in a pivotal... - December 30th, 2023 [December 30th, 2023]
- Explosive DeSantis-Newsom Debate Reflects Nations Culture Wars - KFF Health News - December 2nd, 2023 [December 2nd, 2023]
- Bob Iger of Disney on Culture Wars and Streaming - The New York Times - December 2nd, 2023 [December 2nd, 2023]
- Outrageous: The History of Comedy, Culture Wars, and Kissing Contestants - The Saturday Evening Post - December 2nd, 2023 [December 2nd, 2023]
- Two New Books Consider Comedy and the Culture Wars - The New York Times - December 2nd, 2023 [December 2nd, 2023]
- Endless Culture Wars: On Kliph Nesteroffs Outrageous - lareviewofbooks - December 2nd, 2023 [December 2nd, 2023]
- Sclerotic America The European Conservative - The European Conservative - December 2nd, 2023 [December 2nd, 2023]
- Ohio Fails to Pass Restrictions on College Teaching About Climate ... - InsideClimate News - December 2nd, 2023 [December 2nd, 2023]
- What Sandra Day O'Connor Could Teach Today's Supreme Court - POLITICO - December 2nd, 2023 [December 2nd, 2023]
- Book Review: 'Outrageous: A History of Showbiz and the Culture Wars' argues history repeats itself - AOL - November 28th, 2023 [November 28th, 2023]
- As the culture wars shift to school book fairs, please protect kids' joy ... - LNP | LancasterOnline - November 28th, 2023 [November 28th, 2023]
- Letter: Let's keep public libraries out of the right-wing culture wars - St. Louis Post-Dispatch - November 28th, 2023 [November 28th, 2023]
- The Red State Brain Drain Isn't Coming. It's Happening Right Now. - The New Republic - November 28th, 2023 [November 28th, 2023]
- Do the right thing, like Tim Scott | Guest Commentary - Santa Maria Times - November 28th, 2023 [November 28th, 2023]
- Ashley Carter: Changing culture through simple acts at home - 1819 News - November 28th, 2023 [November 28th, 2023]
- Sex, Lies, and Science Wars SAPIENS - SAPIENS - November 28th, 2023 [November 28th, 2023]
- Responsible ESG investing in the Global South requires overcoming ... - The Conversation - November 28th, 2023 [November 28th, 2023]
- The lasting legacy of the education culture wars may be a familiar one: school choice - The Boston Globe - November 13th, 2023 [November 13th, 2023]
- When Republicans target K-12 parents in culture wars, they don't know who they're dealing with - Daily Kos - November 13th, 2023 [November 13th, 2023]
- Pennsylvania Voters Rejected the Culture Wars in School Board ... - Mother Jones - November 13th, 2023 [November 13th, 2023]
- The culture war, version 2.0 - Inside Higher Ed - November 13th, 2023 [November 13th, 2023]
- Musk and AI: Less culture wars, more Star Wars - POLITICO - November 13th, 2023 [November 13th, 2023]
- Whats at stake in the culture wars? | Nigel Biggar - The Critic - November 13th, 2023 [November 13th, 2023]
- Kings Speech a culture wars dog whistle - Times Higher Education - November 13th, 2023 [November 13th, 2023]
- Rep. Vining: We can do better, and we should. - WisPolitics.com - November 13th, 2023 [November 13th, 2023]
- The Election Day lessons of Polis, Youngkin and Coffman | HUDSON - coloradopolitics.com - November 13th, 2023 [November 13th, 2023]
- Around Town: siblings reunite, an electricity milestone and a ... - Palo Alto Online - November 13th, 2023 [November 13th, 2023]
- Last year's Kansas elections previewed results this year. Voters ... - Kansas Reflector - November 13th, 2023 [November 13th, 2023]
- Educators Celebrate Reelection of Kentucky Governor Andy ... - National Education Association - November 13th, 2023 [November 13th, 2023]
- The culture war over the Gaza war - The Economist - October 30th, 2023 [October 30th, 2023]
- Education minor, TMPS collaborate for 'Culture Wars in Education ... - Binghamton University Pipe Dream - October 30th, 2023 [October 30th, 2023]
- The War on Disco Explores the Racial Backlash Against the Music - The New York Times - October 30th, 2023 [October 30th, 2023]