Press Council makes ruling
Australian Press Council makes its ruling. Source: Supplied
The Australian Press Council has considered a complaint about material in The Daily Telegraph, Sydney, on 26 November 2011.
Front-page headings, "OPEN THE FLOODGATES - Exclusive: Thousands of boat people to invade NSW", were followed by two paragraphs which commenced Thousands of boat people will be released into Sydney's suburbs as the government empties detention centres.
Readers were then directed to articles running across two inside pages with one headline reading "Open the floodgates" and another reading "Detainee deluge for Sydney".
Anna Krjatian complained that the word invade was inaccurate, unfair and offensive because it portrayed asylum seekers and refugees as a threat to public and personal safety.
She also said that the words "open the floodgates" were inaccurate, especially as the number of asylum seekers could not conceivably reach levels which would justify such an extreme term and they would be only a very small proportion of all new immigrants each year.
The newspaper responded that the use of the terms such as open the floodgates and deluge were not inaccurate or unfair, especially as details about likely numbers of asylum seekers being released into the community were provided in the articles and readers could decide for themselves whether the words were appropriate.
It said the State Governments briefing note feared that government services would be swamped and unable to cope with the sudden influx. It did not seek to defend use of the word invade.
The Press Council has concluded that use of the word invade was gravely inaccurate, unfair and offensive because of its clear connotations of forceful occupation. According the complaint is upheld on this ground for what the Council regards as an especially serious breach of its principles.
The Council has concluded that use of the words open the floodgates and deluge were inaccurate and unfair.
Read more:
Press Council makes ruling