Trump’s Afghanistan Policy? Talk Tough, Then Just Pull the Plug – The Daily Beast
The is the second of two columns about some of the lessons learned, or not, in America's longest war. The firstTrump, Afghanistan, and The Tweet of Damocles can be read here.
PARISUnless President Donald Trump decides to end the Afghan war with a bangwith tens of millions killed, as he has threatened more than onceit is going to end with a whimper, if it ends at all.
Its not victory, says counterinsurgency expert David Kilcullen. It isnt ticker-tape and Broadway.
It should be said that what Kilcullen and others consider the best option looks like the one Trump is pursuing just now: a reduction of U.S. forces on the ground to an easily sustainable level of about 9,000, while negotiating to get the Taliban into direct talks, eventually, with the U.S.-backed Afghan government. But after 18 years of a war that has cost $2 trillion and the lives of more than 2,400 U.S. soldiers, such an inconclusive conclusion may not satisfy even an exhausted American publicmuch less the egotistical Mr. Trump.
As he runs for re-election touting his promises kept, the president is going to want something that looks like the definitive end that he's vowed he'll deliver to this endless war. Perhaps there will be some bit of political theater like Trump's incredibly ill-conceived and eventually rescinded invitation to Taliban leaders to come to the United States only days before the anniversary of 9/11 so he could claim his own Camp David Accords. Or, more likely, hell just pull the plug.
Thus Kilcullens memorable phrase, picked up from a U.S. Special Forces operator with rueful experience in Syria, This whole operation is sitting under the tweet of Damocles. Or, putting it another way, Trump wakes up, he sees something on Fox and Friends, gets out of the wrong side of the bed, doesnt like it, says, Fuck it, were pulling out. And I think thats a problem.
In any case, the Taliban know how badly Trump wants out, and they can play with that.
But if by some miracle the current policy of minimal U.S. presence, tough talks, and supposedly unlimited patience does hold, what are some of the strategies and tactics that should be employed going forward? What needs to be done to help Afghanistan become a stable country free of terrorists who might threaten the United States or its citizens? What lessons learned from the past?
For this and the previous column, I called up both Kilcullen, a well-known Australian soldier-scholar who worked with the George W. Bush and Obama administrations, and Ambassador Ryan Crocker, who served as the Americans top diplomat in Afghanistan in 2002 and again in 2011 and 2012.
"Have you ever seen the movie I Am Legend with Will Smith?" Kilcullen asked me. I said I had, vaguely recalling a post-apocalyptic thriller and wondering where this was going.
Theres that scene, said Kilcullen, where the sun goes down and hes checking his watch because the vampires are going to come out and eat him. Well, I wish I had a dollar for every time I have been out in an Afghan district in the late afternoon with an Afghan government official, and the guy starts checking his watch. And the reason is, they dont live there. They dont live in the districts that they govern, because they know if they try to spend one single night in the area that they are officially in charge of the vampires are going to come out and eat them.
Finding a way to reconnect the Afghan government with people at the local level is essential to stabilizing the country, Kilcullen suggested, and corruption made that almost impossible when the U.S. was pumping more money into the place than anyone knew how to handle:
Vast amounts of gringo cash come into Afghanistan, that fuels an economy of corruption, Kilcullen told me. Instability leads to money coming in which leads to corruption which leads to abuse which leads to more people supporting the insurgents which leads to more instability, and you get this sort of self-licking ice cream cone.
If you wanted to be an Afghan police chief you would have to buy that position and it would cost you about 250,000 American dollars.
David Kilcullen
Ambassador Crocker, for his part, is quoted extensively in the U.S. governments lessons learned documents recently published by The Washington Post under the damning headline, At War With The Truth: Our biggest single project, sadly and inadvertently, of course, may have been the development of mass corruption, Crocker said in 2015 when interviewed by a team from the office of the Special Inspector General for Afghanistan Reconstruction (SIGAR). Once it gets to the level I saw, when I was out there, its somewhere between unbelievably hard and outright impossible to fix it.
Over the phone last week, Crocker added,There were no controls except our own, which obviously didnt go far enough. And there was plenty of corruption and waste among Americans as well. He said many thought, Hey, U.S. rules no longer apply. Lets get rich.
In about 2010, Kilcullen looked at bribery among Afghan police in the south of the country. If you wanted to be an Afghan police chief you would have to buy that position and it would cost you about 250,000 American dollars, Kilcullen said. And then you would have to pay every month up the chain of command all the way to Kabul about 50 grand in kickbacks... Imagine how much money you are making from bribes and shakedowns and targeting the population just to make your payment and also make a profit.
The U.S. is still spending taxpayer billions in Afghanistan, a country of 30 million people whose entire gross domestic product is only some $21 billion. This year military aid amounts to about $5 billion, while foreign assistance to civilian projects is about $633 millionstill big numbers, but less than half of what they were a decade ago.
Looking back, Kilcullen said that of $133 billion in reconstruction funds all told, Id say conservatively 20 to 30 percent went directly to the enemy. It was bad. But were not doing that anymore. Its a historical lessons learned, but its not relevant to now.
The investment we have in Afghanistan now is perfectly tuned, said Crocker.
But what of the local corruption? The shakedowns, the intimidationthe kind of thing that Kilcullen witnessed with the police and with regional officials looking at their watches in the late afternoon? His answer is surprising.
Until local government people are capable, respected, effective, Kilcullen said, the disconnect from the local population is not going to be solved. And frankly the only way I can see that happening in much of the country is for those local government people to effectively be Taliban. Thats a side effect of a successful political process, whereby you integrate Taliban into the structure.
The common rap on the Afghan National Army is that its soldiers dont want to serve, and they dont fight. There, too, corruption has been a huge problem with officers pocketing the salaries of troops who arent required to report for duty, so-called ghost soldiers. But the real problem is the casualty rate among those who do fight and do die: some 45,000 killed since 2015 as opposed to fewer than 60 American troops.
The problem is not that we cant sustain it, said Kilcullen. The problem is that the Afghans as they are currently fighting cannot sustain itthey cant sustain their own loss rate. Among the reasons: We did not put enough effort soon enough into the Afghan Air Force, so we started that very late in the game. And they are still very reliant on air power for things like medical evacuation, reconnaissance, battlefield transport, that kind of stuff, and they find it really hard to fight without those assets.
To make matters worse, says Kilcullen, the campaign against the so-called Islamic State in Syria and Iraq diverted many of those resources.
There are ways to lower the loss rates among the Afghan National Army and Afghan National Police, says Kilcullen. But again, its all moot, because if the president wakes up and says, Fuck it, we are leaving, youve got to struggle to execute that strategy.
Afghanistan has become the worlds biggest producer of opium. It produces some 80 percent of the worlds illicit supply, despite $10 billion spent trying to eradicate or replace the poppy crops. The Taliban make a lot of money in the narcotics business, but they are not the only players.
What can be done better? Kilcullen proposes some unconventional solutions since the conventional ones have been such stunning failures.
I think it was a mistake to send our ground troops in a counterinsurgency role, including the Afghan troops, out to support counter-narcotics, says Kilcullen. If you are doing a counterinsurgency campaign and you are told you need to be eradicating poppy crops you will eradicate the crops that you can get to, which by definition will be the crops that are in accessible areas, which by definition means they are more likely to be crops owned by people who are broadly pro-government. So you are actually creating an incentive for people not to back the government and to back the insurgents, because that keeps the [Afghan National Army] out of their area and their crops arent going to be destroyed.
The other thing is I think we blame the farmer too much, he said, offering a little paean to what he called the amazing poppy. Its a medicine that is traditional in Afghanistan that people use to treat their kids. Its a product that keeps forever, it requires no refrigeration and never goes bad. Its tradable for currency and is the closest thing to hard cash in large parts of Afghanistan. And more importantly it grows on any piece of broken ground. It doesnt require a lot of water. It doesnt require any fertilizer, unlike virtually any other crop in Afghanistan, and the customer will pay you for it up front and pick it up from the farm gate. Its basically a perfect crop.
By targeting the farmer, says Kilcullen, you are pissing a guy off for just being logical and trying to follow his own interests. A much better way to think about dealing with it is interdiction, orthere was even an NGO in Afghanistan for years that put forward the entirely sensible policy that we should just buy all the opium, and pay the farmer a fair wage for it, and send it into a government-controlled monopoly. Then we can always just burn it out at sea if we wanted or we could feed it into the [legitimate] international economy. But we should take over and control the economy of opium rather than let the Taliban turn it into support for the insurgency.
If there is general agreement that negotiations with the Taliban are desirable, the question of who should do the talking is not so clear. Several sessions of U.S.-Taliban negotiations in Qatar over the last year were conducted without any participation by the Afghan government at all. U.S. Ambassador Zalmay Khalilzad hammered out an agreement that would have included the staged withdrawal of all U.S. troops (an "evacuation," as the Taliban put it) and only then were they going to consent to talk with the government of President Ashraf Ghani. The result was the Camp David fiasco. Now talks have resumed, but theyre on again and off again.
The Taliban conceded early on that they would not be harboring terrorists like al Qaeda or the South Asian version of the Islamic State, but that's a matter of self interest. Such groups now compete with the Taliban for radical Islamic cred and help to divide its already fractious organization. Trump may eventually hold up such a promise as a mission-accomplished momentonce again he has defeated terrorist. But how can Taliban promises be verified if there are no more Americans on the ground?
The Afghan government could complicate such a deal by demanding something more solid than the flimsy exit pass being discussed thus far. So, Crocker said hes not against negotiations. I just profoundly believe that negotiating without the Afghan government is surrender.
What Kilcullen calls a theoretically viable strategy is to make clear to the Taliban in no uncertain terms that there is no timeline, that we are not leaving, and that they cant wait us out. At the same time, concentrate on developing the intelligence and aviation abilities of the Afghan forces, with less emphasis on U.S. airpower. Weve been trying to bomb the Taliban to the negotiating table, said Kilcullen. Thats killing a lot of civilians.
The better strategy, he suggests, is to say convincingly, You want us to leave? Until you guys are willing to negotiate a deal we are not leaving. I think there is a way to wait them out as opposed to bombing them to the negotiating table.
But all this is theoretical because we have a chief executive problem, said Kilcullen. Around the world, Trump's threats of fire and fury are not taken seriously at this point, and neither are his promises of patient, persistent commitment, especially in Afghanistan.
I think absent President Trump you could make the case, and I think you could probably make it in a way that the American people would understand. U.S. casualties are very low, spending is way down, life has improved for many Afghans living in the cities, and especially for Afghan women.
Lets be clear, Crocker wrote in a Washington Post op-ed last Friday. We came to Afghanistan and remain there now for one essential reason: the United States national security. But what serves that interest? I have argued that a better life for people in a misgoverned country is an essential part of that effort. It is also about American values. What is it, exactly, about nation-building that we must avoid at all costs? Does it extend to looking in the eyes of a hopeful Afghan girl of kindergarten age and saying, Sorry, kid. Youre on your own?
In the mercenary age of MAGA, sadly, talk about defending American values abroad has come to sound almost nave, but that is one thing Crocker, after service as a top diplomat in Lebanon, Syria, Iraq and Afghanistan, is not.
What scares me about Trump, Crocker told me over the phone, is when he gets something in his mind, he can get beaten back, but it will come at you again. He doesnt drop it. And we saw that in Syria. Trump wanted to get all the U.S. troops out of thereonly a few thousandand he reconsidered after Defense Secretary James Mattis and Special Envoy Brett McGurk resigned a year ago. The military meanwhile were telling him the move was dog-ass dumb, as Crocker put it. But then boom, 10 months later he is back at it again. Thats where he is on Afghanistan, and I am really afraid he is going to pull the plug.
Crocker pointed to the recent prisoner swap with the Taliban. An American and an Australian hostage were traded for three Taliban prisoners. Trump tweeted: Lets hope this leads to more good things on the peace front like a ceasefire that will help end this long war. Proud of my team! But one of the released Taliban, Hajji Mali Khan, is reputed to be among their best field commanders.
So we let this guy loose with no ceasefire, said Crocker, and our guys are going to die. I think it speaks to the fact this White House just wants to get the hell out.
See the article here:
Trump's Afghanistan Policy? Talk Tough, Then Just Pull the Plug - The Daily Beast
- UN highlights what it calls "learning poverty" in Afghanistan - Voice of America English News - November 19th, 2026 [November 19th, 2026]
- 16 Days of Activism Against Gender-Based Violence and Systematic Discrimination against Women and Girls in Afghanistan - Amnesty International... - November 19th, 2026 [November 19th, 2026]
- Moscow Balances Relationship with Pakistan and Taliban-led Afghanistan - The Jamestown Foundation - November 19th, 2026 [November 19th, 2026]
- Photos of the secret lives of women in Afghanistan who defy the Taliban - AP News - November 19th, 2026 [November 19th, 2026]
- Iran Says Army, Revolutionary Guards Cooperate to Secure Border with Afghanistan - thekabultribune.com - November 19th, 2026 [November 19th, 2026]
- Afghanistan exports over 31 tons of saffron worth 48 mln USD in first 7 months - Xinhua - November 19th, 2026 [November 19th, 2026]
- Afghanistan Development Update: Water for Recovery and Sustainability (November 2026) - ReliefWeb - November 19th, 2026 [November 19th, 2026]
- Pakistan vows to proceed with US-Iran diplomacy and urges Afghanistan to act on terrorism - The Washington Post - November 19th, 2026 [November 19th, 2026]
- Photos of the secret lives of women in Afghanistan who defy the Taliban - Daily News-Record - November 19th, 2026 [November 19th, 2026]
- Photos of the secret lives of women in Afghanistan who defy the Taliban - chronicleonline.com - November 19th, 2026 [November 19th, 2026]
- UN Concerns Over ISIS-K's Growing Capabilities Are Unfounded, Says Taliban - Afghanistan International - November 19th, 2026 [November 19th, 2026]
- Afghanistan Among Five Countries With Highest Number of Children Killed or Maimed in Wars - 8AM Media - November 19th, 2026 [November 19th, 2026]
- Afghanistan: Emergency response and recovery - People in Need - November 19th, 2026 [November 19th, 2026]
- UN approves US$18 million in emergency funding to support more than 824,000 people through winter and lean season in Afghanistan - ReliefWeb - November 19th, 2026 [November 19th, 2026]
- Terrorist Groups in Afghanistan Seek to Launch Attacks Inside and Beyond the Country - 8AM Media - November 19th, 2026 [November 19th, 2026]
- Taliban: Afghanistan Exports More Than 31 Tonnes of Saffron Worth $48 Million - 8AM Media - November 19th, 2026 [November 19th, 2026]
- Photos of the secret lives of women in Afghanistan who defy the Taliban - Eagle-Tribune - November 19th, 2026 [November 19th, 2026]
- Photos of the secret lives of women in Afghanistan who defy the Taliban - WV News - November 19th, 2026 [November 19th, 2026]
- Terrorist Groups In Afghanistan Have Acquired Advanced Equipment, Says UN Official - Afghanistan International - November 19th, 2026 [November 19th, 2026]
- Afghanistan among 5 countries with highest child casualties in conflicts: Save the Children - Pajhwok Afghan News - November 19th, 2026 [November 19th, 2026]
- ICC judges close Afghanistan investigation covering alleged US war crimes - Jurist.org - November 15th, 2026 [November 15th, 2026]
- Crossing Afghanistan along the 'highway of death' - Revisited - France 24 - November 15th, 2026 [November 15th, 2026]
- UN Afghanistan Trust Fund Marks Fifth Anniversary, Reports Reaching More Than 8 Million People - thekabultribune.com - November 15th, 2026 [November 15th, 2026]
- Splitting the ICCs Afghanistan Investigation: Judicial Oversight or Overreach? - EJIL: Talk! - November 15th, 2026 [November 15th, 2026]
- Iran, Afghanistan to expand agricultural, livestock cooperation - Tehran Times - November 15th, 2026 [November 15th, 2026]
- UN: Many People in Afghanistan with Diabetes Unaware of the Diseases Symptoms - 8AM Media - November 15th, 2026 [November 15th, 2026]
- Russian delegation visits Afghanistan to discuss trade and investment with the Taliban - mypanhandle.com - November 15th, 2026 [November 15th, 2026]
- M-ATV in Afghanistan: The Real-World Test of MRAP in Mountain Terrain - Envanter Medya - November 15th, 2026 [November 15th, 2026]
- Poppy Cultivation Surges in Afghanistan as Russia and the Taliban Square Off Against the UN - 8AM Media - November 15th, 2026 [November 15th, 2026]
- Young Man Found Stabbed to Death in Southern Afghanistan, Body Discovered in Garbage Dump - KabulNow - November 15th, 2026 [November 15th, 2026]
- Five Years Into Taliban Rule, Filmmakers in Afghanistan Battle Poverty and Unemployment - 8AM Media - November 15th, 2026 [November 15th, 2026]
- ICC judges close parts of Afghanistan investigation into alleged US troop crimes and ISIS-K - Mezha.net - November 15th, 2026 [November 15th, 2026]
- Forced Returns: More Than 500 People Returned to Afghanistan Yesterday - 8AM Media - November 15th, 2026 [November 15th, 2026]
- Brendan Taylor strikes another half-century as Zimbabwe extend lead to 291 runs against Afghanistan - Cricket World - November 15th, 2026 [November 15th, 2026]
- Afghanistan faces deepening humanitarian crisis amid sweeping rights restrictions - UN News - November 10th, 2026 [November 10th, 2026]
- Chatham House Prize 2026 awarded to the women of Afghanistan - Chatham House - November 10th, 2026 [November 10th, 2026]
- The six strategic mistakes that led to US defeat in Afghanistan - Atlantic Council - November 10th, 2026 [November 10th, 2026]
- Where East meets West: Tracing the geological crossroads of Iran and Afghanistan - Phys.org - November 10th, 2026 [November 10th, 2026]
- 16 Days of Activism Against Gender Apartheid in Afghanistan - Amnesty International Australia - November 10th, 2026 [November 10th, 2026]
- How Afghanistan War soul-searching led to renaming of Navy expeditionary command - Navy Times - November 10th, 2026 [November 10th, 2026]
- MoD refuses details of SAS Afghanistan murder investigation - Action on Armed Violence - AOAV - November 10th, 2026 [November 10th, 2026]
- Second Conference on the Situation of Women in Afghanistan to Be Held in France - 8AM Media - November 10th, 2026 [November 10th, 2026]
- Congressman Latimer Signs Letter for Homeland Security to Stop Deportation Flights to Afghanistan - Yonkers Times - November 10th, 2026 [November 10th, 2026]
- Cricket Scotland Suspends Bilateral Ties With Afghanistan - Afghanistan International - November 10th, 2026 [November 10th, 2026]
- Scotland Suspends Bilateral Cricket Ties with Afghanistan over Womens Rights - KabulNow - November 10th, 2026 [November 10th, 2026]
- International Week of Science and Peace: Girls in Afghanistan Still Denied Education - 8AM Media - November 10th, 2026 [November 10th, 2026]
- Afghanistan: Time to Rethink Western Aid - 8AM Media - November 10th, 2026 [November 10th, 2026]
- COMMENT: Twenty years in Afghanistan. What did we actually build? - IntelliNews - November 10th, 2026 [November 10th, 2026]
- ISIS-Khorasan: A Real Threat to the People of Afghanistan and a Political Opportunity for the Taliban - 8AM Media - November 10th, 2026 [November 10th, 2026]
- UN warns of severe hunger in Afghanistan ahead of winter - A News - November 10th, 2026 [November 10th, 2026]
- Afternoon front page: Canadian in Afghanistan was epitome of a good soldier; WWI ace gets long-overdue memorial; and more - Yahoo News Canada - November 10th, 2026 [November 10th, 2026]
- Blades a review: Mark Nicols defence of the SAS meets the Afghanistan Inquiry - Action on Armed Violence - AOAV - November 10th, 2026 [November 10th, 2026]
- An Iraqi intelligence report reveals a plan to smuggle oil through Iran to Turkey and Afghanistan - - November 10th, 2026 [November 10th, 2026]
- Closure of 700 Health Centers in Afghanistan Leaves People Stranded Between Illness and No Care - 8AM Media - November 10th, 2026 [November 10th, 2026]
- Taliban: More Than 900 Square Kilometers of Afghanistan Contaminated by Unexploded Ordnance - 8AM Media - November 10th, 2026 [November 10th, 2026]
- UN: More Than Half of Children in Afghanistan Deprived of Formal Education - 8AM Media - November 10th, 2026 [November 10th, 2026]
- Why Scotland suspended cricket ties with Afghanistan outside ICC events - The Times of India - November 10th, 2026 [November 10th, 2026]
- KP Governor Says Provinces Future Will Be Decided in Islamabad, Not Afghanistan - thekabultribune.com - November 10th, 2026 [November 10th, 2026]
- 700 Health Centres Closed In Afghanistan In One Year, Says UN - Afghanistan International - November 10th, 2026 [November 10th, 2026]
- The NYC Marathon Inspired Me to Escape Afghanistan. Now I'm Running the Race - Yahoo - October 30th, 2026 [October 30th, 2026]
- How Chinese Investments in Afghanistan Are Aiding the Talibanand Hurting the People - The National Interest - October 30th, 2026 [October 30th, 2026]
- Afghanistan vs Zimbabwe prediction, team news, pitch report and betting tips for 2nd T20I in Sharjah - Yahoo Sports - October 30th, 2026 [October 30th, 2026]
- When the Fighting Stops but the Conflict Doesn't: Afghanistan and the Limits of Negative Peace - Modern Diplomacy - October 30th, 2026 [October 30th, 2026]
- 1.3 Million Return to Afghanistan as Winter Threatens Vulnerable Families - International Organization for Migration - October 30th, 2026 [October 30th, 2026]
- Impacts of Conflict on Markets and Supply Chains in Afghanistan (July - August 2026) - ReliefWeb - October 30th, 2026 [October 30th, 2026]
- Afghan Women and Girls at the heart of UNESCO's action in Afghanistan - UNESCO - October 30th, 2026 [October 30th, 2026]
- Afghanistan, Ukraine, Syria and Lebanon face rising winter aid needs - Latest news from Azerbaijan - October 30th, 2026 [October 30th, 2026]
- OCHA: More Than 15 Million People in Afghanistan Face Severe Hunger - 8AM Media - October 30th, 2026 [October 30th, 2026]
- Rabab Fatima, the UN Secretary-Generals Special Representative for Afghanistan and head of UNAMA, has said that the United Nations is committed to... - October 30th, 2026 [October 30th, 2026]
- Faiq Calls for Urgent International Action to Improve Human Rights in Afghanistan - 8AM Media - October 30th, 2026 [October 30th, 2026]
- Taliban: More Than 500 People Returned to Afghanistan Through Various Border Crossings on Wednesday - 8AM Media - October 30th, 2026 [October 30th, 2026]
- New Polio Vaccination Campaign to Begin Across Afghanistan on Monday - 8AM Media - October 30th, 2026 [October 30th, 2026]
- Opium Production In Afghanistan Has Increased Fivefold, Says UN - Afghanistan International - October 30th, 2026 [October 30th, 2026]
- Emergency Aid to Afghanistan Is Not Enough, Humanitarian Expert Says - The Times Of Central Asia - October 30th, 2026 [October 30th, 2026]
- Pakistan urges Afghanistan to act against militants and denies recruiting Afghan fighters - The Washington Post - October 30th, 2026 [October 30th, 2026]
- Afghanistan drop Nabi from T20Is and Rasooli from white-ball squads - ESPN - October 2nd, 2026 [October 2nd, 2026]
- Emergency Relief After Devastating Floods in Nuristan, Afghanistan - All Hands & Hearts - October 2nd, 2026 [October 2nd, 2026]
- Afghanistan condemns Pakistan as U.N. mission says airstrikes killed 10 civilians, "most of them children" - CBS News - October 2nd, 2026 [October 2nd, 2026]
- Afghanistan Country Report: The State of the Humanitarian System 2026 - ReliefWeb - October 2nd, 2026 [October 2nd, 2026]
- Deaths reported as Pakistan, Afghanistan engage in fresh clashes - Daily Sabah - October 2nd, 2026 [October 2nd, 2026]