Fight against ‘malinformation’ is censorship by government proxy – Chicago Sun-Times
Last month, I noted that the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention had repeatedly exaggerated the scientific evidence supporting face mask mandates during the COVID-19 pandemic. Facebook attached a warning to that column, which it said was missing context and could mislead people.
According to an alliance of social media platforms, government-funded organizations and federal officials that journalist Michael Shellenberger calls the censorship-industrial complex, I had committed the offense of malinformation. Unlike disinformation, which is intentionally misleading, or misinformation, which is erroneous, malinformation is true but inconvenient.
As illustrated by internal Twitter communications that journalist Matt Taibbi highlighted last week, malinformation can include emails from government officials that undermine their credibility and true content which might promote vaccine hesitancy.
The latter category encompasses accurate reports of breakthrough infections among people vaccinated against COVID-19, accounts of true vaccine side effects, objections to vaccine mandates, criticism of politicians, and citations of peer-reviewed research on naturally acquired immunity.
Disinformation and misinformation have always been contested categories, defined by the fallible and frequently subjective judgments of public officials and other government-endorsed experts. But malinformation is even more clearly in the eye of the beholder, since it is defined not by its alleged inaccuracy but by its perceived threat to public health, democracy or national security, which often amounts to nothing more than questioning the wisdom, honesty or authority of those experts.
Taibbis recent revelations focused on the work of the Virality Project, which the taxpayer-subsidized Stanford Internet Observatory launched in 2020. Although Renee DiResta, the Observatorys research manager, concedes that misinformation is ultimately speech, meaning the government cannot directly suppress it, she says the threat it poses require[s] that social media platforms, independent researchers and the government work together as partners in the fight.
That sort of collaboration raises obvious free speech concerns. If platforms like Twitter and Facebook were independently making these assessments, their editorial discretion would be protected by the First Amendment. But the picture looks different when government officials including the president, the surgeon general, members of Congress, and representatives of public health and law enforcement agencies publicly and privately chastise social media companies for not doing enough to suppress speech they view as dangerous.
Such meddling is especially alarming when it includes specific requests to remove content, make it less accessible or banish particular users. Even without explicit extortion, those requests are tantamount to commands because they are made against a backdrop of threats to punish recalcitrant platforms.
The threats include antitrust action, increased liability for user-posted content and other legal and regulatory measures. Surgeon General Vivek Murthy said such measures might be necessary when he demanded a whole-of-society effort to combat the urgent threat posed by health misinformation.
In a federal lawsuit filed last year, the attorneys general of Missouri and Louisiana, joined by scientists who ran afoul of the ever-expanding crusade against disinformation, misinformation and malinformation, argue that such pressure violates the First Amendment. This week, Terry A. Doughty, a federal judge in Louisiana, allowed that lawsuit to proceed, saying the plaintiffs had adequately alleged significant encouragement and coercion that converts the otherwise private conduct of censorship on social media platforms into state action.
Doughty added that the plaintiffs have plausibly alleged state action under the theories of joint participation, entwinement, and the combining of factors such as subsidization, authorization, and encouragement. Based on that analysis, he ruled that the plaintiffs plausibly state a claim for violation of the First Amendment via government-induced censorship.
Whatever the ultimate outcome of that case, Congress can take steps to discourage censorship by proxy. Shellenberger argues that it should stop funding groups like the Observatory and mandate instant reporting of all communications between government officials and contractors with social media executives relating to content moderation.
The interference that Shellenberger describes should not be a partisan issue. It should trouble anyone who prefers open inquiry and debate to covert government manipulation of online speech.
Jacob Sullum is a senior editor at Reason magazine.
The Sun-Times welcomes letters to the editor and op-eds.See our guidelines.
Continued here:
Fight against 'malinformation' is censorship by government proxy - Chicago Sun-Times
- I Never Imagined My Cocktail Book Would End Up Part of a Censorship Battlebut Im Not Taking It Sitting Down - Slate - November 15th, 2026 [November 15th, 2026]
- Next Time, Impeach Pete Hegseth for Press Censorship - The Intercept - November 15th, 2026 [November 15th, 2026]
- VICTORY: Federal officials agree to end censorship of Facebook group and app reporting ICE activity - FIRE | Foundation for Individual Rights and... - November 15th, 2026 [November 15th, 2026]
- Censorship as Segregation: Book Bans and the Return of Separate but Equal - Race, Racism and the Law - November 15th, 2026 [November 15th, 2026]
- Banned books from Irelands room of evil literature finally see the light of day - The Guardian - November 15th, 2026 [November 15th, 2026]
- Journalist Frat Fstk sentenced to 15 months in prison under Turkeys censorship law - Media and Law Studies Association (MLSA) - November 15th, 2026 [November 15th, 2026]
- The Irish Times view on Irelands history of censorship: dealing with filth - The Irish Times - November 15th, 2026 [November 15th, 2026]
- Granting Ukraine license to produce Patriot missiles still blocked at Pentagon media - . - November 15th, 2026 [November 15th, 2026]
- UChicagos Banned Books Scholar on the Chilling Effect of Censorship Efforts Across the US - WTTW News - November 13th, 2026 [November 13th, 2026]
- Video: Opinion | Is the U.S. Trying to Censor Our View From Space? - The New York Times - November 13th, 2026 [November 13th, 2026]
- GTA 6 censorship worries bubble up in Japan: the install size is different and the age rating drops sex and drugs - Yahoo Tech - November 13th, 2026 [November 13th, 2026]
- 'A very light-touch form of censorship': the iPhone has a 'gray list' of words and phrases that Apple won't auto-complete for you - TechRadar - November 13th, 2026 [November 13th, 2026]
- GTA 6 s File Size Is Smaller In Australia And Japan, Sparking Censorship Concerns - Kotaku - November 13th, 2026 [November 13th, 2026]
- State Library Board to vote Friday on rules tying funding to severe censorship - Arkansas Times - November 13th, 2026 [November 13th, 2026]
- Beyond censorship: Chinas growing influence on Thailands media - RSF - November 13th, 2026 [November 13th, 2026]
- New safety rules or ideological censorship? How Belarus is dismantling its concert industry - Belsat - November 13th, 2026 [November 13th, 2026]
- Why is 'Grand Theft Auto VI' censored in Japan? What to know before buying - Japan Today - November 13th, 2026 [November 13th, 2026]
- What has Russias chief negotiator Vladimir Medinsky been up to since the last round of peace talks? Rewriting history textbooks, praising Soviet... - November 13th, 2026 [November 13th, 2026]
- Jack Reacher author Lee Child condemns silencing of Israeli and Jewish writers - The Jewish Chronicle - November 13th, 2026 [November 13th, 2026]
- Labours conversion therapy ban is censorship in disguise - The Spectator - November 13th, 2026 [November 13th, 2026]
- Meta reinstates page dedicated to tracking the murder of women in Australia - SMH.com.au - November 13th, 2026 [November 13th, 2026]
- Who will defend the stranglewankers? Censorship is becoming a lazy British habit - UnHerd - November 13th, 2026 [November 13th, 2026]
- Man Utd respond after fans accuse them of 'censorship' over removal of protest banners - AOL.co.uk - November 13th, 2026 [November 13th, 2026]
- It is inappropriate to judge Meloni in a history book, as Laterza does. But no to censorship. The head of the headteachers association speaks out - Il... - November 13th, 2026 [November 13th, 2026]
- Meta reinstates page dedicated to tracking the murder of women in Australia - Brisbane Times - November 13th, 2026 [November 13th, 2026]
- GTA 6 censorship worries bubble up in Japan: the install size is different to everywhere else, and the age rating drops sex and drugs - GamesRadar+ - November 13th, 2026 [November 13th, 2026]
- Australian Censor Chief Rejects Claims Digital Duty of Care Will Drive Censorship - Reclaim The Net - November 13th, 2026 [November 13th, 2026]
- Advocacy group urges US to restore Tibetan broadcasting services amid growing Chinese propaganda and censorship - Phayul - November 13th, 2026 [November 13th, 2026]
- No Safe Havens: How Indias Censorship Regime Is Closing Indias Private Film-Screening Spaces - Article 14 - November 5th, 2026 [November 5th, 2026]
- The Media Show | Censorship at student papers and the role of social media in Gen-Z protests - BBC - November 5th, 2026 [November 5th, 2026]
- Fear of being quoted is no basis for censoring the Parliament and public debate - Strategic Analysis Australia - November 5th, 2026 [November 5th, 2026]
- Californias new chatbot law has a free speech problem - FIRE | Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression - November 5th, 2026 [November 5th, 2026]
- Help me move this fight forward : Support for CNEWS: Stop the threats of censorship and closure. - MyPetition.org - November 5th, 2026 [November 5th, 2026]
- Analysis: Censorship by proxy: Who is silencing coverage on fires? - The Jakarta Post - November 5th, 2026 [November 5th, 2026]
- Censorship, arrests, internet shutdown, PR campaign: How Arunachal is trying to control the Siang dam narrative - Alt News - November 5th, 2026 [November 5th, 2026]
- Gira residents spoke out against developments. Then they say they were blocked - Times of Malta - November 5th, 2026 [November 5th, 2026]
- Salome Zourabichvili: Civil society is being destroyed through repressive laws, independent media silenced by censorship, and opposition parties... - November 5th, 2026 [November 5th, 2026]
- Police seek X takedowns against IFF, SFLC.in and @geoblockedindia after notices to stop tracking blocking orders - MediaNama - November 5th, 2026 [November 5th, 2026]
- Censor Rules: Will Tollywood Wakeup? - Telugu360 - November 5th, 2026 [November 5th, 2026]
- Did BNT Censor a Film About the Bulgarian Chernobyl? News from Fakti.bg - Opinions - Fakti.bg - November 5th, 2026 [November 5th, 2026]
- Pakistan warns tech giants, disinformation and digital censo - Pakistan Today - November 5th, 2026 [November 5th, 2026]
- Novelist John Green caught in the crosshairs of Trump-era censorship - Le Monde.fr - November 3rd, 2026 [November 3rd, 2026]
- The Scholarly Kitchen Explores How Government Censorship Hurts Public Health - Information Today, Inc. - November 3rd, 2026 [November 3rd, 2026]
- Startups recalibrate Chinese AI for the West - Rest of World - November 3rd, 2026 [November 3rd, 2026]
- ON THE BOOKSHELF: Heights library offers Censorship by the Numbers display on banned books - The Killeen Daily Herald - November 3rd, 2026 [November 3rd, 2026]
- Dont weaponise the Haines attack for online censorship - AFR - November 3rd, 2026 [November 3rd, 2026]
- Texas Is Testing a Blueprint for Censoring Gender and Sexuality in Higher Education Nationwide - Ms. Magazine - November 3rd, 2026 [November 3rd, 2026]
- Alan Alda Shares Surprising Censorship Rules on 'M*A*S*H' That Limited Language - AOL.com - November 3rd, 2026 [November 3rd, 2026]
- VIDEO: A Sci-Fi Fantasy Bully Mob Tried TO Cancel Me And Censor The News - Fandom Pulse - November 3rd, 2026 [November 3rd, 2026]
- Heretic 2.0 Arrives and Strips Censorship from AI Models with a New Method - Pasquale Pillitteri - November 3rd, 2026 [November 3rd, 2026]
- Censor Board Issues Advisory For Film Certification, Says Only Complete Versions Will Be Accepted - NDTV - November 3rd, 2026 [November 3rd, 2026]
- Ethiopia: FAJ survey reveals poverty, fear and censorship have pushed African journalism into crisis - International Federation of Journalists - IFJ - November 1st, 2026 [November 1st, 2026]
- Opinion | Universities normalized attacks on free speech. Now its all-out war. - The Washington Post - November 1st, 2026 [November 1st, 2026]
- AI systems are censoring queer content and reducing LGBTQIA+ visibility - QueerAF - November 1st, 2026 [November 1st, 2026]
- Sex, censorship and the devil in Ken Russell by his son - The Telegraph - November 1st, 2026 [November 1st, 2026]
- Between culture and censorship: How the internet is reshaping modern Hausa - The ICIR - November 1st, 2026 [November 1st, 2026]
- The horror films censors tried to ban and why they terrified authorities around the world - Radio Times - November 1st, 2026 [November 1st, 2026]
- Macron echoes the EU "party line" on censorship: "Social media platforms MUST remove a great deal of ILLEGAL content under their terms... - November 1st, 2026 [November 1st, 2026]
- A film banned in 1972 is finally reaching Irish cinemas. Does it still have the power to shock? - The Journal - November 1st, 2026 [November 1st, 2026]
- What PEACE OF BULLSHIT have they fed us? / Will Ukrainian economy survive until winter? / Front / Uncensored. VIDEO - . - November 1st, 2026 [November 1st, 2026]
- Digital Duty of Care (censorship) laws pass the Lower House - The Spectator Australia - November 1st, 2026 [November 1st, 2026]
- Who Is Writing The Global Censorship Script? - The Daily Wire - November 1st, 2026 [November 1st, 2026]
- Australias Online Censorship Bill Moves To Senate With Age-Gating Fears Intact - Reclaim The Net - November 1st, 2026 [November 1st, 2026]
- Mbapp Controversy Reveals Beijings Long History of Censoring Athletes - Vision Times - November 1st, 2026 [November 1st, 2026]
- British Bigotry Is Pretty Insidious: Americans Have Only Just Realized That The UK Isnt Much Better Than The US Heres A Breakdown Of Britains Recent... - October 28th, 2026 [October 28th, 2026]
- Indonesia: Activists continue to be targeted, censorship around forest fires and disruption of activism in Papua - Civicus Monitor - October 28th, 2026 [October 28th, 2026]
- Instagram censors a cartoon about censorship. IFF will challenge it. - Internet Freedom Foundation - October 28th, 2026 [October 28th, 2026]
- National media censorship and what it means for student media - PantherNOW - October 28th, 2026 [October 28th, 2026]
- Why are Meta and TikTok censoring womens health content while allowing boner pill ads? - San Francisco Chronicle - October 28th, 2026 [October 28th, 2026]
- Turkish academics report widespread self-censorship amid fears of investigations, dismissal: studies - Stockholm Center for Freedom - October 28th, 2026 [October 28th, 2026]
- Echoes of Trump in a free speech controversy at Columbia University | Jonathan Zimmerman - Inquirer.com - October 28th, 2026 [October 28th, 2026]
- Thousands in Turkey rally against escalating crackdown on media - The Times of Israel - October 28th, 2026 [October 28th, 2026]
- What was leaked in the Censor Board data breach? | Explained - The Hindu - October 28th, 2026 [October 28th, 2026]
- CBFC data leak: Unreleased scripts, 500 film titles, censor cut exposed in security breach - Reports - The Times of India - October 28th, 2026 [October 28th, 2026]
- Post-traumatic laughter in the age of self-censorship - Dhaka Tribune - October 28th, 2026 [October 28th, 2026]
- CBFC data breach exposes scripts, censor cuts, film distribution deals for over 500 titles - ThePrint - October 28th, 2026 [October 28th, 2026]
- Poland Approves New Internet Blocking Powers - Reclaim The Net - October 28th, 2026 [October 28th, 2026]
- Exploring the Mirror World of the Chinese Internet - Jacobin - October 17th, 2026 [October 17th, 2026]
- Video: Why Zara Larsson Refuses to Censor Herself or Dim Her Joy - The New York Times - October 17th, 2026 [October 17th, 2026]
- Rights groups condemn Trkiyes abuse of legal framework to expand internet censorship - Jurist.org - October 17th, 2026 [October 17th, 2026]