Let The Government Censor Away Through Agents It Controls, Say Kwame Raoul And Cabal Of A.G.s To U.S. … – Wirepoints
By: Mark Glennon*
This shouldnt be hard to understand: If you think government should have the power to censor what it says is false, then you dont believe in the bedrock of a democratic republic: free speech.
But a group of progressive state attorneys general apparently think government should have that power because thats exactly what they recently asked the U.S Supreme Court to make the law of the land.
Its in an amicus brief signed by 23 state attorneys general in what will be a historic case now pending before the Supreme Court on whether the government can bypass the First Amendment using private sector tech platforms as its agents to censor what the government doesnt like. Illinois Attorney General Kwame Raoul is among the signers.
The case is Murthy v. Missouri, formerly called Biden v. Missouri.
The Supreme Court has rarely been faced with a coordinated campaign of this magnitude orchestrated by federal officials that jeopardized a fundamental aspect of American life, wrote the federal appellate court in its ruling against the government.
In a fitting and splendid gift to America last Independence Day, a federal trial judge issued a 154-page ruling on the case laying out the facts against the government in detail. The evidence of tech manipulation directed by the government was so strong and the matter so important that the judge issued a temporary, sweeping order barring the Biden Administration and the rest of the federal government from most all contact with social media platforms.
The federal appellate court upheld the ruling though it changed the wording of the order.
Now comes the Supreme Court, which will hear the case this spring.
And enter the group of state A.G.s
The government will lose. The lawsuit will not be vacated. The only real issue is on what terms they will lose, which is what the A.G.s should have addressed. The evidence is simply too overwhelming to deny. The Biden Administration, including the FBI and the Centers for Disease Control, strongarmed social media platforms to squelch unfavorable stories and elevate its narrative of the news about the Hunter Biden laptop scandals, Covid, President Biden, election integrity and more. Its all laid out in the trial courts ruling. Thousands of pages of evidence showing it are summarized therein. Read the trial courts memorandum yourself.
In a ruling of such importance and with such broad consequences, however, theres reasonable disagreement over exactly how to write out what the government must not be allowed to censor.
But the A.G.s brief doesnt do that, asking the Supreme Court to throw the case out entirely: Vacate the lower courts ruling entirely, the brief expressly requests.
Censor away, in other words.
To be specific, this is about stopping the government from skirting its First Amendment obligations by outsourcing censorship to private parties not bound by the First Amendment, like tech platforms, that can censor what they choose if acting on their own.
Government often publishes guidelines and information on foreign travel warnings, cybersecurity threats, scam artists, public health and the like. No problem. But free speech is denied when the government imposes its messaging on private news platforms to suppress competing viewpoints. Those efforts usually travel under the label of combating misinformation, hate speech or the like.
The line can be difficult to draw. When does the government wrongly coerce and encourage censorship by tech platforms?
Suppose the FBI suggests you censor something. Maybe it would be like saying this, as one of the appellate judges put it perfectly during oral arguments: Thats a really nice social media platform you got there it would be a shame if something happened to it.
The appellate court drew the line between harmless government guidance and unconstitutional strongarming by issuing an order saying this:
The appellate court Defendants, and their employees and agents, shall take no actions, formal or informal, directly or indirectly, to coerce or significantly encourage social-media companies to remove, delete, suppress, or reduce, including through altering their algorithms, posted social-media content containing protected free speech. That includes, but is not limited to, compelling the platforms to act, such as by intimating that some form of punishment will follow a failure to comply with any request, or supervising, directing, or otherwise meaningfully controlling the social-media companies decision-making processes.
It reached that conclusion based after a long analysis in its opinion of court precedent, logic and practicality. That temporary order was put on hold by the Supreme Court pending its review, but its all but certain to be made permanent in some fashion, the appellate court concluded, and thats surely true subject only to whatever adjustments the Supreme Court sees fit.
How does the A.G.s brief justify throwing out the case entirely, disregarding rafts of evidence and precedent?
It doesnt.
It resorts to red herrings, first with a big list of ways government publishes routine guidance that should be permissible on matters that nobody has a problem with.
When it comes to whats at issue actually censoring what the government doesnt like Raouls brief claims the appellate court ruled that the mere existence of government amounts to coercion, and that it relied on a vague entanglement standard about government involvement with tech companies.
Those, too, are red herrings. Those factors had little role in the appellate courts ruling. Insofar as they were part of the analysis and should be downplayed, fine, tweak the ruling to fix that. The A.G.s might plausibly have argued for the Supreme Court to do that.
Instead, they asked the Supreme Court to throw out the whole lawsuit.
That result would gut free speech and lobotomize democracy.
For a more scholarly summary of the First Amendment infractions in Raouls brief, see the recent column here by my brother, Mike, a law professor. Better yet, read his new book on the full subject of the modern assault on free speech: Free Speech and Turbulent Freedom: The Dangerous Allure of Censorship in the Digital Era.
Illinois is among the worst offenders in that modern allure of censorship. Its long train of abuse and usurpations is often flagrant, listed in the columns linked below. Making that assault on free speech more terrifying is the abandonment by most media of its traditional role defending free speech. You will find little if anything in Illinois legacy media on the matters in that list.
Above all, know this: Your rights include the right to hear. The right to hear what the government doesnt want you to hear is a corollary of your First Amendment right to free speech, as the courts long ago ruled. Its that right to hear that is being stolen from you, and that right is directly at issue in Murthy v. Missouri.
That right was not given to you by anybody in any level of government. Give it up and youve given up your democratic republic.
*Mark Glennon is founder of Wirepoints.
The column was updated to show the number of attorneys general signing the brief as 23.
Illinois recent, long train of free speech abuses:
Continue reading here:
Let The Government Censor Away Through Agents It Controls, Say Kwame Raoul And Cabal Of A.G.s To U.S. ... - Wirepoints
- Lets say it plainly: Fact-checking is not censorship - Poynter - April 4th, 2024 [April 4th, 2024]
- Little Cash, Lots of Censorship: Bothayna Al-Essa on Opening a Bookstore in Kuwait - Literary Hub - April 4th, 2024 [April 4th, 2024]
- The danger of liberal censorship | Opinion - The Philadelphia Inquirer - April 4th, 2024 [April 4th, 2024]
- The Democrats are hell-bent on alienating women - The Telegraph - April 4th, 2024 [April 4th, 2024]
- Al Jazeera to be banned soon in Israel in unprecedented censorship after months of persecution - Reporters sans frontires - April 4th, 2024 [April 4th, 2024]
- The Courage to Produce: A Conversation on High School Censorship - American Theatre - April 4th, 2024 [April 4th, 2024]
- Netanyahu's regime is built on censorship Israeli culture is being smothered by silence - UnHerd - April 4th, 2024 [April 4th, 2024]
- Opinion | Lets say it plainly: Fact-checking is not censorship - Editor And Publisher Magazine - April 4th, 2024 [April 4th, 2024]
- U.S. Supreme Court Does Not Go Far Enough in Determining When Government Officials Are Barred from Censoring ... - EFF - April 4th, 2024 [April 4th, 2024]
- Brazils dictatorship: Repression, torture, slaughter of Indigenous people and censorship - EL PAS USA - April 4th, 2024 [April 4th, 2024]
- When Fighting Disinformation Becomes Censorship, New WSJ Swing State Polls, Wisconsin's "Zuckerbucks ... - RealClearPolitics - April 4th, 2024 [April 4th, 2024]
- Bipartisan push to ban TikTok is a dangerous move toward censorship - The Ticker - April 4th, 2024 [April 4th, 2024]
- New Hate Crime Hotline Proves Illegal Censorship Is HERE | Guest: Sheriff Bill Waybourn | 4/3/24 - The Glenn Beck ... - iHeartRadio - April 4th, 2024 [April 4th, 2024]
- Censorship | Rod Kersh | The Blogs - The Times of Israel - April 4th, 2024 [April 4th, 2024]
- South Korean censorship obscures vital information - East Asia Forum - April 4th, 2024 [April 4th, 2024]
- Call it by it's name: Censorship - The Ely Times - April 4th, 2024 [April 4th, 2024]
- Nebraska Obscenity Bill to Criminalize Librarians Fails to Advance | Censorship News - News Letter Journal - April 4th, 2024 [April 4th, 2024]
- Group seeks to fight book censorship as Huntington Beach parent advisory board returns for final vote - Los Angeles Times - April 4th, 2024 [April 4th, 2024]
- Colleges Use His Antisemitism Definition to Censor. He Calls It a 'Travesty.' - The Chronicle of Higher Education - March 28th, 2024 [March 28th, 2024]
- Knesset legal adviser pans attempt to remove judicial oversight on foreign media censorship bill as 'constitutionally ... - The Times of Israel - March 28th, 2024 [March 28th, 2024]
- Misinformation 'experts' are paving the way for more censorship - UnHerd - March 28th, 2024 [March 28th, 2024]
- Meta Refuses To Provide Details On Its Gaza War Censorship - Report - I24NEWS - i24NEWS - March 28th, 2024 [March 28th, 2024]
- Nebraska Obscenity Bill to Criminalize Librarians Fails to Advance | Censorship News - School Library Journal - March 28th, 2024 [March 28th, 2024]
- EU mulls removal of Iranian firm linked to internet blackout from censorship list - Arab News - March 28th, 2024 [March 28th, 2024]
- Supreme Court must rely on the First Amendment, not its own precedent, when deciding government censorship case - Washington Examiner - March 28th, 2024 [March 28th, 2024]
- Exclusive: Iran's Censoring Tech Firm To Be Removed From EU Sanctions - - March 28th, 2024 [March 28th, 2024]
- How the Left Censors Dissent, From NBC to the Dane County Board [Up Against the Wall] - Wisconsin Right Now - March 28th, 2024 [March 28th, 2024]
- UK comedian Photoshops poster to hilariously sidestep censors - Creative Bloq - March 28th, 2024 [March 28th, 2024]
- Censorship is only getting worse in the US - Daily Trojan Online - March 28th, 2024 [March 28th, 2024]
- TikTok ban forgets the lessons of the Pentagon Papers - Columbia Journalism Review - March 28th, 2024 [March 28th, 2024]
- Instagram Creators: Check If Your Posts Are Political The Markup - The Markup - March 28th, 2024 [March 28th, 2024]
- Is Fighting Misinformation Censorship? The Supreme Court Will Decide. - The Journal. - WSJ Podcasts - The Wall Street Journal - March 28th, 2024 [March 28th, 2024]
- Microsoft faces bipartisan criticism for alleged censorship on Bing in China - The Register - March 28th, 2024 [March 28th, 2024]
- Meta oversight board finds censoring of word 'shaheed' discriminatory - Middle East Eye - March 28th, 2024 [March 28th, 2024]
- AAUW speaker warns of rise in book censorship, 'similar to a pandemic' - Los Altos Town Crier - March 28th, 2024 [March 28th, 2024]
- NSF paid universities to develop AI censorship tools for social media, House report alleges - The College Fix - March 28th, 2024 [March 28th, 2024]
- Cancel cultures: theatre censorship around the world - The Stage - March 28th, 2024 [March 28th, 2024]
- Bill Maher rips govt for censoring 'dissenting opinions' about COVID-19 pandemic that were the 'right ones' - Fox News - March 28th, 2024 [March 28th, 2024]
- EFF Opposes California Initiative That Would Cause Mass Censorship - EFF - February 25th, 2024 [February 25th, 2024]
- X disagrees with Centres censorship orders, calls for greater transparency - The Indian Express - February 25th, 2024 [February 25th, 2024]
- Quote of the Day: Fifteen Months Later, Despite 50 Alterations and Deletions, Censors Have Yet to Approve This Film. - China Digital Times - February 25th, 2024 [February 25th, 2024]
- Social Media Users say their Palestine Content is being Shadow-Banned -- How to Know if it's Happening to You - Informed Comment - February 25th, 2024 [February 25th, 2024]
- Censorship for minors is not the solution | Opinion - PantherNOW - February 25th, 2024 [February 25th, 2024]
- China could be doing better at censorship, think tank finds - The Register - February 25th, 2024 [February 25th, 2024]
- The blatant censorship of the 2023 Hugo Awards - Observer Online - February 25th, 2024 [February 25th, 2024]
- The Library of Translations: An exploration of censorship and desensitization in We Had To Remove This Post - The Student Life - February 25th, 2024 [February 25th, 2024]
- Zimbabwe Army Accused of Forcing Investigative Outlet to Self-Censor - Voice of America - VOA News - February 25th, 2024 [February 25th, 2024]
- U.S. urged to do more to counter China's growing censorship system - Washington Times - February 25th, 2024 [February 25th, 2024]
- Libraries, Beacons of Freedom, Now Face the Dangers of Censorship - Flagpole - Flagpole Magazine - February 25th, 2024 [February 25th, 2024]
- An Argument for Free Speech, the Lifeblood of Democracy - Tufts Now - February 25th, 2024 [February 25th, 2024]
- Librarians could be criminally charged over 'obscene' books in West Virginia bill - ABC News - February 25th, 2024 [February 25th, 2024]
- Metropolis Public Library Director responds to censorship controversyY - The Southern - February 25th, 2024 [February 25th, 2024]
- The Kids Online Safety Act will censor student journalists - Freedom of the Press Foundation - February 25th, 2024 [February 25th, 2024]
- Bills clarify that parental notice not meant to censor books - Richmond Times-Dispatch - February 25th, 2024 [February 25th, 2024]
- Meet the modern-day censors, wielding their purse-strings over artists and their work - The Guardian - February 25th, 2024 [February 25th, 2024]
- Artists alter, deface their own work at YBCA to protest Gaza silence and decry censorship - 48 hills - 48 Hills - February 25th, 2024 [February 25th, 2024]
- Ai Weiwei Says Censorship in the West Is Sometimes Even Worse Than in Maos China - ARTnews - February 6th, 2024 [February 6th, 2024]
- Biden White House Pressured Amazon to Censor Vaccine-Skeptical Books, Internal Emails Reveal - National Review - February 6th, 2024 [February 6th, 2024]
- Report: Jim Jordan reveals secret emails between White House, Amazon, to censor Covid dissent - The Hill - February 6th, 2024 [February 6th, 2024]
- National Science Foundation spent millions on AI censorship tools to quash 'misinformation' - Washington Times - February 6th, 2024 [February 6th, 2024]
- Most Banned Author To Speak About Censorship At Red Bank Talk - Patch - February 6th, 2024 [February 6th, 2024]
- Biden's AI plan to censor you revealed: Researchers say Americans can't 'tell fact from fiction' - New York Post - February 6th, 2024 [February 6th, 2024]
- Letter to the editor: Biden regime's censorship - Washington Times - February 6th, 2024 [February 6th, 2024]
- DCNF Reporter Reveals How Biden Admin Is Quietly Funding A 'Censorship Industrial Complex' In Congressional ... - Daily Caller - February 6th, 2024 [February 6th, 2024]
- Dem Rep Chews Up Minutes In Censorship Hearing To Warn About The 'Dictatorial' Dangers Of Trump - Daily Caller - February 6th, 2024 [February 6th, 2024]
- Supreme Court Deliberates on Government's Influence on Covid Misinformation - Health News - Medriva - February 6th, 2024 [February 6th, 2024]
- Biden White House pressured Amazon to censor books that countered Covid government party line - Must Read Alaska - February 6th, 2024 [February 6th, 2024]
- Congressional Hearing Probes Alleged Biden Administration Pressure on Big Tech to Censor Content - BNN Breaking - February 6th, 2024 [February 6th, 2024]
- Family Book Shop: DeLand bookstore displays banned books - WESH 2 Orlando - February 6th, 2024 [February 6th, 2024]
- The GOP Has a Plan for Online Safety. It Involves Censoring LGBTQ Content. - The New Republic - February 6th, 2024 [February 6th, 2024]
- Emails Show How Biden Officials Considered Covering Up Censorship Activities In The Wake Of DCNF Report - Daily Caller - February 6th, 2024 [February 6th, 2024]
- Jim Jordan Reveals Emails, Accuses WH Of Pressuring Amazon 'To Censor Books': 'Letting Americans Think For ... - The Daily Wire - February 6th, 2024 [February 6th, 2024]
- Angry Chinese people are using a US embassy social-media page to dodge censors and vent about its slumping ... - Yahoo News - February 6th, 2024 [February 6th, 2024]
- The Association of Appin Training Centers is waging a global censorship campaign to stop you from reading these ... - MuckRock - February 4th, 2024 [February 4th, 2024]
- How China Censors Critics of the Economy - The New York Times - February 4th, 2024 [February 4th, 2024]
- A Startup Allegedly 'Hacked the World.' Then Came the Censorshipand Now the Backlash - WIRED - February 4th, 2024 [February 4th, 2024]
- Negative Takes on China's Economy Are Disappearing From the Internet - The Wall Street Journal - February 4th, 2024 [February 4th, 2024]
- 14 Massachusetts colleges land on restrictive free speech list: Censorship and terrible policies - Boston Herald - February 4th, 2024 [February 4th, 2024]
- Norway owns a part of Putin's propaganda and censorship machine - The Independent Barents Observer - February 4th, 2024 [February 4th, 2024]
- Censorship in the West is the same as Mao's China, says Chinese dissident artist Ai Weiwei - Sky News - February 4th, 2024 [February 4th, 2024]
Tags: