Has Google’s LaMDA artificial intelligence really achieved sentience? – New Scientist
Blake Lemoine, an engineer at Google, has claimed that the firm's LaMDA artificial intelligence is sentient, but the expert consensus is that this is not the case
By Matthew Sparkes
Google is developing a range of artificial intelligence models
KENZO TRIBOUILLARD/AFP via Getty Images
A Google engineer has reportedly been placed on suspension from the company after claim that an artificial intelligence (AI) he helped to develop had become sentient. If I didnt know exactly what it was, which is this computer program we built recently, Id think it was a seven-year-old, eight-year-old kid, Blake Lemoine told the Washington Post.
Lemoine released transcripts of conversations with with the AI, called LaMDA (Language Model for Dialogue Applications), in which it appears to express fears of being switched off, talk about how it feels happy and sad, and attempts to form bonds with humans by talking about situations that it could never have actually experienced. Heres everything you need to know.
In a word, no, says Adrian Weller at the Alan Turing Institute.
LaMDA is an impressive model, its one of the most recent in a line of large language models that are trained with a lot of computing power and huge amounts of text data, but theyre not really sentient, he says. They do a sophisticated form of pattern matching to find text that best matches the query theyve been given thats based on all the data theyve been fed.
Adrian Hilton at the University of Surrey, UK agrees that sentience is a bold claim thats not backed up by the facts. Even noted cognitive scientist Steven Pinker weighed in to shoot down Lemoines claims, while Gary Marcus at New York University summed it up in one word: nonsense.
Neither Lemoine nor Google responded to New Scientists request for comment. But its certainly true that the output of AI models in recent years has become surprisingly, even shockingly good.
Our minds are susceptible to perceiving such ability especially when it comes to models designed to mimic human language as evidence of true intelligence. Not only can LaMDA make convincing chit-chat, but it can also present itself as having self-awareness and feelings.
As humans, were very good at anthropomorphising things, says Hilton. Putting our human values on things and and treating them as if they were sentient. We do this with cartoons, for instance, or with robots or with animals. We project our own emotions and sentience onto them. I would imagine thats whats happening happening in this case.
It remains unclear whether the current trajectory of AI research, where ever-larger models are fed ever-larger piles of training data, will see the genesis of an artificial mind.
I dont believe at the moment that we really understand the mechanisms behind what what makes something sentient and intelligent, says Hilton. Theres a lot of hype about AI, but Im not convinced that what were doing with machine learning, at the moment, is really intelligence in that sense.
Weller says that, given human emotions rely on sensory inputs, it might eventually be possible to replicate them artificially. It potentially, maybe one day, might be true, but most people would agree that theres a long way to go.
The Washington Post claims that Lemoine has been placed on suspension after seven years at Google, having attempted to hire a lawyer to represent LaMDA and sending executives a document that claimed the AI was sentient. Google also says that publishing the transcripts broke confidentiality policies.
Google told the Washington Post that: Our team, including ethicists and technologists, has reviewed Blakes concerns per our AI principles and have informed him that the evidence does not support his claims. He was told that there was no evidence that LaMDA was sentient (and lots of evidence against it).
Lemoine responded on Twitter: Google might call this sharing proprietary property. I call it sharing a discussion that I had with one of my coworkers.
More on these topics:
Go here to read the rest:
Has Google's LaMDA artificial intelligence really achieved sentience? - New Scientist