What will AI do to question-based inquiry? (opinion) – Inside Higher Ed
Twemoji (question mark image) and Just_Super from Getty Images Signature (AI photograph).
Since the release of ChatGPT in late 2022, many questions have been raised about the impact of generative artificial intelligence on higher education, particularly its potential to automate the processes of research and writing. Will ChatGPT end the college essay or prompt professors, as John Warner hopes, to revise our pedagogical ends in assigning writing? At Washington College, our Cromwell Center for Teaching and Learning organized a series of discussions this past spring motivated by questions: What is machine learning doing in education? How might we define its use in the classroom? How should we value it in our programs and address it in our policies? True to the heuristic nature of inquiry in the liberal arts and sciences, this series generated robust but unfinished conversations that elicited some initial answers and many more questions.
And yet, as we continue to raise important questions about AI while adapting to it, surprisingly few questions have been asked of AI, literally. I have come to notice that the dominant grammatical mood in which AI chatbot conversations are conducted or prompted is the imperative. As emphasized by the new conductors of prompt engineering, the skillful eliciting of output from the AI model that has emerged as a lucrative career opportunity, chatbots respond best to explicit commands. The best way to ask AI a question, it seems, is to stop asking it questions.
Writing in The New York Times On Tech: AI newsletter, Brian X. Chen defines golden prompts as the art of asking questions that will generate the most helpful answers. However, Chens prompts are all commands (such as act as if you are an expert in X), no interrogatives, and not even a please recommended for the new art of computational conversation. Nearly every recommendation I have seen from AI developers perpetuates this drifting of question-based inquiry into blunt command. Consider prominent AI adopter and Wharton School professor Ethan Mollick. Observing the tendency of students to get poor results from chatbot inquiry because they ask detailed questions, Mollick proposes a simple solution. Instead of guiding or instructing the chatbot with questions, Mollick writes, tell it what you want it to do and, a point made through an unnerving analogy, boss it like you would an intern.
Most Popular
Why should it matter that our newest writing and research technologies are rapidly shifting the modes and moods of inquiry from interrogatives to imperatives? Surely many seeking information from an internet search no longer phrase inquiry as a question. But I would agree with Janet H. Murray that new digital environments for AI-assisted inquiry do not merely add to existing modes of research, but instead establish new expressive forms with different characteristics, new affordances and constraints. First among these for Murray, writing in Hamlet on the Holodeck (MIT Press, 1998), is the procedural or algorithmic basis of digital communication. A problem-solving procedure, an algorithm follows precise rules and processes that result in a specific answer, a predictable and executable outcome.
Algorithmic procedure might provide a beneficial substructure for fictional narrative, driving a reader (or player, in the case of a video game) toward the resolution of a complex and highly determined plot. But algorithmic rules could also pose a substantial constraint for students learning to write an essay, where more open-ended heuristics, or brief, general rules of thumb and adaptive commonplaces, are more appropriate for composition that aims for context-contingent persuasion, plausibility not certainty.
Drawing on lessons from cognitive psychology, educator Mike Rose long ago addressed the problem of writers block in these very terms of algorithm and heuristic. Process and procedure are necessary for writing, but when writing is presented algorithmically, as a rigid set of rules to execute, developing writers can become cognitively blocked. Perhaps you remember, as I do, struggling to reconcile initial attempts at drafting an essay with a lengthy, detailed Harvard outline worked out entirely in advance. Roses seminal advice from 1980, that educators present learning prompts more heuristically and less absolutely, remains timely and appropriate for the new algorithms of AI.
In turning questions into commands, while still referring to them as questions, we perpetuate cognitive blocking while inducing, apparently, intellectual idiocy. (Ask better questions by not asking them?) We transform key rhetorical figures of inquiry like question and conversation into dead metaphor. Consider what is happening to the word prompt. Students know the word, at least for now, as a term of art in writing pedagogy: the guidelines for an assignment in which instructors identify the purpose, context and audience for the writing, preparing the grounds for the type of question-based inquiry the students will be pursuing. In The Craft of Research (University of Chicago Press), the late Wayne Booth and his colleagues refer to these heuristic guidelines as helping students make rhetorically significant choices.
Reaching back to classical rhetoric, heuristics such as Aristotles topics of invention or the four questions of stasis theory provide adaptive and responsive ideas and structures toward possible responses, not determined answers. When motivating questions are displaced by commands, AI-generated inquiry risks rhetorical unresponsiveness. When answers to unasked questions are removed from audience and context, the opaque information retrieved is no longer in need of a writer. The user can command not just the answer but also its arrangement, style and delivery. Since inquiry is offloaded to AI, why not the entire composition?
As educators we should worry, along with Nicholas Carr in The Glass Cage (W.W. Norton, 2014), about the cognitive de-skilling that attends the automation of intellectual inquiry. Writing before ChatGPT, Carr was already thinking about the ways that algorithmic grading programs might drift into algorithmic writing and thinking. As it becomes more efficient to pursue question-based inquiry without asking questions, we potentially lose more than the skill of posing questions. We potentially lose the means and the motivation for the inquiry. It is hard to be curious about ideas when information can be commanded.
As we continue to raise questions about AI, we need not resist all things algorithm. After all, we have been working and teaching with rule-based procedures long before the computer. But we can choose, as educators, to use emerging algorithmic tools more heuristically and with more rhetorically significant purpose. Rhetorically speaking, the best heuristics are simple concepts that can be applied to interrogate and sort through complex ideas, adapting prior knowledge to new contexts: What is X? Who values it? How might X be viewed from alternative perspectives? Such is inquiry, which, like education, can be guided but hardly commanded. If we are going to use AI tools to find and shape answers to our questions, we should generate and pose the questions.
Sean Ross Meehan, Ph.D., is a professor of English and director of writing and co-director of the Cromwell Center for Teaching and Learning at Washington College.
Original post:
What will AI do to question-based inquiry? (opinion) - Inside Higher Ed
- OpenAI disbands its AI risk mitigation team - - May 20th, 2024 [May 20th, 2024]
- BEYOND LOCAL: 'Noise' in the machine: Human differences in judgment lead to problems for AI - The Longmont Leader - May 20th, 2024 [May 20th, 2024]
- Machine Learning Researcher Links OpenAI to Drug-Fueled Sex Parties - Futurism - May 20th, 2024 [May 20th, 2024]
- What Is AI? How Artificial Intelligence Works (2024) - Shopify - May 20th, 2024 [May 20th, 2024]
- Vitalik Buterin says OpenAI's GPT-4 has passed the Turing test - Cointelegraph - May 20th, 2024 [May 20th, 2024]
- "I lost trust": Why the OpenAI team in charge of safeguarding humanity imploded - Vox.com - May 18th, 2024 [May 18th, 2024]
- 63% of surveyed Americans want government legislation to prevent super intelligent AI from ever being achieved - PC Gamer - May 18th, 2024 [May 18th, 2024]
- Top OpenAI researcher resigns, saying company prioritized 'shiny products' over AI safety - Fortune - May 18th, 2024 [May 18th, 2024]
- The revolution in artificial intelligence and artificial general intelligence - Washington Times - May 18th, 2024 [May 18th, 2024]
- OpenAI disbands team devoted to artificial intelligence risks - Yahoo! Voices - May 18th, 2024 [May 18th, 2024]
- OpenAI disbands safety team focused on risk of artificial intelligence causing 'human extinction' - New York Post - May 18th, 2024 [May 18th, 2024]
- OpenAI disbands team devoted to artificial intelligence risks - Port Lavaca Wave - May 18th, 2024 [May 18th, 2024]
- OpenAI disbands team devoted to artificial intelligence risks - Moore County News Press - May 18th, 2024 [May 18th, 2024]
- Generative AI Is Totally Shameless. I Want to Be It - WIRED - May 18th, 2024 [May 18th, 2024]
- OpenAI researcher resigns, claiming safety has taken a backseat to shiny products - The Verge - May 18th, 2024 [May 18th, 2024]
- Most of Surveyed Americans Do Not Want Super Intelligent AI - 80.lv - May 18th, 2024 [May 18th, 2024]
- How Artificial General Intelligence Will Shape the Future - Analytics Insight - May 18th, 2024 [May 18th, 2024]
- A former OpenAI leader says safety has 'taken a backseat to shiny products' at the AI company - Winnipeg Free Press - May 18th, 2024 [May 18th, 2024]
- DeepMind CEO says Google to spend more than $100B on AGI despite hype - Cointelegraph - April 20th, 2024 [April 20th, 2024]
- Congressional panel outlines five guardrails for AI use in House - FedScoop - April 20th, 2024 [April 20th, 2024]
- The Potential and Perils of Advanced Artificial General Intelligence - elblog.pl - April 20th, 2024 [April 20th, 2024]
- Artificial General Intelligence (AGI) Market size is worth USD 27.47 Billion by 2030 with 37.5 % As Reveale... - WhaTech - April 20th, 2024 [April 20th, 2024]
- DeepMind Head: Google AI Spending Could Exceed $100 Billion - PYMNTS.com - April 20th, 2024 [April 20th, 2024]
- Q&A: Mark Zuckerberg on winning the AI race - The Verge - April 20th, 2024 [April 20th, 2024]
- Say hi to Tong Tong, world's first AGI child-image figure - ecns - April 20th, 2024 [April 20th, 2024]
- Silicon Scholars: AI and The Muslim Ummah - IslamiCity - April 20th, 2024 [April 20th, 2024]
- AI stocks aren't like the dot-com bubble. Here's why - Quartz - April 20th, 2024 [April 20th, 2024]
- AI vs. AGI: The Race for Performance, Battling the Cost? for NASDAQ:GOOG by Moshkelgosha - TradingView - April 20th, 2024 [April 20th, 2024]
- We've Been Here Before: AI Promised Humanlike Machines In 1958 - The Good Men Project - April 20th, 2024 [April 20th, 2024]
- Google will spend more than $100 billion on AI, exec says - Quartz - April 20th, 2024 [April 20th, 2024]
- Tech companies want to build artificial general intelligence. But who decides when AGI is attained? - ABC News - April 8th, 2024 [April 8th, 2024]
- Tech companies want to build artificial general intelligence. But who decides when AGI is attained? - The Bakersfield Californian - April 8th, 2024 [April 8th, 2024]
- Tech companies want to build artificial general intelligence. But who decides when AGI is attained? - The Caledonian-Record - April 8th, 2024 [April 8th, 2024]
- What is AGI and how is it different from AI? - ReadWrite - April 8th, 2024 [April 8th, 2024]
- Artificial intelligence in healthcare: defining the most common terms - HealthITAnalytics.com - April 8th, 2024 [April 8th, 2024]
- We're Focusing on the Wrong Kind of AI Apocalypse - TIME - April 8th, 2024 [April 8th, 2024]
- Xi Jinping's vision in supporting the artificial intelligence at home and abroad - Modern Diplomacy - April 8th, 2024 [April 8th, 2024]
- As 'The Matrix' turns 25, the chilling artificial intelligence (AI) projection at its core isn't as outlandish as it once seemed - TechRadar - April 8th, 2024 [April 8th, 2024]
- AI & robotics briefing: Why superintelligent AI won't sneak up on us - Nature.com - January 10th, 2024 [January 10th, 2024]
- Get Ready for the Great AI Disappointment - WIRED - January 10th, 2024 [January 10th, 2024]
- Part 3 Capitalism in the Age of Artificial General Intelligence (AGI) - Medium - January 10th, 2024 [January 10th, 2024]
- Artificial General Intelligence (AGI): what it is and why its discovery can change the world - Medium - January 10th, 2024 [January 10th, 2024]
- Exploring the Path to Artificial General Intelligence - Medriva - January 10th, 2024 [January 10th, 2024]
- The Acceleration Towards Artificial General Intelligence (AGI) and Its Implications - Medriva - January 10th, 2024 [January 10th, 2024]
- OpenAI Warns: "AGI Is Coming" - Do we have a reason to worry? - Medium - January 10th, 2024 [January 10th, 2024]
- The fight over ethics intensifies as artificial intelligence quickly changes the world - 9 & 10 News - January 10th, 2024 [January 10th, 2024]
- AI as the Third Window into Humanity: Understanding Human Behavior and Emotions - Medriva - January 10th, 2024 [January 10th, 2024]
- Artificial General Intelligence (AGI) in Radiation Oncology: Transformative Technology - Medriva - January 10th, 2024 [January 10th, 2024]
- Exploring the Potential of AGI: Opportunities and Challenges - Medium - January 10th, 2024 [January 10th, 2024]
- Full-Spectrum Cognitive Development Incorporating AI for Evolution and Collective Intelligence - Medriva - January 10th, 2024 [January 10th, 2024]
- Artificial Superintelligence - Understanding a Future Tech that Will Change the World! - MobileAppDaily - January 10th, 2024 [January 10th, 2024]
- Title: AI Unveiled: Exploring the Realm of Artificial Intelligence - Medium - January 10th, 2024 [January 10th, 2024]
- The Simple Reason Why AGI (Artificial General Intelligence) Is Not ... - Medium - December 2nd, 2023 [December 2nd, 2023]
- What does the future hold for generative AI? - MIT News - December 2nd, 2023 [December 2nd, 2023]
- One year after its public launch, ChatGPT has succeeded in igniting ... - Morningstar - December 2nd, 2023 [December 2nd, 2023]
- Macy's Could See Over $7.5 Billion in Additional Business Gains ... - CMSWire - December 2nd, 2023 [December 2nd, 2023]
- Securing the cloud and AI: Insights from Laceworks CISO - SiliconANGLE News - December 2nd, 2023 [December 2nd, 2023]
- Amazon unleashes Q, an AI assistant for the workplace - Ars Technica - December 2nd, 2023 [December 2nd, 2023]
- You're not imagining things: The end of the -3- - Morningstar - December 2nd, 2023 [December 2nd, 2023]
- OpenAI researchers warned board of AI breakthrough ahead of CEO ouster, sources say - Reuters - November 24th, 2023 [November 24th, 2023]
- What the OpenAI drama means for AI progress and safety - Nature.com - November 24th, 2023 [November 24th, 2023]
- The fallout from the weirdness at OpenAI - The Economist - November 24th, 2023 [November 24th, 2023]
- How an 'internet of AIs' will take artificial intelligence to the next level - Cointelegraph - November 24th, 2023 [November 24th, 2023]
- OpenAI Is Seeking Additional Investment in Artificial General ... - AiThority - November 24th, 2023 [November 24th, 2023]
- Top AI researcher launches new Alberta lab with Huawei funds after ... - The Globe and Mail - November 24th, 2023 [November 24th, 2023]
- Will AI Replace Humanity? - KDnuggets - November 24th, 2023 [November 24th, 2023]
- This Week in AI: Accelerationism, AGI and the Law - PYMNTS.com - November 24th, 2023 [November 24th, 2023]
- Tesla FSD v12 Rolls Out to Employees With Update 2023.38.10 ... - Not a Tesla App - November 24th, 2023 [November 24th, 2023]
- Searching AI-powered ChatGpt for HNP authors, the Great Salt ... - The Daily Herald - November 24th, 2023 [November 24th, 2023]
- Unveiling the Mechanics of AI: How Artificial Intelligence Works - Medium - August 16th, 2023 [August 16th, 2023]
- The stakes are high so are the rewards: Artificial intelligence and ... - Building - August 16th, 2023 [August 16th, 2023]
- The Department of State's pilot project approach to AI adoption - FedScoop - August 16th, 2023 [August 16th, 2023]
- Anthropic and SK Telecom team up to build AI model for telcos - Tech Monitor - August 16th, 2023 [August 16th, 2023]
- Derry City & Strabane - Explore the Future of Education and ... - Derry City and Strabane District Council - August 16th, 2023 [August 16th, 2023]
- Ethical Considerations of Using AI for Academic Purposes - Unite.AI - August 16th, 2023 [August 16th, 2023]
- Elon Musk says Tesla cars now have a mind, figured out 'some aspects of AGI' - Electrek - August 13th, 2023 [August 13th, 2023]
- To Navigate the Age of AI, the World Needs a New Turing Test - WIRED - August 13th, 2023 [August 13th, 2023]
- What's Behind the Race to Create Artificial General Intelligence? - Truthdig - August 13th, 2023 [August 13th, 2023]
- Why Hawaii Should Take The Lead On Regulating Artificial ... - Honolulu Civil Beat - August 13th, 2023 [August 13th, 2023]
- Artificial Intelligence (AI) Explained in Simple Terms - MUO - MakeUseOf - August 13th, 2023 [August 13th, 2023]