Judge hears Democrat and Chronicle plate reader suit
A judge asked Monroe County to provide him with the records of a reporter's license plate.(Photo: Christina Nellemann, Getty Images/iStockphoto)
An attorney for the Democrat and Chronicle argued Tuesday in state Supreme Court that Monroe County officials erred in refusing to release records that could show how extensively police use high-speed license-plate cameras to log where and when law-abiding citizens are driving.
The county maintains a database of license-plate records collected by these cameras, which often are mounted on police cruisers, and had amassed about 3.8 million records as of last summer. In July, reporter Steve Orr asked to see any records on his own license plate, those of six colleagues and two used on a pair of government vehicles assigned to Mayor Lovely Warren and Deputy County Executive Dan DeLaus.
County officials denied Orr's request. The Democrat and Chronicle asked a judge this fall to step in and order the records released.
Attorney Christopher Thomas of Nixon Peabody LLP told Justice John J. Ark on Tuesday morning that other law enforcement agencies including the Greece Police Department have readily handed over such information to people who asked for records on their own plates.
Deputy County Attorney Matt Brown said the decisions of other government agencies are "wholly irrelevant" because there have been no other court cases to settle how to deal with this issue.
The county has argued that releasing the records would be an invasion of personal privacy or interfere with a law enforcement investigation two reasons that government agencies can withhold records under the state's open records law.
Thomas criticized the county's argument that the records could somehow compromise an investigation.
"What the county is saying is that we're all suspects until we're not suspects, and we can't see our own data because we might some day be a suspect," he said.
Thomas also said the county simply could have requested proof that the reporters and editors involved in the request consented for their records to be released. All have since signed letters saying as much.
Read the original:
Judge hears Democrat and Chronicle plate reader suit