Portugal’s Socialists Highlight the Rot Within the European Left – The European Conservative
Antnio Costas eight years as prime minister of Portugal reached an ignominious end on 7 November 2023, when the justice authorities carried out a total of 43 raids on government buildings and homes, including the prime ministerial residence. They were investigating misuse of funds in ambitious green energy initiatives into which European Union funding was being ploughed. The smooth, paternalistic lawyer concluded within hours that his position had become untenable and he announced that he was quitting (to be followed by an insistence that he had no plans to resume office). Over 75,000 was discovered in wine boxes and bookshelvesmoney belonging to his chief aide, Vtor Escria, who was placed under arrest. Costa himself figured in a long list of suspects but insisted (and continues to insist) that he is blameless, which may well be the case. But he was the 13th member of his government to swiftly vacate office because of criminal investigations or conflicts of interest. Soon after, yet more government ministers would be facing the attentions of state investigators.
On Sunday, 10 March, in what was the third general election in five years, the Portuguese electorate removed the Socialist Party (PS) from power. It lost heavily, but the centre-right, the nominal winner, hardly budged. It was the surge in support for the populist challenger Chega (the word means enough in Portuguese) that made this a watershed election. Its support soared from 7% to 18% on a turnout of 64%, up nearly 12% since the last election. The young turned out in big numbers. They cast their votes for Chega in the hope that it could sweep away the torpor and the cronyism and promote structural change that could stem the hmorrhage of population that has been visible since the Eurozone crisis, from 2009 onwards.
Only the over-55s have remained broadly loyal to the Socialist Party. It had created a strong power base within an ageing electorate by depicting itself as the guarantor of social protection, much of which was paid for from EU transfer funds. A steady cash flow from Brussels passed through the hands of Socialist power brokers in local councils and state agencies. Patronage structures became embedded, which made it hard for the Left to be dislodged from office. Only its chronic economic mismanagement of the country, which intensified the effects of the Eurozone crisis for Portugal, condemned it to opposition status.
The early decades of the century have been very frustrating for young Portuguese. A declining level of productivity means that when they can acquire a job it will often be in a low-wage sector such as tourism. The money earned is rarely enough to be able to start a family. One in three Portuguese aged 15-39 have left Portugal, either to avoid unemployment or the high taxation on their paltry salaries, if they are even able to break into a tightly regulated labour market.
Chegas fluent, and self-confident leader, Andr Ventura, won over enough young people to place his party firmly on the electoral map. He has a varied career profile, unlike the worthies from the mainstream parties, which are staffed by lawyers or local government barons who often have backgrounds in teaching or public administration. His partys vote appears to have more than doubled, which means that a party which didnt even exist five years ago will now have 49 deputies elected. Late results seem set to give Chega two of the four seats allocated to the numerous Portuguese living overseasa group with no love for the blockedpolitics they left behind. Ventura is a professor of law who later became a popular radio sports commentator. His verbal prowess enables him to be a dominating presence in the National Assembly, and his social media followers outnumber those of the other main political contenders added together.
Conversely, the new leader of the PS, 46-year-old Pedro Nuno Santos, proved no match for Ventura on the campaign trail. Santos exemplifies the tendency across Europe for left-wing parties to choose leaders who promote a political order based on virtue rather than the ability to get things done. Santoswas infrastructure minister until his removal by Costa, in 2022, after he announced the location for a much-disputed new airport serving the capital, when the PM was out of the country, and without having cleared it with him. More seriously, billions of euros were wasted in a saga over the state airline, TAP, which is seen as one of the favourite sinecures of the PS. Originally privatised when the centre-right was in office, it was re-nationalised only for its privatisation to be arranged once again at huge cost to the exchequer but with no visible benefit.
Like any number of prominent Socialists across Europe, Santos owes practically his entire career to the party from student days onwards. From his teenage years, he has been a full-time politician, drawn from a middle-class family in business, the bulk of whose wealth derives from trading with the state. His attention is focused on redistributing wealth, not producing it. Just like the more moderate Costa, he lacks an economic vision for Portugal. He obtained the leadership by emphasising far-left themes requiring people to make major adjustments to their lives in order to fit in with the lofty climate and racial equality agendas imported from elsewhere.
Except for Chega, the aspirants for office are a pretty dull and uninspiring lot, perhaps because Portugal has been content to follow EU directives on most aspects of domestic policy. In office for most of the last third of a century, PS oversaw a period when what was once a trading organisation massively expanded its reach over perhaps most aspects of governance. The opening up of the Portuguese economy to competition from the rest of the EU has resulted in the shrivelling of the countrys once respectable industrial base and the rapid decline of its agriculture.
Most of the nations political players have come to accept Portugals dependency status because supervision is accompanied by what seems like a generous injection of funds on a regular basis. Portugal has thus far received 133 billion worth of EU funding, from joining the entity in 1986 to the start of 2023 (a figure that does not include the large amount released in order to promote post-COVID economic recovery). The property sector and infrastructure have benefited from this injection of funding. These are sectors which do not strengthen the labour market or long-term growth. Perhaps the lions share of EU funding goes into maintaining a large social state. The PS is careful to channel the money towards its own support groups via state agencies, where the party often has a strong grip.
A recent best-selling work, As Causas do Atraso Portugus (The Causes of Portugals Backwardness) by Nuno Palma, an economics professor at the University of Manchester, contends that Portugal would be better off in the long-run ifwithout leaving the EUit were weaned off external support from the EU and required to stand on its own two feet to carry out long-overdue structural reforms.
Arguably EU largesse has been a recipe for social stability. It has kept elite quarrels to a minimum and muffled social and economic tension. Without the avuncular supervision of the EU, it is an open question whether the liberal republic could have endured for so long. But the price has been high in terms of stagnation. As well as declining productivity, the Socialists have been content to preside over both a rate of emigration unsurpassed since the 1960s, and one of Europes lowest birth-rates. Moreover, the political class does not have to account for how the money from Brussels is spent. Checks are lax, and the heavily-subsidised local media rarely makes life difficult for the authorities by investigating potential scandals.
EU structural funds exist to narrow the gulf between rich and poor EU states and promote eventual economic convergence. Portugal is not the only country where this lofty goal has been forgotten, but it is perhaps one of the most glaring examples at present. Social mobility has declined, as favoured groups (often linked to those who wield influence) succeed in determining recruitment on informal rather than meritocratic criteria. More importantly, structural reform is ruled out in favour of gaining short-term advantages by the Machiavellian distribution of EU funds. Perhaps the main beneficiaries of the externally shaped status quo in Portugal are not vulnerable social groups relying on state help but rather cartels in the media and commerce. There is evidence that they are able to receive state financing, or else are shown leniency over price-fixing, in return for backing during elections and times of crisis.
It is perhaps no coincidence that the major media companies, with their plunging circulations and disappearing profit margins, have appeared keen to prevent Chega enjoying a major breakthrough in this election. Nevertheless, early results show that Portugal has become the latest European country where populists have broken through.
Even though his party now seems destined for opposition, Antnio Costa could still be the one who has the last laugh. If the authorities decide that he has no case to answer, he could end up holding the top job in the EUs European Council. He was seen as a favourite because of his negotiating skills and the friendships he had built across the political spectrum. Indeed, some allege that he neglected his duties at home to lobby for this position. It is unelected and it seems that such positions are the ones left-wingers on the continent of Europe have the best chance of acquiring these days.
Meanwhile, his successor Pedro N. Santos surveys the ruins of the Socialist house. The PS has lost 43 seats and has seen its vote share reduced by 13%. It was pinning its hopes on next months celebrations to mark the 50th anniversary of the army coup in Lisbon that placed Portugal on a long leftist path to socialism. However, the occasion is more likely to seem like a funeral than a festival.
Chega has eaten into the Lefts support base in what used to be its southern strongholds. Dismissing the vigorous political upstart as far-right means that the PS and parties further to the left (which mostly fared disastrously on 10 March) are besmirching many of their former supporters, and potentially alienating them permanently. The final bitter pill to swallow is that Chega will get nearly 4 million of state aid while PS funding has been slashed.
A majority right-wing government able to determine its spending priorities and its reform aims would have four years to dismantle the empire which the PS has constructed within the state apparatus, one that has enabled party bigwigs and their lieutenants to do business in politics with other peoples money.
The PS notables played the system and refused to govern. Santos and his shrinking army of Socialist sloganisers will be pinning their hopes on Chega playing a strong hand badly, resulting in it crashing to earth once early elections take place. This could be a forlorn hope. Most of Chegas 49 deputies are unlikely to be of any special calibre, though some may prove pleasant surprises. But in Ventura, the party has a skilful and tenacious commander. He currently has no equal elsewhere in Portuguese politics.
A low-grade political class, devoid of leadership, intellect and, above all, a sense of public service has got what it deserves. Enough voters deserted the Left, or else gave up on their non-voting habits, to place a new contestant in the game. Whatever comes next, the sterile two-party system, dominated by a swarm of usually unprepossessing careerists, looks like it has had its day. A critical mass of Portuguese have shaken off their deference and chronically low expectations.
Enough Portuguese seem still to believe in the nation and its need for long-overdue structural reforms in order for it to remain viable and keep its citizens productive and at home, rather than successful but abroad.
To the dismay of a shabby political class recruited to pursue business in politics and ill-equipped to perform its national duties, the Portuguese have suddenly become alert, vocal, and even demanding. A people too readily dismissed by the political bosses as ignorant, stupid, and incapable, seem at last to have awakened. It will be quite a job getting them to go back to sleep, especially because of the uproar that is occurring across Europe. Socialists who lost touch with electoral bases, and instead ended up pushing niche causes incubated in universities or woke boardrooms, are now struggling to stay relevant. In Portugal, the chances of them putting in place a status quobased on the post-national objectives dreamt up by European bureaucrats, corporate managers, and woke activistssuffered a considerable setback on 10 March. There is now a small window of opportunity for Portugal to renew itself, so that anniversary celebrations next month in favour of liberty might ring a little less hollow.
This essay was originally published at Scotview. It has been edited for length and is republished with kind permissionoftheauthor.
Read the original post:
Portugal's Socialists Highlight the Rot Within the European Left - The European Conservative
Tags: