This week, Congress sent a long-overdueforeign aid packageto President Joe Bidens desk, finally authorizing $61 billion in desperately needed military assistance for Ukraine. But before you breathe a sigh of relief for Ukrainians who have been bravely fighting Russias invasion for two years, consider that in the six months it took for skeptical Republicans to approve the package, Russia made half-a-years worth of battlefield advances. The question that nags me is whether U.S. aid was too little, too late not just for Ukraine, but also for the United States.
More From Our Experts
Thats because the belated vote in Congress to approve the foreign assistance package was critical not only for Ukraines ability to defend its territory and its people but also for Americas credibility on the world stage as a reliable partner willing to support friends against unprovoked threats from adversaries and authoritarians. This aid package, however large, is not enough to ensure that message gets through; the U.S. needs to make a commitment to ongoing assistance so Kyiv can regain enough territory to force Moscow to make concessions on the battlefield or in peace talks.
More on:
Ukraine
The War in Ukraine
Europe
Russia
Europe Program
While Congress was arguing, Russia was making steady advances in the last six months and has reconstituted its military strength with the help of China, Iran and North Korea. For now, U.S. military support will allow Ukraine to hold the line and quash Russian advances, but it is too late for a Ukrainian offensive or a quick or decisive Ukrainian victory.
A curation of original analyses, data visualizations, and commentaries, examining the debates and efforts to improve health worldwide.Weekly.
Images of Russian advances were becoming a sign of U.S. weakness and Americas willingness to abandon its partners. U.S. failure to act would have invited further aggression not only from Moscow, but also from Beijing. Both capitals have been closely following domestic debates in the United States.
The majority of Republicans in the House voted against the bill; many Republicans and supporters of former President Donald Trump say more weapons for Ukraine will only prolong a war that Kyiv cannot win. They argue that it is Europes, not the United States responsibility to prevent Russias takeover of Ukraine. What these critics fail to mention is that without those weapons, Ukraine will most certainly lose to Russia on the battlefield or in forced negotiations.
More From Our Experts
Without a credible commitment to ongoing bipartisan support for Kyiv, Moscow wouldnt be wrong to assume that the U.S. will abandon Ukraine sooner or later, especially if this years U.S. presidential election returns Trump to the White House. Regardless of the results in November, a failure by Congress to build on the latest aid package in words and deeds will undermine U.S. leadership and credibility around the world, emboldening our enemies.
Even with fresh U.S. assistance that began flowing this week, Ukraine isstill likely to be outgunned this year. There is hope that increased U.S. and European ammunition production could turn the tide next year, but Russia has the advantage for now. In a best-case scenario, Ukraine can use long-range missiles the so-called ATACMS, which werequietly deliveredby Washington to Ukraine in recent weeks to pressure Russian forces behind the frontlines, especially in Crimea, laying the groundwork for future offensive action.
More on:
Ukraine
The War in Ukraine
Europe
Russia
Europe Program
U.S. military support will give Ukraine some breathing room until the end of the year, allowing its military to bolster defenses and mobilize the necessary manpower to go back on the offensive. Ukraine has some problems that foreign aid funding wont solve: it needs more soldiers and younger ones. The Ukrainian parliament passed a mobilization bill earlier this month tolower the conscription ageto 25 and add penalties for dodging military service.
At least for now, the long-delayed passage of the U.S. foreign aid bill has signaled to our partners and adversaries around the world that Washington does not abandon its friends, even in the face of deep domestic polarization.
Follow this link:
Is U.S. Aid to Ukraine Too Little, Too Late? - Council on Foreign Relations
Tags: