Can the synodal process overcome Europe’s East-West divide? – The Pillar
A Mass at Westminster Cathedral in London, England, marking the opening of the synod on synodality on Oct. 16, 2021. Mazur/cbcew.org.uk.
The Vatican on Friday will unveil plans for the second phase of the Churchs discernment process, leading to the 2023 synod on synodality in Rome.
The details will be presented at a press conference by Cardinal Mario Grech, Secretary General of the Synod of Bishops, and Cardinal Jean-Claude Hollerich, general rapporteur of next years gathering of the worlds bishops on the theme For a Synodal Church: Communion, Participation, Mission.
The two-year initiative is entering what the Vatican calls the continental phase. In the first stage - the diocesan phase - organizers were given the task of consulting as many Catholics as possible in a brief period at the tail end of a pandemic.
The second stage will present a different challenge: identifying concerns that are shared by Catholics living in vastly different national settings.
Synod organizers on the seven inhabited continents - North America, Latin America, Europe, Africa, the Middle East, Asia, and Oceania - may struggle to pick out themes that unite Catholics separated by borders, cultures, and vast distances.
In Europe, some observers believe that Church leaders overseeing the continental phase will find it hard to reconcile the contrasting priorities of Catholics living in the East and West of the continent.
How difficult will it be? The Pillar takes a look.
Share
Most people accept that Europes 44 countries can be divided into two broad categories: East and West.
That division is rooted in recent political history as much as it is in geography. Eastern countries are generally defined as those that belonged to the Communist Bloc. So someone living in Prague, capital of the former Czechoslovakia, might be called Eastern European, even though they live further west than a Western European resident of the Austrian capital Vienna.
The division of Europe into East and West is crude, but it is also useful because it highlights important differences between countries that experienced decades of communism and those where capitalism has held sway.
European Catholic communities that suffered under communism have evolved in different ways to those that passed through the 20th century without long-lasting state-sponsored persecution.
The divide between Catholics in Eastern and Western Europe can arguably be seen in responses to the German synodal way. The controversial initiative is expected to close next year with a call for radical changes to Church teaching, practice, and structures.
The Bosnian Cardinal Vinko Pulji said last year that the synodal ways proposals were alien to Catholics who had survived communism.
A Church that has weathered the challenge of communism does not have such exotic ideas. Indeed, such attitudes offend and astonish our believers, he commented. We cannot understand a Church in which sacrifice is a foreign word and there is a Jesus without a cross.
In former communist Poland, the bishops conference president issued a strongly worded 3,000-word critique of the synodal ways trajectory.
Let us avoid the repetition of worn-out slogans, and standard demands such as the abolition of celibacy, the priesthood of women, Communion for the divorced, and the blessing of same-sex unions, Archbishop Stanisaw Gdecki wrote in February.
The Nordic bishops - representing Sweden, Denmark, Norway, Finland, and Iceland - have also voiced concern about the German process. But Church leaders in more populous Western European countries, such as the U.K., France, Italy, and Spain, have not made comparable official statements.
The Vatican asked the worlds bishops conferences to submit a document summarizing local synod discussions by Aug. 15. Several national episcopal conferences have missed that deadline.
Many Western European bishops conferences filed their submissions in time, including those in Belgium, England and Wales, France, Germany, Ireland, Italy, Scotland, and Switzerland. But several of Eastern European countries seem to have either overshot the deadline or submitted their reports to Rome without publicity.
At the time of writing, at least two former communist territories have published national synod syntheses - the Czech Republic and Lithuania - while many Polish dioceses have also issued reports.
Although there is a limited amount of material with which to make comparisons, the available texts do have a different feel to those of Western European countries.
Lithuanias national synthesis, for example, begins with a reflection on faith. While considering the various details of our Church life, we often forget the main condition - the need to constantly nurture our communio, our relationship with the Lord Jesus Christ, it says.
It voices concern about a lack of true community in the Church and calls for priests to make greater efforts to work with lay people, while sympathizing with the clergys struggles with loneliness and high expectations.
It concludes by identifying five priorities: to foster relations between clergy and laity; to build an open and responsible community; to help people to grow and develop in the Church; to not alienate people; and to be fully committed to being a synodal Church.
Compare this with the Irish Churchs synthesis, which begins by describing the impact of clerical abuse. It then sets out the case for co-responsible leadership, saying: Many people feel that decision-making and authority are exercised solely by priests and bishops. This power structure provokes discontent in them, frustration and anger with the processes of decision-making and exercise of authority at all levels in the Church.
The Irish report notes that there were calls from both young and older participants for optional celibacy, married priests, female priests, and the return of those who had left the priesthood to marry.
It also emphasizes that there was a clear, overwhelming call for the full inclusion of LGBTQI+ people in the Church.
Its tempting to conclude from this brief comparison that Eastern European submissions are concerned with matters of faith and community, while Western European ones are focused more on power structures and sexuality. But we would need to compare more documents to be able to assert this confidently.
Besides, concerns about the treatment of LGBT+ Catholics are not absent from diocesan stage reports in ex-communist countries.
The Polish Archdiocese of Pozna noted in its synthesis that according to a significant group of synod participants, the Churchs attitude toward LGBT+ people is inadequate: There is a lack of love of neighbor.
It observed that young people expressed their pain at the tough and sometimes even aggressive language of some clergy and laity toward LGBT+ people, although a very small group of participants expressed hope for a change in Church teaching.
It concluded: The majority of synod participants who spoke out made it clear that a change in language and attitudes toward these people is needed: We expect them to be treated with respect, compassion, and gentleness, just as the Catechism speaks of.
Leave a comment
Europes diocesan synod reports suggest that its helpful to make other distinctions, too beyond East and West.
There is also arguably a division between Catholics in northern and southern Europe. The German national synthesis report, for instance, has strikingly different concerns than that of Italy.
The German report concludes with this quotation:
If they wish to restore trust in the Church, the bishops need to take up a clear position on the pressing issues of our time, such as equal access for all baptized people to church offices, a reassessment of sexual morality, and a non-discriminatory approach to homosexual and queer people.
Taking up a clear position also means speaking a language that people can understand and that does not hide behind convoluted wording. As regards the abuse scandals, there needs to be an unambiguous acceptance of responsibility; power needs to be taken under control, and an attempt made to make amends to the victims of sexual and spiritual abuse.
The Italian report, meanwhile, makes only a glancing reference to LGBT+ people with their parents in a list of groups that are seeking greater inclusion in the Church.
It says that the local Church is too priest-centric and calls for a greater sharing of responsibilities between clergy and lay people. But it also notes that laity are not exempt from the risk of developing forms of clericalism in the management of the small spaces of power entrusted to them.
Moving beyond broad geographical distinctions, there are also cultural and linguistic divisions in the European Church.
The Swiss bishops conference noted in May that there were glaring differences within the Church in Switzerland itself. It contrasted the concerns of the countrys French and Italian speakers (sometimes called Latins) with those of German speakers.
In the reflection on the quality of synodical work, the spiritual concerns of Latin Switzerland, focused more on attitude, were supplemented with the observations and advice of German-speaking Switzerland, which are more structure-oriented, it said.
So we could compare the reports of Latin and Germanic countries, highlighting the spiritual concerns of the former and the latters emphasis on structural changes.
This might be a useful way of exploring the divisions within the European Church, but it also has its limitations. The national synthesis documents of France and Germany actually overlap at many points. Both are centered on the abuse crisis, governance issues, married priests, the role of women, divorce and remarriage, and homosexuality.
The various synod reports could also be sorted into those of core and periphery countries, with rich nations like France, Germany, and Austria on one side and poor ones such as Albania, Belarus, and Bosnia-Herzegovina on the other.
There are countless other ways to frame the divisions between European Catholics - which is not surprising when you consider that the continent has around 750 million inhabitants, about 200 languages, and some 160 distinct cultural groups.
This analysis is pretty good, dont you think? Dont forget to share it.
Share
Fortunately, the participants in Europes continental phase will not be asked to draw common themes out of the national synthesis documents.
They will focus instead on the first edition of the synod on synodalitys instrumentum laboris, or working document, which will be produced by the General Secretariat of the Synod of Bishops and based on all the whole worlds national synthesis documents.
According to the Vaticans official handbook, each continent will produce a final document, inspired by the first instrumentum laboris, which will be used to draft a second working document for use at the bishops assembly in October 2023.
But as Europes Church leaders draft the final text, contrasting priorities will inevitably emerge. Will the document be able to reflect the desires of Western European Catholics without downplaying those of Eastern Europeans? Will it have a Latin or Germanic flavor? Will it lean towards the concerns of the core or the periphery?
According to the synod handbook, the group responsible for the continent-wide meeting will be the Council of European Bishops Conferences (CCEE). Thats a good sign because the CCEE is a truly representative organization. It has 39 members, including not only national bishops conferences but also lesser-known bodies such as the Eparchy of Mukachevo (in western Ukraine) and the Diocese of Chiinu (based in Moldova).
The CCEEs president is the (U.S.-born) Lithuanian Archbishop Gintaras Gruas. Its vice presidents are the Serbian Bishop Ladislav Nemet and Luxembourgs Cardinal Hollerich, who is also a pivotal figure in the synod on synodalitys third and final stage. So the CCEEs leadership has a good balance between different geographical regions.
Will the continental phase result in a final document that equally delights French traditionalists, German synodal way participants, and Ukrainian Catholics living in bomb shelters?
That is probably impossible.
But it will be worth watching how the documents drafters navigate the many fault lines of European Catholicism, and what viewpoints on the continent take centerstage.
The rest is here:
Can the synodal process overcome Europe's East-West divide? - The Pillar
- I spent years studying American communism. Heres what I learned - The Guardian - May 18th, 2024 [May 18th, 2024]
- Communism alive and well at Oakville's town hall - Toronto Sun - May 18th, 2024 [May 18th, 2024]
- The Southern Truth About Communism - Black Agenda Report - May 18th, 2024 [May 18th, 2024]
- Swiss rediscover communist zeal after 84-year hiatus - SWI swissinfo.ch - SWI swissinfo.ch in English - May 18th, 2024 [May 18th, 2024]
- Revolutionary Communists take on Tory warmongers - The Communist - May 18th, 2024 [May 18th, 2024]
- Communist Party of Ireland: On the 50th anniversary of the 1974 Dublin-Monaghan terrorist attack - In Defense of Communism - May 18th, 2024 [May 18th, 2024]
- Hung Cao: We Must Stop Communism From Taking Over America - One America News Network - May 18th, 2024 [May 18th, 2024]
- Florida Governor DeSantis signs new law mandating teaching the evils of communism to children as young as five - WSWS - May 1st, 2024 [May 1st, 2024]
- Trump, Biden, communism and more: Letters to the Editor, April 28, 2024 - Florida Today - May 1st, 2024 [May 1st, 2024]
- Communists to run in Karl Marx hometown's election - In Defense of Communism - May 1st, 2024 [May 1st, 2024]
- Slow Down. How Degrowth Communism Can Save the Earth book review - Counterfire - May 1st, 2024 [May 1st, 2024]
- Ron DeSantis wants to teach young people about communism. He should use rock n roll - Washington Examiner - May 1st, 2024 [May 1st, 2024]
- A Survivor of the Cultural Revolution Reviews New Book, 'The Devil and Communist China' - The Stream - May 1st, 2024 [May 1st, 2024]
- European Communist Action: Long live the 1st of May Long live socialism! - In Defense of Communism - May 1st, 2024 [May 1st, 2024]
- Florida children to learn that communism is evil, slavery a skills training program - The South Florida Times - May 1st, 2024 [May 1st, 2024]
- 'Unbridled Agenda of Communism or Socialism, Not in the Constitution Today': SC - ETV Bharat - May 1st, 2024 [May 1st, 2024]
- Pol Pot's Atrocities Still Matter, 45 Years After Khmer Rouge's Fall - Reason - January 12th, 2024 [January 12th, 2024]
- Taiwan election: victory in the face of Chinese communism as country gears up for 'fair election' - GB News - January 12th, 2024 [January 12th, 2024]
- Lenin lives! Join the communists to celebrate his life and ideas! - Socialist Appeal - January 12th, 2024 [January 12th, 2024]
- Goodbye Socialist Appeal The Communist is coming! - Socialist Appeal - January 12th, 2024 [January 12th, 2024]
- Xi Jinpings once-unquestioned authority is showing cracks - The Hill - January 12th, 2024 [January 12th, 2024]
- UK told to 'wake up' to Poland crisis with Donald Tusk 'turning back clock to communism' - Express - January 12th, 2024 [January 12th, 2024]
- The Reality of CommunismWhat Is Social Democracy and Why Is It a Capitalist Dictatorship? - revcom.us - January 12th, 2024 [January 12th, 2024]
- Why Did the Berlin Wall Fall? - The Imaginative Conservative - November 13th, 2023 [November 13th, 2023]
- 1947 and now - The Interpreter - November 13th, 2023 [November 13th, 2023]
- Albania's deal with Italy on migrants has been welcomed by many ... - Las Vegas Sun - November 13th, 2023 [November 13th, 2023]
- Grothman's Bipartisan Hmong New Year Resolution | U.S. ... - Glenn Grothman - November 13th, 2023 [November 13th, 2023]
- Another View: DeSantis was strong, Haley was sharp, Ramaswamy ... - Press Herald - November 13th, 2023 [November 13th, 2023]
- Communism in Britain: The unbroken thread - Socialist Appeal - November 11th, 2023 [November 11th, 2023]
- November 7 as Victims of Communism Day - 2023 - Reason - November 11th, 2023 [November 11th, 2023]
- The Fall of the Berlin Wall and the Fate of the West - Breakpoint - BreakPoint.org - November 11th, 2023 [November 11th, 2023]
- Cruzs new book Unwoke shows readers how to defeat cultural ... - 1330 WFIN - November 11th, 2023 [November 11th, 2023]
- The aftermath of the Velvet Revolution was justice delivered? - Radio Prague International - November 11th, 2023 [November 11th, 2023]
- Remember, Remember, the 9th of November - The Imaginative Conservative - November 11th, 2023 [November 11th, 2023]
- Country Road Chronicles: Communist camp in Westerly in the '30s - The Westerly Sun - November 11th, 2023 [November 11th, 2023]
- The Russian Revolution: The greatest event in history - Socialist Appeal - November 11th, 2023 [November 11th, 2023]
- What Happened to the ACLU by Helen Andrews | Articles - First Things - November 11th, 2023 [November 11th, 2023]
- Open Forum: Thinking of Donald Trump after Tuesday's election - The Winchester Star - November 11th, 2023 [November 11th, 2023]
- Was the USSR Socialist?: an Interview with Alexander Nogovishchev - Lefteast - November 11th, 2023 [November 11th, 2023]
- Remembrance Day: the 11th hour of the 11th day of the 11th month - Fairfaxtimes.com - November 11th, 2023 [November 11th, 2023]
- New York Man Sentenced on Felony Assault Charge for Actions ... - Department of Justice - November 11th, 2023 [November 11th, 2023]
- U.S. Rep. Grothman: Bipartisan Hmong New Year resolution - WisPolitics.com - November 11th, 2023 [November 11th, 2023]
- 'Nazigate' Has Been Quickly Forgotten, But Scholars Warn Its ... - The Maple - November 11th, 2023 [November 11th, 2023]
- Defining the US-China cold war - - November 11th, 2023 [November 11th, 2023]
- Green Township voters remove 5 officials who support Gotion ... - FOX 17 West Michigan News - November 11th, 2023 [November 11th, 2023]
- Louisiana's 'In God We Trust' law tests limits of religion in public ... - American Press - November 11th, 2023 [November 11th, 2023]
- Czechast with Irena Kalhousov, Director of the Herzl Center for ... - Radio Prague International - November 11th, 2023 [November 11th, 2023]
- Letter to the editor: We mustn't forget communism's many victims - Bozeman Daily Chronicle - October 19th, 2023 [October 19th, 2023]
- Writing triumphed over 'hell of communism', says Albania's Kadare - Yahoo News - October 19th, 2023 [October 19th, 2023]
- Opinion Showing anti-communism the red card - Morning Star Online - October 19th, 2023 [October 19th, 2023]
- Letter to the Editor: The Minnesota Daily is against communists ... - Minnesota Daily - October 19th, 2023 [October 19th, 2023]
- Long before the Kentucky legislature waged war on 'woke,' it ... - The Hastings Tribune - October 19th, 2023 [October 19th, 2023]
- All the traditions lost after the Communists entered Beijing The China Project - The China Project - September 9th, 2023 [September 9th, 2023]
- Communism, the youth, and the fight for revolution - Socialist Appeal - September 9th, 2023 [September 9th, 2023]
- Salazar, 27 GOP cosponsors offer bill to educate students about ... - Ripon Advance - September 9th, 2023 [September 9th, 2023]
- Head of Zeus seizes history of communism by broadcaster and ... - The Bookseller - September 9th, 2023 [September 9th, 2023]
- Death threats, communism claims swirl around EV battery project - Automotive News - September 9th, 2023 [September 9th, 2023]
- The New Useful Idiots - Shield of the Republic - The Bulwark - September 9th, 2023 [September 9th, 2023]
- Rift in Samastha over stand towards CPM - Times of India - September 9th, 2023 [September 9th, 2023]
- South Korean president's anti-communist taunts are opening up ... - The Conversation - September 9th, 2023 [September 9th, 2023]
- Argentine priests celebrate reparation Mass after presidential ... - America: The Jesuit Review - September 9th, 2023 [September 9th, 2023]
- Oppenheimer: communism, McCarthyism, and the bomb | United ... - In Defence of Marxism - August 12th, 2023 [August 12th, 2023]
- When teachers have more say than parents, communism has arrived - Hernando Sun - August 12th, 2023 [August 12th, 2023]
- 130 years of Mayakovsky: Art, communism, and revolution - Socialist Appeal - July 20th, 2023 [July 20th, 2023]
- Captive Nations Week Marked for First Time in Ukraine - Jamestown - The Jamestown Foundation - July 20th, 2023 [July 20th, 2023]
- What Was the Marshall Plan? - The Collector - July 20th, 2023 [July 20th, 2023]
- Politics of the Rift: On Thorie Communiste - Notes - E-Flux - July 20th, 2023 [July 20th, 2023]
- The return of EU enlargement | The Strategist - The Strategist - July 20th, 2023 [July 20th, 2023]
- Putin's holy war on Ukraine - UnHerd - July 20th, 2023 [July 20th, 2023]
- The zing zazz factor in a slogan - RNZ - July 20th, 2023 [July 20th, 2023]
- Family who carried Sacred Heart statue were carried by Sacred ... - Catholic Diocese of Lincoln - July 20th, 2023 [July 20th, 2023]
- Risk and Revolution | Wen Stephenson - The Baffler - July 20th, 2023 [July 20th, 2023]
- Victims of Communism, Victims of Modernism - Heritage.org - June 7th, 2023 [June 7th, 2023]
- Communism: FIU event discusses Soviet influence in Cuba and the ... - PantherNOW - May 29th, 2023 [May 29th, 2023]
- Nuclear communism: Lukashenka offers 'nukes for everyone' - TVP World - May 29th, 2023 [May 29th, 2023]
- Georgi Gospodinov and Angela Rodel win International Booker ... - NPR - May 29th, 2023 [May 29th, 2023]
- The China Dragon Roars Back Whether the US Likes It or Not - KCRW - May 29th, 2023 [May 29th, 2023]
- EU, US might not be best digital ID models, but they can help African ... - Biometric Update - May 29th, 2023 [May 29th, 2023]
- Opinion: Young Canadians should learn about the Polish ... - The Hub - May 29th, 2023 [May 29th, 2023]
- Gig Line: Memorial Day - The Coastland Times | The Coastland Times - The Coastland Times - May 29th, 2023 [May 29th, 2023]