Immigration Reform Isn't Just About NumbersIt's About Skills, Too
Since immigrants are disproportionately poorly educated, any overhaul needs to focus on bringing in fewer but more talented people.
Reuters
At a Hollywood conference on innovation on Friday, Vice President Joe Biden credited constant and overwhelming immigration for American creativity. Obviously, immigrants have contributed hugely to Americas legendary dynamism. From Alexander Hamilton to Sergey Brin, people born off these shores have founded new companies, invented new products, and disseminated new ideas.
All the most enthusiastic tributes to immigration as a source of renewal are true.
But those tributes are not the whole truth.
Since 1965, American immigration policy has tilted further and further in favor of the poorly educated and the unskilled. In consequenceand with full acknowledgement of the many, many spectacular individual success storiesAmerican immigration policy in the aggregate has degraded the countrys skill levels and pushed the United States down to the bottom of the developed world in literacy, numeracy, and problem-solving.
A new OECD report delivers grim news about how poorly Americans score in the skills necessary to a modern economy: Larger proportions of adults in the United States than in other [advanced] countries have poor literacy and numeracy skills, and the proportion of adults with poor skills in problem solving is slightly larger than average, despite the relatively high educational attainments among adults in the United States.
In literacy, for example, the OECD graded populations into five categories, 1 and 2 being the lowest. One in six American adults scored below level 2 for literacy, as compared to one in 20 adults in Japan. Nearly one in three scored below level 2 for numeracy. One in three scored at the lowest level for problem-solving in an advanced technical environment.
Why did Americans score so uniquely badly?
Immigration isnt the whole answer, but it is the largestand fastest-growingpart of the explanation of the deskilling of the American labor force.
View post:
Immigration Reform Isn't Just About NumbersIt's About Skills, Too